- 1 - !" #!$!! ! %& %'() &%(( * ! "##$ % ! "##$ # & ! "##$ Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! "##$ # # & ! "##$ ' ( ) % ! ! ! & ' ( ! &* ") & &( )#& - 3 - + %$ & & & ,$ & ( ) & ! & - ( - ) ./ 0/121234/56 7/248 5/60349/41 36 13 # 24 5:26; 3%$ 34 1./ <2:/ 3< 1./ :/=54/9 524;20=: 2>2: ?98/ (5 4) =49 & .=:@2 A<35 6.351 B52=: 3?51CD<2:/9?49/5 /;12343<531/;12343<3E/4<53E 3E/612;23:/4;/;1A<356.351B ;1CD7F1./G2</3< 0/121234/536//@248>=523?6359/56?49/5 /;12346 , $ =49 3< ;1 =5/ 6//@248 13 H?=6. 1./ ;52E24=:053;//9248624212=1/9=8=24611./E /=59 52 =>2 .//E6248. .=G=4 :/=54/9 ;3?46/: <35 1./ 0/121234/56 =49 52 //0=@ =5=9 - 4 - :/=54/9 ;3?46/: <35 1./ 5/60349/416 /5?6/9 1./ E=1/52=:6345/;359 4 >2/G 3< 1./ 52>=: ;341/412346 ?58/9 7F 1./ :/=54/9;3?46/:6<35731.1./0=512/61./032411.=1G3?:9 =526/<35EF;34629/5=123426 !"#$% F =46G/5 13 1./ =73>/ 03241 26 24 <351./<3::3G248 ./0=512/6=5/5/</55/913=60/51./255=4@248 7/<35/1./52=:3?51<351./6=@/3<;34>/42/4;/ # /60349/41 36 =49 ./5/24 7/248 1./ 0/121234/5 36 =49 7/<35/ 1./ 52=: 3?51 <2:/9 1./ 5:26; 3%$ ?49/5 /;1234 3< 1./ ;1 - 5 - =8=2461 5/60349/41 36 13 # /60349/41 3 26 1./ .?67=49 3< 0/121234/5 3 =49 1./25 E=552=8/ G=6 0/5<35E/934$$<1/51./25E=552=8/0/121234/5 3 61=51/9 5/629248 G21. 5/60349/41 3 24 1./ E=152E342=: .3?6/ 1 1./ 12E/ 3< E=552=8/ =6 93G5F 83:9354=E/416=49;=6.G/5/82>/4131./5/60349/416 73?1 62I E341.6 1./5/=<1/5 1./ 5/60349/416 61=51/9 9/E=49248 =9921234=: 93G5F =49 15/=1/9 0/121234/5 3 G21.;5?/:1F/60349/4136=497/2481./0=5/416 5/60349/41 3 7/248 1./ 7531./5 =49 5/60349/41 3# 7/2481./6261/5"24":=G3<5/60349/413G/5/246128=1248 5/60349/41 3 =49 =;;359248:F ./ ?6/9 13 15/=1 0/121234/5 3 G21. ;5?/:1F ./ G=6 431 053>29/9 G21. E/92;=:15/=1E/417F5/60349/413/>/4G./46./G=6 05/84=41./46./.=99/:2>/5/9=7=7F825:434/3<1./ 5/60349/416 .=>/ ;=E/ 13 ./5 0=5/41=: .3?6/ =523?6 =::/8=12346 =5/ E=9/ 7F 1./ 0/121234/5 =8=2461 1./ 5/60349/416248/4/5=:61=12481.=15/60349/413G=6 246128=1/9 7F 1./ 31./5 5/60349/416 1 26 61=1/9 1.=1 - 6 - 0/121234/5 .=6 <2:/9 1./ ;52E24=: ;=6/ 5/8261/5/9 24 52E/ 3%$ =8=2461 1./ 5/60349/416 <35 1./ 3<</4;/6 0?426.=7:/ ?49/5 /;1234 , #$ #$ =49 5/=9 G21. /;1234,3<492=4/4=:39/A<356.351BCD=49 ?49/5 /;12346=493< 3G5F53.2721234;1A<356.351 BC ;1D /60349/41 3 <2:/9 3$$ 6//@248 92>35;/ G.2;. 26 =:63 0/49248 <35 ;34629/5=1234 ./5/<35/ 1./ 0/121234/5 63?8.1 <35 E=241/4=4;/ <53E 5/60349/413=490531/;1234359/5=8=24615/60349/41 3613# 126753?8.1131./4312;/3<1./3?511.=11./ 0/121234/5 .=6 =:63 <2:/9 =431./5 ;3E0:=241 5/8261/5/9 24 52E/ 3$# 3< .=:@2 3G4 3:2;/ 1=1234 =8=2461 5/60349/41 36 =49 =::/8248 ;3EE266234 3< 1./ 3<</4;/?49/5 /;12346#$#$,#$5/=9G21. /;1234 3<./6/<=;16=49;25;?E61=4;/62<;34629/5/9241./ :28.13<1./=::/8=12346E=9/241./0/121234926;:36/1.=1 1./E=24852/>=4;/3<1./0/121234/526=8=24615/60349/41 - 7 - 37/248./5.?67=497?16./.=6530/9245/60349/41 3613#7/248.26<=E2:FE/E7/56 % 1 26 61=1/9 7F 1./ :/=54/9 ;3?46/: <35 1./ 0/121234/5 1.=1 5/60349/41 3 7/<35/ 1./ 52=: 3?51 26 0=F248 6%#$$" 0/5 E341. =6 E=241/4=4;/ =49 6?;. 0=FE/416=5/E=9/?0139=1/.26<=;1264319260?1/9 7F 1./ :/=54/9 ;3?46/: <35 1./ G2</ =@248 2413 ;34629/5=1234 =:: 1./6/ <=;16 =49 ;25;?E61=4;/6 =E 3< 1./ 3024234 1.=1 5/60349/41 3 7/248 1./ .?67=49 26 431 /4121:/9 <35 1./ 7/4/<21 3< H?=6.248 1./ ;52E24=: 053;//92486 3G/>/5 246121?1234 3< 6?;. ;52E24=: 053;//92486=8=24615/60349/413613#7/<35/1./52=: 3?51 26 24 =7?6/ 3< 053;/66 3< :=G E=@248 7=:9 =49 8/4/5=:=::/8=12346=491./5/<35/1./6=E/26:2=7:/137/ H?=6./9 ;;359248:F=46G/51./=73>/03241 =49053;//9130=661./<3::3G248 - 8 - (2) ./0/12123426 (22) ./ 0/121234 <2:/9 7F 0/121234/5 3 ./5/245/60349/413245:26;3%$ 34 1./ <2:/ 3< 1./ 2>2: ?98/ =49 & 3?51 .=:@2 29=5 26152;1 26 ./5/7F 926E266/9 (222) ./0/121234<2:/97F0/121234/536 13 # ./5/245/60349/41 36 13 # 7/<35/ 1./ 52=:3?5126=::3G/9 (2>) ./ 053;//92486 0/49248 7/<35/ 1./ 52=: 3?51 24 5:26; 3%$ =8=2461 5/60349/41 36 13 # 26 H?=6./9 =49 G2:: ;34124?/ 34:F =8=2461 5/60349/41 3 G.3 26 0/121234/5./5/24 +) %!!( $ 2613 :3 !