Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 43010 (KAR)
SHIVARAYA @ SHIVAARAO v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/200934/2025 · 2025-12-11
Sachin Shankar Magadum
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43010 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 43010 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$"%""
"
&' &()* '&)) +
! "# $" %
& ! '&
! "# $" %
( )" *$ +
,$ $
$" % ) " $"+
& $! ! $ *! Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$" -& (
)" $ " , . $ , &+
, & , " )!+ & , /
& , , * , $" , '
& , $" , ,," )+%&%' !% ,%
, ,
! 0" *$
12 34567892: 52676789 7; <7=2: >? 612 79=4@; 8< ;2389: A2;589:296
:4BC162A79=4@ ;22D79C EB4;179C 8< 612 5A8322:79C; 529:79C 79 8
& <8A 612 8<<2932; 5B97;14>=2 B9:2A 236789; %&% ' A24: @761 236789 % 8< 9:749 294= 8:2 ' 49: B9:2A236789;%49:8<8@A?A817>7678936' & 12;2389:A2;589:296@187;612:4BC162A79 =4@ 8< 612 526767892A; =8:C2:438F5=479689 '&
- 3 -
4==2C79C 6146 ;12 @4; ;B>G2362: 68 14A4;;F296 49: 7== 6A246F296>?12A1B;>49:49:79=4@;49:6146;12@4;
A252462:=? 382A32: 68 >A79C 4::767894= :8@A? <A8F 12A 54A2964= 18F2 12 <BA612A 4==2C2: 6146 12A 54A296; 14:
C7H29 ;B<<737296 :8@A? 46 612 67F2 8< F4AA74C2 79 612 5A2;2932 8< 892 7:A4F4554 4 A267A2: ? 49: 14:
4=;8 ;5296 49 4::767894= ;BF 8< ;&
68@4A:;
29C4C2F296 2I529;2; 338A:79C 68 12A ;12 =7H2: 4 38A:74= F4A764= =7<2 @761 433B;2: 8 89=? <8A 4>8B6 6@8 F8961;4<62A@173112A;7;62A79=4@@1814:38F218F2 <8A :2=7H2A? >2C49 4>B;79C 12A 79 <7=61? =49CB4C2 49:
;B>G23679C 12A 683AB2=6? "4;2: 89 612 ;47:38F5=4796 4 3A7F794= 34;2 @4; A2C7;62A2: 49: 4<62A 79H2;67C46789 612 9H2;67C4679C<<732A<7=2:4314AC2;1226 % 24A92: 38B9;2= <8A 612 526767892A; A2762A4679C 612CA8B9:;BAC2:7961252676789;B>F76;614679;8<4A4;
612;7;62A79=4@7;38932A92:612A74=8BA614;4=A24:? 4==8@2: 12A :7;314AC2 455=7346789 @1731 8A:2A 14; >229 B512=: >? 612 2H7;7894= 8BA6 79 A7F794= 2H7;789
- 4 -
2676789 8
&& 6 7; <BA612A ;B>F7662: 6146 612 526767892A; A2=? 89 612 GB:CF296 8< 612 ,4F7=? 8BA6 79 8&
& @12A279 612 F4AA74C2 >26@229 612 ;2389: A2;589:296 49: 433B;2: 8 14; >229 :7;;8=H2:
89 612 CA8B9: 8< :2;2A6789 18BC1 49 45524= 14; >229 5A2<2AA2: >? 612 ;2389: A2;589:296 38B9;2= 58796; 8B6 6146 612A2 14; >229 98 A25A2;29646789 49: 612 7962A7F 8A:2A24A=72ACA4962:>?6127H7;789"293114;986>229 2I629:2:;89:462987962A7F8A:2A7;79<8A32
2A3896A4612=24A92:7C18BA68H2A9F296 =24:2A 45524A79C <8A A2;589:296 8 - 6462 ;B>F76;
6146 986@761;649:79C 612 :7;;8=B6789 8< F4AA74C2 612 4==2C46789; 8< 3AB2=6? 49: 14A4;;F296 389;676B62 79:2529:296 3A7F794= 8<<2932; 49: 4A2 A2EB7A2: 68 >2 4:GB:73462: 89 6127A 8@9 F2A76; 2 ;B>F76; 6146 612 3A7F794= 5A8322:79C; 349986 >2 EB4;12: ;8=2=? 89 612 CA8B9:6146612F4A764=A2=46789;175>26@229433B;2:8 49:612;2389:A2;589:29614;;7932>229:7;;8=H2:
- 5 -
4H79C124A:612=24A92:38B9;2=89>861;7:2; 617;8BA614;34A2<B==?2I4F792:612GB:CF296A29:2A2: >? 612 ,4F7=?
8BA6 79 8&
&
"2<8A2 5A8322:79C <BA612A 617; 8BA6 <79:; 76 455A85A7462 68 A25A8:B3232A6479A2=2H496<79:79C;38964792:7954A4CA451 8;& 49: & 49: 612 52A679296 58A6789 8< 54A4CA451 8& 8< 612 ;47: GB:CF296 @1731 >24A :7A236=? 89 612 F47964794>7=76? 8< 612 5A2;296 5A8322:79C; 79;8<4A 4; 612 526767892A;
79=4@; 4A2 38932A92: 338A:79C=? 612 ;47: 54A4CA451;4A22I6A4362:12A279>2=8@
!"!! #
" #
# $
% ! "
! &
"" '
&( )
& *
+
"
"
#
- 6 -
+ ,! ! " # & ! ,! " & ! ,! &
" '
& ( " ! " *- #" ,! "
*-
" ! &(&! &
! *-
"
" ! *-% ,! "
! ! " +
! #
"
# # " #
"
- 7 -
. +
"
!" !! " #
#
#
"
! # # /01! +
"
! ! ! ! "! "
#
! " ! "
! 2! "
#
# ! #
#
" ! , ! ! "
! ! 3
"
- 8 -
"
! ! ! $
! "
4
! "
+
! ! "
+ "
! ! ! #
! #
#3
#
"
4
"
# ! #
! 5
! #
!" !! 6101 ! # !78.1#
!" !! "
-! 6.92:%%008 +*; +
- 9 -
#
" ! ! +
! # "
#
!" !! 3,/ 3,/8
"
! !" !! #
"
! "
+
!" !! "
#
# ! ! 2
"
"
4
" "
6,,,,2
#"
"
# #
! "
! "" ! "
"
#
" $
#
" $
- 10 -
7 ! 7
! 7%
! < 93! :<
' 9 4 34A2<B= 389;7:2A46789 8< 612 <79:79C;
2I6A4362: <A8F 612 GB:CF296 8< 612 ,4F7=? 8BA6 76 >238F2; 2H7:296 6146 ;2H2A4= F462A74= 4;5236; :237;7H2=? ;B558A6 612 34;2 8< 612 526767892A; 12 A238A:; :7;3=8;2 61466121B;>49:@17=2;22D79C:7;;8=B67898<F4AA74C279 8&
& 14; 389;7;6296=?
4;;2A62: 6146 612 ;2389: A2;589:296 14: =2<6 612 F46A7F8974= 18F2 79 368>2A & 17; 4;;2A6789 C479; ;B>;649674= 38AA8>8A46789<A8F54A4CA4518&8<612,4F7=?8BA6J;
GB:CF296@12A279612;2389:A2;589:29612A;2=< 14; 79 3462C8A734=62AF;4:F7662::BA79C3A8;;2I4F79467896146 ;12 14; >229 A2;7:79C 79 12A 54A2964= 18F2 <8A 612 54;6 <8BA?24A;
12 ,4F7=? 8BA6 4<62A 2I4F7979C I; 68 '14;A26BA92:43=24A49:<7AF<79:79C6146612;2389:
- 11 -
A2;589:296 14; >229 A2;7:79C ;254A462=? <A8F 612 526767892A1B;>49: ;7932 368>2A & 49: <BA612A 6146 612 38F5=4796 =8:C2:
>? 12A 4C479;6 612 5A2;296 526767892A; @18 4A2 612 79=4@; @4; 2H7:296=? F867H462:
>? 49 796296 68 14A4;; 49: 34B;2 F2964= 4C89? 68 612 1B;>49: 49: 17; <4F7=? F2F>2A; 12 ,4F7=? 8BA6 14;
<BA612A 8>;2AH2: 6146 612A2 7; 98 F462A74= @146;82H2A 68 :2F89;6A4626146612;2389:A2;589:296@4;;B>G2362:68 3AB2=6?>?6121B;>49:8A17;<4F7=?F2F>2A;4649?58796 4<62A368>2A&
12 B92EB7H834= <79:79C 8< H8=B964A? :2;2A6789 89 612 54A6 8< 612 ;2389: A2;589:296 38F5=262=? B9:2AF792; 612 4==2C46789; 8< 3AB2=6? ;47: 68 14H2 >229 F262:8B6>?612526767892A;8A6127A;8912;2<79:79C; >279C3462C8A734=49:>4;2:892H7:2932C868612A8868< 612 F4662A 49: ;6A7D2 46 612 H2A? <8B9:46789 8< 612 3A7F794=34;279767462:>?612;2389:A2;589:296
9612=7C168<6124>8H249:14H79C:B2A2C4A:
686124B618A76467H249:B94F>7CB8B;<79:79C;A238A:2:>? - 12 -
612,4F7=?8BA6617;8BA67;8<612389;7:2A2:H72@6146 389679B46789 8< 3A7F794= 5A8322:79C; 4C479;6 612 5A2;296 526767892A;@184A2;2978A3767K29;4C2:4>8B649:'& ?24A; @8B=: 4F8B96 68 4 CA8;; 4>B;2 8< 612 5A832;; 8< =4@123A7F794=34;214;A2F4792:529:79C;7932& 49: @2 4A2 98@ 79 612 ?24A && 2AF76679C 612 5A8;23B6789 68 389679B2 :2;5762 612 3=24A <436B4= <79:79C; A29:2A2:>?61238F526296,4F7=?8BA6@8B=:98689=?>2 3896A4A?686127962A2;6;8<GB;6732>B6@8B=:4=;8;B>G236 612526767892A;68B9@4AA4962:14A:;175
6 7; 4=;8 8< ;7C97<734932 6146 612 4==2C46789 8< 3AB2=6? 4C479;6 612 1B;>49: 17F;2=< 14; 986 >229 2;64>=7;12: 79 612 F46A7F8974= 5A8322:79C; 932 612 5A7F4A?4==2C46789<47=;612:2A7H467H2433B;46789;4C479;6 612 79=4@; @18 4A2 ;7F7=4A=? ;76B462: ;2978A 3767K29;
349986 >2 4==8@2: 68 ;649: 9 ;B31 37A3BF;64932; 612 526767892A; 4A2 <B==? 29676=2: 68 79H8D2 612 GBA7;:736789 8< 617; 8BA6 <8A EB4;179C 8< 612 5A8322:79C; B9:2A 236789 &8<612"14A467?44C4A7DBA4D;14491764&&%
- 13 -
589 49 79:2529:296 4;;2;;F296 8< 612 GB:CF296 A29:2A2: >? 612 ,4F7=? 8BA6 79
8&
&49:89418=7;673389;7:2A467898<612<436B4= F46A7I617;8BA67;;467;<72:61466123A7F794=5A8322:79C;
529:79C 4C479;6 612 526767892A; 349986 >2 52AF7662: 68 389679B212;4F24A2=74>=268>2EB4;12:338A:79C=? 612<8==8@79C8A:2A7;54;;2:
712526767897;
77125A8322:79C;798
&4A7;79C8B6 8< A7F2 8'
& 8< B=>4AC4 !8F29 8=732 646789 <8A 612 8<<2932; 5B97;14>=2 B9:2A 236789; %&% ' A24: @761 236789% 8<6129:749294= 8:2 '49:B9:2A236789;%49:8<6128@A?A817>76789 36 ' 529:79C 89 612 <7=2 8< 612 ::767894= * , 8BA6 $4=4>BA4C7 4A2 12A2>?
EB4;12: 79;8<4A 4; 612 5A2;296526767892A;4A238932A92:
- 14 -
777 6 7; 3=4A7<72: 6146 612 5A2;296 8A:2A ;14== 986 79 49?F4992A7F52:28A5A2GB:732612A7C16;8<612;2389:
A2;589:296
38F5=479496 79 5A8;23B679C , 8&
&&&@17317;529:79C4:GB:7346789>2<8A2612 89J>=27H7;789"29318<617;8BA6
,* &"") %
* 7;68&=8&