- 1 - !"# $#%## # &' &()* &)) + !"!#$ % !"!$& '( & ! !"!#$ %'() '( * ' ( !"!#$ Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !"!$+ & & % !"!#$ * ' , -$&$&! &( #"& ' ( !&" '( ( % '( !&$+ + '('( '&( ""# & ' &$! ( . - 3 - ' . ( /0 10232345 36 73809 :; 102323450<6 35=4>35? 35/0<052 @A<3693B2345 47 2/36 4A<2 A590< 0B2345 !&" 47 /C<C23;C C?C<3> A<C>6/C C5/32C &$& 600>35? DAC6/35? 47 2/0 105935? 1<4B00935?6 35 10B3C8 C60 '( 4!&$+ C<3635?4A247 <3E04&$! <0?3620<09 :;4>C;A>2C 483B0 39C< 74< 2/0 47705B0 1A536/C:80 A590< 0B23456 + C59 '( '( <0C9 F32/ 0B2345 '&( 47 <0=052345 47 4<<A12345 B2 "" ' B2( C59 0B2345 # 47 593C5 05C8 490 "-$ 105935? 45 2/0 7380 47 <8 362<3B2 C59 0663456A9?039C< & /0102323450<6B4520592/C22/0B45235AC234547 B<3E35C8 1<4B00935?6 F4A89 CE4A52 24 C5 C:A60 47 2/0 1<4B066478CF1C<23BA8C<8;3583?/2472/03<0G450<C234545 390523BC8 B/C<?06 35 C 902C3809 901C<2E052C8 05DA3<; B459AB209 :; 2/0 1C84>C;A>2C 2 36 6A:E32209 2/C2 2/0 C880?C23456F0<02/4<4A?/8;0GCE3509352/06C3905DA3<; - 4 - C59 2/0 B/C<?06 F0<0 BC20?4<3BC88; /089 24 :0 A56A62C35C:8045E0<326 /0 :<307 7CB26 80C935? 24 2/0 1<06052 1<4B00935?6C<0C6A590< B4E18C352 BCE0 24 :0 849?09 :074<0 <061459052 4 45 &+$"&$! F/0<035 2/0 B4E18C35C52 C660<209 2/C2 /0 9063<09 24 ?02 2/0 1/493 F4<> BC<<309 4A2 35 <0610B2478C59:0C<35?;4$#E0C6A<35?-CB<06$ ?A52C6@43528;4F509:;/367C2/0<:<42/0<C59/3E6087 BB4<935? 24 2/0 B4E18C35C52 F/05 /0 C11<4CB/09 102323450< 4& F/4 FC6 2/05 F4<>35? C6 C A<=0;4< 35 2/0 4773B0 47 2/0 C/6389C< 102323450< 4& C880?098; 90EC59093880?C8?<C2373BC234547Rs.!$$$$ 74<7CB3832C235? 2/06C39F4<> # /0 B4E18C35C52 7A<2/0< C660<26 2/C2 :035? A5F38835? 24 6ABBAE: 24 2/0 C880?09 90EC59 /0 C11<4CB/09 2/0 4>C;A>2C 483B0 45 &&$"&$! C59 5C<<C209 2/0 35B39052 5 CBB4<9C5B0 F32/ 2/0 62C59C<9 - 5 - 2<C1 1<4B09A<06 2/0 4>C;A>2C 483B0 1<4=3909 C 93?32C8 =43B0 <0B4<90< 24 2/0 B4E18C35C52 24 BC12A<0 2/0 C880?09 B45=0<6C2345236C880?092/C2102323450<4&8C20<=363209 2/0 B4E18C35C52 C845? F32/ 102323450< 4 9A<35? F/3B/ 102323450< 4& <0320<C209 90EC596 47 Rs.&$$$$ 74< 1<01C<C2345 47 2/0 311C53 Rs.!$$$ 74< 6A<=0; F4<> C59 Rs.$$$ 0CB/ 74< CBBA609 46 C59 & 24FC<96 C5B388C<; 0G105606 /0 B4E18C35C52 B8C3E6 2/C2 2/060 B45=0<6C23456F0<09A8;<0B4<909 ! C609 45 2/0 C:4=0 C880?C23456 <3E0 4&$!FC6<0?3620<09A:60DA0528;45&+$"&$! C2 C<4A59 -$ 1E 2/0 4>C;A>2C 483B0 4<?C53609 C 2<C1 9A<35? F/3B/ 102323450< 4& FC6 C880?098; BCA?/2 F/38090EC5935?Rs.&$$$$ 7<4E2/0B4E18C35C5242/ 102323450<6 F0<0 2/0<0C720< C11<0/05909 C59 1<49AB09 :074<0 2/0 @A<3693B2345C8 4A<2 145 B4E1802345 47 35=0623?C2345 C B/C<?0 6/002 FC6 73809 C59 2/0 80C<509 362<3B2 C59 0663456 A9?0 39C< 244> B4?53HC5B0 C59 <0?3620<0910B3C8C60'(4!&$+74<2<3C8 - 6 - - /0 102323450<6 6A:E32 2/C2 2/0 901C<2E052C8 05DA3<; 35323C209 45 2/0 =0<; 6CE0 602 47 C880?C23456 0=3905B0 C59 B3<BAE62C5B06 <06A8209 35 2/03< B4E18020 0G450<C2345 45 E0<326 2 36 A<?09 2/C2 635B0 C 901C<2E052C8 35DA3<; 410<C206 45 C B4E1C<C23=08; 80660< 62C59C<9 47 1<447 5CE08; 1<014590<C5B0 47 1<4:C:3832306 C590=05456AB/62C59C<92/0B/C<?06F0<074A5924:0 A56A:62C523C209 10<E32235? 2/0 B<3E35C8 1<460BA2345 F/3B/<0DA3<061<447:0;459<0C645C:8094A:2241<4B009 F4A89:0A5FC<<C5209/0102323450<67A<2/0<0E1/C63H0 2/C254C9932345C8359010590524<7<06/EC20<3C836<08309 A145 :; 2/0 1<460BA2345 35 2/0 B<3E35C8 BC60 /0<074<0 B45235AC2345472/0B<3E35C81<4B00935?6F4A89:0C7A2380 0G0<B360 C59 C5 C:A60 47 1<4B066 B452<C<; 24 2/0 1<35B31806 8C39 94F5 :; 2/0 45I:80 A1<0E0 4A<2 35 !! "# + 0< B452<C 80C<509 B4A5608 C110C<35? 74< 2/0 4>C;A>2C 6A:E326 2/C2 E0<0 0G450<C2345 35 C - 7 - 901C<2E052C8 35DA3<; 9406 542 CA24EC23BC88; FC<<C52 DAC6/35? 47 B<3E35C8 1<4B00935?6 2 36 B45205909 2/C2 1A<6AC52 24 2/0 2<C1 2/0 102323450<6 F0<0 BCA?/2 <09 /C5909 F/380 90EC5935? 3880?C8 ?<C2373BC2345 2/0<0C720< C11<0/05909 C59 1<49AB09 :074<0 2/0 B4E102052 4A<2 2367A<2/0<6A:E322092/C2C901C<2E052C805DA3<;:035?C 6AEEC<;1<4B00935? 326 4A2B4E0 BC5542:0 C 6480 :C636 74<20<E35C235?B<3E35C81<460BA2345 " C=35?/0C<92/080C<509B4A560874<2/01C<2306 C59 10<A609 2/0 @A9?E0526 <08309 A145 2/0 366A0 2/C2 C<360674<B456390<C234536 J/02/0< B45235AC2345 47 B<3E35C8 1<4B00935?6 36 @A6237309 F/05 2/0 102323450<6 /C=0 :005 0G450<C20945E0<32635C901C<2E052C835DA3<; 45 390523BC8 B/C<?06 C59 F/05 54 C9932345C8 EC20<3C83674<2/B4E35?352/0B<3E35C8BC60KL 074<0 0GCE3535? 2/0 6A62C35C:3832; 47 2/0 1<4B00935?62/364A<2900E632C11<41<3C20240G2<CB22/0 <080=C52 735935?6 <0B4<909 :; 2/0 5DA3<; 773B0< F/380 - 8 - 0G450<C235? 2/0 102323450<6 C<C?<C1/6 &$ 24 $ 47 2/0 05DA3<;<014<2C<0471C<23BA8C<63?5373BC5B0C592/06CE0 C<02/0<074<0<01<49AB09/0<03574<<0C9;<070<05B0 ! "" # # $% & '( '()* " %$ #'( '() +!# ,$$$ $ $ "! $"$ "!" -# + ! # $ ) .%" # " # , # # & ! ! "$ # $ #"" ) - !$ # "" " #""" # * ! # $$!" / ) .! ## " 0 # ! ! " # ! ! " - 9 - # & ) . " "#, ,* + " " " " , , *..+#! # 1! # "!"$ # ! . , " ! # ) . " 2+ %# " 2/3 )//3/ $ ! 2 2 / 4 / " ( " $% ) 4 / " "# ! !+!! $%# ! " + ! !#) 4 / $%5"6 +%5# / 3 / ,"7 $% $ ! " + # $ 6 $ 3 8 + # +$##"# $ ## # + $!# ! # $ ""+ # ! ( '(4 . # # ( "! - 10 - 8+%# %$ ,! , 9 +: 6 4 3 2 %$ ! %$ $ ! !( '(3 4& "! ! # * ! ! "" # # $% "" # + !# "#% " "" # & ! # $ $$%# "# # ! "" # $% - #! $%# $"# # # ###! 3 & ! # ) " * ! # $ $ !" # $ ) . $ # ! #"" "; $ $% # $"# - * ! ! "$ #"" "# ###!# - 11 - < & ! # ) . $ # ! ! $$" # '( 0 - " ).$ !# ! # ## " # * " # # * #""" . * ##" ""= $ 5 C B8460 C59 BC<07A8 0GCE35C2345 47 2/0 735935?6 <0B4<909 :; 2/0 5DA3<; 773B0< B0<2C35 B<AB3C8 C610B26 0E0<?0 F32/ A5E362C>C:80 B8C<32; /0 74<0E462 CE45? 2/0E 36 2/C2 2/0 C880?C23456 74<E35? 2/0 :C636 47 :42/ 2/0 901C<2E052C8 05DA3<; C59 2/0 1<06052 B<3E35C8 1<4B00935?6 C<0 390523BC8 35 EC20<3C8 1C<23BA8C<6 /0 7CB2AC8 6A:62<C2AE 2/0 5C2A<0 47 CBBA6C23456 C59 2/0 F32506606 B3209 C<0 2/0 6CE0 B4E1C<C23=0 <0C935? 47 2/0 05DA3<; <0B4<96 C59 2/0 B/C<?0 6/002 EC20<3C86 90E4562<C206 2/C2 2/0 =0<; F32506606 F/460 20623E45; FC60=C8AC2099A<35?2/0901C<2E052C805DA3<;/C=0:005 - 12 - C?C35 B3209 35 2/0 B<3E35C8 1<4B00935?6 /A6 2/0 0=390523C<; 74A59C2345 35 :42/ 1<4B00935?6 36 542 E0<08; 63E38C<:A26A:62C523C88;390523BC8 7A<2/0< 63?5373BC52 B3<BAE62C5B0 2/C2 BC5542 :0 8462 63?/2 47 36 2/C2 2/0 >0; 6/C94F F325066 F/4 FC6 359361056C:80 74< 1<4=35? 2/0 C880?09 90EC59 36 <014<209 24 :0 54 845?0< C83=0 4<0 3E14<2C528; 2/0 B4E18C35C52 /3E6087F/4362/013=42472/00523<01<460BA2345=0<6345 939 542 6A114<2 2/0 C880?C23456 9A<35? 2/0 901C<2E052C8 1<4B00935?6 C59 BC20?4<3BC88; <063809 7<4E /36 0C<830< 62C20E0526 /0 <0B4<96 <0=0C8 2/C2 2/0 901C<2E052C8 CA2/4<32;A590<244>C7A88 7809?0905DA3<;:;0GCE3535?C88 <080=C52 F32506606 C59 94BAE0526 145 6AB/ 902C3809 6B<A235; 32 FC6 B45B8A909 2/C2 2/0 B/C<?06 F0<0 F/488; A51<4=09 /0 1<460BA2345 /C6 542 18CB09 C5; 50F 359010590524<C9932345C8EC20<3C8C845?F32/2/0B/C<?0 6/002 2/C2 B4A89 936235?A36/ 2/0 B<3E35C8 BC60 7<4E 2/0 901C<2E052C805DA3<;05B02/0B<3E35C8BC60360523<08; - 13 - 74A5909 45 2/0 =0<; 6CE0 0=3905B0 F/3B/ /C6 C8<0C9; :005936:0830=09 & 2 36 F088 6022809 C59 50096 54 <0320<C2345 2/C2 2/0 62C59C<9 47 1<447 <0DA3<09 35 C B<3E35C8 2<3C8 36 7A59CE052C88; 93770<052 C59 F/05 B4E1C<09 24 C 901C<2E052C8 05DA3<; /0<0C6 C 901C<2E052C8 05DA3<; 1<4B0096 45 2/0 24AB/62450 47 1<014590<C5B0 47 1<4:C:3832306 C B<3E35C8 1<460BA2345 EC59C206 1<447 :0;459 C88 <0C645C:80 94A:2 /36 936235B2345 /C6 :005 <010C2098;0E1/C63H09:;2/045I:80A1<0E04A<235C BC205C 47 @A9?E0526 35B8A935? $ %%& % !! , !! "#,C59' ( ) *$ +, !- % !! & & /0 BAEA8C23=0 80?C8 0770B2 47 2/060 CA2/4<32C23=0 1<454A5B0E0526362/C2F/0<0C880?C234567C380=05452/0 84F0< 62C59C<9 47 1<447 C1183BC:80 24 901C<2E052C8 1<4B00935?6 2/0; BC5542 :0 10<E32209 24 6A<=3=0 2/0 /3?/0<2/<06/489<0DA3<0935B<3E35C88CF - 14 - 118;35?2/06060228091<35B31806242/07CB2645 /C59 32 :0B4E06 0=39052 2/C2 2/0 102323450<6 F0<0 6A:@0B209 24 C B4E1<0/0563=0 901C<2E052C8 05DA3<; B459AB2091C<C8808242/0B<3E35C81<460BA2345452/0=0<; 6CE0 C880?C23456 0=3905B0 C59 B3<BAE62C5B06 /0 05DA3<; FC6 5032/0< 6AEEC<; 54< 10<7A5B24<; 35 5C2A<0 52/0B452<C<;2/0<0B4<96<0780B22/C232FC6C902C3809 62<AB2A<09 C59 0G/CA623=0 0G0<B360 0=0<C8 F32506606 35B8A935?2/0B4E18C35C522/04773B0<635=48=09352/02<C1 1<4B00935?6C6F088C64773B3C86B45=0<6C52F32/2/01/493 C59 2311C53 1<4B09A<06 F0<0 0GCE3509 C2 805?2/ /0 C880?C23456F0<06B<A2353H097<4EC88<080=C52C5?806:074<0 2/0102323450<6F0<00G450<C209 # /005DA3<;<014<2<0=0C862/C22/0B4E18C35C52 ' ( A50DA3=4BC88; 2A<509 /462380 C59 939 542 6A114<2 2/0 C880?C23456 47 90EC59 4< CBB012C5B0 47 3880?C8 ?<C2373BC2345/06/C94FF325066F/4F4A89/C=0:005C B<AB3C8 35901059052 F325066 24 B4<<4:4<C20 2/0 C880?09 90EC59 36 54 845?0< C83=0 C59 2/0<074<0 A5C=C38C:80 24 - 15 - 206237;/05DA3<; 773B0<C720<CE023BA84A6C5C8;63647 2/0 0523<0 EC20<3C8 <0B4<909 C B80C< 735935? 2/C2 54 0=3905B0 F4<2/; 47 <083C5B0 FC6 74<2/B4E35? 0=05 24 062C:836/ 2/0 B/C<?0 45 2/0 :C636 47 1<014590<C5B0 47 1<4:C:3832306 4560DA0528; :; C 902C3809 C59 <0C64509 4<90<9C209&&$+&$&#2/0936B31835C<;CA2/4<32;9<41109 2/0 B/C<?06 C59 0G450<C209 2/0 102323450<6 /0 735935?6 C<0 BC20?4<3BC8 2/C2 2/0 1<460BA2345 624<; B488C1609 45 E0<326 C59 7C3809 24 B<466 0=05 2/0 E353EAE 0=390523C<; 2/<06/489C1183BC:8024901C<2E052C81<4B00935?6 ! 5=30F472/060B<323BC8735935?6<0B4<909352/0 901C<2E052C8 1<4B00935?6 B4A1809 F32/ 2/0 CA2/4<32C23=0 1<454A5B0E0526 47 2/0 45I:80 A1<0E0 4A<2 35 $ ' ( ) 2/36 4A<2 36 47 2/0 B456390<09 4135345 2/C2 B45235AC2345 47 2/0 B<3E35C8 1<460BA2345 35 10B3C8 C60 '( 4!&$+ F4A89 B456232A20 6/00< C:A60 47 1<4B066 47 8CF /0 1<460BA2345 :035? 0523<08; :C609 45 0=3905B0 C8<0C9; 936:0830=09 35 C 902C3809 - 16 - 05DA3<; C59 54 C9932345C8 EC20<3C8 /C=35? :005 :<4A?/2 45<0B4<92/0B<3E35C81<4B00935?6BC5542:010<E3220924 B45235A0 - 4< 2/0 74<0?435? <0C6456 2/36 4A<2 1<4B0096 241C662/074884F35? 3 /0<3E35C8023234536 33 /0 0523<0 1<4B00935?6 35 10B3C8 C60 '( 4!&$+ C<3635? 4A2 47 <3E0 4&$! <0?3620<09 :; 2/0 4>C;A>2C 483B0 39C< 74< 2/0 47705B06 1A536/C:80 A590< 0B23456 + C59 '('9( <0C9 F32/ 0B2345 '&( 47 2/0 <0=052345 47 4<<A12345 B2 "" C59 0B2345 # 47 593C5 05C8 490 "-$ 105935? 45 2/0 7380 47 <8 362<3B2 C59 0663456 A9?0 39C<C<0/0<0:;DAC6/09 - 17 - 333 88 105935? 3520<84BA24<; C1183BC23456 37 C5;62C599361460947 ,* &##) % 3624&84&