- 1 - !" #!$!! !% & '(')*& +'** , ! " #$%& % & ' %(&& %%(( ! $ %%(&& & $$%!) " #$ %%$ %' Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % ( *) ( % !+!+ $ % ( !+!+! % +*!+!+ $ % +!+ $ % ( % (( % ( ( % % , % %-$ #%-$ ' ./0/121234/5243!+!+!341./627/361./ 7/854/9 992123487 /4235 2:27 ;9</ 849 ( 2=8>80;58 ?635 @.351 A5287 3;51BC 2@ 2D0;<424< 1./ =;9<D/41 981/9 !+!+ E34:2E124< .2D 635 1./ 366/4E/@ 0;42@.8F7/ ;49/5 /E1234@ +)* 849 ! 36 49284/48739/?635@.351ABC849/E1234)361./ 49284 3135 /.2E7/@ E1 ?635 @.351 A E1BC 849 @/41/4E24< .2D 13 08> 624/ 36 @!!! 635 1./ 366/4E/ 0;42@.8F7/ ;49/5 /E1234 +)* 36 13 ;49/5<3 @2D07/ - 3 - 2D052@34D/41635@2GD341.@8491308>624/36@!!! 635 1./ 366/4E/ 0;42@.8F7/ ;49/5 /E1234 ! 36 H 6;51./5 ./ @.877 08> 624/ 36 @!!! 635 1./ 366/4E/ 0;42@.8F7/ ;49/5 /E1234 ) 36 E1 I21. 9/68;71 @/41/4E/@ I.2E. I8@ E34625D/9 24 57 3+!+ 34 +*!+!+ 34 1./ 627/ 36 1./ 992123487 2@152E1 849 /@@234@ ;9</ 2=8>80;58 ?635 @.351 A(25@1 00/7781/ 3;51BC + %/859 52 .82184>8J;D85 .84952J2 7/854/9 E3;4@/7 635 1./ 5/:2@234 0/121234/5 849 52 8D8985 .8.8F;99247/854/9%2<.3;513:/54D/417/89/5635 1./5/@0349/41181//5;@/91./D81/5287@345/E359 4 :2/I 36 1./ 52:87 @;FD2@@234@ D89/ F> 1./ 7/854/9E3;4@/7@635F31.1./08512/@1./032411.81I3;79 852@/635D>E34@29/5812342@ - 4 - > 84@I/5 13 1./ 8F3:/ 03241 2@ 6351./63773I24< 1 2@ 1./ E341/41234 36 1./ 053@/E;1234 1.81 34 !+!*81!0D1./8EE;@/9F/24<1./952:/536 1./84J/5F/8524<5/<2@15812343&+ +!)953:/1./ @8D/24858@.8494/<72</41D844/584981.2<.@0//9 /4984</524< .;D84 726/ 849 98@./9 13 1./ 1I3 I.//7/5 F/8524< 5/<2@1581234 3&++* 8@ 8 5/@;71 36 I.2E.1./529/5361./1I3I.//7/5@;@1824/96818724=;52/@ 849@;EE;DF/9131./@8D/341./@8D/98>I.27/18J24< 15/81D/41241./ 2@152E1%3@021872=8>80;58 ./ ;4E7/ 36 1./ 9/E/8@/9 627/9 1./ 625@1 24635D812348@0/5G8<824@11./ 52:/5361./184J/5 877/<24<1.81./.8@E3DD211/91./366/4E/;49/5/E1234@ +)*849!36849;49/5/E1234)36 E1 ./ ( E8D/ 13 F/ 5/<2@1/5/9 849 24:/@12<81234 I8@ - 5 - ;49/518J/4 61/5 24:/@12<81234 62487 5/0351 E8D/ 13 F/ 627/9 /854/9 8<2@1581/ 133J E3<42K84E/ 36 1./ 366/4E/ 849 5/<2@1/5/9 3!+!+! ./ 8EE;@/9 800/85/9F/635/1./52873;5184907/89/9431<;271>635 1./366/4E/@877/</9./053@/E;1234/G8D24/9,@13 ) 849 <31 D85J/9 G@ 13 24 @;00351 36 21@ E341/41234./8EE;@/9.8@9/42/98771./24E52D248124< D81/5287@8:8278F7/345/E359F;1.8@431E.3@/4137/89 84> /:29/4E/ 24 @;00351 36 .2@ 9/6/4E/ ./ 5287 3;51 861/5 18J24< 2413 E34@29/581234 877 1./@/ D81/5287@ 34 5/E359E8D/13F/1./E34E7;@2341.811./053@/E;12342@ @;EE/@@6;7 24 053:24< 1./ <;271 36 1./ 8EE;@/9 F/>349 5/8@348F7/ 93;F1 849 8EE35924<7> 08@@/9 1./ 2D0;<4/9 =;9<D/41 36 E34:2E1234 849 359/5 36 @/41/4E/ 8@ @181/9 8F3:/ ) $/24< 8<<52/:/9 F> 1./ @8D/ 1./ 8EE;@/9 .89 05/6/55/9 57 3+!+ F/635/ 1./ (25@1 00/7781/ - 6 - 3;51./(25@100/7781/3;51345/8005/E281234361./ D81/5287@345/E359E34625D/91./=;9<D/4136E34:2E1234 849359/536@/41/4E/$/24<8<<52/:/9F>1./@8D/1./ 8EE;@/92@F/635/1.2@3;51 :/4 1.3;<. @/:/587 <53;49@ I/5/ 582@/9 24 1./ 5/:2@234 0/121234 7/854/9 E3;4@/7 635 1./ 0/121234/5 5/@152E1/9.2@85<;D/41@13@//J7/42/4E>2468:3;5361./ 0/121234/5 I.27/ @/41/4E24< 635 1./ 366/4E/ 0;42@.8F7/ ;49/5/E1234!3612@@181/91.8124E29/41.89 3EE;55/99;524<+!*8491./0/121234/52@8>3;4<D84 .8:24< 5/@034@2F2721> 13 @;00351 .2@ 68D27> 849 1./ @8D/ D8>F/E34@29/5/9@>D081./12E877>132D03@/@/41/4E/635 1./366/4E/0;42@.8F7/;49/5/E1234!36 * 1 2@ 1./ E341/41234 36 1./ 053@/E;1234 1.81 1./ 0/121234/5 2@ 1./ 952:/5 36 1./ 184J/5 F/8524< 5/<2@1581234 3&+ +!) 849 ./ 953:/ 1./ @8D/ 24 8 58@. 849 4/<72</41D844/581.2<.@0//9@38@13/4984</5.;D84 726/84998@./921131./1I3I.//7/5F/8524<5/<2@1581234 - 7 - 3&++* 8@ 8 5/@;71 36 I.2E. 1./ 529/5 @;@1824/96818724=;52/@849781/592/9241./.3@021873 053:/ 21@ E341/41234 1./ 053@/E;1234 /G8D24/9 ,@ 13 ):/41.3;<.1./@/I214/@@/@I/5//G8D24/9817/4<1. 431.24< .8@ F//4 /72E21/9 653D 1./D 13 92@F/72/:/ 1./25 :/5@234 ./ 8EE;@/9 .8@ 9/42/9 877 1./ 24E52D248124< D81/5287@ 8:8278F7/ 34 5/E359 F;1 .8@ 431 18J/4 84> @0/E262E 9/6/4E/ 49/5 @;E. E25E;D@184E/@ 1./ 5287 3;51 .8@ 52<.17> E34:2E1/9 1./ 8EE;@/9 635 1./ 8635/@829 366/4E/@ 4 5/8005/E281234 1./ (25@1 00/7781/ 3;51 92@D2@@/9 1./ E52D2487 800/87 ./5/635/ 93 431 6249 84> 277/<8721> 24 1./ 2D0;<4/9 =;9<D/41 36 E34:2E1234 08@@/9F>1./52873;51I.2E.2@E34625D/9F>1./(25@1 00/7781/3;51 ! 12@4312E/91.811./52873;51.8@053E//9/913 E34:2E11./8EE;@/9F31.6351./366/4E/@0;42@.8F7/;49/5 /E1234@+)*849!3612@8@/117/903@2123436 78I 1.81 1./ 366/4E/ ;49/5 /E1234 +)* 36 F/24< 1./ D2435 366/4E/ D/5</@ I21. 1./ D8=35 366/4E/ ;49/5 - 8 - /E1234!3624:2/I361./9/E2@234361./%34BF7/ 0/G 3;51 24 %/4E/ 8D 36 1./ 3024234 1.81 1./I.27/E34625D24<1./=;9<D/4136E34:2E12340;42@.8F7/ ;49/5 /E1234 +)* 36 2D03@24< 36 @/41/4E/ 635 1./ @8D/2@728F7/13F/@/18@29/ 4 1./ D/8412D/ E34@29/524< 1./ @;FD2@@234 D89/ F> 1./ 7/854/9 E3;4@/7 635 1./ 0/121234/5 7/42/4E> D8>F/@.3I42468:3;5361./0/121234/5I.27/@/41/4E24< 1./0/121234/58EE;@/96351./366/4E/;49/5/E1234! 3618J24<2413E34@29/5812341./68E11.811./24E29/41 .893EE;55/934!+!*8491./8EE;@/9I8@8</9+* >/85@811./12D/368EE29/41 + ./52873;51@/41/4E/91./8EE;@/913;49/5<3 @2D07/ 2D052@34D/41 635 @2G D341.@ 849 13 08> 624/ 36 @!!!6351./366/4E/@0;42@.8F7/;49/5/E1234! 36 849 @/41/4E/9 13 08> 624/ 36 @!!! 635 1./ 1 #+!+') - 9 - 366/4E/ ;49/5 /E1234 ) 36 E1 I21. 9/68;71 @/41/4E/ 93 431 6249 84> 5/8@34 13 241/56/5/ I21. 1./ @8D/49/5@;E.E25E;D@184E/@8D361./30242341.81 1./ 2D0;<4/9 359/5 36 @/41/4E/ D8> F/ D39262/9 24 1./ 241/5/@136=;@12E/ 4 :2/I 36 1./ 8F3:/ 84@I/5 1./ 8F3:/ 03241 849 053E//9 13 08@@ 1./ 63773I24< (i) ./ 52D2487/:2@234 /121234 2@ ! (ii) ./=;9<D/4136E34:2E123408@@/9F>1./ 7/854/9 997 /4235 2:27 ;9</ 849 ( 2=8>80;58 635 1./ 366/4E/ 0;42@.8F7/ ;49/5 /E1234)36 E12@./5/F>" ! (iii) ./359/536@/41/4E/08@@/9F>1./5287 3;516351./366/4E/0;42@.8F7/;49/5/E1234 +)*362@ ! - 10 - (iv) (24/ 8D3;41 26 84> 9/03@21/9 635 1./ 366/4E/0;42@.8F7/;49/5/E1234+)*362@ 359/5/913F/5/6;49/9131./0/121234/5349;/ 29/41262E81234 (v) %3I/:/5 1./ 359/5 36 @/41/4E/ 635 1./ 366/4E/ ;49/5 /E1234 ! 36 08@@/9 F> 1./52873;512@D39262/98@;49/5 8' ./ 5/:2@234 0/121234/5 2@ @/41/4E/9 13 ;49/5<3 52<353;@ 2D052@34D/41 635 8 0/5239361.5//D341.@8491308>624/36 @+!!!! 635 1./ 366/4E/ 0;42@.8F7/ ;49/5/E1234!3649/68;7113 08> 624/ ./ @.877 ;49/5<3 @2D07/ 2D052@34D/4163534/D341. F' ./624/8D3;412@13F/9/03@21/9I21.24 1.5//D341.@653D1./981/361.2@359/5 - 11 - E' ./ 5/:2@234 0/121234/5 2@ /41217/9 635 1./ F/4/621 36 @/1 366 8@ 053:29/9 ;49/5 /E1234+365 /<2@15> 2@ 925/E1/9 13 @/49 F8EJ 1./ 5287 3;51 5/E359@ 8734< I21. E30>361.2@ 359/5 635 24635D81234849 4//96;78E1234 -& '!!* $ $ 2@1373+ &