- 1 - !" # $ % %% &"' ( !! "# $#$% # # ! & # # ! $!' ! "# $$&( $ ')''* ! % & & )*"%&$ ! !! ! ! # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & '*' ! #&$ $ #+$$!$*' ', !! && $ -# ! $ ./0122314/05/436171/8099.3:;67<3891861=1>6 61936'*'210036?@9.3$66/9/A814 38/A>/B/4 ;6731863<?3>+$$/:1@12;>1/8$A*' A5', .3 C41/<189 1736' @31>06A/8717>/C;49;>3 =A>D<39=/9.181CC/6389A8','',1860;091/836 7>/3BA;0/8:;>30.3>35A>3.35/4361C41/<239/9/A8?35A>3 9.3 >/?;814 C41/</87 CA<238019/A8 A5 0''''' .3 >/?;814 CA80/63>/87 9.3 389/>3 3B/638C3 A8 >3CA>6 7>18936 CA<238019/A8 A5 0)'' =/9. /893>309 19 E 21 5>A< 9.3 6193 A5 239/9/A8 9/44 >314/019/A8 186 6/>3C936 >302A86389 A80;>18C3 A<218@ 9A 632A0/9 9.301<3 - 3 - * 77>/3B36?@9.301/6:;67<3891861=1>69.3 /8:;>36 C41/<189 .10 2>353>>36 9./0 122314 /8 =./C. /9 /0 CA8938636 9.19 9.3 1<A;89 7>18936 ;863> A9.3> CA8B389/A814 .3160 1>3 <317>3 3 5/436 <36/C14 ?/440 ;863> F!) 5A> 18 1<A;89 A5 0*''''' ?;9 9.3 >/?;814.107>18936A84@0,) .36AC9A>10030036 9.3 6/01?/4/9@ 19 E 9A E 9A 9.3 4359 ;223> 4/<? ?;9 9.3 >/?;814 .10 91D38 A84@ E 6/01?/4/9@ 9A 9.3 =.A43 ?A6@.3/893>309/09A?338.18C369A,E21.3>35A>3 >3G;309365A>38.18C3<389A5CA<238019/A8 31>69.31>7;<3890A5?A9.0/630 .A;7. 9.3 122344189 091936 9.19 .3 =10 31>8/870''' 23><A89..3.108A92>A6;C3618@ /8CA<32>AA5.3>35A>39.3>/?;814.10>/7.94@91D38./0 8A9/A814 /8CA<3 19 0*' 23> <A89. 10 23> 9.3 7;/634/830A59.31>8191D1 91933714 3>B/C30;9.A>/9@ 109.31CC/6389/0A59.3@31>',3=101736'@31>0 1869.3>35A>39.3<;49/24/3>=10>/7.94@91D3810HI0 23> F!=A;86 C3>9/5/C193 9.3 122344189 .10 0;091/836 - 4 - 5>1C9;>3A54359.;<3>;0=./C./07>/3BA;0/8819;>3.3 122344189.103F1</8369.36AC9A>10!1869.36AC9A> /00;36 6/01?/4/9@ C3>9/5/C193 ;863> F!, 186 10030036 9.3 6/01?/4/9@19E9AE A *>6A59.301<3CA<309A E1869.3>/?;814.10>/7.94@CA80/63>369.301<3186 9.;0 C14C;41936 9.3 4A00 A5 5;9;>3 31>8/870 19 0' 1869.301<3833608A/893>53>38C3 .3 >/?;814 .10 1=1>636 18 1<A;89 A5 0,) 9A=1>60 <36/C14 3F238030 186 /9 83360 8A9 /893>53>38C3 ) .3 122344189 =10 16</9936 /8 9.3 .A02/914 5A> ') 61@0 A80/63>/879.3819;>3 A5/8:;>/3018623>/A6A5 .A02/914/019/A8 9./0 A;>9 5/860 /9 >310A81?43 9A 7>189 18 1<A;89A50'''' 5A>21/81860;553>/870''' 5A> 4A00 A5 1<38/9/30 186 0*'''' 5A> 9>1802A>919/A8 3F9>18A;>/0.<389186199386189C.1>730 .3 122344189 </7.9 8A9 .1B3 19938636 18@ =A>D 19 43109 5A> 1 23>/A6 A5 5A;> <A89.0 6;3 9A 9.3 - 5 - /8:;>/300;091/836.3>35A>39./0A;>95/860/9>310A81?43 9A7>189181<A;89A50*''' "0*'F%5A>4A00 A5/8CA<36;>/8741/6;223>/A6 , 023>9.33B/638C3A59.36AC9A>9.3122344189 .10 0;091/836 4359 0;2>1CA86@41> 5>1C9;>3 A5 .;<3>;0 =./C. =10 A23>1936 ?@ A238 >36;C9/A8 /893>814 5/F19/A8 =/9. 2419/87 .3>35A>3 9./0 A;>9 5/860 /9 >310A81?43 9A 7>189 18 1<A;89 A5 0''' 5A> 5;9;>3 <36/C14 3F238030/35A>>3<AB14A5/<24189 ' 38C39.3122344189/0389/94365A>9.3<A6/5/36 CA<238019/A8;863>6/553>389.316010?34A= !1/81860;553>/87 0'''' 36/C143F238030 0,) A00A55;9;>331>8/870 0' A00A5/8CA<36;>/8741/6;223>/A6 0*''' >1802A>919/A8 3F9>1 8A;>/0.<389 186199386189C.1>730 0*'''' A00A51<38/9/30 0''' &;9;>3<36/C143F238030 0''' A914 3001=1>636?@>/?;814 8.18C3<389 0*')) 0)'' )** - 6 - .3 80;>18C3 A<218@ .10 14>316@ 632A0/936 9.3 1<A;89 1=1>636 ?@ 9.3 >/?;814 .;0 9.3 122344189 /0 389/94365A>38.18C36CA<238019/A8A50),)) =/9. /893>309 19 E 23> 188;< 186 9.3>35A>3 9.3 122314 6303>B309A?3144A=36/821>9 89.3>30;499.35A44A=/87A>63>/0210036 "/% 22314/0144A=36/821>9 "//% .3 122344189 C41/<189 /0 389/9436 5A> 9.3 38.18C36 CA<238019/A8 A5 0),)) =/9. /893>309 19 E 23> 188;< 5>A< 9.3 6193 A5 239/9/A8 9/44 9.3 6193 A5 >314/019/A8 A=3B3> 1023>A>63> 61936')''*9.3 122344189/08A9389/94365A>/893>3095A>9.36341@3623>/A6 A5,'61@0/85/4/879.3122314 "///% 302A86389 A80;>18C3 A<218@ /0 6/>3C936 9A 632A0/9 9.3 15A>301/6 CA<238019/A8 1<A;89 =/9./8A83<A89.5>A<9.36193A59./0:;67<389 - 7 - "/B% 8 0;C. 632A0/9 9.3 122344189 /0 23></9936 9A =/9.6>1= 9.3 389/>3 1<A;89 14A87 =/9. /893>309 1CC>;36 A8/9 )+, &% ' $ /09A 4A