- 1 - ! " #$ % % "" &%' () "" * ( ) ! " # $ % & % # '()( ) % * () Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ()%+, % %,( # ') ! " - )$ ,( "$ %)) . . . ,))+ %)) . . *( ) % & " $ % # ') ! " $ - 3 - % * (( ()%+, % %,( # ') ) ! " # )- % ,)) $ ,( "$ . ,))+ . . %)) . # / . - 4 - 0 . $ 1)(+%))+ 23 42567 89 :;6 2<3=>?<@6 @1AB?<9 @;?556<C2<C :;6 D=7CA6<: ?<7 ?E?>7 7?:67 ,))+ 2< 1%)) B?3367 89 :;6 772:21<?5 6<21> 2F25 .=7C6 ?<7 . ?<7 772:21<?5 ?:?5?8=>?C2"41>3;1>:G>28=<?5/$ ) 1)+%)) 23 42567 89 :;6 @5?2A?<: 366H2<C 6<;?<@6A6<: 14 @1AB6<3?:21< 2< :;6 D=7CA6<: ?<7 ?E?>7 7?:67 ,))+ 2< 1%)) B?336789:;6>28=<?5 ( ;6 4?@:3 56?72<C :1 4252<C 14 @5?2A B6:2:21< ?>6 ?3=<76> ;?:1<II))?:?81=:&(?A:;6@5?2A?<: E?3B>1@6672<C89E?5H1<?C?>?';?;?B=>A?2<>1?7 <6?>?C?>F255?C6?::;?::2A6:;6>276>14A1:1>@9@56 86?>2<C 6C 1()+, >176 ;23 A1:1>@9@56 2< ? - 5 - >?3; ?<7 <6C52C6<: A?<<6> ?<7 7?3;67 :1 ;2A =6 :1 E;2@;;63=3:?2<67C>26F1=32<D=>263?<7?7A2::672<:;6 ;13B2:?5;6@5?2A?<::?H6<:>6?:A6<:?<742567:;6@5?2A B6:2:21<;6>28=<?5?3363367@1AB6<3?:21<?<7B?3367 :;6 2AB=C<67 ?E?>7 ;6 @5?2A?<: ;?3 42567 :;6 B>636<: ?BB6?5366H2<C6<;?<@6A6<:14:;6@1AB6<3?:21< + 6?>7 56?><67 @1=<365 41> :;6 @5?2A?<: ?<7 56?><67@1=<36541>2<3=>?<@6@1AB?<9 6?><67 @1=<365 41> :;6 2<3=>?<@6 @1AB?<9 E1=57 @1<:6<7 :;?: :;6 @5?2A?<: ' 2<D=>67 E?3 96?>3 157?31<:;67?:614?@@276<:;676@2321<14:;61</856 =B>6A6 1=>: 2< :;6 @?36 14 !" #$ %&'(%)) >6B1>:672<*+ ,+ -./0"23:186?BB5267;6>28=<?5;?36>>672<<1: ?BB592<C:;63?2776@2321<;6>28=<?5;?36>>672<:?H2<C :;6 2<@1A6 14 :;6 @5?2A?<: ' 2<D=>67 ?<7 @?5@=5?:2<C :;6 @1AB6<3?:21<=<76>:;6;6?7145133144=:=>62<@1A6 - 6 - I 6?><67@1=<36541>:;6@5?2A?<:E1=57@1<:6<7 :;?::;6@5?2A?<:E?3?C67?81=:96?>3?31<:;67?:6 14 ?@@276<: ;6 >28=<?5 ;?3 >646>>67 :1 :;6 76@2321< 14 :;62F2321< 6<@;14 :;23 1=>: ?<7>2C;:59?3363367 :;6 5133144=:=>62<@1A664=>:;6>3=8A2:3:;?::;6@5?2A?<: ;?33=3:?2<674>?@:=>614564:?@6:?8=5?>?<7564:D12<: 72351@?:21< 1<3276>2<C :;6 3?A6 :;6 71@:1> E;1 6J?A2<67 ;2A ;?3 233=67 J& ' 723?8252:9 @6>:242@?:6 3:?:2<C :;?: :;6 @5?2A?<: 23 ;?F2<C (&K 723?8252:9 14 :;6 E;1568179;6>28=<?5;?36>>672<:?H2<C:;6723?8252:9 ?:K;6@5?2A?<:;?3866<?7A2::672<:;6;13B2:?541> 7?93 1<3276>2<C :;6 3?A6 :;6 @1AB6<3?:21< ?E?>76741>B?2<?<73=446>2<C5133142<@1A67=>2<C5?27 =B B6>217 5133 14 ?A6<2:263 ?>6 1< 51E6> 3276 E;2@; >6L=2>63:1866<;?<@67 2:;:;636;6B>?93:16<;?<@6 :;6@1AB6<3?:21< , ?F2<C;6?>756?><67@1=<36541>:;62<3=>?<@6 @1AB?<9?<756?><67@1=<36541>:;6@5?2A?<::;231=>: B6>=367:;62AB=C<67D=7CA6<:?<7>2?51=>:>6@1>73 - 7 - ;6 @5?2A?<: E?3 ?C67 ?81=: 96?>3 ?3 1< :;67?:614?@@276<:261<II))?<752?8252:914:;6 2<3=>?<@6@1AB?<9?>6<1:2<723B=:6 & ;6 >28=<?5 @1<3276>67 :;6 76@2321< 14 :;6 2F2321< 6<@; 14 :;23 1=>: 2< :;6 @?36 14 (&& (%1') 2 ( 3 ( ) 4 2< +.5+5 )) +. 5 . 5 . ?<7 :;6 76@2321< 14 :;6 1</856 =B>6A6 1=>: 2< :;6 @?36 14 (!!#4 2#(%) - ) >6B1>:67 2< + - 4 67 0 ;?3>2C;:59?BB5267:;6B>2<@2B563142<@1A6?<7A=5:2B526> ?<7 @?5@=5?:67 :;6 5133 14 4=:=>6 2<@1A6 < F26E 14 :;6 4?@::;?::;6@5?2A?<:E?3?C6796?>3?31<:;67?:614 ?@@276<::;6>28=<?5;?3>2C;:59?BB5267:;6A=5:2B526>?: ;6>28=<?5;?3>2C;:59:?H6<:;6<1:21<?52<@1A6?: 3+)% ?3 B6> :;6 ;?>: B>6B?>67 41> 36::56A6<: 14 723B=:63 2< 1H7?5?:; 89 :;6 ?><?:?H? 6C?5 6>F2@63 =:;1>2:941>:;696?>));6>28=<?5@1<3276>2<C:;6 - 8 - 76@2321< 14 :;6 1</856 =B>6A6 1=>: 2< :;6 @?36 14 #$ () 3'->6B1>:67 2< *+5, +0 - 0" ;?3 >2C;:59 :?H6< :;6 4=:=>6 B>13B6@:3?:+K ;671@:1>E;1;?36J?A2<67:;6@5?2A?<:;?3 233=67J&'723?8252:9@6>:242@?:6E;6>62<;6;?33:?:67 :;?: :;6 @5?2A?<: 23 ;?F2<C (&K 723?8252:9 14 :;6 E;156 8179 1<3276>2<C :;6 4>?@:=>6 14 564: ?@6:?8=5?> ?<7 564: D12<:72351@?:21<:;6>28=<?5;?36>>672<:?H2<C:;6 723?8252:9 ?: K ?3 ?C?2<3: (&K ?3 3:?:67 89 1@:1> ;6>641>6 :;6 723?8252:9 ;?3 :1 86 :?H6< ?: (&K 14 :;6 E;1568179 <F26E14:;6?81F6:;6@5?2A?<:236<:2:567:1 5133144=:=>62<@1A6?3=<76> 3+)%M+KN3&&%J)JJ(&K N3I% - 9 - ) 1<3276>2<C:E1A?D1>4>?@:=>63:;6@5?2A?<:23 6<:2:567:1B?2<?<73=446>2<C2<?3=A143%?3 ?C?2<3: 3(% ?<7 3% :1E?>73 5133 14 ?A6<2:263 ?3 ?C?2<3: 3)% ?3 ?E?>767 89 :;6 >28=<?5 ( ;6@5?2A?<:;?3866<?7A2::672<:;6;13B2:?5 41> 7?93 ;6>641>6 ;6 23 6<:2:567 :1 ?::6<7?<: ?<7 @1<F69?<@6 @;?>C63 6:@ 2< ? 3=A 14 3% ?3 ?C?2<3:3(%?3?E?>76789:;6>28=<?5 + ;6@5?2A?<:236<:2:567:15133142<@1A67=>2<C :;65?27=BB6>21741>(A1<:;32<?3=A143+),% "3+)% J ($ ?3 ?C?2<3: 3)% ?3 ?E?>767 89 :;6>28=<?5 ;6 >28=<?5 ;?3 >2C;:59 ?E?>767 :;6 @1AB6<3?:21<:1E?>73A672@?56JB6<363?:3I(,% I <F26E14:;6?81F6:;6?BB655?<:'@5?2A?<:23 6<:2:567:1:1:?5@1AB6<3?:21<?3=<76> - 10 - + ,-./ 012,3/-453 12,3/-453 -6-7.,.894:5/;74 133144=:=>62<@1A6 3I% ) ?2<?<73=446>2<C 3% ( ::6<7?<: ?<7 @1<F69?<@6@;?>C63 3% + 133 14 2<@1A6 7=>2<C 5?27=BB6>217 3+),% 13314?A6<2:263 3% I 672@?56JB6<363 3I(,% 4-+ / < *( , <F26E14:;6?81F6:;6?BB655?<:'@5?2A?<:23 6<:2:567 :1 @1AB6<3?:21< 14 3)&+,% ?3 ?C?2<3: 3I&)&%?3?E?>76789:;6>28=<?5E2:;2<:6>63:?: :;6 >?:6 14 IK B? 4>1A :;6 7?:6 14 B6:2:21< :255 2:3 >6?52O?:21< - 11 - ;6@5?2A?<:23<1:6<:2:567:12<:6>63:41>765?9 B6>217147?932<4252<C:;6?BB6?5?3B6>1>76>7?:67 )))) & <F26E14:;6?81F6:;641551E2<C- ;6 ?BB6?5 42567 89 :;6 2<3=>?<@6 @1AB?<9 23 723A23367 ;6?BB6?54256789:;6@5?2A?<:23?551E672<B?>: ;6 D=7CA6<: ?<7 ?E?>7 7?:67 ,))+ 2< 1%)) B?3367 89 :;6 772:21<?5 6<21>2F25.=7C6?<7. ?<7772:21<?5 ?: ?5?8=>?C223A1724267?3=<76> ;6 ?BB655?<: ' @5?2A?<: 23 6<:2:567 :1 :1:?5 @1AB6<3?:21< 14 3)&+,% ?3 ?C?2<3: 3I&)&%?3?E?>76789:;6>28=<?5?51<CE2:; 2<:6>63: ?: :;6 >?:6 14 IK B? 4>1A :;6 7?:6 14 B6:2:21<:2552:3>6?52O?:21< - 12 - ;6 @5?2A?<: 23 <1: 6<:2:567 :1 2<:6>63: 41> 765?9 B6>217 14 7?93 2< 4252<C :;6 ?BB6?5 ?3 B6> 1>76> 7?:67)))) ;62<3=>?<@6@1AB?<93;?5576B132::;63?27?E?>7 ?A1=<: E2:; 2<:6>63: 8641>6 :;6 >28=<?5 E2:;2< E66H34>1A:;237?94?252<CE;2@;2:2352?856:1B?9 2<:6>63:?::;6>?:614&KB? ;6 ?A1=<: 2< 76B132: 3;?55 86 :>?<3A2::67 :1 :;6 >28=<?541>:;E2:; ;66C23:>92372>6@:67:136<:8?@H:;6>2?51=>: >6@1>73?51<CE2:;@1B914:;23D=7CA6<:41>:;E2:; <F26E14723B13?514:;6A?2<?BB6?5:;6B6<72<C 324?<971<1:3=>F2F641>@1<3276>?:21<?<7:;63?A6 ?>6723B136714 .( & % %' $ .. 23: 15 1)) :-H