- 1 - !" #$ %# & &"## '( !" # $ % & ' ' ( & ! && ) !* Digitally signed by PREMCHANDRA M R Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - + '' !! ' !! , ) ' !! " -, ) ' !! , ' !! * -, !" ' !! & , , )! ' !! && , ' !! - 3 - &! , ' !! &) , . ' !! &+ , ! ' !! & ) ' !! & , !" ' !! &" + ' !! # $ ' & )/ ' ' +/ &"% , ' !! !!" ' ' ' - 4 - , ' 0 1 234452565 5738 9:;4<=8 >:2 7?= @=7373:4=2 235883A52B;4 5?;A52 >:2 2=<@:4C=47< & 7: ) 2332=D57? 9:;4<=8 :4 E=?58> :> D75745 ?3F56:G3D57? >:2 2=<@:4C=47 :+ 54C 235<?5< 3A<?379:;4<=8 >:22=<@:4C=47<7:&"?5F=5@@=52=C34 @=2<:4 ! ?=95@73:4=C,237=7373:43<>38=C<==A34G5,237:> =273:25237:H;5<?7?=:739=C57=C!& !!3<<;=CE67?= <<3<7547:DD3<<3:4=2958834G>:25D==734G7:9:4<3C=25: 9:4>3C=49=D:73:47?57?5CE==4D:F=C5G534<77?=@=7373:4=2 ) ?=@=7373:45F=2D=47<52=5<>:88:I< 73<<757=C7?577?=@=7373:4=23<7?==8=97=C2=<3C=47:> 7?=25D549?5657:> ?575G;45A354C?=?5<E==4I:2A34G I37?;7D:<7<349=23769:DD37D=4754C?:4=<7654C?5<E==4 <=2F34G 7?= @;E839/ ?:I=F=2 7?= =DE=2< :> 7?= 25D 549?5657D:F=C52=@2=<=47573:4:4! !!7:3437357=5 - 5 - 4:9:4>3C=49= D:73:4 5G534<7 ?3D 4 !& !! 7?= <<3<7547:DD3<<3:4=23<<;=C54:739=E6I?39??=9:4F=4=C5 <@=9358D==734G:>7?=549?56577:9:4<3C=27?=D:73:4:>4: 9:4>3C=49= 7?57 ?5C E==4 D:F=C 5G534<7 7?= @=7373:4=2 ?= D==734GC57=I5<&&"!!?=@=7373:4=29:47=4C<7?577?= 4:739=I5< <=2F=C:4?3D:4) !!:47=4C34G7?57?= C3C4:7?5F=5&C5698=524:739=>2:D7?=C57=:4I?39?7?= 4:739=I5<<=2F=C:4?3D7?=@=7373:4=23<E=>:2=7?3<:;27 + :;4<=8 >:2 7?= 2=<@=973F= @5273=< ;2G=C <=F=258 9:47=473:4< :;4<=8 >:2 7?= @=7373:4=2 <;ED37< 7?57 7?=2= 3< 4: 98=52 &C56 4:739= 54C?=49= 7?= <5D= 3< 4:7 34 599:2C549= I37? ;8= )$!% :> 7?= 524575A5 549?5657 5B $:73:4 :> : :4>3C=49=G534<7C?65<A?554C@C?65<A?5%;8=<&**+ :;4<=8 7?=2=>:2= <;ED37< 7?57 7?= ,237 =7373:4 D56 E= 588:I=C >:22=<@:4C=47<&7:)54C9:;4<=8>:22=<@:4C=47< 7: &" B:34786 <;ED37 7?57 7?=2= 3< 5 9:D@83549= I37? 7?= ;8= 54C<;ED377?575C=7538=C<757=D=47:>:EB=973:4<3<>38=C54C - 6 - 7?=<5D=D56E=75A=44:7=:>54C7?=,237=7373:4D56E= C3<D3<<=C =52C 7?= 52G;D=47< 54C @=2;<=C 7?= ,237 @5@=2< I37? 952= ?=3<<;=>588<I37?3454522:I9:D@5<<54C2=857=< 7:7?=4:9:4>3C=49=D:73:4D==734G4:739= < 7?=2= I5< 5 <=23:;< 9:47=<7 2=G52C34G 7?= <=2F39= :> 4:739= 7?3< :;27 C32=97=C 7?= 7: >38= 54 5>>3C5F37 99:2C34G86 54 5>>3C5F37 3< >38=C E6 7?= @=2;<58 :> 7?= <5D= C=@397< 7?57 23==2=<? 377345?5883 ?575G;45A3 25D5 549?5657 ?5< <I:24 7: 5 C=9852573:4 :> >597< <75734G 7?57 ?= 2=9=3F=C 7?= 4:9:4>3C=49= D:73:4 4:739= C57=C !& !!>2:D7?=:>>39=:>7?=<<3<7547:DD3<<3:4=24C3 >7=27?=2=9=3@7:>7?=4:739=?=58:4GI37?7?==92=7526:> 7?=25D549?5657 ?575G;45A3I=477:<=2F=7?=4:739=7: 7?=@=7373:4=2:4!& !!E;77?=@=7373:4=22=>;<=C7:75A= 7?=<5D==?5<58<:<757=C7?57:47?=4=J7C567?=6723=C7: <=2F=7?=<53C4:739=E;77?=@=7373:4=22=>;<=C7:2=9=3F=7?= 4:739= 349= 7?= @=7373:4=2 2=>;<=C 7: 2=9=3F= 7?= 4:739= :4 !) !! 7?=6 I=2= 9:4<72534=C 7: 5>>3J 7?= 4:739= :4 7?= - 7 - 4:739= E:52C :> 7?= :>>39= :> 7?= 25D 549?5657 3= 7?= I:2A34G @859= :> 7?= @=7373:4=2 54C C25I4 D5?5K52 54C 7::A @?:7:G25@?< ?= ?5< >;27?=2 <757=C 7?57 7?= 4:739= I5< <=477?2:;G?7?=@:<758<=2F39=:4! !!?=72;= 9:@3=< :> 7?= 5?5K52 2=9=3@7 54C 7?= 9:4<3G4D=47 7259A34G 2=@:27 52= 544=J=C 7: 9:47=4C 7?57 7?= 37=D I5< C=83F=2=C:4! !! ?=5>>3C5F373<@859=C:42=9:2C@=2;<58:>7?=5>>3C5F37 C=@397< 7?57 7?= @=7373:4=2 2=>;<=C 7: 2=9=3F= 7?= 4:739= 7 3< <3G43>39547 7: 4:7= 7?57 7?= 4:739= <=47 7?2:;G? I5< 2=9=3F=CE67?=@=7373:4=2?=52G;D=47:>7?=9:;4<=8>:27?= @=7373:4=2 7?57 7?= 4:739= 3< 388=G58 5< 7?= @=7373:4=2 C3C 4:7 ?5F=5&C5698=524:739=>2:D7?=C57=:4I?39?7?=4:739= I5< <=2F=C 9544:7 E= 599=@7=C <349= 7?= ;8= :486 2=H;32=< 7?577?=<<3<7547:DD3<<3:4=27:G2547&C56<198=524:739= >2:D 7?= C57= ?= 9?::<=< 7: 9:4F=4= 7?= D==734G ?= ;8= C:=< 4:7 9:47=D@857= & C56<1 98=52 4:739= >2:D 7?= C57= :4 I?39? 7?= 4:739= 3< <=2F=C ?=2=>:2= >34C 4: D=237 34 7?3< 95<=54C?=49=7?=I237@=7373:43<835E8=7:E=C3<D3<<=C =<;87547867?=,237=7373:43< - 8 - ?3<:;27F3C=:2C=2C57=C&"!!?5C:2C=2=C7?57 7?=:9:4>3C=49=D:73:4<9?=C;8=C7:E=?=8C:4&&"!! <?588 E= <;EB=97 7: 7?= 2=<;87 :> 7?= ,237 =7373:4 54C 2=<;87< I388 4:7 E= 544:;49=C I37?:;7 7?= @=2D3<<3:4 :> 7?= :;27 =95;<= :> 7?= C3<D3<<58 :> 7?= ,237 =7373:4 7?= 5;7?:2376 9:49=24=C3<57583E=2767:544:;49=7?=2=<;87< =95;<= :> 7?= C3<D3<<58 :> 7?= ,237 =7373:4 @=4C34G 347=28:9;7:26 5@@839573:4< 3> 546 52= C3<@:<=C :> 54C 347=23D C32=973:4<:2347=23D:2C=2<3>546<754CC3<9?52G=C )* '&"##( & 3<7:&8:)*