Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43061 (KAR)
SRI M UDAYKUMAR SHETTY v. KALYANA KARNATAKA
WP/203029/2025 · 2025-10-08
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43061 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43061 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#$%!$!$
&$'
! " #
!!$ % & '
(( ! $
&
'
! %
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
)
(
$$ $$ (
(
')(
* !!$!$
#!$!$$ $ +
( $!$! !"$!$
!$!$$ $
(
+
' ) ( +
(
$!,$!$
+
' ) -
(
( (
(
)
. - 3 -
&
. '
/010123/4156/724/081529406/13:;::41/</=6>08/ /3=245/?/30=;0/=!!$!$<1=/ 33/@94/ 6>A81B8 815 4/C91510123 724 /@0/35123 27 D1B/3B/ E/412= 02 2BB9E> ;3= 493 08/ 69513/55 27 4/50;94;30 13 08/ E4/?15/5 6/D23:13: 02 08/ 4/5E23=/305;90824101/5 8;5 6//3 =/BD13/=
$ /5E23=/302 8;=13<10/=0/3=/45;9B012313: 105B2??/4B1;DE4/?15/523D1B/3B/D/;5/6;515724;E/412= 27 >/;45 =9413: 08/ ?2308 27 ;39;4> $!$ /010123/4 8;= E;401B1E;0/= ;3= A;5 =/BD;4/= 59BB/5579D 61==/4 13 4/5E/B0 27 ; 820/D E4/?15/ 13 B/304;D 69550;3= 1F;>;E94; 3 ;:4//?/30 A;5 ;BB24=13:D> /30/4/= 1302 6/0A//3 08/ E/010123/4 ;3= 08/ 4/5E23=/30 2$ 23 $$! $!$ 30/4?527A81B808/E/010123/4A;5;DD2A/= 022BB9E>;3=02493820/D69513/55724;E/412=27>/;45 B2??/3B13:742?! !$$!$ ;3=/@E1413:23, ! $!$
- 4 -
596F/B0 02 B23=10123 27 E;>?/30 27 D1B/3B/ 7// ;5 ?/30123/=08/4/13
, 8/ B;5/ 08/ E/010123/4 15 08;0 08/ ;724/5;1= ;:4//?/30 A81B8 A;5 /30/4/= 1302 15 =9/ 02 /@E14/ 23 , ! $!$ 08;0 513B/ 8/ 8;5 /50;6D158/= 815 69513/55 8;<13: ?24/ 08;3 $! /?ED2>//5 A24G13: 8/ 8;= 529:80 724 /@0/35123 27 D/;5/D1B/3B/ 724 ; 79408/4 E/412= 27 ! >/;45 59B8 4/E4/5/30;0123 A;5 ?;=/ 23 $!,$!$ ;5 E/4 33/@94/ 3 4/5E235/ 02 08/ 5;?/ 33/@94/ B;?/026/1559/=6>08/4/5E23=/3052308/E4/?15/08;0 08/4/153259B8E42<1512393=/408/49D/5724/@0/3512327 D/;5/D1B/3B/E/412=;5529:807246>08/E/010123/4/13: ;::41/</=6>08/5;?/08/E/010123/4156/724/08152940
# /;43/= B2935/D 724 08/ E/010123/4 ;EE/;413:
08429:8 <1=/2 B237/4/3B13: 0;G13: 0815 2940 08429:8 08/ 4/B24=5 4/7/45 02 /0/3=/4 320171B;0123 E42=9B/= ;0 33/@94/ 4;A13: ;00/30123 27 0815 2940 02 D;95/ E42<1=13: 724 D1B/3B/ E/412= 8/ 596?105 08;0 08/4/ 15 ;3
- 5 -
2E0123 724:4;30 27D1B/3B/ E/412= 724 !>/;45 ;3= 513B/ 08/4/15;E42<15123724E42<1=13:D1B/3B/724;E/412=27 ! >/;45 08/ 4/5E23=/30;90824101/5 B;3320 BD;1? 02 08/ B2304;4> / ;D52 4/7/44/= 02 =2B9?/30 ;0 33/@94/ A81B81508/B244/5E23=/3B/=;0/= $!$!$ ;EE;4/30D> 1559/= 6> 08/ 4/5E23=/30;90824101/5 13 7;<294 27 23/ 4;G;58 8/00> /7/4413: 02 08/ 5;?/ D/;43/= B2935/D 596?10508;008/4/5E23=/30;90824101/58;</;BB24=/=08/ 4/C9/50 27 08/ 5;1= E/4523 6> 79408/4 /@0/3=13: 08/ D/;5/D1B/3B/E/412=724>/;4513B/08/E/010123/415;D52 51?1D;4D>5109;0/=15/3010D/=72404/;0?/3023E;410>895 23 08/5/ 0A2 :4293=5 D/;43/= B2935/D 724 08/ E/010123/4 135150508/E4;>/427E/010123/46/:4;30/=6>C9;5813:08/ /3=245/?/30;0 33/@94/ ;3==14/B013:08/4/5E23=/305 02B2351=/48154/E4/5/30;0123;0 33/@94/6>/@0/3=13:
08/D/;5/724;E/412=27 !>/;45
/;4=/495/=08/4/B24=5
- 6 -
=?100/=D>08/E/010123/48;56//3;DD200/=08/ E4/?15/56/D23:13:024/5E23=/302 72408/E94E25/27 493313: 4/50;94;30 13 0/4?5 27 ;3 ;:4//?/30 =;0/= ! !$$!$ 724 ; E/412= 27
>/;45 /@E1413: 23 , !
$!$ A81B8 15 E4/B/=/= 6> 0/3=/4 320171B;0123 13 A81B8 08/ E/010123/4 A;5 8/D= 02 6/ 59BB/5579D 61==/4 13B/ 08/ 5;1= E/412= 27 >/;45 15 =9/ 02 /@E14/ 23 , ! $!$ 08/ 4/5E23=/30;90824101/5 8;</ 1559/= / 0/3=/4=;0/= !"$!$B;DD13:72408/130/4/50/=E;401/5 02 E;401B1E;0/ 13 08/ 5/D/B0123 E42B/55 0 D2 27 08/ 5;1=/0/3=/4320171B;012308/E4/?15/5E4/5/30D>2BB9E1/= 6> 08/ E/010123/4 15 582A3 ;5 H=9/ 02 6/ <;B;0/= 23 , ! $!$I 8/ D;50 =;0/ 724 71D13: ;3= E;401B1E;013: 13 08/0/3=/4E42B/5515 , !$!$
/;43/=B2935/D72408/E/010123/47;14D>596?105 08;0 08/4/ 15 32 1?E/=1?/30 724 08/ E/010123/4 02 E;401B1E;0/ 13 08/ ;724/5;1= 0/3=/4 E42B/55 2A/</4 815 23D>;EE4/8/351231508;0513B/08/E/010123/48;5;D4/;=>
- 7 -
/50;6D158/581569513/5508/0/3=/4E42B/5558;DD320B;95/ ;3>=150946;3B/135?2208493313:2708/69513/55
/7/4/3B/?;=/6>08/D/;43/=B2935/D72408/ E/010123/40208/=94;012327D1B/3B/E/412=;5?/30123/=;0 ;4;:4;E82708/5;1=/0/3=/4=2B9?/30152732;<;1D 13;5?9B8;5130/4?52708/5;1=;4;:4;E808/E/412= 27 D1B/3B/ 13 4/5E/B0 27 582E5 2E/3 5E;B/ 6;3G ;3= 08/ 2771B/5E;B/026/95/=6><;4129524:;31J;012352B1/01/515 23D>724;E/412=27>/;45A81D/08/E/412=27D1B/3B/724 08/E94E25/27=24?1024>D2=:13:;3=029415082?/15724 ! >/;45 8/ E/010123/4 15 B;44>13: 23 08/ 69513/55 27 820/D4/50;94;30A81B8=2/53207;DDA1081308/B;0/:24>27 =24?1024>D2=:13:0294150 82?/ 3 ;3> /</30 08/ 5;1= ;4;:4;E8 B;3320 6/ 4/;= 02 ?/;3 08/ E/010123/4 15 /3010D/=724/@0/3512327E/412=A108290E;401B1E;013:1308/ 0/3=/4E42B/55 559B8 08/ :4293= 94:/= 13 0815 4/:;4= B;33206/;BB/E0/=
" 8/4/7/4/3B/?;=/02 33/@94/
130/4?527 A81B8 08/ 4/5E23=/305 8;= E94E240/=D> /@0/3=/= 08/
- 8 -
E/412=27D/;5/134/5E/B023/4;G;588/00>15;D522732 ;<;1D 13;5?9B8 ;5 59B8 /@0/35123 8;= 6//3 ;EE;4/30D> :4;30/=23 $!$!$ 1379408/4;3B/02B/40;1350;3=13: 24=/45 6/;413: 2 !$!$! ?/30123/= 13 08/ 5;1= =2B9?/30259B850;3=13:24=/45;4/E42=9B/=
! 20A10850;3=13:08/;62</513B/08/E42B/5527 ;DD20?/30 27 E4/?15/5 6> 08/ 4/5E23=/30;90824101/5 15 93=/40;G/36>13<1013:/0/3=/45;3=1308/D1:802708/4/ 6/13:321?E/=1?/3072408/E/010123/402E;401B1E;0/0815 2940 =2 320 5// ;3> 4/;523 02 130/47/4/ 13 08/ E42B/55 /<2D</= 6> 08/ 4/5E23=/305 13 ;DD20013: 08/ E4/?15/5 08429:8/0/3=/4E42B/55 8/E/010123 D;BG5 ?/410;3=15 ;BB24=13:D>=15?155/=
!() &$!$' %
$,