- 1 - !" #$%$ $ && '%( ) ! " # $ ! ! % # " &' (!! $ Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % " ! " " ! &' (!! ! ! &' (!! ) * " # + , + - ## # % # & (!! # &' (!! ) * + , ' - - 3 - + + - " # " ! " # " $ + " # ! # + . # + " #/ + # 0# " # # *% $ * 0# " # #- 1233456789::49;23<2;48=>?14:;927?2<<393392;27@ ?14AB8@C47?978845D44:93348=>?14;49D748 D2752:9; 4726D2E2;"B8@4978124<"B82529;#9@23?D9?49;9=BD9@2 *<6D316D?F?14+2D3?::4;;9?46BD?G-27 6 ! H14D4=> ?14 845D44 6< :4DC9747? 27AB75?267 @D97?48 27 <9E6BD6<?14:;927?2<<3=>?14;49D748 D2752:9;2E2;"B8@4 *"B726D 2E23267- 9;9=BD9@2 *<6D 316D? F?14 D29; 6BD?G- 276 $59C4?6=4D4E4D348978?143B2?H93 - 4 - 56734IB47?;> 823C23348 14 82E4D@47? <27827@3 D456D848 => ?14 ?H6 6BD?3 =4;6H 9D4 ?14 3B=A45? C9??4D 6< 519;;47@427?1239::49;9??14273?97546<?14:;927?2<<3 +6D ?14 39J4 6< 567E4724754 ?14 :9D?243 319;; =4D4<4DD48?693:4D?142DD97J=4<6D4?14D29;6BD? 14 <95?3 @2E27@ D234 ?6 ?14 :D4347? 9::49; 27 =D24<9D493<6;;6H3 14 :;927?2<<3 273?2?B?48 6 $ 344J27@9 845D44 6< :4DC9747? 27AB75?267 27 D43:45? 6< 97 6:47 3:954 =49D27@ 97519>9? 6 (! *74H 6 (- C493BD27@ 93?K43? >9D83 * <44?- 978 6D?1K 6B?1 >9D83 *$ <44?- 32?B9?48 9? 2D766D E2;;9@4 9;9=BD9@29;BJ=6B784867?1493?=>9688267?14 43?=>?1416B346<93H97? 962D984D#9;2:9?2;67?14 6D?1 => 9 :B=;25 H9> 978 67 ?14 6B?1 => 9 H9> 14 :;927?2<<35;92C?6=4?149=36;B?46H74D327:6334332676< ?143B2?35148B;4:D6:4D?>14>567?478?19??142D<9?14D H93 ?14 6D2@279; 6H74D 978 ?19? 9 :6D?267 6< ?14 3928 - 5 - :D6:4D?> H93 =427@ B348 93 9 6882 978 59??;4 3148978 9;36 <6D 3?6D27@ <4D?2;2L4D ? 23 <BD?14D :;49848 ?19? 67 % !?142D<9?14D1989::;248<6D:4DC233267?6:B? B: 5673?DB5?267 H1251 H93 8B;> @D97?48 => ?14 ?147 ABD23825?2679; 9132;89D <?4D ?142D <9?14D/3 84C234 67 ?14:;927?2<<32714D2?48?14:D6:4D?>978?142D 79C43 H4D4 CB?9?48 27 ?14 D4E47B4 D456D83 14> 5;92C ?619E4567?27B4827:6334332679789D4D4@B;9D;>:9>27@ :D6:4D?> ?9M43? 23 9;36 9E4DD48?19? ?142D4;84D =D6?14D 4M:2D48 67 978 ?19? ?14 :;927?2<<3 19E4 32754 D4C92748 27 4M5;B32E4 :633433267 978 47A6>C47? 6< ?14 :D6:4D?> 14 @D24E9754 6< ?14 :;927?2<<3 23 ?19? ?14 84<47897?3 =427@ 27<;B47?29; :4D3673 9D4 9??4C:?27@ ?6 27?4D<4D4H2?1?142D:4954<B;:63343326797847A6>C47?6< ?143B2?:D6:4D?>7454332?9?27@?14:D4347?3B2? :67 34DE254 6< 3BCC673 ?14 84<47897?3 47?4D489::49D9754978<2;48984?92;48HD2??473?9?4C47? 847>27@ 9;; ?14 9E4DC47?3 C984 27 ?14 :;927? 14> 3:452<259;;> 567?47848 ?19? ?14 :D6:4D?243 6H748 => ?14 - 6 - :;927?2<<3978?16346H748=>?1484<47897?39D447?2D4;> 823?275? 978 B7D4;9?48 4<47897? 63 978 :;49848 ?19? ?142D :D6:4D?243 9D4 32?B9?48 9=6B? <44? 9H9> <D6C ?14 :;927?2<<3/ 16B34 =49D27@ 6 (! ? H93 ?142D 5934?19??14:;927?2<<3H2?197B;?4D26DC6?2E4?6475D6951 B:67 ?142D :D6:4D?> 19E4 <2;48 ?14 :D4347? 3B2? => 84;2=4D9?4;> 9332@727@ ?14 =6B789D243 6< ?14 84<47897?3/ ;978?6?143B2?35148B;4:D6:4D?>1484<47897?3<BD?14D 9;;4@48 ?19? ?14 :;927?2<<3 19E4 <9=D259?48 978 :D68B548 <9;34 865BC47?3 =4<6D4 ?14 6BD? 978 ?19? ?14 C9: 9::47848?6?14:;927?232756DD45?978C23;49827@ ! 6?1 :9D?243 988B548 6D9; 978 865BC47?9D> 4E284754 27 3B::6D? 6< ?142D D43:45?2E4 5;92C3 14 D29; 6BD? B:67 9::D4529?267 6< ?14 4E284754 978 ?14 98C2332673 4;252?48 8BD27@?14 5D633(4M9C279?267 6< :9D?25B;9D;> 123 98C233267 ?19? :D6:4D?> =49D27@ 6 ( =4;67@3 ?6 ?14 :;927?2<<3 14;8 ?19? ?14 :;927?2<<3 198 43?9=;23148 ?142D :633433267 6E4D ?14 3B2? 35148B;4 :D6:4D?>556D827@;>?14D29;6BD?845D448?143B2?978 - 7 - @D97?48 9 :4D:4?B9; 27AB75?267 D43?D92727@ ?14 84<47897?3 <D6C27?4D<4D27@H2?1?14:;927?2<<3/:4954<B;:633433267978 47A6>C47?6<?14:D6:4D?> % 14 +2D3? ::4;;9?4 6BD? 16H4E4D D4E4D348 ?14845D446<?14D29;6BD?:D2C9D2;>67?14@D6B78?19? ?14 :;927?2<<3 <92;48 ?6 43?9=;231 ?142D ?2?;4 6E4D ?14 3B2? 35148B;4:D6:4D?>14::4;;9?46BD?6=34DE48?19??14 :;927?2<<3 198 76? :D68B548 ?14 6D2@279; @D97? 54D?2<259?4 9;;4@48?619E4=447233B48=>?149132;89D97867?19? =9323 86B=?48 ?14 :;927?2<<3/ 6H74D312: ? <BD?14D 6:2748 ?19??14:;927?2<<319876?9::D695148?146BD?H2?15;497 197836734IB47?;>?149::49;H939;;6H48978?143B2? 59C4 ?6 =4 823C23348 1434 567?D9D> <27827@3 9D4 76H B784D519;;47@427?1233456789::49; $ 123 6BD? => 6D84D 89?48 !% % 198 272?29;;><D9C48?14<6;;6H27@3B=3?97?29;IB43?2676<;9H - 8 - ! B=34IB47?;>B:67149D27@?14;49D74856B734;<6D =6?1 32843 978 67 D49::D9239; 6< ?14 D456D8 ?123 6BD? <6B78 2? 9::D6:D29?4 ?6 D4<D9C4 ?14 3B=3?97?29; IB43?2673 6< ;9H 556D827@;> => 6D84D 89?48 ! ?14 <6;;6H27@3B=3?97?29;IB43?26736<;9HH4D4<D9C48 F2" # $ " # % % &$ '"( - 9 - ) *+ , -( . ! +,-+,./,/01/23,2+34506/2+,437/+3,-++ 14 ;49D748 56B734;3 H4D4 59;;48 B:67 ?6 3B=C2? ?142D 9D@BC47?3 67 ?14 74H;> <D9C48 3B=3?97?29; IB43?2673 6< ;9H 6?1 ?14 56B734;3 19E4 4M?4732E4;> 9D@B48 27 3B::6D? 6< ?142D D43:45?2E4 5;92C3 6 988D433 ?1434?H63B=3?97?29;IB43?26736<;9H?1236BD?844C32? <2? ?6 4M?D95??1498C2332673 4;252?48 27 5D633(4M9C279?267 6<978 “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` 6B:;48H2?1?1459?4@6D259;98C23326734;252?48 27?145D633(4M9C279?2676<?1484<47897?3/H2?743343?14 :;927?2<<3 19E4 9;36 D4;248 B:67 865BC47?9D> 4E284754 C9DJ48 93 M3 978 93 H4;; 93 M3 % 978 $ 1236BD?193C4?25B;6B3;>4M9C2748?143928865BC47?3 H1251 275;B84 :D6:4D?> D456D83 ?9M :928 D4542:?3 978 6?14D D4E47B4 47?D243 :4D?92727@ ?6 ?14 3B2? 35148B;4 :D6:4D?> 14 ?9M D4542:?3 :D68B548 => ?14 :;927?2<<3 5;49D;> 56DD43:678 ?6 ?14 E4D> :D6:4D?> 8435D2=48 27 ?14 35148B;4 ?6 ?14 :;927? 147 ?1434 865BC47?3 9D4 567A627?;>D498H2?1?146D9;4E284754978?1498C2332673 4M?D95?488BD27@5D633(4M9C279?2676<?14567?43?27@ 84<47897? 978 9 D9C 97519>9? 6<<2529; 2? =456C43 4E2847? ?19? ?14 +2D3? ::4;;9?4 6BD? 193 - 12 - C972<43?;> 4DD48 27 E47?BD27@ 27?6 ?14 IB43?267 6< ?2?;4 H1251H93 H16;;>4M?D9746B3?6?14356:46<?14:D4347? :D6544827@3 14 5D633(4M9C279?267 6< 933BC43 :9D?25B;9D 32@72<259754 93 14 193 B74IB2E659;;> 98C2??48 ?19?:D6:4D?>=49D27@ 97519>9?6 (=4;67@3?6?14 :;927?2<<3 123 98C233267 H147 D498 27 ;2@1? 6< ?14 865BC47?9D> 4E284754 B7C23?9J9=;> 56DD6=6D9?43 ?14 :;927?2<<3/ :633433267 +BD?14D ?14 4E284754 6< ?14 97519>9?6<<2529; 567<2DC3 ?19? ?14 D456D83 :D68B548 => ?14:;927?2<<39D4@47B274 97519>9?D456D83C927?9274827 ?14 6D8279D> 56BD34 6< =B327433 978 8B;> 233B48 => ?14 56C:4?47? 9B?16D2?> 14 5BCB;9?2E4 4<<45? 6< ?123 4E284754 845232E4;> 43?9=;23143 ?19? ?14 :;927?2<<3 H4D4 27 ;9H<B;97834??;48:6334332676<?143B2?35148B;4:D6:4D?> 9367?1489?46<?143B2? - 13 - ? 23 9 34??;48 :D6:632?267 6< ;9H ?19? 27 9 3B2? <6D 27AB75?267 32C:;252?4D ?14 6BD? 23 76? D4IB2D48 ?6 4M9C274 6D 98AB8259?4 B:67 ?14 ?2?;4 6< ?14 :9D?243 978 ?14 84?4DC279?267 CB3? D43? 36;4;> B:67 ?14 <95?BC 6< :633433267 H74D312: 4E47 2< 2752847?9;;> 9334D?48 23 D4;4E97? 67;> ?6 ?14 ;2C2?48 4M?47? 6< 93343327@ H14?14D ?14 :;927?2<</3 :633433267 23 ;9H<B; 978 76? ?19? 6< 9 D97J ?D43:9334D 7 ?14 :D4347? 5934 ?14 C9?4D29;3 67 D456D8 :9D?25B;9D;> ?14 98C2??48 :632?267 4C4D@27@ <D6C ?14 5D633(4M9C279?267 6< 978 5675;B32E4;> 43?9=;231?19??14:;927?2<<3H4D427567?27B6B3:633433267 6< ?14 3B2? 35148B;4 :D6:4D?> 14 84<47897?3/ =9;8 978 B73B=3?97?29?489334D?267?19??14:;927?2<<39D49??4C:?27@ ?6 475D6951 B:67 ?142D ;978 => C972:B;9?27@ ?14 =6B789D243 23 D4784D48 =934;433 27 ;2@1? 6< ?142D 6H7 98C2332673 978 ?14 6<<2529; D456D83 :D68B548 => ?14 :;927?2<<3 ?14 :D2752:9; 567?43?27@ 84<47897? 193 59?4@6D259;;> 98C2??48 ?14 :;927?2<<3/ :633433267 6E4D ?14 - 14 - :D6:4D?> 27 IB43?267 2J4H234 =427@ 97 2784:47847? 6<<2529; H2?7433 193 567<2DC48 ?19? ?14 97519>9? D456D83 D4;248 B:67 => ?14 :;927?2<<3 9D4 9B?147?25 978 8B;> C927?92748 27 ?14 97519>9? 6<<254 B51 4E284754 4C979?27@ :9D?;> <D6C ?14 84<47897?3 ?14C34;E4397856DD6=6D9?48=>:B=;25D456D83;49E4376 C9774D 6< 86B=? ?19? ?14 :;927?2<<3 H4D4 27 34??;48 :633433267 14 +2D3? ::4;;9?4 6BD? 16H4E4D 823D4@9D848 ?123 E2?9; 93:45? 978 4DD6746B3;> 312<?48 2?3 <65B3?6?14:;927?2<<3/?2?;4H1251H9374E4D27233B4279 3B2?6<?12379?BD4 7E24H6<?14<6D4@627@8235B33267?1236BD?23 6<?145673284D486:27267?19??14+2D3?::4;;9?46BD?193 ?D9E4;;48=4>678?14356:46<?14:;49827@3978?14D4;24< 36B@1? => ?14 :;927?2<<3 14 233B4 =4<6D4 ?14 6BD? H93 567<2748 ?6 ?14 :;927?2<<3/ :633433267 978 ?14 9;;4@48 27?4D<4D4754 => ?14 84<47897?3, ?14 IB43?267 6< ?2?;4 H93 H16;;><6D42@7?6?1427IB2D>2793B2?<6D=9D427AB75?267 14 ::4;;9?4 6BD?/3 <27827@ ?19? ?14 :;927?2<<3 <92;48 ?6 - 15 - 43?9=;231?142D?2?;49782?356734IB47?D4E4D39;6<?14D29; 6BD?/3845D4423?14D4<6D4;4@9;;>B73B3?9279=;4 ! ? 23 9;36 :4D?2747? ?6 6=34DE4 ?19? ?14 +2D3? ::4;;9?46BD?H12;4D4E4D327@?14AB8@C47?6<?14D29; 6BD?19376?98E4D?48?66D9332@74897>56@47?D493673 ?6823;68@4?143:452<25<27827@3D456D848=>?14D29;6BD? 67?1493:45?6<:63343326714D29;6BD?1988235B3348 ?14 6D9; 978 865BC47?9D> 4E284754 27 84?92; 978 198 D2@1?;> 5675;B848 =9348 67 ?14 98C2332673 6< 978 ?19??14:;927?2<<3H4D427 ;9H<B; :633433267 6< ?14 3B2? :D6:4D?> 14 +2D3? ::4;;9?4 6BD? =427@ ?14 <279; <95?(<27827@ 9B?16D2?> H93 B784D 9 3?9?B?6D> 8B?> ?6 D4( 9::D4529?4 ?14 47?2D4 4E284754 978 9332@7 2784:47847? D49367327?4DC36<D84DN B;46<?146846<2E2; D6548BD4 ?3 <92;BD4 ?6 86 36 E2?29?43 2?3 <27827@3 D4784D27@ ?14 AB8@C47? :4DE4D34 978 567?D9D> ?6 ?14 34??;48:D2752:;436<9::4;;9?4D4E24H - 16 - % +6D ?1434 D493673 ?123 6BD? 16;83 ?19? ?14 +2D3?::4;;9?46BD?19356CC2??489@D9E44DD6D=6?127 ;9H97867<95?3=>E47?BD27@27?6?14233B46<?2?;4978=> D4E4D327@ ?14 H4;;(D4936748 <27827@3 6< ?14 D29; 6BD? H2?16B?97>8235B332676<?144E28475467:63343326714 <27827@ ?19? ?14 :;927?2<<3/ ?2?;4 H93 86B=?<B; 23 ?14D4<6D4 :9;:9=;> 4DD6746B3 978 :4DE4D34 6734IB47?;> B=3?97?29; &B43?267 6< 9H 6*2- 23 973H4D48 27 ?14 978 B=3?97?29; &B43?267 6< 9H 6*22- 23 973H4D48 27 ?14 16;827@ ?19? ?14 AB8@C47? 978845D446<?14+2D3?::4;;9?46BD?9D4B73B3?9279=;4 27;9H $ +6D ?14 <6D4@627@ D493673 978 27 E24H 6< ?14 <27827@3D456D84867?143B=3?97?29;IB43?26736<;9H?123 6BD?:D654483?6:933?14<6;;6H27@ *2- 149::49;2314D4=>9;;6H48 - 17 - *22- 14 AB8@C47? 978 845D44 89?48 :93348 => ?14 ;49D748 D2752:9;4726D2E2;"B8@4978124< "B82529; #9@23?D9?4 9;9=BD9@2 27 6 ! 2334?93284 *222- 14 AB8@C47? 978 845D44 89?48 D4784D48 => ?14 ;49D748 D2752:9;2E2;"B8@4*"B726D2E23267- 9;9=BD9@2 27 6 $ 23 D43?6D48978567<2DC48 *2E- 14 4@23?D> 23 82D45?48 ?6 8D9H ?14 845D449556D827@;> *E- 66D84D93?6563?3 -8 '$ $( % 23?6 ;6