Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43058 (KAR)
SMT. DAYAMANI AND ANR v. THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER AND ORS
WP/200427/2024 · 2025-09-23
Jyoti Mulimani
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43058 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43058 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$"%%!""
&'
!"#"$%
&
"
!"#"$% '
( )
**"#"$%
**"#"$%
**
"#"$% '
( &+ &)
Digitally signed by PREMCHANDRA M R Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
* *
* &
*
*
,-
./01/02/34567893:5.2;9<92/2/579.807=./03;0. 05 0357> ?/2; ./033/@0.A67 0;6@0. :5. 2;9 .98<57=9728;0190<<90.9=/7<9.857
;940<2/579=./292/2/57/8:/39=899@/7>:5335?/7> .93/9:8 0) 5/88690?./25:9.2/5.0./5.0=/.942/5725B608;2;9 5.=9. =029= %%$ /7 */39 5
%$
$ <0889= CD 2;9 :/.82 .98<57=972 062;5./2D08/339>0307=0.C/2.0.D1/=9779E6.9+ C) 5/88690?./25:07=0F68=/.942/7>.98<57=9728 07= 752 25 =93929 2;9 70F9 5: 2;9 <92/2/579.8 /7 .98<942 5: D 5"G
("G
) F9086./7> %$ 4.98 # 67208 8/26029= 02 F030<6. /330>9 036@0 07= /82./42/=0. ;9<92/2/57019.F97280867=9. - 3 -
2 /8 82029= 2;02 <92/2/579. 5 /8 2;9 93=9. 857 /7 2;9 :0F/3D 07= ?08 /8869= ?/2; ,- *5.F 67=9. *5.F 5 /7 .98<942 5: <5.2/57 5: 307= /7 D 5"G
("G
) F9086./7> %$ 4.98 # 67208 8/26029= 02 F030<6. /330>9 036@ 07= /82./42 /=0. /7 */39
5
#G
GG$
# =029= %#%GG$ .945>7/H/7> 67062;5./H9= 4632/102/57 /7 .98<942 5:
519.7F972 307= 2 /8 80/= 2;02 2;9 307= C90./7> D 5"G 252033D F9086./7> G 4.98 # 67208 ?08 5./>/7033D ,0/.070- 307= 07= 2;9.9 ?9.9 ;56898 C9/7> 45782.6429= 67=9. 4;9F9 25 2;9 5::/49 5: 07= .945>7/H/7> 2;9 9E2972 5:
67062;5./H9= 4632/102/57 CD <92/2/579. 5 0 49.2/:/4029 5:
.9>/82.02/57 ?08 /8869= <6.86072 2;9.925 /7 2;9 70F9 5:
<92/2/579. 5?;/4;?08=63D9729.9=/72;9.919769.945.=8 07= 8/749 ;9 ?08 .9<.98972/7> 2;9 A5/72 :0F/3D ;/8 F52;9.-8 70F9 /9 0D0F07/
591/=08 (<92/2/579. 5) ?08 9729.9= /7 2;9 .919769 .945.=8 CD 1/.269 5: 6202/57
5
GGG 6.86072 25 /8860749 5: ,- *5.F 2;9 .919769 062;5./2/98 /=972/:/9= 2;9 <5.2/57 5: 2;9 <.5<9.2D 4632/1029= CD 2;9<92/2/579.8/7252039E29725:D 5"G07=/8088/>79=?/2; /880 5CD=.0?/7>08@924;
- 4 -
8 2;/7>8 8255= 2;68 <92/2/579. 5 ?08 /8869= ?/2; 0 752/49CD2;95::/495:2;988/820725FF/88/579.C089=572;9 0339>9= .9<5.2 .949/19= CD 2;9 2;/.= .98<57=972 .9>0.=/7> 0339>9= 974.504;F972 07= 80F9 C9/7> 430/F9= 08 ,99F9= *5.982-082;90;8/3=0.0339>9=3D;07=9=519.2;980/=307=25 2;9 *5.982 9<0.2F972 1/=9 39229. =029= %#GG 07= 2;9.9:5.9 856>;2 25 457=642 07 /7B6/.D ;9 <92/2/579.8 86CF/229=0332;9.945.=8<9.20/7/7>252;9307=07=856>;225 =.5< 2;9 <.5499=/7>8 5?919. 2;9 2;/.= .98<57=972 :/39= 5CA942/578.93D/7>6<572;93/825:,-07=,-307=8856>;225C9 2.078:9..9=CD2;90;8/3=0./7:015.5:*5.9829<0.2F972 2 /8 457297=9= 2;02 C089= 57 2;9 4572972/578 .0/89= CD 2;92;/.=.98<57=9722;988/820725FF/88/579.<.5499=9=25 ;53=2;022;90;8/3=0.;0=75062;5./2D25/88695.=9.5:>.072 CD457297=/7>2;022;9307=C9/7>3088,-07=,-674632/10C39 307= 07= 80F9 ?08 ;07=9= 519. 25 2;9 *5.982 9<0.2F972 /7 GG 2 /8 0385 5C89.19= 2;02 2;9 86CA942 307= :0338 ?/2;/7 @F8.0=/685:/=0.67/4/<03/F/282;9.9:5.92;9>.072F0=9 CD0;8/3=0./84572.0.D25639%(/1)5:&0.7020@007=.072 6398GG07=;93=2;0286CA942307=/8*5.982307=07=7520
- 5 -
.919769 307= 07= 2;9 <.51/8/578 5: 07= .072 6398 0.9 752 0<<3/40C39 07= <.5499= 25 89208/=9 2;9 5.=9. 5: 0;8/3=0.
/886/7>*5.F57%#%GG$2?080385=/.9429=2;02307=25 C9 .986F9= 07= 19829= /7 2;9 519.7F972 :.99 :.5F 033 9746FC.07498 07= =/.9429= 2;9 0;8/3=0. 25 F0@9 972./98 /7 08 ,*5.982 9<0.2F972 519.7F972 5: &0.7020@0- /7 ;55F/ 5:2?0.9 1/=9 5.=9. =029= %%$ 7=9. 2;989 4/.46F82074982;9<92/2/579.80.9C9:5.92;/856.2 $ 567893 :5. 2;9 .98<942/19 <0.2/98 6.>9= 8919.03 4572972/578 .>/7> 8919.03 4572972/578 4567893 :5. 2;9 <92/2/579. <3049=.93/0749572;9=94/8/57/7
& /7 5%%%G
% =/8<589= 5:57$%% ;9 82029F972 5: 5CA942/578 /8 :/39= CD 2;9 519.7F972 .>/7>8919.034572972/5782;9519.7F972<3049=.93/074957 2;9:5335?/7>=94/8/578 ) * & &
I
%G%
GG
- 6 -
)
*
I ()
GG * GG )
*
I%"
"$ 90.= 2;9 0.>6F9728 07= <9.689= 2;9 ./2 <0<9.8 ?/2; 40.9
" ;9 :0428 0.9 86::/4/9723D 80/= 07= =5 752 .9B6/.9 .9/29.02/57;9/8869.91531980.567=2;99E9.4/895:2;9<5?9. CD 2;9 88/82072 5FF/88/579. 67=9. 2;9 <.51/8/578 5: 2;9 &0.7020@007=91976942G$6::/49/22575292;022;9 307= /7 D 5"G F9086./7> G 4.98 # 67208 8/26029= 02 F030<6./330>9?0800/.070307=07=2;980F9?0867=9. 4632/102/575:67062;5./H9=<9.85787=9.0 52/:/402/57 5 G=029=G%GG2;90;08/3=0./8869=09.2/:/4029 5:0>6103/;/2/7:015.5:<92/2/579. 5 2/80.>69=57C9;03:5:2;9519.7F9722;022;9307=/7 B6982/57/83088,-07=,-674632/10C39307=07=2;90;8/3=0. 1/=939229.%#GG2.078:9..9=07=;07=9=519.2;9307=25 2;9*5.9829<0.2F9722/80.>69=57C9;03:5:2;9<92/2/579. - 7 -
2;02 2;9 307= /7 D 5"G /8 79/2;9. 0 752/:/9= 75. 0 .989.19= :5.982 67=9. 942/57 $ 5: 2;9 *5.982 42 75. /8 /2 0 =99F9= :5.982 57 /782.642/57 86CF/28 2;02 52/:/402/57 67=9. 942/57$/8752/8869=/7.98<9425:307=88/26029=02F030<6. /330>9 >.902=9035:0.>6F972/80==.9889=0C5628942/57$5: 2;9*5.98242;9@9D08<94285:2;90.>6F972?089E0F/79= 942/57 $ 5: 2;9 *5.982 42 =9038 ?/2; 752/:/402/57 CD 2;9 >519.7F97207=/2.90=808:5335?8 942/57$ 52/:/402/57CD519.7F972I();97919./2 ;08C997=94/=9=2545782/262907D307=0.989.19=:5.9822;9 2029519.7F9728;033/88690752/:/402/57 (0) =9430./7> 2;02 /2 ;08 C997=94/=9= 2545782/2629 864;307=0.989.19=:5.982J (C) 8<94/:D/7> 08 790.3D 08 <588/C39 2;9 8/2602/57 07=3/F/285:864;307=J07= (4) 0<<5/72/7> 07 5::/49. (;9.9/70:29. 40339= 2;9 K*5.982 92239F972 ::/49.L) 25 /7B6/.9 /725 07= =929.F/79 2;9 9E/829749 7026.9 07= 9E2972 5:
07D ./>;28 430/F9= CD 5. 0339>9= 25 9E/82 /7
- 8 -
:0156. 5: 07D <9.857 /7 5. 519. 07D 307= 45F<./89= ?/2;/7 864; 3/F/28 5. /7 5. 519. 07D :5.982 <.5=649 07= 25 =903 ?/2; 2;9 80F9 08 <.51/=9=/72;/8;0<29. () ;9 5::/49. 0<<5/729= 67=9. 430689 (4) 5: 86C 8942/57 () 8;033 C9 0 <9.857 752 ;53=/7> 07D :5.982 5::/49 9E49<2 2;02 5: *5.982 92239F972 ::/49.JC620*5.982::/49.F0DC90<<5/729=CD 2;9 2029 519.7F972 25 .9<.98972 /2 /7 2;9 /7B6/.D 67=9. 2;/8 ;0<29. CD 2;9 *5.982 92239F972::/49.
;9 519.7F972 ;08 <3049= .93/0749 57 0 82029F972 8;5?/7> 2;9 .9F0/7/7> ,- 07= ,- 3088 307= (519.7F972 07=) 2.078:9..9= 25 2;9 *5.982 9<0.2F972 5: 036@0 /=0. 8/>79= CD 2;9 0;8/3=0. 57 %#GG 25 457297= 2;02 2;9 :5.982 307= 4563= 752 ;019 C997 >.0729= 25 2;9 89457= <92/2/579. 0>6103/;/24563=752;019C997/8869=/7.98<942 5:0:5.982307=;94572972/575:2;9519.7F9722;02/2-80 :5.982307=407752C986820/79=08/2/8</152032575292;022;9 *5.98242;0845F9/725:5.49/7G;5?919./72;90C89749
- 9 -
5: 0 752/:/402/57 67=9. 942/57 $ 5: 2;9 &0.7020@0 *5.982 42 2;9 0;8/3=0. 0<<90.8 25 ;019 <.9<0.9= 0 82029F972 2;02 2;9 86CA942 307= ;08 C997 2.078:9..9= 25 2;9 *5.982 9<0.2F972
99=3988 25 80D 2;9 *5.982 42 F07=0298 /8860749 5: 0
52/:/402/5767=9.942/57$803.90=D7529=0C5192;9.9/8 75 52/:/402/57 67=9. 942/57 $ 5: 2;9 &0.7020@0 *5.982 42 G;9.9:5.92;94572972/575:2;9519.7F9722;02/2/80 :5.982307=F6827949880./3D:0/3
9E2 392 F9 4578/=9. ?;92;9. 2;9 88/82072 5FF/88/579.4563=;0197633/:/9=2;9*5.F0:29.030<895:
03F582 2?972D7/79 D90.8 ;9 078?9. /8 75 ;9 .90857 /8 8/F<39 ;9 30? /8 ?933 892239= 2;02 2;9 <5?9. F682 C9 9E9.4/89=?/2;/70.908570C392/F972;9<.9897240892;9.9 /807/75.=/7029=930D7FD1/9?2;9<.5499=/7>80.94390.3D C0..9=CD304;98*6.2;9.F5.92;9519.7F9724563=752;019 9E9.4/89=<5?9.254074932;9>.0728572;9>.567=2;022;9.9 /8 0 1/5302/57 5: 639 %# 5: 2;9 &0.7020@0 07= 919769 6398 567893:5.2;9.98<942/19<0.2/98<3049=.93/0749572;9 =94/8/578 .9:9..9= 25 86<.0 =5 752 2;/7@ 2;02 2;9 30? /8 /7
- 10 -
=56C204;=94/8/5726.7857/285?7:0428;9<.989724089/8 038529829=/72;93/>;25:2;90:5.980/==94/8/578 *5.2;9.90857882029=0C5192;95.=9.5:2;988/82072 5FF/88/579. /8 3/0C39 25 C9 892 08/=9 445.=/7>3D /2 /8 892 08/=9
;9 ./2 5: 9.2/5.0./ /8 5.=9.9= ;9 .=9. =029= %%$ <0889= CD 2;9 88/82072 5FF/88/579. /7 */39
5 %$
$ 1/=9 779E6.9+ /8 B608;9= # 986320723D2;9./292/2/57/8 940689 5: 2;9 =/8<5803 5: 2;9 ./2 92/2/57 <97=/7> /729.354625.D 0<<3/402/578 /: 07D 0.9 =/8<589= 5: 07= 2;9 /729./F=/.942/57/:07D8207=8=/84;0.>9=
() &%!""' %
&
/82 53 5