Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 42995 (KAR)

SRI.SANTOSH S/O YALLAPPA v. SOMASHEKHAR @ SOMASHEKHARAYA AND ORS

CRL.A/200064/2016 · 2025-09-04

H P Sandesh, T M Nadaf

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !" ! #"$! #"$" "!! %&'%(!)* +%)) , ! "# " Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ " "# % "% $ %# # &!&! ' ( - 3 - ) ( * #+ ( '+ ,-,,+ ( # ( ( #$ , " ( ( ( ( . ,, , $ #$ , " . ( (( " * ,$ "- ( &&* ( -'- ( ( , ,-,% ( / ( 0 ( 1 1( - 4 - -$" 1 2345637389:9;;<9:34=3:<>529::<8?38?@2<AB>?7<8@ 98> C6><6 C= 95DB3@@9: >9@<> ,, , $ 38 ;<539: 94< C#$ , " EF @2< >>: <443C84 B>?< B:E96?92<6<389=@<66<=<66<>@C94/639:CB6@0=C6@2< C==<85<4;B83429E:<B8><6<5@3C84 "98>,$6<9>G3@2 <5@3C8 "- C= @2< 8>398 <89: C>< 98> B8><6 <5@3C8 H 98> H3 98> I C= @2< 52<>B:<> 94@<498>52<>B:<>63E<4 6<I<8@3C8C=@6C53@3<45@ -'- 5@ 2< =95@B9: 79@63H C= @2< 594< C= @2< ;6C4<5B@3C8E<=C6<@2<639:CB6@34@29@@2<5C7;:93898@J =9@2<6C=><5<94<>29>:C>?<>95C7;B@<63K<>5C7;:938@ G2352 34 796L<> 94 H23E3@ J ' 4@9@38? @29@ 2< 294 43H 4C8498>@26<<>9B?2@<64 B@C=@2<74<I<896<79663<> 98> 2< 6<43><4 G3@2 234 G3=< 98> @GC 4C84 B83: 98> 23I9;;9@349:4C234594<@29@234=CB64C8496<6<43>38? - 5 - 4<;969@<:F G3@2 @2<36 =973:3<4 98> 234 >9B?2@<64 96< 9:4C 6<43>38?9:C8?G3@2@2<366<4;<5@3I<2B4E98>4 2< 4C8 298>69L98@2 ><5<94<> G94 <L38? CB@ 234 :3I<:32CC> EF 6B8838? 9 ?6C5<6F 42C; 8 %,", "9@9ECB@",,;72<:<=@C82347C@C65F5:< @C E638? 3@<74=C6 234 42C;EB@2< >3> 8C@ 6<@B684 2< B4<>@C4@9F9@38>9?3C6B:E96?9>B638?@2<83?2@98> 6<@B6838@2<7C6838?@2<5C7;:93898@L<;@DB3<@383@39::F @ 34 9:4C 234 594< @29@ 234 C@2<6 4C8 98@C42 79>< 6<;<9@<> 59::4 @C@2< ><5<94<> EB@@2<><5<94<> >3> 8C@ 6<5<3I< @2< 59::4 BE4<DB<8@:F 2< 79>< 59::4 @C 9:: 6<:9@3I<4 98> <8DB36<> 9ECB@ @2< ><5<94<> EB@ 2< 5CB:> 8C@E<@695<> " 8 #,", " G2<8 5C7;:93898@04 4C8 23I9;;9G946<@B6838?389;63I9@<I<235:<@C@2<36I3::9?< 2< 8C@35<> @2< 7C@C65F5:< C= @2< ><5<94<> 8<96 9 G9@<6 52988<:38@2<36:98><377<>39@<:F38=C67<>@2<=973:F 7<7E<64 2<6<9=@<6 234 4C84 B83: 98@C42 97<42 98> 234 E6C@2<6 38?9;;9 G<8@ 8<96 @2< :98> 98> =CB8> - 6 - @29@ @2< ><5<94<> G94 7B6><6<> 98> @29@ 234 EC>F G94 :F38?E<8<9@29<<7@6<<@349:4C234594<@29@2<9:C8? G3@2 234 G3=< E6C@2<6 98> 4C84 G<8@ @C @2< 4;C@ 98> C8 =38>38? @2< EC>F 8C@35<> @29@ @2<6< G<6< 38AB63<4 @ 34 5C8@<8><> @29@ 9ECB@ @26<< 7C8@24 ;63C6 @C @2< 3853><8@ @2< 955B4<> ;<64C84 29> G968<> @2< ><5<94<> 4@9@38? @29@@2<FGCB:>=383422373=2<>3>8C@@6<9@234G3=<3< @2<36434@<69L4273E9338?CC>7988<6@349:4C9::<?<> @29@ 234 >9B?2@<6J38J:9G 9L4273E93 29> ><I<:C;<> 98 3::353@ 6<:9@3C8423; G3@2 C8< C7942<L2969FF9 =C6 G2352 @2< ><5<94<> 298>69L98@2 29> CEA<5@<> 98> 2<85< 2< G947B6><6<> % 94<> C8 @2< 5C7;:938@ @2< J 9>6973 C:35< @9@3C8 6<?34@<6<> @2< 594< 38 637< C"% , " 9@ @2< =364@ 384@985< =C6 @2< C==<85<4 ;B83429E:<B8><6<5@3C84,98>, C= 98><5@3C8 H C= @2< 5@ 98> 344B<> @2< ( < =C6G96><>@2<497<@C@2<AB634>35@3C89:;C:35<2<6<9=@<6 J , 63 98@C42 9EB >>3@3C89: B69: BEJ - 7 - 3I343C8@CCLB;=B6@2<638I<4@3?9@3C8<I343@<>@2<4;C@ >69G8 38DB<4@ 7929K96 38 @<674 C= H23E3@ J 6<5C6><> @2<4@9@<7<8@4C=G3@8<44<498>@2<;2C@C?69;24@9L<89@ @2<45<8< G<6< 796L<> 94 H23E3@4 J @C J $. <9:4C ;6<;96<> @2< 4;C@ ;98528979 38 @<674 C= H23E3@ J 38 @2<;6<4<85<C=@2<G3@8<44<498>4<3K<>@2<96@35:<4G2352 G<6< =CB8> 9@ @2< 4;C@ 2< ><9> EC>F G94 @2<8 423=@<> 98>;C4@J7C6@<7 G945C8>B5@<>@26CB?2@2<>C5@C6 98>@2<;6<:373896F6<;C6@G94?3I<838@<674C=H23E3@ J < 9:4C 6<5C6><> @2< 4@9@<7<8@4 C= 4C7< C= @2< G3@8<44<4 98> @2< E6C@2<64 ;96<8@4 98> B85:< G2C 5C8434@<8@:F4@9@<>@29@@2<><5<94<>G947B6><6<> $ B638?@2<5CB64<C=38I<4@3?9@3C8@2<=389: 6<;C6@G94CE@938<>G2<6<383@G94=CB8>@29@@2<59B4< C= ><9@2 G94 C8 955CB8@ C= 5C84B738? ;<4@353>< <85< =B6@2<6 4@9@<7<8@4 C= G3@8<44<4 G<6< 6<5C6><> 98> 9 5296?<J42<<@ G94 =3:<> 38ICL38? @2< 9ECI< C==<85<4 9::<?38? @29@ @2< 955B4<> ;<64C84 29> 9E<@@<> @2< ><5<94<>@C@9L<@2<<H@6<7<4@<;C=5C773@@38?4B353>< - 8 - # 639: CB6@ 9=@<6 5C843><638? @2< 5296?<J42<<@ 79@<639: 4<5B6<> @2< 955B4<> 55B4<> C4 @C $ G<6< 6<:<94<>C8E93:98>4BE4<DB<8@:F955B4<>C#G949:4C 6<:<94<> C8 E93: 2< 955B4<> >3> 8C@ 9>73@ @2< 5296?<4 98>5:937<>@639: ' 2< ;6C4<5B@3C8 38 C6><6 @C ;6CI< 3@4 594< <H9738<> 4J @C "98>?C@796L<>H23E3@4 J @C J # 98> 4 @C " 2< @639: CB6@ 6<5C6><> @2< 4@9@<7<8@4 C= @2< 955B4<> ;<64C84 B8><6 <5@3C8 6 98> @2< 955B4<> >3> 8C@ :<9> 98F ><=<85< <I3><85< 9I38? 5C843><6<> EC@2 C69: 98> >C5B7<8@96F <I3><85< @2< @639: CB6@ 984G<6<> 9:: @2< ;C38@4 =C6 5C843><69@3C8 38 @2< 8<?9@3I< 98> 95DB3@@<> @2< 955B4<> <85<@234;6<4<8@9;;<9:34=3:<>E<=C6<@234CB6@ - 2< 7938 5C8@<8@3C8 C= :<968<> 5CB84<: 9;;<9638? =C6 @2< 9;;<::98@ 34 @29@ @2< AB>?7<8@ C= 95DB3@@9:345C8@696F@C:9G98>@2<=95@4C=@2<594<2< 5CB84<:38234 96?B7<8@4GCB:> I<2<7<8@:F 5C8@<8>@29@ H23E3@ J- 5:<96:F 42CG4 @29@ G23:< ?3I38? @2< =389: - 9 - C;383C8 3@ G94 7<8@3C8<> @29@ @2<6< 34 9E4<85< C= @2< FC3> EC8< 2<8 4B52 9 6<;C6@ 34 ?3I<8 @2< @639: CB6@ CB?2@ @C 29I< @9L<8 8C@< C= @2< 493> =95@ 38@C 5C843><69@3C8 98> 2<85< 3@ 34 9 =3@ 594< @C 4<@ 943>< @2< C6><6 C= 95DB3@@9: @ 34 9:4C 5C8@<8><> @29@ @2< 38I<4@3?9@3C8 G94 2C;<:<44:F 5C8>B5@<> 38 9 596<:<44 7988<6 98> 8C@ ;6C;<6:F 38I<4@3?9@<> =6C7 @2< 98?:< C= 7B6><6 98> >349;;<96985< C= @2< FC3> C8< =6C7 @2< 4<9:<> EC@@:< G94 ><:3E<69@< 98> @234 94;<5@ G94 8C@ 5C843><6<> @ 34 =B6@2<6 5C8@<8><> @29@ 59:: ><@93:4 G<6< 9I93:9E:<=6C7@2<59::6<5C6>4C=955B4<>C4 98>#EB@ @2< 497< G<6< 8C@ ;6C;<6:F 38I<4@3?9@<> C6 5C::<5@<> @2< 4 4@CC> 38 @2< 897<4 C= @2< 955B4<> ;<64C84 2< 6<94C838? ?3I<8 EF @2< @639: CB6@ 34 <66C8<CB4 98> ;<6I<64< 98> @2< 95DB3@@9: 6<DB36<4 38@<6=<6<85< EF @234 CB6@ , :<968<>>>3@3C89: 9;;<9638?=C6 @2<@9@<GCB:>4BE73@@29@@2<@639:CB6@<H@<8><>@2< E<8<=3@ C= >CBE@ 38 =9ICB6 C= @2< 955B4<> C8:F C8 @2< - 10 - ?6CB8> @29@ 59:: ><@93:4 96< 8C@ ;6CI<> ;96@ =6C7 @29@ @2<CB6@>3>8C@@9L<8C@<C=@2<<I3><85<C= J ,98> J @3498<66C68C@@C29I<5C843><6<>@2<<I3><85< C= 4J @C # 4385< @2C4< G3@8<44<4 29I< 59@<?C6359::F ><;C4<> E<=C6< @2< CB6@ @29@ @2<6< G94 8C 5C6>39:3@F E<@G<<8 @2< ><5<94<> 98> 234 G3=<J955B4<> C# 98> 3@ 6<DB36<438@<6=<6<85< 9I38? 2<96> @2< :<968<> 5CB84<: =C6 @2< 9;;<::98@ 94 G<:: 94 @2< 5CB84<: 9;;<9638? =C6 @2< 6<4;C8><8@J@9@< 98> 9:4C C8 5C843><638? @2< 79@<639: 9I93:9E:< C8 6<5C6> @2< ;C38@4 @29@ GCB:> 9634< =C6 5C843><69@3C8C=@234CB6@96< 234 CB6@ 29I38? 5C843><6<> @2< 79@<639: C8 6<5C6> CE4<6I<> @29@ @2< ;6C4<5B@3C8 7938:F 6<:3<4 B;C8 - 11 - @2< <I3><85< C= 4J @C " 98> H23E3@4 J @C # 98> 4J @C"3<EC@2C69:98>>C5B7<8@96F<I3><85< @ 34 8C@ 38 >34;B@< @29@ @2< ><5<94<> 98> 955B4<> C# 96< 2B4E98> 98> G3=< 98> @2<36 796639?< @CCL;:95< F<9649?CCG<I<6EC@2C=@2<7G<6<8C@ 29I38?98F344B<42<594<C=@2<;6C4<5B@3C8349:4C@29@ 955B4<>C4 98>#G<6<29I38?983::353@6<:9@3C8423;98> 955B4<> C# B4<> @C @<94< 2<6 2B4E98> @ 34 9:4C @2< 594< C= @2< ;6C4<5B@3C8 @29@ 955B4<> C4 @C $ >3> 8C@ 2<<> @C @2< 6<DB<4@ C= @2< ><5<94<> 9ECB@ 3::353@ 6<:9@3C8423;E<@G<<8955B4<>C4 98>#98>2<85<@2< ><5<94<> @CCL @2< <H@6<7< 4@<; C= 5C773@@38? 4B353>< 2<@639:CB6@294@9L<88C@<C=@2<38IC59@3C8C=C==<85<4 B8><6@2<4;<539:<895@7<8@385C738?@C@2<5C85:B43C8 @29@955B4<>C E<:C8?4@C@2<38?9F9@5C77B83@F98> @2<><5<94<>E<:C8?4@C @9L38?8C@<C=H23E3@ J# 594@<5<6@3=359@<98>9:4C@2<<I3><85<C86<5C6>2<6<34 8C4<63CB4>34;B@<G3@26<?96>@C@2<497<94=9694594@< 345C85<68<> - 12 - " CG G3@2 6<?96> @C @2< 5296?<4 :<I<::<> 9?9384@ @2< 955B4<> ;<64C84 @2< ;6C4<5B@3C8 <H9738<> 4J @C " J 34@2<7C@2<6C=@2<><5<94<> J34 @2< B85:< C= @2< ><5<94<> 4J " $ 98> # 96< @2< E6C@2<64 C= @2< ><5<94<> C >CBE@ 9:: @2<4< G3@8<44<4 29I< 4B;;C6@<> @2< 594< C= @2< ;6C4<5B@3C8 2< ;6C4<5B@3C8 9:4C 6<:3<> B;C8 @2< 38><;<8><8@ G3@8<44<4 4J' 98> - G2C 96< @2< 8<3?2ECB64 C= @2< ><5<94<> 2< <I3><85< C= J G2C 34 GC6L38? 38 @2< ;<4@353>< 42C;=6C7G2<6<@2<><5<94<>34493>@C29I<;B65294<> @2< ;<4@353>< 34 9:4C 6<:3<> B;C8 CG<I<6 2< >3> 8C@ 3><8@3=F @2< ><5<94<> 94 @2< ;<64C8 G2C ;B65294<> @2< ;<4@353>< % 2< ;6C4<5B@3C8 =B6@2<6 6<:3<> B;C8 @2< <I3><85< C= 4J , 98> 3< ;C:35< G3@8<44<4 2<F29I<9:6<9>F;C38@<>CB@@29@@2<6<348C>34;B@<@29@ EC@2 @2< ><5<94<> 98> 955B4<> C# G<6< 79663<> F<9649?C98>29>8C344B<42<4;<53=359::<?9@3C8C=@2< ;6C4<5B@3C834@29@@2<955B4<>C4 98>#29>><I<:C;<> - 13 - 983::353@6<:9@3C8423;2CB?2@2<<I3><85<C= 4J @C$ 34 5C8434@<8@ EB@ 4J# 98> ' 29I< 8C@ =B::F 4B;;C6@<> @2< 594< C= @2< ;6C4<5B@3C8 B@ @2< CB6@ 294 @C @9L< 8C@<@29@9@@2<=364@384@985<989::<?9@3C8C=7B6><6G94 9::<?<> 9?9384@ @2< 955B4<> ;<64C84 9I38? 5C843><6<> @2< >C5B7<8@ 3< H23E3@ J5C7;:938@ <H5<;@ @2< 9::<?9@3C8 C= 7B6><6 98> 3::353@ 6<:9@3C8 C= 955B4<> C4 98>#8C@238?=B6@2<6349@@63EB@<>@349:4C37;C6@98@@C 8C@<@29@>B638?@2<5CB64<C=@2<38I<4@3?9@3C89@@2<=364@ 384@985< 9:: C= @2<7 29> 79>< 9 4@9@<7<8@ @29@ 3@ 34 9 594< C= 7B6><6 2<8 @2< =389: 6<;C6@ G94 6<5<3I<> 38 @<674C=H23E3@ J'3@6<I<9:4@29@@2<><9@2G94>B<@C 596>3CJ6<4;369@C6F 966<4@ 59B4<> EF C6?98C;2C4;2C6B4 ;C34C838? <85< 3@ 34 9 594< C= 5C773@@38? 4B353>< EF 5C84B738? ;C34C8 98> 2<85< 38ICL<> @2< C==<85< B8><6 <5@3C8,$C= G3@2C@2<6C==<85<4B8><6<5@3C84 " 98> "- $ CG29I38?5C843><6<>@2<<I3><85<G2352G< 29I< 9:6<9>F ;C38@<> CB@ @29@ 3@ 34 9 594< C= 5C84B738? - 14 - ;C34C898>@234CB6@294@C<H9738<G2<@2<6@2<6<3498F 9E<@7<8@@C5C773@4B353><@348C@38>34;B@<@29@ J 34@2<7C@2<6 4J"$98>#96<@2<E6C@2<64C=@2< ><5<94<>98> J34@2<B85:<B@>B638?@2<5CB64<C= 56C44J<H97389@3C8 J 9>73@@<>@29@@2<><5<94<>29> EC66CG<> :C98 =6C7 @2< E98L 98> 9:4C =6C7 ;63I9@< :<8><64EB@42<29442CG82<63?8C6985<9ECB@@2<E98L 344B38?9><798>8C@35<@C@2<><5<94<>59::38?B;C8237 @C 79L< ;9F7<8@ <85< 3@ 34 5:<96 @29@ 2< 29> 9I93:<> :C988C@C8:F=6C7@2<E98LEB@9:4C=6C7;63I9@<;<64C84 # 9I38?5C843><6<>@234984G<6<:353@<>=6C7@2< 7CB@2C= J @234CB6@2949:4C<H9738<>@2<<I3><85< C= 4J"$98>#94G<::94 J 98>8C>CBE@@2<F 29I< ><;C4<> G3@2 6<?96> @C 98 9E<@7<8@ @C 5C773@ 4B353>< ;<6B49: C= H23E3@ J 8C@238? 34 4@9@<> G3@2 6<?96> @C 9E<@7<8@ 38 @9L38? @2< <H@6<7< 4@<; C= 5C773@@38?4B353>< ' @ 34 9:4C 37;C6@98@ @C 8C@< @29@ @2< ;C4@J 7C6@<76<;C6@34I<6F5:<96@29@8CC@2<6<H@<689:38AB63<4 - 15 - G<6< =CB8> @2CB?2 98 9::<?9@3C8 34 79>< @29@ @2< ><5<94<>29>4B4@938<>38AB63<4@34=B6@2<637;C6@98@@C 8C@< @29@ >B638? @2< 5CB64< C= 38I<4@3?9@3C8 3@ <7<6?<> @29@ @2< ><5<94<> G94 9:4C 29I38? 98 3::353@ 6<:9@3C8423; G3@2C8<<<:97792<497<34<:353@<>=6C7@2<7CB@2 C= J , @2< 8I<4@3?9@38? ==35<6 G2C 59@<?C6359::F 9>73@@<> @29@ >B638? @2< 38I<4@3?9@3C8 2< 597< @C L8CG @29@ @2< ><5<94<> 29> 3::353@ 6<:9@3C8423; G3@2 <<:9779 98>493><<:9779G94=C6538?237@C7966F2<6<294 9:4C ?3I<8 9 59@<?C6359: 9>73443C8 @29@ 2< =<:@ @29@ @2< 955B4<> G<6< 8C@ 6<4;C843E:< =C6 @2< ><9@2 C= @2< ><5<94<> - @349:4C37;C6@98@@C8C@<@29@@2<<I3><85<C= J , 5:3852<4 @2< 344B< @29@ @2< ><5<94<> 29> 3::353@ 6<:9@3C8423; G3@2 <<:9779 98> @29@ 2< 59@<?C6359::F 9>73@@<> @29@ @2< :94@ 59:: 6<5<3I<> EF @2< ><5<94<> G94 =6C7 <<:9779 2< =95@ @29@ <<:9779 G94 38 @2< I3::9?<349:4C9>73@@<>EF@2<;6C4<5B@3C8G3@8<44<42< I<6F><=<85<C=@2<955B4<>;<64C84>B638?@2<5CB64<C= - 16 - 56C44J<H97389@3C8C=;6C4<5B@3C8G3@8<44<4349:4C@29@@2< ><5<94<>29>983::353@6<:9@3C8423;G3@2<<:9779 , 2< 9>73443C8 ?3I<8 EF J 6<?96>38? @2< ><5<94<>29I38?EC66CG<>:C98=6C7@2<E98L94G<::94 ;63I9@< ;<64C84 G94 9:4C >345B44<> 38 969 - C= @2< AB>?7<8@ C= @2< 639: CB6@ C 9:4C G3@2 6<?96> @C @2< 38><;<8><8@ G3@8<44<4 5C85<68<> 3< J' 98> J- ><;C4<>@2<FG<6<8C@9G96<C=3::353@6<:9@3C8423;E<@G<<8 955B4<>C 98>955B4<>C#98>EC@2G3@8<44<429I< 42CG83?8C6985<94@C2CG@2<><5<94<>7<@G3@2><9@2 J' 4@9@<> @29@ @2< 6<:9@3C8423; E<@G<<8 @2< ><5<94<> 98> 955B4<> C# G94 5C6>39: EB@ @2<F 29> 8C 344B<4 <85< @2< <I3><85< C= J' 98> J- 9:4C >C 8C@ 4B;;C6@4@2<594<C=@2<;6C4<5B@3C8 @349:4C37;C6@98@@C8C@<@29@@2<;6C4<5B@3C8 <H9738<>C8<7C6<G3@8<44 J <8L9@9<>>F<9> C84@9E:< C= I<6F 497< C:35< @9@3C8 < 59@<?C6359::F ><;C4<> @29@ E<=C6< @2< ><9@2 C= @2<><5<94<> 234 G3=< 3< 955B4<> C # 29> ?3I<8 9 5C7;:938@ 79L38? - 17 - 9::<?9@3C84 9?9384@ 2<6 2B4E98> 3< @2< ><5<94<> G94 29I38?983::353@6<:9@3C8423;G3@2C8<<<:977998>2<85< 2<B4<>@C:<9I<2<6382<6;96<8@402CB4<94<>C8@29@ 5C7;:938@ @2< E6C@2<64 98> B85:< C= @2< ><5<94<> G<6< 9:4C 4<5B6<> G2<6< 98 9::<?9@3C8 G94 79>< @29@ 9:: C= @2<7 29> ;:988<> @C 4C:<783K< @2< 796639?< C= @2< ><5<94<>G3@29:9>F=6C7=K9:;B634<I3><85<345:<96 @29@2<29>4<5B6<>@2<><5<94<>234E6C@2<6498>B85:< @C @2< ;C:35< 4@9@3C8 98> 9=@<6 5C853:39@3C8 @2< ><5<94<> 9?6<<> @C @9L< E95L 955B4<> C# 98> 29> <H<5B@<> 98 B8><6@9L38? @29@ 2< GCB:> :CCL 9=@<6 234 G3=< 38 9 ?CC> 7988<6 98> 9:4C 4<< @29@ 234 E6C@2<64 GCB:> 8C@ @6CBE:< 2<62CB?2@234G3@8<44G9456C44J<H9738<>8C@238?34 <:353@<>38=9ICB6C=@2<;6C4<5B@3C8 8@23494;<5@3@G94 9:4C@9L<88C@<C=EF@2<@639:CB6@38;969?69;2C 2<@639:CB6@9:4C6<=<66<>@C@2<9>73443C8C8@2<;96@ C= J ,38;969?69;2C, 2<@639:CB6@=B6@2<6>345B44<>G3@26<?96>@C @2<;2C8<59::><@93:45C8@938<>38H23E3@ J"98>H23E3@ - 18 - J% H23E3@ J" 34 38 5C88<5@3C8 G3@2 @2< ;2C8< 59::4 E<@G<<8@2<><5<94<>98><<:977998>H23E3@ J%34 38 6<4;<5@ C= @2< ;2C8< 59::4 493> @C E< C= 955B4<> C# 98> 955B4<> C B@ 38 C6><6 @C ;6CI< @29@ @2< ;2C8< 59:: E<:C8?4 @C EC@2 C= @2<7 8C@238? 34 ;6CI<> 2< 59:: ><@93:4 G<6< 5C::<5@<> EF @2< 8I<4@3?9@38? ==35<6 C= @2< 7CE3:<4 C= @2< 955B4<> EB@ 2< 294 8C@ =3:<> @2< 497< E<=C6<@2<CB6@9:C8?G3@2@2<5296?<J42<<@4385<2<>3> 8C@ CE@938 38=C679@3C8 6<?96>38? 38 G2C4< 897< @2< 596>9::<?<>:FB4<>EF955B4<>C#4@CC>4385<@2<497< G948C@4@98>38?38@2<897<C=955B4<>C# J%C8:F 4@9@<> 9ECB@ @2< ;2C8< 8B7E<6 C= 955B4<> C # EB@ @2<6< 34 8C@238? @C 42CG @29@ 3@ 4@98>4 38 @2< 897< C= 955B4<>C#C698FC@2<6955B4<><85<@2<@639:CB6@ >3>8C@5C843><6@2<497<><@93:<>>345B443C8G9479>< 38;969?69;2CC=@2<AB>?7<8@98>98CE4<6I9@3C834 79>< @29@@2<6< G94 9 :9;4< 98> 3895@3C8 C8 @2< ;96@ C= @2<8I<4@3?9@38? ==35<6385C::<5@38?@2<79@<639:H23E3@ J% 42CG4 @29@ @2< :94@ 59:: =6C7 7CE3:< 8B7E<6 C= - 19 - 955B4<>C G94@C955B4<>C#98>@2<497<G94C8 "@2 CI<7E<6 , G2<6<94 @2< 3853><8@ @CCL ;:95< 38 ;63:, " 9I38? @9L<8 8C@< C= @2< <I3><85< C= ;6C4<5B@3C8G3@8<44<4;96@35B:96:F @2<<I3><85<C= 4J @C$98>9:4C@2<9>73443C84C8@2<;96@C= 4J ,98> @2<6<348C5C66CEC69@3I<;3<5<C=<I3><85<G3@26<?96> @C @2< 9::<?9@3C8 @29@ 955B4<> C# @<94<> @2< ><5<94<> =C6 8C@ ;6C5B638? 9 523:> 98> DB966<:38? 237 8 @2< 5C8@696F@2<<I3><85<C= 4 ,98> ?C<49?9384@@2< ><5<94<> 98> 38 C6><6 @C ;6CI< @2< 38?6<>3<8@4 C= 9E9@<7<8@@C5C773@4B353><8C@238?34C86<5C6>@@2< =364@384@985<@2<9::<?9@3C8G94@29@@2<955B4<>;<64C84 5C773@@<>7B6><698>4BE4<DB<8@:F38@2<7C8@2C=B:F =B6@2<64@9@<7<8@4C=G3@8<44<4G<6<6<5C6><>G3@26<?96> @C9E9@<7<8@98>3::353@6<:9@3C8423;98>3=@2<F29>6<9::F 2<96>955B4<>C#@<9438?><5<94<>98>DB966<:38?G3@2 237=C68C@E<?<@@38?9523:>98>@29@42<9E<@@<>@C>3< @2<F 5CB:> 29I< 4@9@<> @2< 497< 9@ @2< <96:3<4@ ;C38@ C= - 20 - @37< EB@ 4B52 9::<?9@3C84 G<6< 8C@ 4@9@<> 9@ @29@ @37< 639:CB6@9:4C8C@<>@29@G2<8@2<><5<94<>2374<:=29> <H<5B@<>98B8><6@9L38?98>E6CB?2@E95L234G3=<@C234 2CB4<98>@2C4<79@<639:45:<96:F6<I<9:@29@@2<><5<94<> 2374<:=29>?3I<84B5298B8><6@9L38? " @ 34 =B6@2<6 37;C6@98@ @C 8C@< @29@ G23:< 38ICL38?98C==<85<B8><6<5@3C8,$ @2<6<7B4@E< ;6CH373@F@C59B4<=C6@2<><9@298>9:4C@C9E<@7<8@4 =96 94 9E<@7<8@ 34 5C85<68<>@2< <I3><85< C86<5C6> >C 8C@ 384;36< 5C8=3><85< C= @2< CB6@ 4385< 9@ @2< =364@ 384@985< @2<6< G94 8C 4B52 9::<?9@3C8 98> C8:F 9=@<6 @2< =389:6<;C6@G946<5<3I<>4@9@38?@29@3@G9494B353><98> 8C@97B6><6=B6@2<64@9@<7<8@4G<6<6<5C6><>98>@2C4< =B6@2<6 4@9@<7<8@4 C= G3@8<44<4 9:4C >C 8C@ 5C66CEC69@< G3@2 @2<36 9::<?9@3C8 C= 9E9@<7<8@ 2< @639: CB6@ 294 63?2@:F@9L<88C@<C=9::@2<4<79@<639:38@C5C843><69@3C8 8 @2< 9E4<85< C= 98F 79@<639: G3@2 6<?96> @C 9E<@7<8@ 38ICL38?<5@3C8,$C= >C<48C@9634< - 21 - % 4=9694@2<C@2<6C==<85<4B8><6<5@3C84 " 98> "- 96< 5C85<68<> G23:< 38ICL38? <5@3C84 " 98> "-@2<6<7B4@E<95C77C8CEA<5@8@2<;6<4<8@ 594<8C5C77C8CEA<5@349:4C734438?2<6<349:4C8C 4;<53=35 5296?<4 9?9384@ @2< C@2<6 955B4<> ;<64C84 @29@ @2<F 9E<@@<> @2< ><5<94<> 38 @9L38? @2< <H@6<7< 4@<; C= 5C773@@38? 4B353>< 8:F C783EB4 9::<?9@3C84 29I< E<<8 79><9?9384@@2<C@2<6955B4<>@29@@2<F>3>8C@2<9>@C @2< 6<DB<4@ C= @2< ><5<94<> G2<8 @2< 9::<?9@3C8 C= 955B4<>C4 98>#29I38?3::353@6<:9@3C8423;G9479>< 2< @639: CB6@ 9:4C 63?2@:F 79>< 98 CE4<6I9@3C8 @29@ @C 38ICL< <5@3C8 ,$ C= @2<6< 7B4@ E< ;6CH373@F @C 59B4<C=><9@2 $ C >CBE@ @2< 5CB84<: 9;;<9638? =C6 @2< 9;;<::98@ 38 234 96?B7<8@ E6CB?2@ @C @2< 8C@35< C= @234 CB6@@2<>C5B7<8@9@H J-G2<6<3896<;C6@34?3I<8 @29@@2<FC3>C8<348C@=CB8>2<497<G3::8C@2<:; @2<;6C4<5B@3C8@C@3:@@2<6<94C838?38C6><6@C38ICL<@2< ;<89: ;6CI343C8 B8><6 <5@3C8 ,$ C= C >CBE@ - 22 - 5CB84<: 9;;<9638? =C6 @2< 9;;<::98@ 5C8@<8>4 @29@ @2< C6><6 C= 95DB3@@9: 34 <66C8<CB4 98> @639: CB6@ CB?2@ @C 29I<@9L<88C@<C=@2<>C5B7<8@9@H J-98>@2<CB6@ 294@C>69G9838=<6<85<6<?96>38?@2<9E4<85<C=FC3> C8<G23525988C@E<955<;@<> # 2< C@2<6 5C8@<8@3C8 @29@ 38I<4@3?9@3C8 C= @2< 594< 34 8C@ >C8< 38 9 ;6C;<6 7988<6 C >CBE@ @2<6< 34 =C65<38@2<5C8@<8@3C8C=@2<:<968<>5CB84<:@29@@2CB?2 38=C679@3C8 C= 59:: ><@93:4 C= 955B4<> C4 98> # 34 5C::<5@<>38C6><6@C;6CI<@2<3::353@6<:9@3C8423;2<=95@ 6<79384@29@@2CB?2 %4@9@<4@29@@2<;2C8<8B7E<6 E<:C8?4@C955B4<>C#C8:FEB@@C;6CI<@29@@2<497< 8C@238? 34 5C::<5@<> 98> 8C8J5C::<5@3C8 C= ><@93:4 C= @2< ;96@35B:96;2C8<8B7E<694@C38 G2C4<897<3@4@98>4 5988C@@9L<9G9F@2<594<C=@2<;6C4<5B@3C82<6<7B4@ E<C@2<6<I3><85<E<=C6<@2<CB6@98>@2<38?6<>3<8@4C= <5@3C8,$ 96<8C@;6CI<> ' 8@2<C@2<6298>@2<<I3><85<C= 4J ,98> ?C<4 9?9384@ @2< ;6C4<5B@3C8 B638? @2< 5CB64< C= - 23 - 38I<4@3?9@3C8 3@ 294 <7<6?<> @29@ @2< ><5<94<> G94 29I38?3::353@6<:9@3C8423;G3@2C8<<<:977998>@2<497< 349>73@@<>EF@2< @349:4C59@<?C6359::F><;C4<>EF J @29@E<=C6<><5<94<>5C773@@38?4B353><@2<G3=< 3< 955B4<> C# 29> :C>?<> 9 5C7;:938@ 98> @2< 955B4<> 98> E6C@2<64 C= @2< ><5<94<> 29> 9:4C E<<8 4<5B6<> @C @2< ;C:35< 4@9@3C8 2< 955B4<> 29> <H<5B@<> 98B8><6@9L38?@29@2<GCB:>@9L<596<C=955B4<>C# 2<8 4B52 79@<639: 34 9:4C =CB8> @2< DB<4@3C8 C= 38@<6=<6<85<EF@234CB6@>C<48C@9634<@348C@9594<C= <H@<8>38? @2< E<8<=3@ C= >CBE@ 38 =9ICB6 C= @2< 955B4<> 2<6< 34 8C 5C66CEC69@3I< <I3><85< @C ;6CI< @2< 5296?<4 :<I<::<> 9?9384@ @2< 955B4<> 8 594< C= 5C8I35@3C8 @2<6< 7B4@ E< 9 5C66CEC69@3I< ;3<5< C= <I3><85< 98> @2< ;6C4<5B@3C89:4C7B4@;6CI<@2<497<E<FC8>6<94C89E:< >CBE@ 2< <I3><85< 9I93:9E:< C8 6<5C6> >C<4 8C@ 5C66CEC69@< @2< 594< C= @2< ;6C4<5B@3C8 <85< @2< DB<4@3C8C=6<I<6438?@2<AB>?7<8@C=639:CB6@>C<48C@ - 24 - 9634< 55C6>38?:F @2< 984G<6 @C @2< ;C38@4 =C6 5C843><69@3C83438@2<8<?9@3I< - 8I3<GC=@2<>345B443C8479><9ECI<G<;944 @2<=C::CG38? ;;<9:34>347344<> .* %!) $ .* %") $ 34@C :C'