- 1 - ! " #$ %#&!#!# '!!( !"#$ % & $ & '!"#$% ( & & &&& !$$$ % & !$ Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !"#$ # && !"$ && && !"#$ ) '!"#$ ( * & #) %%) %%+ , ' ! $% %$%%!%%"$-%$%% .! ! $% %$%%!%$+$+%$% .! ) %%%$% /0/12/ !% %$%%!% # .! 3 & & & & 4&&& - 3 - 5/ 6/787891/:; 52;3,1< ,1< =8>/ ,:/ 3/>9:/ 758; 92:7;//?81@>9AA9=81@:/A8/>B;* C, ;;2/ , =:87 9> D/:789:,:8 <8:/D7891 E2,;581@ 75/9:</:6,;;/<3F:<:/;691</1781>8A/9 ! $% %$%%!% <,7/< %"$-%$%% 08</ 11/G2:/! 81 >8A/ 9 ! $% %$%%!% <,7/< $+$+%$% 08</ 11/G2:/! ,1< 75/ 9:</: 6,;;/< 3F 75/ )75 :/;691</17 <,7/< %%%$% 81 >8A/ 9 :/0/12/ !% %$%%!% # 08</ 11/G2:/! 7975/=:876/787891 3 ;;2/ ,1F 975/: 9:</: <8:/D7891 81 08/= 9> 75/ >,D7; ,1< D8:D2H;7,1D/; 9> 75/ D,;/ 91 5,1< <8:/D781@75/:/;691</17,2759:878/;796,F75/D9;7 9>75/6:/;/17=:876/7878917975/6/787891/:;I % /787891/: 9 =,; ,669817/< ,; 69;7 H,;7/: 3F 75/ :/;691</17; 691 ,1 ,AA/@,7891 9> H8;,66:96:8,7891 9> >21<; 5/ =,; ;2;6/1</< 6/1<81@ <8;D86A81,:F 6:9D//<81@; 1978D/ =,; 8;;2/< 3F 75/ :/;691</179D,AA81@269175/6/787891/:979D:/<87 ,;2H9>;#)%""# !=87581$<,F;9175/6:/H8;/9> ;,H/3/81@75/,H9217H8;,66:96:8,7/<3F75/6/787891/: 9 /;691</17 9 8;;2/< , ;59=!D,2;/ 1978D/ 79 6/787891/: 9 ,66,:/17AF 91 75/ 3,;8; 9> 75/ - 4 - :/6:/;/17,7891 H,</ 3F :/;691</17 9 3/>9:/ :/;691</17 9# >9: :/D90/:F 9> ,1 ,H9217 9> ;#)$""# ! ,; ,::/,:; 9> A,1< :/0/12/ 592@5 <8;D86A81,:F /1E28:F =,; 81878,7/< 1/875/: ,1F ,:78DA/; 9> D5,:@/; 5,0/ 3//1 8;;2/< 19: ,1F 1978D/ 9> /1E28:F 5,; 3//1 8;;2/< 79 6/787891/: 9 581@; ;799< 752; :/;691</17 9)!,5;8A<,: 8;;2/< ,1 9:</: <,7/< %"$-%$%% <8:/D781@ 75/ 6/787891/: 9 79 </69;87 75/ ,H9217DA,8H/<3F:/;691</179>,8A81@=58D5,D7891; 21</:75/:908;891;9>,1</0/12/D7-)#=92A<3/ 81878,7/< /,:1/< D921;/A >9: 75/ 6/787891/:; 7,?81@ 758; 92:7 75:92@5 75/ :/D9:< ;23H87; 75,7 =5/1 ,<H877/<AF /1E28:F 8; ;78AA 81 6:9@:/;; ,1< 19 D91DA2;891 5,; 3//1 ,::80/<,7/;7,3A8;581@75/@28A79:75/A8,38A87F9>6/787891/: 975/:/;691</17,2759:878/;D92A<1975,0/0/172:/< 79 8;;2/ 75/ 1978D/; D9HH218D,7891 ,; 9> 75/ 91/ 81 75/ 6:/;/17D,;/,77,D581@,1<6:969;81@79;/AA19791AF75/ 6:96/:7F3/A91@/<796/787891/:9327,A;975/6:96/:7F - 5 - 3/A91@/< 79 6/787891/: 9% / >2:75/: 0/5/H/17AF ;23H87;75,781,1F/0/17:/;691</17,2759:878/;5,0/19 ,2759:87F 79 ;//?,77,D5H/17 ,1< ;,A/ 9> 75/ 6:96/:7F 9> 6/787891/: 9% =59 8; 1/875/: ,1 /H6A9F// 19: 5,; @97 ,1F7581@79<9=87575/,<H818;7:,78919>75/:/;691</17; 5/:/>9:/5/;23H877/<75/9:</:7975,7/G7/178;6:8H, >,D8/ 8AA/@,A ,1< =875927 J2:8;<8D7891 /1D/ ;//?; >9: ,AA9=81@9>75/6/787891 # 1 :/;691;/ :82<58:;81@5 8J,F62: A/,:1/< /627F 9A8D879: /1/:,A 9> 1<8, ,66/,:81@ >9: 75/ :/;691</17!,2759:878/; >8A81@ 75/ ;7,7/H/17 9> 93J/D7891; ,1< :/>/::81@ 79 75/ <9D2H/17; 75/:/81 ;23H87; 75,7 75/ /1E28:F 5,; ,A:/,<F 3//1 D9H6A/7/< ,1< 75/ /1E28:F :/69:7 81<8D,7/ 75/ @28A7 9> 6/787891/: 9 5,081@ 3//1 6:90/<,1<75/D5,:@/;5//78;3/81@8;;2/< /;23H87; 75,775/D9HH218D,7891,711/G2:/!=,; 8;;2/<7975/ /@891,A 9HH8;;891/: ,; , 6:/D,27891 79 ;/D2:/ 75/ ,;;/7;9>75/6/787891/:79:/D90/:75/,H9217=58D55,< 3//1 H8;,66:96:8,7/< / ;23H87; 75,7 75/ ;,8< ,D7891 8; - 6 - 91AF ,; , 6:/D,27891,:F H/,;2:/ ,1< 197581@ H9:/ / ;23H87; 75,7 >2:75/: ,D7891 =92A< 3/ 7,?/1 ,>7/: D9H6A/7891 9> <8;D86A81,:F /1E28:F ,; D917/H6A,7/< 21</: 75//17:,A808A2A/;A,;;8>8D,7891917:9A,1<66/,A 2A/; -) 5/:/>9:/ 5/ ;23H87; 75,7 6/787891/: 5,; 19 D,2;/ 9> ,D7891 79 H,817,81 75/ 6/787891 ,1< ;//?; >9: <8;H8;;,A9>6/787891 /,:<6/:2;/<75/:/D9:<; ) 11/G2:/;! ,1< ,:/ 75/ D9HH218D,7891; 8;;2/< 3F :/;691</17 9 79 75/ :/;691</17 9# ;//?81@ 79 8109?/ /D7891 # 9> 75/ 23A8D DD9217,17B; />,2A7D7%9>"$>9:;59:7K75/D7B81:/;6/D79> 6:96/:78/; 3/A91@81@ 79 75/ 6/787891/: 9; ,1< % :/;6/D780/AF + /D7891#9>75/23A8DDD9217,17B;/>,2A7D7 :/,<;,;21</:* #)*+,-./01,,-0.10.*102*-)+./+* !5/6/:;919:6/:;91;,775/5/,<9>75/9>>8D/ 79 =58D5 ,1F 623A8D ,DD9217,17 3/A91@; H,F - 7 - 6:9D//<,@,81;7,1F;2D5623A8D,DD9217,17,1< 58; ;2:/78/; >9: ,1F A9;; 9: </>,AD,7891 81 58; ,DD9217; ,; 8> 75/ ,H9217 75/:/9> =/:/ ,1 ,::/,:9>A,1<!:/0/12/<2/7990/:1H/17 " 5/ ,AA/@,7891 ,@,81;7 75/ 6/787891/: 8; H8;,66:96:8,78919>75/>21<;7975//G7/179>#)$""# ! 592@5 87 8; D917/17/< 3F 75/ :/;691</17 75,7 , /1E28:F 5,; 3//1 D91<2D7/< 81 =58D5 75/ @28A7 9> 75/ 6/787891/: 9 5,; 3//1 6:90/< ,1< 75/ ,:78DA/; 9> D5,:@/; 5,0/ 3//1 19= 8;;2/< >9: 75/ 62:69;/ 9> 81878,781@ ,1< D91<2D781@ 75/ <8;D86A81,:F 6:9D//<81@; 75/ >,D7 :/H,81; 75,775/<8;D86A81,:F6:9D//<81@;5,0/1973//1D91DA2</< F/7592@575/:/8;,D91;8</:,3A/>9:D/8175/;23H8;;891 3/81@ H,</ 3F 75/ A/,:1/< D921;/A79 75/ 6/787891/:75,7 2178A ,1< 21A/;; /1E28:F D917/H6A,7/< 21</: 75/ A,= 8; D9H6A/7/<75/:/;691</17!,2759:878/;D,11976:/D91D/80/ 75/@28A79>75/6/787891/:9798109?//D7891#9>75/ D77975//G7/17,77,D581@75/6:96/:78/;9>75/6/787891/: 9 ,; =/AA ,; 6/787891/: 9 % 79 :/D90/: 75/ 6:9D//<; 7:/,781@ ,; , A,1< :/0/12/ ,; ;23H877/< 3F 75/ A/,:1/< - 8 - /627F 9A8D879: /1/:,A 9> 1<8, >9: :/;691</17! ,2759:878/;878;91AF,6:/D,27891,:FH/,;2:/ - 2:75/: 75/ 11/G2:/! 8; ,1 9>>8D8,A H/H9:,1<2H <,7/< %%%$% 8;;2/< 3F 75/ ,5;8A<,: =58D5H/:/AF;,F;75//17:FH,</8175/D9A2H199> 75/ :/>A/D781@ ,::/,:; 9> A,1< :/0/12/ 9> ;#$+% ! 81 :/;6/D7 9> A,1< 3/,:81@ F9%$) # H/,;2:81@ ,D:/; @217,; 5/ ;,H/ 81 ,1F /0/17 D,1197 3/ >921< 79 3/ D,2;81@ ,1F 8H6/<8H/17 79 75/ 6/787891/:9 $ /75,7,;878;8175/A8@579>;23H8;;891H,</ 3F A/,:1/< /627F 9A8D879: /1/:,A 9> 1<8, 75/ D9HH218D,7891; ,7 11/G2:/;! ,1< =/:/ 91AF ,; , 6:/D,27891,:F H/,;2:/ 79 ;,>/@2,:< 75/ 623A8D >21< ,1< 75,7>2:75/:,D7891=92A<3/81878,7/<91AF2691D9H6A/7891 9> 75/ /1E28:F D917/H6A,7/< 758; 92:7 <9 197 ;// ,1F :/,;9179?//6758;H,77/:6/1<81@ - 9 - 175,708/=9>75/H,77/:6/7878918; =87575/>9AA9=81@<8:/D7891;* , 5/ :/;691</17!,2759:878/; =92A< 3/ /1787A/< 796:9D//<79:/D90/:75/,H9217;<2/8>91 D91DA2;8919>75//1E28:FD917/H6A,7/<21</: A,= 87 8; >921< 75,7 75/ 6/787891/: 9 8; @28A7F 9> H8;,66:96:8,7891 8AA ;2D5 78H/ 75/ :/;691</17!,2759:878/; ;5,AA 197 6:/D8687,7/ 75/H,77/: 3 81D/ 6/787891/: 9% =59 8; 75/ =8>/ 9> 6/787891/:9D917/1<75,7;5/5,;197581@ 79 <9 =875 75/ ,AA/@,7891; H,</ ,@,81;7 6/787891/: 9 ,1< 75/ 592;/ 6:96/:7F 3/A91@; 79 5/: ;5/ 8; ,7 A83/:7F 79 H,?/ 1/D/;;,:F :/6:/;/17,7891 79 75/ :/;691</17! 9;//?81@,66:96:8,7/9:</:79:/A/,;/5/: 6:96/:7F >:9H ;2D5 ,77,D5H/17 ,1< 9:</: 75/:/91 ;5,AA 3/ 6,;;/< 3F :/;691</17 9 - 10 - =87581 )$ <,F; >:9H 75/ <,7/ 9> 6/787891/: 9%H,?81@:/6:/;/17,7891 D /787891/:9;5,AA19759=/0/:D:/,7/,1F 758:<6,:7F817/:/;790/:75/6:96/:7F3/,:81@ F9%$) # H/,;2:81@ ,D:/; @217,; /787891/:9%;5,AA,A;9197D:/,7/,1F758:< 6,:7F 817/:/;7 2178A <8;69;,A 9> 5/: :/6:/;/17,78913F:/;691</179 !23 '#!#( & & 8;79A9%#