- 1 - ! " # $ $%&' $&& ( ! " # $ $ ! % # %&&' ( ) ' ( $ %& ) ' ( Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ $'(!%$'( ( * && ' + ( $ # && ' +( !& $ " " $ ',( '-( '.($ & " $$ $ $ ( $ $ / / 0 " '/0 " ( 12341516 765-5-28-9 :-956.;2< ,.=-99-28 >-51516 ?289685 2; :6,<86. ?23896: ;2< 516 7,<5-69 -5 -9 5,@68 37 ;2<;-8,:.-9729,: 16 765-5-286<9 A6-84 ,??396. 29 ,8. -8 2!&28516;-:62;:6,<86. ..-5-28,:-B-: "3.46 ,8. " $ ,:,A3<,4- <64-956<6. ;2< 516 2;;68?6 738-91,A:6 38.6< 6?5-28 ',('-( 738-91,A:6 38.6< - 3 - 6?5-28 '.( 2; 516 <349 ,8. 29=65-?9 ?5 & ,<6 966@-8452C3,91516?<-=-8,:7<2?66.-849-8-5-,56.,4,-895 516= D 6,<. <- -51E,8,8., :6,<86. ?23896: ;2<516765-5-286<9,8.<-27,:@<-918, ,.,B:6,<86. -41 23<5 2B6<8=685 :6,.6< ;2< 516 <69728.685 F 5,566<396.516=,56<-,:928<6?2<. 8 B-6> 2; 516 <-B,: ?285685-289 3<46. AE 516 :6,<86.?23896:;2<A2515167,<5-6951672-8551,5>23:. ,<-96;2<=E?289-.6<,5-28-9/ !" E,89>6<52516,A2B672-85-9-8516 ;2<516;2::2>-84/ % 7<-B,56 ?2=7:,-85 ?,=6 52 A6 ;-:6. AE 516 5,56 ,5 516 -895,8?6 2; 99-95,85 <349 2852::6< - 4 - ,:,A3<,4--<?:6,:,A3<,4-,4,-895,??396.2A6-84 5161,<=,?635-?,:2=7,8E,8.,??396.2A6-84516 6?18-?,: -<6?52< ,8. 3512<-G6. -48,52<E ,8. ,:92 <697289-A:6 76<928 ;2< .,E52.,E ,?5-B-5-69 2; ,??396. 2,::64-84?2==-99-282;5162;;68?6738-91,A:638.6< 6?5-28 ',('-( 738-91,A:6 38.6< 6?5-28 '.( 2; 516 <349,8.29=65-?9 ?5& 16 :6,<86. ?23896: ;2< 516 765-5-286<9 ?28568.6. 51,5 5,@-84 ?248-G,8?6 2; 516 2;;68?6 AE 516 <-,: 23<5 -9 A6E28. 516 76<-2. 2; :-=-5,5-28 ,8. -5 -9 -8 B-2:,5-282;6?5-282;<6,:92?28568.6.51,5 -8B-6>2;6?5-28D'(2;516<349,8.29=65-?9 ?5-5 -9 28:E 516 76?-,:!699-28 23<5 >1-?1 -9 ,3512<-G6. 52 5,@6?248-G,8?62;5162;;68?635-85167<69685?,96 :6,<86. ,4-95<,56 1,9 5,@68 ?248-G,8?6 >1-?1 -9 A,. 38.6<:,> 6?5-28 D 2; 516 <349 ,8. 29=65-?9 ?5 .6,:9 >-51 5,@-84 ?248-G,8?6 2; 516 2;;68?6 ,8. 3A - 5 - 6?5-28'(A,<9,8E2516<23<59-8;6<-2<5251623<52; 699-28;<2=5,@-84?248-G,8?6,8.5162;;68?638.6<51-9 1,756< 976<6?5-28'('?(2;<516<6-9A,< ;2<5,@-84?248-G,8?6,;56<:,7962;76<-2.2;:-=-5,5-28,8. 51676<-2.7<69?<-A6.38.6<:,396'?(2;3A6?5-28'( 2; 9,-. 6?5-28 -9 51<66 E6,<9 >168 516 2;;68?6 -9 738-91,A:6 >-51 -=7<-928=685 ;2< , 56<= 6H?66.-84 286 E6,<A358256H?66.-8451<66E6,<9162;;68?6,::646. -85167<69685?,96;,::938.6<3A6?5-282;?:,396'?( 2;6?5-282;< 976<516?,962;5167<296?35-285169,=7:6 .<34>,9.<,>8;<2=,??396.29,8.28&&D& ,8. 9685 ;2< ,8,:E9-9 16 99-95,85 <349 285<2::6< 93A=-556.1-9<672<528&&&,96.285169,=6 ,7<-B,56?2=7:,-85?,=652A6;-:6.28&&16<6 -9 :284 :,796 2; =2<6 51,8 &% E6,<9 -8 ;-:-84 516 7<-B,56 ?2=7:,-85 - 6 - & 6,<86. ?23896: ;2< 516 765-5-286< 1,9 7:,?6. <6:-,8?6 28 516 .6?-9-28 2; 51-9 23<5 -8 >16<6-8 2<.-8,56 68?1 2; 51-9 23<5 1,9 ?289-.6<6. , 9-=-:,< 9-53,5-28 >16<6 516 ?248-G,8?6 >,95,@68,;56<51676<-2.2;:-=-5,5-28 #AE?28.28-84 516 .6:,E 2; & E6,<9 & =28519 AE ,::2>-84 ,77:-?,5-28 ;-:6. 38.6< 6?5-28 % 2; 516 -=-5,5-28 ?5 , ?285685-28 >,9 <,-96. 51,5 516<6 >,9 .6:,E -8 4655-84 516 9,8?5-28!76<=-99-28 ;<2= 516 ?2=765685 ,3512<-5E 38.6< 6?5-28 DD 2; 516 ?5 16 2<.-8,56 68?1 =,.6 -5 ?:6,<51,5,976<6?5-28DD2;516<349,8.29=65-?9 ?5 1,756< F -9 ,77:-?,A:6 28:E 52 ?6<5,-8 .<349 >1-?1,<6 E3<B6.-?-..1,2<8,8- 8 516 7<69685 ?,96 516 .<349 ,::646. -9 ::27,51-?,8.-5.269825;,::38.6<1,756< F 2;<349 ,8. 29=65-?9 ?5 16 2<.-8,56 68?1 1,9 ?,5642<-?,::E 16:. 51,5 -5 -9 825 516 .,56 28 >1-?1 516 1 <:2!&D!&& - 7 - 23<5 5,@69 ?248-G,8?6 2; 516 2;;68?6 51,5 -5 A6?,=6 ,77:-?,A:6;2<<-42<2;6?5-282;<A35516.,56 28 >1-?1 ?<-=-8,: ?,96 ?,=6 52 A6 <64-956<6. 8 516 7<69685?,969,=7:69>6<6.<,>828&&D&,8.516 <672<5 ;<2= 516 99-95,85 <349 285<2::6< -9 <6?6-B6. 28 &&897-562;51,57<-B,56?2=7:,-85?,=652A6 ;-:6.28&& #,;56<:284:,7962;=2<651,8&% E6,<9 16<6;2<6 516 ?<-=-8,: 7<2?66.-849 -8-5-,56. A6E28.51676<-2.2;:-=-5,5-28-9:-,A:652A6C3,916. 5-9825-?6.51,5516<-,:23<5 #516:6,<86. ..-5-28,:-B-:"3.46,8." $,:,A3<,4-1,95,@68 ?248-G,8?6 2; 516 2;;68?6 28 516 A,9-9 2; 516 7<-B,56 ?2=7:,-85 ,8. <64-956<6. -82!& -482<-84 516 A,< 7<2B-.6. 38.6< 6?5-28 D 2; 516 <349 ,8. 29=65-?9 ?5 8 51-9 ?2385 ,:92 516 ?<-=-8,: 7<2?66.-849,<6:-,A:652A6C3,916. D 8B-6>2;516,A2B6,89>6<516,A2B672-85 -8516 ,8.7<2?66.527,99516;2::2>-84/ - 8 - '-( 16?<-=-8,:765-5-28-9,::2>6. '--( 16 ?<-=-8,: 7<2?66.-849 -8 2!&28516;-:62;516:6,<86. ..-5-28,: -B-: "3.46 ,8. " $ ,:,A3<,4- <64-956<6. ;2< 516 2;;68?69 38.6< 6?5-28 ',('-( 738-91,A:6 38.6< 6?5-28 '.( 2; 516 <349 ,8. 29=65-? ?5&,<616<6AEC3,916. 8 B-6> 2; .-9729,: 2; 516 ?<-=-8,: 765-5-28 2!&-9.-9=-996. )' $ & # ! -952/:2/D /