- 1 - !" # $ % %% &'( ) ! " # $% &'(")" * + ,, & , , ,, ' + &)" , *- "& *)).*)* +! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - + , , "."! , + + ,+ + ,+ & "*.#*)"' "/"**)** , + + , + + + 0 + $ " +1234561237891:5;<=><56;?41; * 6?;2@@12A?;=?A14>B561CA2?92:5272?:;5561 D84791:5 2:4 2E234 42514 "/"**)** @2;;14>B 561 44?5?<:2A 1:?<3 ?F?A 8471 2:4 19>13 & ?D2B2@832 G=<3 ;6<35 H3?>8:2AIJ ?: <"*.#*)"' ;11K?:71:62:C191:5<=C<9@1:;25?<: 61 ?:D8314 CA2?92:5 2714 ) B123; 915 E?56 2: 2CC?41:5 <: "))#*)"' 2:4 ;8;52?:14 73?1F<8; ?:D83?1; +1:C1 ;61 =?A14 2 CA2?9 @15?5?<: >1=<31 561 3?>8:2A ;11K?:7 C<9@1:;25?<: <= ;#))))))& 61 - 3 - 3?>8:2A 2=513 C<:;?413?:7 561 1:5?31 1F?41:C1 <: 31C<34 2E23414561C<9@1:;25?<:<= ;*'""))&E?56?:5131;5 25(L@132::89=3<95614251<=@15?5?<:5?AA312A?M25?<: 2:44?31C51431;@<:41:5<*&:;832:C1<9@2:B5<@2B 561C<9@1:;25?<: # 773?1F14 >B 561 ;2?4 2E234 561 2@@1AA2:5& CA2?92:562;@31=1331456?;2@@12A92?:ABC<:51:4?:75625 561C<9@1:;25?<:2E23414>B5613?>8:2A?;?:241N8251 5 ?; C<:51:414 5625 CA2?92:5 62; ;8;52?:14 73?1F<8; ?:D83?1; 5< 2AA <F13 561 ><4B- ;61 E2; 5312514 2; ?:4<<3 @25?1:5=<32@13?<4<=##42B;-"&<C5<362;2;;1;;14 5614?;2>?A?5B<=)L5<.L5<561:183<A<7?C2A4?;2>?A?5B >85 561 3?>8:2A C<:;?41314 561 4?;2>?A?5B 25 #)L 5 ?; 2A;< C<:51:414 561 ?:C<91 C<:;?41314 >B 561 3?>8:2A 25 ;"".)&@139<:56?;<:561A<E13;?412:4568;561 C<9@1:;25?<:2E23414>B5613?>8:2A8:4132AA6124;?; <:561A<E13;?416131=<3131N81;514=<31:62:C?:7561 C<9@1:;25?<: - 4 - 5 ?; ;8>9?5514 >B 561 A123:14 C<8:;1A =<3 31;@<:41:5 <* O :;832:C1 <9@2:B 5625 561 C<9@1:;25?<:2E23414>B5613?>8:2A?;D8;52:4@3<@13 2:4:114;:<?:513=131:C1 ( 49?5514AB ?5 ?; 561 C2;1 <= 561 4?;2>?A?5B ;8==1314>B561CA2?92:5;@13P &<8:4135?=?C251 561CA2?92:562;;8;52?:14561=<AA<E?:7?:D83?1; " ! . 61 CA2?92:5 1P29?:14 561 183<A<7?C2A 8371<: 2; " 2:4 61 ;52514 5625 CA2?92:5 62; 61242C61><4B2C61;61715;7?44?:1;;;6162;5?:7A?:7 2:4 :89>:1;; 2AA <F13 561 ><4B 2:4 ;61 62; A<;; <= 919<3B2:4A<;;<=C<:C1:5325?<:,83561361;5251;5625 - 5 - 561 CA2?92:5 C2::<5 52AK @3<@13AB 2:4 ;61 62; A1;; ;A11@ 2:4;61?;41@1:41:5<:68;>2:42:4=29?AB919>13;=<3 613 42?AB 3<85?:1; 61 8:4137<:1 C32:?<5<9B <: ")#*)"' CC<34?:7AB 561 "62; 2;;1;;14 )L5< .L 4?;2>?A?5B 61 3?>8:2A C<:;?413?:7 561 1:5?31 1F?41:C1 2F2?A2>A1 <: 31C<34 62; 3?765AB 2;;1;;14 )L 4?;2>?A?5BE6?C6:114;:<?:513=131:C1 ' ,835613 56<876 561 CA2?92:5 ;5251; 5625 ;61 E2;123:?:7 ;")))&@139<:56;6162;:<5@3<48C14 2:B 4<C891:5 5< @3<F1 561 ;291 ; 561 2CC?41:5 ?; <= 561 B123 *)"' 2; @13 561 78?41A?:1; ?;;814 >B 561 23:252K25251172A13F?C1;856<3?5B5613?>8:2A62; 3?765AB C<:;?41314 :<5?<:2A ?:C<91 <= 561 CA2?92:5 25 ;"".)& @13 9<:56 ; 561 CA2?92:5 E2; 2714 ) B123; 25 561 5?91 <= 2CC?41:5 561 3?>8:2A 62; 3?765AB 24414#)L<= ;"".)&! !" ;#.))&5<E234;=85831 @3<;@1C5; 2:4 3?765AB 2E23414 2 ;89 <= ;"(../))& 5<E234; A<;; <= =85831 123:?:7 C2@2C?5B E6?C6 :114; :< ?:513=131:C1 >B 56?; <835 ; @13 561 914?C2A >?AA; 561 - 6 - 3?>8:2A 2E23414 2 ;89 <= ;")*/#'& 5<E234; 914?C2A1P@1:;1;E6?C62A;<:114;:<?:513=131:C1 / 61 CA2?92:5 E2; 249?5514 ?: 561 6<;@?52A =<3 ##42B;<:;?413?:7561@13?<4<=6<;@?52A?M25?<::25831 <= ?:D83?1; 2:4 <5613 31A1F2:5 =2C5<3; 56?; <835 =?:4; ?5 312;<:2>A1 5< 732:5 2: 29<8:5 <= ;")))))& =<3 @2?: 2:4 ;8==13?:7 ;#))))& =<3 A<;; <= 291:?5?1; ;#))))& =<3 532:;@<3525?<: 1P532 :<83?;691:5 2:4 2551:42:5C62371;815<561?:D83?1;561CA2?92:59?765 :<5 62F1 2551:414 2:B E<3K 25 A12;5 =<3 2 @13?<4 <= ( 9<:56;61:C1;61?;1:5?5A14=<3 ;.)))&=<3A<;;<= ?:C<91483?:7A2?48@@13?<4 ") 61 C<9@1:;25?<: 2E23414 >B 561 3?>8:2A ?; 9<4?=?142;8:413 A < +124; E234>B561 3?>8:2A E234>B56?; <835 " 2?:2:4;8==13?:7 ;))))& ;")))))& * 14?C2AP@1:;1; ;")*/#'& ;")*/#'& <;; <= =85831 123:?:7C2@2C?5B ;"(../))& ;"(../))& - 7 - # 32:;@<3525?<: 1P532 :<83?;691:5 2:4 2551:42:5C62371; ;"))& ;#))))& <;;<=291:?5?1; ;")))& ;#))))& ( <;; <= ?:C<91 483?:7 A2?4 8@ @13?<4 ;*))& ;.)))& <52A ;*'""'& ;*/.''& 6131E?AA>11:62:C191:5<= ;"#())& "" :56131;8A5561=<AA<E?:7<3413?;@2;;14 ?! @@12A?; ??! 61 CA2?92:5 ?; 1:5?5A14 =<3 561 1:62:C14 C<9@1:;25?<: <= ;"#())& E?56 ?:5131;5 25 (L @13 2::89 =3<9 561 4251 <= @15?5?<:5?AA5614251<=312A?M25?<: ???! 1;@<:41:5 <* O :;832:C1 <9@2:B ?; 4?31C514 5< 41@<;?5 561 2=<31;2?4 C<9@1:;25?<:29<8:52A<:7E?56?:5131;5E?56?: <:19<:56=3<95614251<=56?;D84791:5 - 8 - ?F! : ;8C6 41@<;?5 561 CA2?92:5 ?; @139?55145<E?56432E5611:5?3129<8:52A<:7 E?56?:5131;52CC3814<:?5 *+, &% ( $ ?;5<"A<.*