Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 43047 (KAR)

LALBI W/O DONGRISA INAMDAR v. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER AND ORS

WP/201911/2021 · 2025-10-28

M G S Kamal

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " # $%&!%!% '!( ! " #$"%" & #$&"& ' ( )) #$&"& * Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - #$&"& )" &+ )' *! ) && &&, ) ) ! ) ) "&%-&%&% ) &%&%# &" ) * (# ! ) ) ) ' "%-&%&%) (#" %%'&%&" (#) ! ) ) ) ! ) ) ) ) - 3 - . . ! /010123/4 15 6/724/ 0815 2940 5//:13; 72<<2=13; 4/<1/75 ! "#$%&'$ ( ) * ( + , - . * (' .-/ * (0 1 2 / 2 & 8/ >?5/ 27 08/ @/010123/4 15 08?0 58/ 15 08/ ?652<90/2=3/413A2130@255/5512327<?3B13C2"%&$ D/?59413;"-;930?55109?0/B13?<?;1E1<<?;/9BB/618?< ?<9:8?05/E/4?<C/?45?;24/5@23B/30#?90824101/58?B <?1B ? :?>8? D/0?< 42?B >233/>013; E1<<?;/ ?<?;1 ?3B - 4 - E1<<?;/9<<94?559413;08/@/010123/4?3B208/42=3/4508?0 08/C =29<B 6/ 5910?6<C >2D@/35?0/B 8/ 5?1B 42?B =?5 <?1B =108290 ?>F91413; 08/ <?3B 13 08/ D?33/4 :32=3 02 <?= ' 8?0 ?6290 '% C/?45 ?;2 9@23 08/ B/D?3B27 08/E1<<?;/454/5@23B/30#?90824101/58?E13;7293B08/42?B <?1B6C08/D/?4<1/4=?5320>23E/31/30?3B=2408C2795/ @42@25/B 02 <?C?3/= 42?B=81>8@?5508429;8?3208/4 @2401232708/<?3B2708/@/010123/4 /5@10/08/4/5150?3>/ 27 D?3C <?3B <25/45 13><9B13; 08/ @/010123/4 08/ 4/5@23B/30#?90824101/5=/30?8/?B13<?C13;?3208/442?B /0 ?;?13 @/010123/4 ?3B 208/4 <?3B2=3/45 =/4/ D?B/ 02 6/<1/E/ 08?0 08/C =29<B 6/ 5910?6<C >2D@/35?0/B 8?0 513>/ 08/ 5@?>/ 6/0=//3 08/ 2<B 42?B ?3B 08/ 3/= 42?B =?5 E/4C 5D?<< ?3B 320 E1?6</ 724 ?3C ?;41>9<094?< @94@25/5 @/010123/4 >235049>0/B 8/4 3/= 8295/ 23 08/ 5?1B @240123 27 08/ <?3B ?3B 51D1<?4<C 208/45 ?<52 >235049>0/B 8295/5 13 08/ 5?1B @240123 27 08/ <?3B 93B/4 - 5 - 08/ 3B14??=?52A?3?8/3?D/2708/@/010123/4=?5 ?<52/30/4/B1308/4/E/39/4/>24B5 * 813; 5022B 0895 9@23 08/ ?<</;?0123 27 @/010123/4 ?3B 208/45 8?E13; /3>42?>8/B 9@23 08/ 5?1B 5@?>/ 3201>/5 >?D/ 02 6/ 1559/B >?<<13; 9@23 08/ @/010123/4 ?3B 208/45 02 72408=108 B/D2<158 08/ 8295/5 >235049>0/B 6C 08/D 23 08/ 5?1B 5@?>/ 3 4/5@235/ @/010123/4 ?<23; =108 208/45 ;?E/ 4/@4/5/30?01235 02 08/ /@90C 2DD155123/4 =81>8 =/30 938/?4B 23504?1313; 08/D 02 ?@@42?>8 0815 2940 6C 71<13; 08/ @4/5/30 =410 @/010123 $ 8?0 0815 2940 6C ?3 130/41D 24B/4 B?0/B %"%&%&"8?B@/4D100/B08/@/010123/402?@@/?46/724/ 4/5@23B/302*?3B02596D108/426A/>01230208/3201>/ ?033/G94/# =10879408/4B14/>0123024/5@23B/302*02 >2351B/4 08/ 5?D/ ?3B @?55 ?@@42@41?0/ 24B/45 =10813 &*""&%&" 0 =?5 79408/4 B14/>0/B 01<< 59>8 01D/ 08/ 8295/2708/@/010123/4320026/B/D2<158/B - 6 - /?43/B>2935/<72408/@/010123/4596D10508?0 32 ?>0123 8?5 6//3 0?:/3 6C 08/ 4/5@23B/305 /108/4 13 ?>>24B?3>/=108<?=24?5B14/>0/B6C0815294001<<B?0/ /596D10508?008/?>01232308/@?402708/4/5@23B/305 15 23/ =108290 ?9082410C ?46104?4C ?3B 931<?0/4?< 8/ 3201>/?033/G94/# =108290@4/>/B/B6C?3C/3F914C15 1<</;?<?3B4/F914/B026/5/0?51B/ , 34/5@235/</?43/B>2935/<?@@/?413;72408/ 4/5@23B/3025'?3B*71<13;50?0/D/302726A/>0123?<23; =108 084// B2>9D/305 596D105 08?0 5965/F9/30 02 08/ 24B/4 @?55/B 6C 0815 2940 23 %"%&%&" 08/@/010123/4 8?B13B//B596D100/B50?0/D/302726A/>0123 0=?5B9<C >2351B/4/B =2 4/@2405 =/4/ 71</B ?3B 7293B 08?0 08/ @/010123/4 ?3B 208/45 8?B 13B//B /3>42?>8/B 9@23 08/ <?3B 13 08/14 @255/55123 8?0 8?E13; >23B9>0/B 08/ /3F914C ?3B 8?E13; 6//3 5?01571/B =108 4/;?4B 02 08/ /3>42?>8D/30 08/ 24B/4 B?0/B &$%,&%&& @42B9>/B ?0 33/G94/#' 02 08/ 50?0/D/30 27 26A/>0123 >?D/ 02 6/ @?55/B 8/ 79408/4 596D105 513>/ 08/ 130/41D B14/>0123 - 7 - ;1E/3 6C 0815 2940 8?E13; >2D@<1/B 82<B13; @/010123/4 /3>42?>8/B 9@23 08/ <?3B @/010123 B2/5 320 594E1E/ 724 >2351B/4?0123/3>/5//:5724B15D155?<2708/@/010123 3 4/5@235/ </?43/B >2935/< ?@@/?413; 08/ @/010123/4 596D105 08?0 0829;8 33/G94/#' @42B9>/B ?<23;08/50?0/D/302726A/>01234/7/450252D/@94@240/B /3F914C 8?E13; 6//3 >23B9>0/B 6C 08/ 4/5@23B/305 32 3201>/ 27 59>8 /3F914C 8?5 6//3 ;1E/3 02 08/ @/010123/4 /108/408/@/010123/48?56//3;1E/32@@2409310C028?E/ 8/45?C1308/D?00/48/4/724/8/596D100/B/3F914C17 ?3C157?4>/?3B935950?13?6</1308//C/527<?= - /?4B/495/B08/4/>24B5 "% 8/ 7?>05 3?44?0/B ?62E/ B2 320 4/F914/ ?3C 4/@/010123 815 2940 6C 130/41D 24B/4 B?0/B %"%&%&" 8?BB14/>0/B08/@/010123/4?3B4/5@23B/302*?593B/4 3& ! 4 4 - ) - 8 - & 2 ) 2 25 2 6 & ) 25 2 ) & ) 2 7 -8 "" 8/4/<1?3>/15@<?>/B236C08/</?43/B>2935/< 72408/4/5@23B/30#?9082410C?033/G94/#'=81>81508/ @42>//B13;5 ?3B 08/ 24B/4 @?55/B 6C 08/ 4?D? ?3>8?C?08 771>/ 9BB/618?< ?;/ 2& 27 08/ 5?1B B2>9D/304/7/450208/>?5/2708/@/010123/48/4/138/ <?50 9339D6/4/B @?4?;4?@8 27 @?;/ 2"$ 27 08/ 5?1B 24B/44/?B5?593B/4 ! " #$%& ' ( )* "+ " ,-! '../ 012 ( 03 4 567 8 8 & ( 9 , 8 : 8 '../ 0;< =( 2>>.10 ? 6@ A B"=' (C# DE" FG"=. )' / & H D I3J ! (K 'L H D I<J ( ,/ 1MN1MN2122 "= 2ON1PN2122 "8 ) 8& Q ,& 8 H DI;J ( - 9 - R( (9 S ,-'& 65(# 7C 7TUK 'L! "8 =(K "#R (T7! V &" (C.W 235/F9/30<C 08/ 24B/4 8?5 6//3 @?55/B 23 &$%,&%&& >?<<13;9@2308/@/010123/402B/D2<1588/48295/ "& /495?< 27 08/ 5?1B 24B/4 B2 320 13B1>?0/ ?3C /3F914C 8?E13; 6//3 >23B9>0/B ;1E13; 2@@2409310C 27 @/4523?<8/?413;2708/@/010123/4829;8104/7/450208/ 50?0/D/302726A/>0123@94@240/B028?E/6//371</B6C08/ @/010123/4?3B32B/0?1<527/3F914C8?E13;6//3>23B9>0/B 24 ?3C 3201>/ 8?E13; 6//3 1559/B 02 08/ @/010123/4 15 4/7</>0/B 815 @?401>9<?4<C 13 E1/= 27 08/ 5@/>171> B/31?< D?B/6C08/</?43/B>2935/<72408/@/010123/408152940 B23205//?3C4/?52302?>>/@008/5?1B@42>//B13;5026/ >2351B/4?01232726A/>012371</B6C08/@/010123/4=1081308/ D/?313;2708/B14/>0123;1E/36C08152940 "' /E/408/</55 513>/ 08/ 1559/ 13E2<E/B 13 0815 @/010123 15 =108 4/;?4B 02 41;80 010</ ?3B 130/4/50 ?3B @255/55123 27 08/ @/010123/4 2E/4 08/ ?724/5?1B @42@/40C - 10 - </?43/B >2935/< 724 08/ @/010123/4 5//:5 <16/40C02 13101?0/ ?@@42@41?0/ @42>//B13;5 6/724/ 08/ >2D@/0/30 2940 27 <?= "* 308?0E1/=2708/D?00/4@?5508/72<<2=13; "! 8/ 1D@9;3/B 24B/43201>/ B?0/B "&%-&%&% 6C 08/ 4/5@23B/30 2* ?0 33/G94/# 155/0?51B/ &! 13>/ 08/ 1559/ 13E2<E/B 13 08/ D?00/4 15 =1084/;?4B022=3/4581@@255/55123?3B 1B/30171>?0123 27 @42@/40C 6/13; ><?1D/B 6208 6C 08/ @/010123/4 ?5 =/<< ?5 08/ 4/5@23B/30#?90824101/5 @/010123/4 15 4/</;?0/B 02 8?E/ 8/4 41;80 /50?6<158/B 6/724/08/>2D@/0/30294027<?= '! 8/@/010123/41752?BE15/B58?<<5//:59>8 4/D/BC?5D?C6/@/4D15516</93B/4<?= 6/724/08/>2D@/0/30294027<?= =10813 ? @/412B 27 % B?C5 742D 08/ B?0/ 27 4/>/1@027>/40171/B>2@C27081524B/4 - 11 - *! 8/ 130/41D 24B/4 ;4?30/B 13 0815 @/010123 58?<<>230139/01<<08/@/010123/45//:5?3B 260?135 59>8 3/>/55?4C 24B/4 742D 08/ 294002=81>808/@/010123/4154/</;?0/B $! 8/ 24B/4 B?0/B &$%,&%&& @42B9>/B ?<23;=10808/50?0/D/302726A/>012371</B 6C08/4/5@23B/3015:/@013?6/C?3>/ ! 015D?B/></?41308//E/30@/010123/4320 0?:13; ?3C ?>0123 ?5 B14/>0/B =10813 01D/ 71G/B 8/4/13 4/5@23B/30#?9082410C 58?<< @42>//B13?>>24B?3>/=108<?= !)* '%!%( & "''