Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43037 (KAR)
AMBIKA v. NAGABHUSHAN
RPFC/200128/2023 · 2025-11-14
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43037 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43037 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#$
%$& $ $
#$"
'( #$"
! '
(
!"#
$%
&&
'
&%% (
)
$%
'%'
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
%* *
#(! * *
% %
' % %
% +%&
*,-./
##" #0" "
* )""" 1"""" %
2%
'
! (
&%%
"
!"#
$%
'%'
! !"#
$%
&&
'
%* *
#(! * *
%
% #0" " % % % &
*
% % *
- 3 -
%
%
%
*% %%
%
* *
3&
% 3&
%* ,""# " 41 56 78/4/4,98.:4;8 :<4=8 %* ,""##""! 41 56 /<8 .817,9>89/<-15?9> 5849@?@@.48A8>56/<8,.>8.>?/8>#0" "7?118>49 .=14B ,##",9 /<8 ;4=8,;%.49B47?= &->@8 *?C4=6 ,-./4>?.<8.849?;/8..8;8..8>/,?1D/<8*?C4=6,-./+ ;,. 5.8A4/6 9 /8.C1 :<4B< /<8 *?C4=6 ,-./ :<4=8 ?==,:49@/<8?77=4B?/4,9;4=8>-9>8.8B/4,9#,;,>8,;
.4C49?= %.,B8>-.8 56 /<8 78/4/4,98.:4;8 >4.8B/8> /<8 .817,9>89/<-15?9>/,7?61)"""78.C,9/</,:?.>1 C?49/89?9B8 ;.,C /<8 >?/8 ,; 78/4/4,9 48 #0"" %8/4/4,98.:4;8 41 188E49@ 89<?9B8C89/ :<4=8 /<8 .817,9>89/<-15?9>18//49@?14>8/<81?4>,.>8. - 4 -
8?.98> B,-918= ;,. /<8 78/4/4,98.:4;8 ?778?.49@ /<.,-@< A4>8, B,9;8.89B8 1-5C4/1 /<?/ /<8 .817,9>89/<-15?9> ?9> <41 7?.89/1 ,:9 A?1/ 7.,78./481 49 /<8 B4/6 ,; 4>?. <?/ ?7?./ .817,9>89/<-15?9> ?9> <41 ;?/<8. 41 .-9949@ <,/8= 49 /<8 % ?.> ,; -.?> 8?.949@ ? 1-C ,; 1#"""" 78. >?6 <-1 <8 1-5C4/1 /<?//<8*?C4=6,-./:4/<,-//?E49@49/,B,914>8.?/4,9,;
/<41 ?178B/ ,; /<8 C?//8. <?1 @.?9/8> 7?=/.6 1-C ,; 1)"""
78. C,9/< :<4B< 41 <4@<=6 49?>8F-?/8 B,914>8.49@ /<8 1/?/-1 ,; /<8 7?./481 /, :<4B< /<86 :8.8 ?BB-1/,C8> /, 8 5.49@1 /,/<8 9,/4B8,9 /<41 ,-./ /<8 7<,/,@.?7<1 7.,>-B8> ?/ G% ?1 :8== ?1 /<8 <,-18 :?.C49@49A4/?/4,9B?.>7.,>-B8>?/G%/,B,9/89>/<?/ /<8 1?4> ?>C4//8> >,B-C89/1 :,-=> B?/8@,.4B?==6 49>4B?/8 /<81/?/-1,;/<87?./481/,:<4B</<86?.8?BB-1/,C8>/, <8.8;,.8 /<8 *?C4=6 ,-./ ,-@</ /, <?A8 B,914>8.8> @.?9/49@ ,; ? H-1/4;4?5=8 ?C,-9/ ;,. /<8 7-.7,18 ,;
C?49/89?9B8 ,; /<8 78/4/4,98.:4;8 89B8 188E1 ;,. 89<?9B8C89/
- 5 -
/<8B,-918=;,..817,9>89/<-15?9> 1-5C4//<?//<8.817,9>89/<-15?9>41:,.E49@,9?>?4=6 :?@85?14149/<8<?9?A?==4?9>4/>,819,/58=,9@8>/, <4C 8 ;-./<8. 1-5C4/1 /<?/ /<,-@< /<8 7?./481 ?.8 .814>49@ 49 -.?> /<8 78/4/4,98.:4;8 <?1 ;4=8> /<8 7.,B88>49@1 49 4>?. ?9> /<8 4>?. *?C4=6 ,-./ <?1 9, H-.41>4B/4,9 ;,. /<8 1?C8 89B8 188E1 ;,. ?==,:49@ /<8 78/4/4,9;4=8>56/<8.817,9>89/<-15?9> ! 8?.>%8.-18>/<8.8B,.>1
<8 C?..4?@8 58/:889 /<8 7?./481 41 9,/ 49 >417-/8 <,-@< /<8 78/4/4,98.:4;8 <?> 1,-@</ ;,. ?9 ,.>8.,;C?49/89?9B849?1-C,;1""""78.C,9/< /,:?.>1 C?49/89?9B8 ,9 /<8 7.8C418 ,; .817,9>89/ <-15?9> 8?.949@ 1#"""" 78.
>?6 1<8 <?1 9,/ 7.,>-B8> ?96 >,B-C89/ 8A4>89B49@ /<8 1,-.B8 ,; 49B,C8 ,; /<8 .817,9>89/<-15?9> 1-B< ?9 49B,C8 ;.,C /<8 8?/8.6 5-149811 4C4=?.=6 /<,-@< /<8 .817,9>89/ <-15?9>B=?4C1/<?/<841,9=6?>?4=6 :?@88C7=,68849 /<8 8?/8.6 <8 <?1 ?=1, 9,/ 7.,>-B8> ?96 >,B-C89/ /,
- 6 -
1<,:/<?/<841?>?4=6:?@88C7=,688,:8A8./<8;?B/ .8C?491/<?//<8.817,9>89/<-15?9>418?.949@;.,C/<8 8?/8.6 5-149811 817,9>89/<-15?9> B,-=> <?A8 8G?C498>/<8,:98.,;/<88?/8.64;<8:?1?>?4=6:?@8 8C7=,688 , /<8.8;,.8 49;8.89B8 C?6 <?A8 /, 58 >.?:9 /<?/<841.-9949@/<8E<?9?A?=4 ) 8B,9>=6 /<8 >,B-C89/ 7.,>-B8> ?/ G% :<4B< 41 /<8 <,-18 :?.C49@ B8.8C,96 ?77?.89/=6 B,9>-B/8>56/<8 .817,9>89/<-15?9> ?9><417?.89/1,;
/<84. <,-18 :,-=> ?=1, 49>4B?/8 /<8 1/?/-1 /, :<4B< /<8 7?./481 :8.8 ?BB-1/,C8> /, 98 ,; /<8 B.4/8.4? ;,. @.?9/49@ C?49/89?9B8 41 ?7?./ ;.,C 1,-.B8 ,; 49B,C8 41 /<81/?/-1/,:<4B</<87?./481:8.8?BB-1/,C8> 0 ,914>8.49@ /<8 C?/8.4?= C?>8 ?A?4=?5=8 ,9 .8B,.>?9>/<81-5C4114,9,;7?./481/<41,-./>88C14/ ?77.,7.4?/8/<?//<878/4/4,9;4=8>56/<878/4/4,98.:4;858 B,914>8.8>5689<?9B49@/<8C?49/89?9B8;.,C1)""" /, 1(""" ?9> /<8 78/4/4,9 ;4=8> 56 /<8 .817,9>89/ <-15?9>41?BB,.>49@=6>41C4118>
- 7 -
<878/4/4,9%* ,""# ";4=8>56/<8 78/4/4,98.:4;841 ( <8 .817,9>89/<-15?9> 41 >4.8B/8> /, 7?6 ? 1-C ,; 1(""" 78. C,9/< ?1 C?49/89?9B8 /, /<8 78/4/4,98.:4;8 <8 89<?9B8C89/ 1<?== 58 8;;8B/4A8 ;.,C /<8>?/8,;/<41,.>8. #" <878/4/4,9%* ,""##""!;4=8>56/<8 78/4/4,98.<-15?9>41
)' *$ $+ &
41/ ,#= ,( %