- 1 - ! "!#$ %$!&!$$ $## '(')#*+ '!!** , ! " # $ % # && '" " () " $ % # " * ) ( # $ % Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # + * ) ' $ % # + * ) # $ % # " * % ) ) # $ % # " * , ) - " $ % # * ) "" $ % # * ) ! " % . " (- '& % % " (#& # # - 3 - " % " " " "% $ "$ / """ & $ $ / """ 012321453673238320649:0 2012037 74; 483<9823 4=>?1 >@3<3A963 03B A6151661C 20>B 3AA13= >DA9:7>7: 201 @9C:D172 45 3?E9>223= C321C A3BB1C >7 A1?>3= 48 3B1 4 (#& 47 201 5>=1 45 =13671C 6>7?>A3= 1BB>47B 9C:1#201 A1?>3= 9C:1 32 >@3<3A963 3?E9>22>7: 201 3??9B1C 546 201 45517?1B A97>B03F=1 97C16 1?2>47B - 37C ( 45 201 61G172>47454669A2>47?2546B0462H?2I 01 53?2B 45 201 ?3B1 >7 F6>15 361 2032 47 ( 32 A D 3??9B1C 4 ;3B ;468>7: 3B "4246 10>?=1 7BA1?246 >7 +3=38> 01?8 4B2 ;0>=1 3??9B1C 4B 24 ) F1>7: 201 D>CC=1D17 37C 3??9B1C 4B - 37C F1>7: 201 4D1:936CB ;161 3BB>B2>7: - 4 - 3??9B1C 4 ;04 9B1C 24 B24A =466>1B A3BB>7: 20649:0 20101?84B247201A6121J245?01?8>7:201G10>?=137C ?4==1?2>7: >==1:3= :632>5>?32>47 42016 2037 201 =1:3= 61D971632>47 564D 201 C6>G16B 37C 4;716B 45 G36>49B G10>?=1B 63>C;3B01=C4720101?84B237C3??9B1C 4 F1>7:201A9F=>?B16G372;3B5497C>7A4BB1BB>4745 B - (# 3??9B1C4B 24);161?4==1?2>G1=<5497C>7 A4BB1BB>4745B # 2>B3==1:1C2032 201B3D1;3B 4F23>71CF<?4669A246>==1:3=D137B546;0>?02013??9B1C ;161 742 03G>7: 37< 613B473F=1 1JA=3732>47 0161F< 201< 03G1 ?4DD>221C 201 45517?1 3B B2321C 3F4G1 01 B1>K961 D303K36 ;3B C63;7 B1>K>7: 201 973??49721C D471< 5497C >7 201 A4BB1BB>47 45 201 3??9B1C 7G1B2>:32>47 ;3B ?4DA=121C 37C ?036:1 B0112 ?3D1 24 F15>=1C ( 01 6>3= 4962 2448 ?4:7>K37?1 45 201 45517?1 37C B9DD471C 201 3??9B1C 24 3AA136 F15461 201 4962 013??9B1C03G13AA1361CF154612016>3=4962 A=13C1C 742 :9>=2< 37C ?=3>D1C 24 F1 26>1C 01 A64B1?92>47 03B - 5 - 1J3D>71C %B 24 ( :42 D3681C JB 24 ( 37C >C172>5>1C" >7B9AA46245>2B?472172>47 013??9B1C 03G1 C17>1C 3== 201 >7?6>D>732>7: D3216>3=B 3G3>=3F=1 47 61?46C F9203G1742=1C37<1G>C17?1>7B9AA46245201>6 C1517?1 ' 01 6>3= 4962 35216 238>7: >724 ?47B>C1632>47 3== 201 D3216>3=B 47 61?46C ?3D1 24 201 ?47?=9B>47 2032 201A64B1?92>47>B742B9??1BB59=>7A64G>7:201:9>=245201 3??9B1C F1<47C 613B473F=1 C49F2 37C 3??46C>7:=< 3?E9>221C 201 3??9B1C 1>7: 3::6>1G1C F< 201 >DA9:71C @9C:D172 45 3?E9>223= A3BB1C F< 201 6>3= 4962 201 36732383 483<982303BA6151661C20>B3AA13= 136C 6> 496>B0 03B03DA96 =13671C A1?>3= 497B1= 546 201 3AA1==372 483<9823 6> " 03:;32 =13671C 17>46 497B1= 3AA136>7: 546 61BA47C1724 37C6>3G> 32>= =13671C?497B1=546 61BA47C172 4B 24 169B1C 201 D3216>3=B >7?=9C>7: 2016>3=496261?46CB - 6 - ) 7 G>1; 45 201 6>G3= ?472172>47B 96:1C F< 201 =13671C?497B1=546F420201A362>1B 201A4>722032;49=C 36>B1546D<?47B>C1632>47>B$ "<37B;16242013F4G1A4>72>B>7201HI546 20154==4;>7:$ !! - 2 >B 201 BA1?>5>? ?472172>47 45 201 A64B1?92>47 2032 3??9B1C 4 ;3B 201 A9F=>? B16G372 ;468>7: 3B "424610>?=17BA1?246>7+3=38> 01?84B2 3??9B1C 4B 24 ) 361 D>CC=1D17 37C 3??9B1C 4B - 37C 361 4D1:936CB ??9B1C 4B 24 9B1C 24 ?4==1?2 >==1:3= :632>5>?32>47 564D 201 4;716B 37C C6>G16B 45 G36>49B G10>?=1B 47 201 A6121J2 45 ?01?8>7: 201 G10>?=1B 32 201 >7B237?1453??9B1C4 % &201>7546D37203B5>=1C201 5>6B2 >7546D32>47 3B A16 J ' 47 61?1>A2 45 ?61C>F=1 - 7 - >7546D32>47 37C F< 4FB16G>7: 201 3?2>G>2>1B >7 201 01?8 4B2 47 ' ( 37C ( 3216 % ( 3=47: ;>20 A37?03B ;172 24 201 BA42 37C 01=C 3 63>C 47 ( 323F492 A D 2>BB2321C2032 3??9B1C 4 ;3B>7A4BB1BB>4745?3B045B () '# F9201;3B 03G>7: 61?1>A2B 546 47=< B -# 09B 20161 ;3B 1J?1BB ?3B0 45 B - (# ??9B1C 4B 24 ) ;161 >7 A4BB1BB>47 45 ?3B0 45 B # 01 3??9B1C ;161 742 3F=1241JA=3>73F492A4BB1BB>47452011J?1BB3D4972>7 201>6 A4BB1BB>47 01 3D4972 45 B ( # ;3B B1>K1C 97C16 201 D303K36 ;0>?0 >B >C172>5>1C 3B " 01615461 >2 >B 201 ?472172>47 45 201 A64B1?92>47 2032 3??9B1C4 F1>7:201A9F=>?B16G3723BB>B21CF<3??9B1C 4B 24 ;161 ?4==1?2>7: >==1:3= :632>5>?32>47 564D 201 C6>G16B37C4;716B37C?4DD>221CD>B?47C9?2A97>B03F=1 97C161?2>47B- 37C(45201?2 4 A64G1 >2B ?472172>47 201 A64B1?92>47 03B 1J3D>71C % 201 D303K36 ;>271BB 24 201 B1>K961 D303K36J ) ;04 >B 201 >==3:1 ??4972372 ;04 - 8 - 3??4DA37>1C2017G1B2>:32>7: 55>?16% ( 01;>271BB B2321C 2032 >7 0>B A61B17?1 201 ?3B0 ;3B A64C9?1C F< 3??9B1C 4 37C 201 B3D1 ;3B B1>K1C 97C16 201 D303K36 96>7: ?64BB1J3D>732>47 201 ;>271BB A=13C1C 0>B >:74637?1 3B 24 ;0>?0 45 201 A16B47B 03G1 A3>C 201 3D497224201455>?>3=B>720101?84B2 13CD>2B24201 B9::1B2>47 A92 F< 201 =13671C ?497B1= 546 201 3??9B1C F154612016>3=49622032 20161;161?96617?<742145 B # ( ?96617?< 7421B 45 B # ?96617?< 7421B 45 B # ?96617?< 7421B 45 B # ?96617?<742145B #C174D>732>47 ?96617?<7421 45B #37C(?96617?<7421B45B # 92B2637:1=< ;>271BB 3CD>2B 2032 201B1 7421B 361 742 A362 45 " 0161 >B 74 611J3D>732>47 F< 201 =13671C A1?>3= 9F=>? 64B1?9246 24 20>B ;>271BB 24 B118 ?=36>5>?32>47 564D 0>D 7546297321=< 201 42016 D303K36 ;>271BB 24 J ) 03B 742F117 1J3D>71C F15461 201 6>3= 4962 09B 20161 >B 1G>C17?1 45 47=< % F1>7: 47145 201 D303K36;>271BB - 9 - 37C % (201 7G1B2>:32>7: 55>?16 ;04 03C C63;7 201 D303K36 & B A16 201 ?3B1 D3C1 492 F< 201 A64B1?92>47 % &L201 >6?=1 7BA1?246 45 4=>?1 61?1>G1C ?61C>F=1 >7546D32>47 47 ' ( 61:36C>7: 201 >==1:3= 3?2>G>2>1B 2032 ;161 F1>7: ?47C9?21C >7 +3=38> 01?8 4B2 1 ;172 24201 BA4237C 4FB16G1C 2013?2>G>2>1B 1 03C 742 61:>B2161C201 472032C3< 746 03C01 01=C 63>C 7 ( 01 3:3>7 ;172 7136 201 +3=38> 01?8 4B2 4FB16G1C 546 B4D1 2>D1 37C ?3D1 F3?8 ;>20492 04=C>7: 37<63>C 3216 015>=1C2015>6B2>7546D32>473BA16J ' 37C ?3D1 24 F1 61:>B2161C 7 A169B3= 45 J ' 20161 >B 74 6151617?1 24 % & :4>7: 24 201 BA42 47 ' ( 46 ( 37C 4FB16G>7:201 3?2>G>2>1B >7 20101?84B2 0161;3B3FB4=921=<74613B473B24;0< 01 03B 742 D172>471C 201 B3D1 >7 201 5>6B2 >7546D32>47 0161>B3=B4741JA=3732>473B24;0<% &03C74201=C 37<63>C1>201647' ( 46 ( 0161>B3=B4 - 10 - 741JA=3732>473B24;0<% &03C74261:>B2161C201 47' ( >2B1=5 01 A64B1?92>47 1J3D>71C %B ' ) - 37C F1>7: 201 C6>G16B 37C 4;716B 45 201 G36>49B =466>1B 24 BA138 3F492 201 C1D37C 546 >==1:3= :632>5>?32>47 F< 201 3??9B1C 37C 24 ?475>6D 2032 201< 03G1 A3>C 201 D471< 92 747145201B1;>271BB1B03G159==<B9AA4621C201?3B1 45201A64B1?92>4737C201>61G>C17?1>B74201=A59=24201 A64B1?92>47 % >B201C6>G1645201?69>B16G10>?=1 ;0>?0 ;3B23817476172F<201A4=>?124613?020101?84B2 %B 37C 361 201 455>?>3= ;>271BB1B % >B 201 B37?2>47>7:392046>2< 01615461 >2>B ?=1362032 24A64G1 201B1>K961D303K36J ) 20161>B47=<2011G>C17?145 %B 37C ( 3G3>=3F=1 47 61?46C >7?1 20161 >B B16>49B C>B?61A37?<>72011G>C17?145% 201B3D1?37742F1 201 B4=1 F3B>B 24 ?47G>?2 201 3??9B1C 2 ?37742 F1 B3>C 2032 2011G>C17?145% >B45B216=>7:E93=>2<24F3B1201 ?47G>?2>47452013??9B1C 7C16B9?0?>6?9DB237?1B 3D - 11 - 452014A>7>472032 >2?37742F101=C2032 201A64B1?92>47 >B B9??1BB59= >7 A64G>7: 201 :9>=2 45 201 3??9B1C F1<47C 613B473F=1C49F2 03G1:47120649:0201>DA9:71C@9C:D17245 3?E9>223= A3BB1C F< 201 6>3= 4962 01 6>3= 4962 03B 23817 >724 ?47B>C1632>47 3== 201 D3216>3=B 2032 361 A=3?1C F15461>237C03B366>G1C322016>:02?47?=9B>472032 201 A64B1?92>47 >B 742 B9??1BB59= >7 A64G>7: 201 :9>=2 45 201 3??9B1CF1<47C613B473F=1C49F2 ( B A16 201 ?6>D>73= @96>BA69C17?1 201 3??9B1C >B 3=;3<B A61B9D1C 24 F1 >774?172 >7?1201 6>3= 4962 03B 61?46C1C 3 5>7C>7: 2032 201 A64B1?92>47 >B 742 B9??1BB59=>7A64G>7:201:9>=2452013??9B1C 20161D9B2 F1 B4D1 B2647: 613B47B 24 61G16B1 201 @9C:D172 45 3?E9>223=37C24546D3C>55161724A>7>4737C2404=C2032 201 A64B1?92>47 >B B9??1BB59= >7 A64G>7: 201 :9>=2 45 201 3??9B1CF1<47C613B473F=1C49F2 C47425>7C37<B2647: 613B47B 24 546D B9?0 4A>7>47 37C 201615461 3D 45 201 4A>7>472032 2013AA13=>B=>3F=124F1C>BD>BB1C - 12 - ' ??46C>7:=< 37B;16 201 3F4G1 A4>72 >7 201 71:32>G137CA64?11C24A3BB20154==4;>7:$ 013AA13=>B !-+ '$$* & >B24 $=4 $