- 1 - !" #$%$$ $ &' &()* &)) + ! ! "" # " ""$%&''( ) * !" ! " "! + ! !" , Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! !" ' " * " " + - "" #"" " ! $%&' !" % ! ! "" # " ""$%&''( ) " * ! "!-. !""',','% "+ "" (& *"+ " %& *+ # " %&'" "!''% ! " " "" " " ( " " " " " / " - 3 - * / "+ 01234515167128194:;<50417$9=>2244?17@AB=2017@ 68 504 3C6D44:17@2 347:17@ 17 C1E17=9 12D499=746B2 6%&' 8194: B7:4C 4D5167 68 504 C654D5167 68 6E478C6E"6E4251D!16947D4D5''%*86C206C5F"! D5G+ 244?17@ D6E3472=5167 8C6E 504 345151674C2 =7: 0B2;=7:>0612765=3=C5<5650123C6D44:17@2 04 94=C74: D6B7249 86C 504 345151674C2 C4154C=517@ 504 @C6B7:2 BC@4: 17 504 34515167 0=2 39=D4: C491=7D4 67 3=C=@C=30 6& 68 504 D6E39=175 8194: B7:4C 4D5167 68 504 "! D5 ''% 484CC17@ 56 504 2=1: 3=C=@C=30 04 D67547:2 50=5 504 D6E39=17=75 04C2498 0=2 D=54@6C1D=99< =:E1554: 50=5 204 =7: 04C 0B2;=7: >4C4 C421:17@=5=E?0=7:1=7:>4C4H61759<CB7717@=E4:1D=9 2063 17 3=C574C2013 5 12 8BC504C 2B;E1554: 50=5 504 E=54C1=9 67 C4D6C: D94=C9< :4E6725C=542 50=5 504 345151674C20=I474I4C91I4:17=:6E4251DC49=51672013>150 504 C42367:475D6E39=17=75 =5 =7< 36175 68 51E4 04 - 4 - 345151674C2 =C4 34CE=7475 C421:4752 68 B;91 =7: 504C486C4 504 94=C74: D6B7249 >6B9: BC@4 50=5 504 3C6D44:17@2 17151=54: B7:4C 4D5167 68 504 "! D5 17268=C =2 504 3C42475 345151674C2 =C4 D67D4C74: =C4 >0699<E12D67D41I4:=7:B72B25=17=;94179=> 504 94=C74: D6B7249 =334=C17@ 86C C42367:475 62 =7: 2B;E152 50=5 504C4 =C4 234D181D =994@=51672 E=:4 =@=1725 504 345151674C2 =2 >499 =7: 504C486C4 5012 12 765 = 815 D=24 86C 4J4CD1217@ 504 :12DC45167=C< 36>4C B7:4C 4D5167 %& 68 504 0=C=51<= =@=C1? BC=?20= =7015= ' 86C AB=2017@ 504 3C6D44:17@2=5501225=@4 ( 0=I4 04=C: 504 94=C74: D6B7249 86C 504 345151674C2 =7: 504 94=C74: D6B7249 =334=C17@ 86C C42367:47562=7: % 486C4 =:I4C517@ 56 504 C1I=9 D6754751672 5012 6BC5817:215=33C63C1=54564J5C=D53=C=@C=306&68504 - 5 - D6E39=175 8194: B7:4C 4D5167 68 504 "! D5 >01D0 C4=:2=286996>2 !" #$% &' () !" * + ,- . /.0 + 123 4 567 8+!" 9 + $:!" ,2 3' .( ,23 ;<!" =>? >!" *)#>@ > /AB .( *)#>@ !".; ) ). + C. 40& *)#> @ > + .( ,- B), ;'9 : # ,01&1( 9.8 0 ; * ; + A23 D + ;*9* * & 1 80 8E F* !" G 9 !" .;9 D @>D H)I.) 35 &; 9JK ; 8+ 8 LC ) , + 4B 8 8- 9 D.78/ 8(B' E F* L!.> .3@>!" 5 + )M3 & 18 0 N L!. + ) ), 9 9 N& ;' 8 0 C$ *1 .OB& $ *)P 4 8/ Q+ 1& ' 8 80 O Q B 1(9.80 A2 39 R 7 = 39=17 C4=:17@ 68 3=C=@C=30 6& 5012 6BC5 12 68 504 D6721:4C4: I14> 50=5 504 345151674C2 >06 =C4 504 17$9=>2 68 504 D6E39=17=75 0=I4 74I4C 20=C4: = D6EE67 06B24069: >150 504 C42367:475D6E39=17=75 76C >4C4 504< 4I4C 17 = :6E4251D C49=51672013 >150 04C 04 - 6 - D6E39=17=75 04C2498 0=2 B74AB1I6D=99< =:E1554: 50=5 204 >=2C421:17@>15004C0B2;=7:=5=E?0=7:1>04C4;650 68504E>4C4H61759<E=7=@17@=E4:1D=92063012D94=C =:E122167 =2 C4894D54: 17 504 4J5C=D54: 36C5167 68 504 D6E39=175C41786CD42504345151674C2GD67547516750=5504< >4C47653=C56850420=C4:06B24069: 012 6BC5 8BC504C D6721:4C2 15 =33C63C1=54 56 4J5C=D5504C4914826B@0586C17504E12D499=746B234515167 >01D0C4=:2=286996>2 ! "# $ % & '! % (% ) % * + ,----.-- % * /0 1----23% * 456 7 8 9! :; < = 4> ?@ A B 6?C 6 (% D-----.-- 7E $ & FGH '! I 4 '! 1-----.--% * 4 J% /0 K-----23% * 4 #E ? @ I H '! 4 (% 6 7 > L MFH H?H " $ E I 4> L M ) A < % ?@ N - 7 - & 7=D=C48B934CB2=968504C49148226B@0517504 E12D499=746B2 3C6D44:17@2 15 12 4I1:475 50=5 504 3C1E=C< @C14I=7D4 68 504 D6E39=17=75 12 :1C4D54: =@=1725 04C 0B2;=7: 04 D6E39=17=75 0=2 234D181D=99< 26B@05 = E67509< E=17547=7D4 68 2''''$ =7: =7 =E6B75 68 2(''''$56>=C:29151@=51674J3472428C6E04C0B2;=7: 1@7181D=759<175044751C4C49148D69BE7504C4127654I47 =>01234C68=7<234D181DC4914826B@05=@=17255043C42475 345151674C2 >06 =C4 504 17$9=>2 D67H6175 C4=:17@ 68 3=C=@C=306&68504D6E39=175=7:504C49148226B@0517 504 34515167 8194: B7:4C 4D5167 68 504 "! D5 ''% E=?42 15 =;B7:=759< D94=C 50=5 504C4 =C4 76 =994@=51672 :12D96217@ =7< =D5 68 :6E4251D I16947D4 =55C1;B5=;94 56 50424345151674C204C4D6C:D94=C9<:4E6725C=54250=5504 345151674C2 0=I4 74I4C 91I4: >150 504 D6E39=17=75 17 = 20=C4:06B24069:76C12504C4=7<E=54C1=956206>50=5 504< 0=I4 2B;H4D54: 04C 56 =7< 86CE 68 30<21D=9 4E65167=9 6C 4D676E1D =;B24 04C486C4 504 I4C< - 8 - 17151=5167683C6D44:17@2=@=1725504345151674C2=334=C256 ;4=@C622E12B24685043C6D422689=> , 5 12 =7 =:E1554: 36215167 50=5 504 E=C15=9 :12D6C:4J125226949<;45>447504C42367:475>184=7:04C 0B2;=7: >06 12 =CC=<4: =2 C42367:475 6 17 504 DC1E17=9 E12D499=746B2 34515167 04 :123B54 ;417@ E=5C1E671=9 17 7=5BC4 504 C42367:475>184 12 >499 >15017 04CC1@0556E=175=17=3C6D44:17@B7:4C 4D516768504 "!D5=@=172504C0B2;=7:.06>4I4C5042=E4D=7765;4 25C45D04: 56 1E391D=54 504 0B2;=7:G2 8=E19< E4E;4C2 17 504 =;247D4 68 =7< D6@475 6C 234D181D =994@=51672 04 E=54C1=92 67 C4D6C: B7E125=?=;9< 206> 50=5 504 345151674C2 >06 =C4 34CE=7475 C421:4752 68 B;91 0=I4 ;447 B774D422=C19< :C=@@4: 1756 504 3C6D44:17@2 :423154 0=I17@ 76 C694 17 504 =994@4: =D52 68 :6E4251D I16947D4 6E349917@504E568=D45C1=9=5B::4;10=9>6B9:765679< D=B24504EB7:B40=C:2013;B5>6B9:=926=E6B7556=7 =;B24685043C6D422689=>47D45624DBC450447:268 HB251D4 =7: 3C4I475 2BD0 =;B24 5012 6BC5 817:2 15 - 9 - =33C63C1=54 56 4J4CD124 152 1704C475 36>4C2 56 AB=20 504 3C6D44:17@217268=C=2504345151674C2=C4D67D4C74: ' 7 I14> 68 504 86C4@617@ :12DB22167 =7: 504 C4=2672 C4D6C:4: 04C417=;6I4 5012 6BC5 12 68 504 D6721:4C4: 6317167 50=5 504 D67517B=5167 68 504 3C6D44:17@2=@=1725504345151674C212>0699<B7>=CC=754: =7:B72B25=17=;94179=>DD6C:17@9<50486996>17@6C:4C 123=224: 1 04345151671204C4;<=996>4: 11 04 3C6D44:17@2 17 C1E17=9 12D499=746B2 6%&'%6750481946850494=C74:1I19 B:@4 =7: B::4;10=9 17268=C =2 504< C49=54 56 504 3C42475 345151674C2 =C4 04C4;<AB=204: 111 5 12 06>4I4C E=:4 D94=C 50=5 5012 6C:4C 20=99 765 3C4D9B:4 6C 17 =7< E=774C =884D5 504 C42367:475>184G2 C1@05 56 3BC2B4 04C - 10 - C4E4:142 =2 =@=1725 04C 0B2;=7: 17 =DD6C:=7D4>1509=> 1I 99 347:17@ 1754C96DB56C< =3391D=51672 18 =7<25=7::123624:68 ,* &$$) % 1256 96(