- 1 - ! " #$ % % "" &%' ( !"#$% & ' % ( % %!)!!* +"#$% Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ,% +"#$% & ' ,- )%%,$, ( *'( ,%$*%,$, % % ,#,$. %" ,$ "$$!%, $$ $$$! ,/ 0 % 1 % - 3 - $ 234 566758 34 9387: ;< =27 5667885>= +?853@5>= 477A3>B7>25>?7@7>=C9?C@67>45=3C>545D5E:7:3>=27 FG:B@7>= 5>: 5D5E: :5=7: ,%$*%,$, 65447: 3> C%,#,$. ;< 3E4= ::3=3C>58 7>3CE 3H38 G:B7 5>: 5>: 53?2GE% ,% 5?=4875:3>B=C9387?853@67=3=3C>5E754G>:7E- 25= C> ,%$*%,$* =27 ?853@5>= 5>: 27E @C=27E 254 ;77> =C E3 53 7@687 =C 67E9CE@ =27 6CCF5% 9=7E =25==27<25H7;C5E:7: ;G4;75E3>B C%!)! *% = 5;CG= ,%$6%@% ;C=2 C9 =27@ BC= :CD> 5= 5E5A585:3>>3 3885B7 5>: 5= =25= =3@7 :E3H7E C9 =27 ;G4 D3=2CG=583B2=3>BCE;8CD3>B2CE>2544G::7>8<4=5E=7:=27 ;G4>7B83B7>=8<5>::G7=C234453:5?= 879=43:7D2778C9 =27453:;G425465447:C>=2787B4C9=27?853@5>=%27 ?853@5>=2544G4=53>7:3>FGE<5>:9387:?853@67=3=3C>%27 E3;G>58 254 5447447: =27 ?C@67>45=3C> 5>: 65447: =27 5D5E:%73>B>C=45=34937:D3=2?C@67>45=3C>5D5E:7:;< - 4 - =27 E3;G>58 =27 ?853@5>= 254 9387: =234 566758 9CE 7>25>?7@7>=C9?C@67>45=3C>% % 75E: 875E>7: ?CG>478 9CE =27 5667885>= 5>: 875E>7:?CG>4789CEE746C>:7>= C%,% #% 75E>7: ?CG>478 9CE =27 5667885>= DCG8: ?C>=7>: =25= =27 ?853@5>= D54 5B7: $* <75E4 54 C> =27 :5=7C95??3:7>=%G7=C=275??3:7>=27E879=87B4G4=53>7: ?EG423>FGE< :G7=C3=4278C4=27E=C745>:42734=5A3>B =E75=@7>= =388 :5=7% 7 4G;@3=4 =25= :C?=CE 254 4=5=7: :345;383=< 5= "/% 7 9GE=27E 4G;@3=4 :G7 =C 5??3:7>= =27E7348C44C93>?C@7:G7=C:345;383=<%74G;@3=4=25= =27 5??3:7>= 254 =5A7> 685?7 3> =27 <75E ,$* 5= =25= =3@7 >C=3C>583>?C@793I7:;<=277B587EH3?74G=2CE3=< 9CE47==87@7>=C9:346G=743>CA!5:585=29CE<75E,$*34 4%$ ,"$!% 7 4G;@3=4 =25= =27 ?853@5>= 34 7>=3=87: 9G=GE7 6EC467?=G4 5= #$/% 7 9GE=27E 4G;@3=4 =25= =27 ?853@5>= D54 5:@3==7: 3> =27 2C463=58 9CE #, :5<4 5>: ?C>43:7E3>B =27 45@7 ?C@67>45=3C> 5D5E:7: ;< =27 E3;G>589CE5==7>:5>=5>:?C>H7<5>?7?25EB7434C>8CD7E - 5 - 43:7% 7 4G;@3=4 =25= =388 :5=7 =27 ?853@5>= 34 =5A3>B =E75=@7>= 54 =27E7 34 9CE@5=3C> C9 6G4 3> 27E 879= 9CC= 3> =27 685?7 C9 3>FGE<% 27E79CE7 427 34 7>=3=87: =C 23B27E @7:3?58 7I67>474 =25> =27 =E3;G>58 5D5E:7:% 7 685?7: :7?343C>C9C!CE:3>5=77>?2C9=234CGE=3>=27?547C9 3=2 =2747 27 6E5<4 =C 588CD =27 566758 5>: 7>25>?7=27?C@67>45=3C>% "% 75E>7: ?CG>478 9CE E746C>:7>= C%, DCG8: ?C>=7>: =25= =27 E3;G>58 =5A3>B 3>=C ?C>43:7E5=3C> C9 :7?343C> C9 C>J;87 67I CGE= 3> =27 ?547 C9 !" # $ % 254 E3B2=8< 5D5E:7: ?C@67>45=3C>% 27E7 5E7 >C BECG>:4 9CE 7>25>?3>B?C@67>45=3C>%3=2=2747 276E5<4=C:34@344 =27566758% 1 reported in NC : 2025:KHC-K:3234 2 Reported in (2014) 14 SCC 396 - 6 - )% 5H3>B 275E: 875E>7: ?CG>4784 =234 CGE= 254 67EG47: 3@6GB>7: FG:B@7>= 5>: @5=7E3584 685?7: C> E7?CE:% *% 27 :5=7 C9 5??3:7>= 5B7 C9 ?853@5>= 5>: 835;383=< C9 E746C>:7>= C%,% +>4GE5>?7 ?C@65>< 5E7 >C= 3>:346G=7%275??3:7>=34=5A7>685?7C>,%$*%,$*%4 C>=27:5=7C95??3:7>= =27?853@5>=D545B7:$*<75E4% G7 =C =27 5??3:7>= =27 ?853@5>= D54 5:@3==7: 3> =27 2C463=58 9CE #, :5<4% 27 :C?=CE ! %%, D2C 7I5@3>7: 27E?853@5>= 254 344G7: :345;383=< ?7E=393?5=7 + I% 5>: 4=5=7: =25= =27 ?853@5>= 254 "/ :345;383=< C9 =27 D2C87 ;C:<%27C!E:3>5=77>?2C9=234CGE=3>=27?547C9 &'?C>43:7E3>B=27:7?343C>4C9C>J;8767I CGE=5>:=234CGE=254C;47EH7:=2G4- !"#$%& "$ ' ( ) ) * ! + - 7 - , , - * . ! / 0!##$%& 1 !"#$%& 2 #!$$%& 3$456 - " - 0 3 5 - 7$4 3 5 8 "!$!$0$%& ! % "!$!$0$%& 9 % 4 5??3:7>= 254 =5A7> 685?7 3> =27 <75E ,$*% 27>C=3C>583>?C@793I7:;<=277B587EH3?74G=2CE3=< 9CE 47==87@7>= C9 :346G=74 3> CA!5:585=2 9CE =27 <75E ,$*34$ ,"$!%467E5;CH7453::7?343C> =27?853@5>= 34 7>=3=87: =C 9G=GE7 6EC467?=G4 5= #$/% 27 @G8=36837E 56683?5;8734%>H37DC9=275;CH7 8C44C93>?C@7:G7 =C:345;383=<3454G>:7E- ) * +, - +) . . / . , -0 /+/1) .% 27 =E3;G>58 254 E3B2=8< 5D5E:7: 9CE 653> 5>: 4G997E3>B 3> 4G@ C9 4%"$ $$$! 5>: @7:3?58 7I67>474 3> 4G@C94%,$ $$$!%4?853@5>=345:@3==7:3>=272C463=58 - 8 - 9CE #, :5<4 427 34 7>=3=87: 5==7>:5>= 5>: ?C>H7<5>?7 ?25EB74C94%#, $$$!545B53>4=,$ "$$!545D5E:7:;< =27 E3;G>58% 27 =E3;G>58 254 E3B2=8< 5D5E:7: 8C44 C9 9G=GE7 5@7>3=374 3> 4G@ C9 4%# $$ $$$! ?C>43:7E3>B =27 5B75>:8C44C9@5EE35B76EC467?=G4C9=27?853@5>=%27 ?853@5>= 34 4=388 =5A3>B =E75=@7>= 54 =27E7 34 9CE@5=3C> C9 6G4 3> 27E 879= 87B 3> =27685?7 C9 3>FGE<% 27 34 7>=3=87: 9G=GE7 @7:3?58 7I67>474 3> 4G@ C9 4%)$ $$$! 5B53>4= 4%$ $$$! 54 5D5E:7: ;< =27 E3;G>58% C>43:7E3>B 5;CH7 5467?=4 ?853@5>= 34 7>=3=87: =C =C=58 ?C@67>45=3C> 54G>:7E- 2 3450 6738049:8 :80 C44C93>?C@7 $ # )$! , 53>5>:4G997E3>B "$ $$$! 7:3?58 I67>474 ,$ $$$! # C44C9@7>3=374 # $$ $$$! " ==7>:5>=J4?25EB74 #, $$$! ) G=GE7 7:3?58 I67>474 )$ $$$! 942:840;60 11/1) $% >H37DC9=275;CH7 =275667885>=+?853@5>=34 7>=3=87: =C=58 ?C@67>45=3C> C9 4%) ") )$! 54 5B53>4= 4%" ,$ "$$! 54 5D5E:7: ;< =27 E3;G>58 D3=2 3>=7E74=% - 9 - 27E3;G>582545D5E:7:3>=7E74=5==27E5=7C9./6%5% 5>:3=34C>23B27E43:7%27E79CE7 =27?853@5>=347>=3=87: 3>=7E74=5==27E5=7C9)/6%5%27?853@5>=34>C=7>=3=87: 3>=7E74= 9CE =27 :785< 67E3C: C9 "$ :5<4 3> 9383>B =234 5667585467ECE:7E:5=7:)%%,$,% % >H37DC9=275;CH7 =279C88CD3>B 3( 2756675834( 33( 27 ?853@5>= 34 7>=3=87: 9CE =C=58 ?C@67>45=3C> 5@CG>= C9 4%) ") )$! 54 5B53>4= 4%" ,$ "$$! 54 5D5E:7: ;< =27 E3;G>58 D3=2 3>=7E74= 5= =27 E5=7 C9 )/ 67E 5>>G@ 9EC@ =27 :5=7C967=3=3C>=388E7583K5=3C>% 333( 27 CE:7E C9 :76C43= C9 ?C@67>45=3C> 5@CG>= 65447:;<=27E3;G>5834E7@53>7:G>:34=GE;7:% 5) & % %' $ 34= C%8 C%#*