Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 42979 (KAR)
SIDRAM AND ORS v. SUMANGALA AND ORS
RSA/200523/2024 · 2025-11-21
M G S Kamal
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 42979 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 42979 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#
$#%##
&&
'&(&)
*
!"#
$
!"#
$
!"#
% &
'
()
!"#
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$
("
!"#
"
(
"
"
"
$! *
$"
! $(
)
$
#
(
)
$
*"
!"#
)
- 3 -
!"
(
*
!"#
*
!"#
"
# !#$
*
#
!"#
! *! !"#
)
!"#
$#
$
!"#
$
*
- 4 -
!"#
$$
(
+ +
!"#
%
& +(
$#'
+ ## +
$)"$#$(
# $#$#
+ + $* $#
++ + + +
$ *
+
,
%# &
, '
-./ 011203 ./ 45 627286089
/$ 9 $ 42.8: 0::;.2<26459-2=>6:?28908662@;2260926##$#$# 10//26.8
$* $#89-27.327 66.9.803.<.3 >6:2086 +.=051>;0A-2;2.80792;;272;;2690/9-2
- 5 -
B;.03 >;9C 7; 4;2<.95D E-.@- ./ @87.;?26 45 9-2 =>6:?289 086 62@;22 60926 $)#"$#$( 10//26 .8 # $#$#89-27.3279-2 66.9.80328.;.<.3 >6:2 .=0501>;0 A-2;2.80792; ;272;;26 9 0/ 9-2 B+.;/9 11233092>;9C7;4;2<.95D $ >4=2@9 ?0992; 7 04<2 />.9 ./ 3086 420;.8: 5
"* $ ?20/>;.8: " 0@;2/ $( :>890/ /.9>0926 09 0/040 <.330:2 7 .=0501>;0 A-2;2.80792; ;272;;26 9 0/ B9-2/>.9/@-26>321;12;95C7;4;2<.95D
4<2/>.9./7.326459-2130.89.77/7;10;9.9.8 086 /210;092 1 .8 @30.?.8: 9-09 130.89.77/ 086 9-2 627286089
/ 9 ) 0;2 9-2 ?2?42;/ 7 9-2 =.89 70?.3582?22801109-21;1/.9>/E0/9-2E82;7 9-2/>.9/@-26>321;12;95-2/0.6?2280110-067.<2 @-.36;2880?235&'0;0/0110&$'0/0110&'.;0:2110 &(' -086;0/-2F-0; .2 627286089
) 086 &' 030<<0 27286089
./ 9-2 E.72 7 62@20/26 4;9-2; 7 130.89.77 45 80?2 -;.?089 086 627286089
/$ 9 * 0;29-2 /8/ 7 627286089
27286089
/! 086)
- 6 -
0;2 9-2 4;9-2;/ 7 9-2 130.89.77 27286089
# ./ 9-2 0>89 7 9-2 130.89.77/ 27286089
/ 9 0;2 9-2 @-.36;28 7 62@20/26 .;0:2110 E- ./ 9-2 >8@32 7 9-2 130.89.77/27286089
"./9-20>8979-2130.89.77/086 9-2 E.72 7 9-2 62@20/26 >8@32 7 9-2 130.89.77/ 45 80?2 0/0110 27286089
/* 086 ! 0;2 9-2 /8/ 7 627286089
"086627286089
)./9-2>8@3279-2 130.89.77/ 27286089
/$# 9 $$ 0;2 9-2 @-.36;28 7 080?089-
>@@-.
E- 1>;@-0/26 9-2 />.9 /@-26>32 1;12;957;?627286089
) ( -09 0792; 9-2 62?./2 7 ?2280110 -./ 7.<2 @-.36;28 80?26 04<2 @0?2 .89 1 .8 086 28=5?289 7 9-2 />.9 /@-26>32 1;12;95 0/E82;/9-2.; 80?2/-0<.8:4228?>926.89-2;2<28>2;2@;6/0/12; (**$ .8 #)*( -2 @-.36;28 7 ?2280110 F219 9-2 />.9 /@-26>32 1;12;95 .8 9-2 80?2 7 62@20/26 030<<0 7; 9-2 1>;1/2 7 -2; ?0.892808@2 0/ /-2 E0/ 1-5/.@0335 @-03328:26 E.9- 0 @86.9.8 9-09 0792; -2; 62?./2 9-2 1;12;95 /->36 42 6.<.626 0?8:/9 9-2 7>;
- 7 -
4;9-2;/ 2G>0335 0.6 030<<0 10//26 0E05 320<.8: 42-.86-2;7>;4;9-2;/0/-2;32:03-2.;/>;.8:9-27.;/9 E22F 7 2@2?42; $#$ 130.89.77/ ;2G>2/926 9-2 627286089
) 086 033 9-2; 627286089/ 9 2772@9 9-2 10;9.9.8 E-.@- E0/ ;27>/26 -2 627286089
) .87;?26 9-09 -2 -06 03;2065 /36 9-2 />.9 /@-26>32 1;12;95.870<>;7709-2;7627286089
/$#9$38: 0: 30.89.77/ 8 320;8.8: 9-2 /0?2 490.826 0 @2;9.7.26 @15 7 9-2 ;2@;6/ 7 ;.:-9/ 086 ?>909.8 289;.2/ 086 320;899-09627286089
).8@33>/.8E.9-9-22<28>2 77.@2;/ 490.826 ?>909.8 7 -./ 80?2 0/ 9-2 835 4;9-2; 7 62@20/26 030<<0 27286089
) -0/ />11;2//26 9-2 ?092;.03 70@9/ E.9- ;2:0;6 9 9-2; 9-;22 4;9-2;/ E- 0;2 03/ 32:0335 289.9326 7; /-0;2 7 9-2 1;12;95-09130.89.77/086627286089
/9)0;29-2 =.8970?.35?2?42;/0869-2/>.9/@-26>321;12;95./9-2 =.8970?.351;12;95//>@-9-2/>.97;10;9.9.8
27286089
/$!99!$#9$ 01120;26 086 7.326 9-2.; E;.9928 /9092?289 27286089
- 8 -
/ ( 9 * ( ) 086 $# ;2?0.826 04/289 086 E2;2 130@26 27286089
$ 7.326 E;.9928 /9092?289 086 9-2 @>892; @30.? E-.@- ./ 061926 45 627286089 /# 086 27286089
* 7.326 E;.9928 /9092?289 038: E.9- @>892; @30.? E-.@- ./ 061926 45 627286089
/" 086 ! 27286089
$ 7.326 -./ /210;092 E;.9928 /9092?289 -2 /0?2 -0/ 4228 061926 45627286089
/$$086$
" 27286089
/$ 086 * .8 9-2 E;.9928 /9092?289 06?.9926 9-2 ;2309.8/-.1 086 03/ 06?.9926 ?2280110E0/9-21;1/.9>/42.8:9-2E82;79-2/>.9 /@-26>32 1;12;95 -25 03/ 06?.9926 9-2 @30.?
7 130.89.77/ 086 1;0526 7; 10;9.9.8 086 0339?289 7 9-2.; ;2/12@9.<2/-0;2/ * 27286089
$ 628.26 9-2 130.89 0<2;?289/ 086 03/ 628.26 9-2 ;2309.8/-.1 9 ./ @8928926 9-09 9-2 />.9 1;12;95 E0/ 9-2 04/3>92 1;12;95 7 030<<0 086 9-2 />.9 ./ 40;;26 45 3.?.909.8 0/ 9-2 130.89.77/ 086 627286089
/ 9 ) -0<2 3/9 9-2.; 1 .8 7 />.9
- 9 -
/@-26>321;12;95.89-2520;)*(0866.689@-03328:2 9-2 /032 6226 2H2@>926 45 627286089
) 30.89.77/ >:-99-0<27.3269-2/>.9E.9-.8 520;/;09320/9$ 520;/7;?9-2609270990.8.8:?0=;.95//>@-/>:-9 7;6./?.//0379-2/>.9 ! 0/2689-213206.8:/;.03>;97;0?269-2 733E.8:.//>2/
! "
# $ %
"
"
"" $ &
"
"
""'
) 30.89.77/.8;62;91;<29-2.;@0/22H0?.826 130.89.77
$0/ 0861;6>@267>;6@>?289/E-.@-
- 10 -
0;2 ?0;F26 0/ H/ 9 ( .8@2 ;2?0.826 04/289 086 6.6 89 ;2862; 7; @;// 2H0?.809.8 />.9 7 9-2 130.89.77/ E0/ 6./?.//26 45 ;62; 60926 $"$#" -2;20792; 8 $)$#" 627286089
/$ 086 * ?<26080113.@09.89;2/9;29-2/>.90/9-25-067.326 @>892; @30.? .8@2 9-2 />.9 E0/ 7; 10;9.9.8 086 /210;092 1 .8 086 @>892; @30.? E0/ 1286.8: />.9 E0/ ;2/9;26 086 06=>6.@0926 9-2 @>892; @30.? 7 627286089
/$086*27286089
*E0/2H0?.826 0/ 0861;6>@269-;226@>?289/?0;F260/H/ 9 27286089
$ E0/ 2H0?.826 0/ $ 27286089
$E0/2H0?.8260/ 086-21;6>@26 9E6@>?289/0/H/ (086 # 8011;2@.09.872<.628@2.//>2
/086 E2;2 -236 9 42 ;26>86089 .//>2
$ E0/ -236 .8 9-2 82:09.<2086066.9.803.//>2
/086$E2;2-236.89-2 077.;?09.<28/2G>289359-2;.03>;962@;2269-2/>.9 0/>862;
- 11 -
(
""
&
"
)*#
( +* ! "
( + , %
"
! "
( % -
"
! "
( +! -% "
*
-
(
"
"
." ,!/0/
1 "* 2
)
"
3)"""* '
2.8: 0::;.2<26 627286089
/$ 9 $ 1;272;;26 ;2:>30; 011203 .8
# $#$# -2 +.;/9 11233092 >;9 7;0?26 9-2 733E.8: 1.89/ 7; .9/ @8/.62;09.8
*
( /
"""
- 12 -
*
(/ )
""
" *)
*" (/ !
"'
$ 8 ;2 011;2@.09.8 9-2 +.;/9 11233092 >;9 08/E2;26 1.89
086 $ .8 9-2 077.;?09.<2 086 1.89 .8 9-2 82:09.<2 086 @8/2G>28935 6./?.//26 9-2 011203 2.8: 0::;.2<26 1;2/289 011203 45 627286089 /$9$
20;826 @>8/23 7; 9-2 011233089/ ;2.92;09.8: 9-2:;>86/>;:26.89-2?2?;086>?7011203/>4?.9/ 9-099-2;.03>;90869-2+.;/911233092>;970.3269 011;2@.0929-090792;62?./27 030<<09-2/>.93086@0?2 9 42 ?>90926 .8 9-2 80?2 7 627286089
) -086;0/2F-0;086011233089/0792;12;>/.8:9-2;2@;6/ 1>;@-0/26 9-2 />.9 /@-26>32 1;12;95 .8 92;?/ 7 ;2:./92;2662267/03260926#()!"-2;20792;9-2.;
- 13 -
80?2/E2;2?>90926.89-2;2<28>2;2@;6/>.97.32645 9-2 130.89.77/ 0792; /2<2;03 520;/ 9-25 89 42.8: .8 1 .8 086 28=5?289 7 9-2 1;12;95 E0/ 9-2;27;2 89?0.890.80432-099-2;2E0/08;62;7.8=>8@9.8.8 70<>;79-2011233089/.892;?/7=>6:?28908662@;22 10//26.8
(! )!)E-.@--0/0990.8267.803.958 9-2 /0.6 />.9 /?2 7 9-2 627286089/ E2;2 10;9.2/ 086 9-25-0<2890//0.3269-2=>6:?28908662@;2210//26.8 9-2 /0.6 />.9
1;7 7 />.9 1;12;95 42.8: 08@2/9;03 1;12;95 ;2G>.;.8: 10;9.9.8 0?8:/9 9-2 4;9-2;/ 7 030<<0 0792; -2; 62?./2 .8@2 9-2 /032 6226 -0/ 89 4228 @-03328:26 @>892; @30.?
?062 45 9-2 627286089 /$ 086 * @>36 89 -0<2 4228 :;08926 -2;27;2 />4?.9/ 9-09 />4/9089.03 G>2/9.8 7 30E E>36 0;./2 7;
@8/.62;09.8 ;2G>.;.8: 06=>6.@09.8 09 9-2 -086/ 7 9-./ >;9 ( 2; @89;0 320;826 @>8/23 01120;.8: 7; 9-2 ;2/186289/ =>/9.75.8: 9-2 =>6:?289 086 62@;22 10//26 459-2;.03>;9/>4?.9/9-099-2/>.9/@-26>321;12;95
- 14 -
;.:.803354238:2699-21;1/.9>/?2280110792;-./ 62?./2E.9-9-2@8/28/>/;2<28>2;2@;6/E2;22892;26 .89 9-2 80?2 7 0330<<0 0/ /-2 E0/ 1-5/.@0335 @-03328:268350/0/2@>;.957;-2;/>;<.<03-2;20792;
0792; -2; 62?./2 9-2 />.9 /@-26>32 1;12;95 E0/ 9 42 /-0;262G>03350?8:/99-27>;4;9-2;/-09627286089 ) -06 :.<28 E;8: .87;?09.8 9 9-2 ;2<28>2 0>9-;.9.2/ 7 -2 42.8: 9-2 835 4;9-2; 7 030<<0 086 -06490.8269-2?>909.8.8-./80?240/268E-.@--2 -0/ 03.280926 9-2 1;12;95 .8 70<>;7 627286089
/$# 9 $ E- 0;2 9-2 011233089/ 427;2 9-./ >;9 -09 8 <03.69.932-0/4228@8<2526.89-2.;70<>;.8@29-2/>.9 ./827;10;9.9.8086/210;0921 .8086627286089 )6.689-0<20852H@3>/.<2;.:-9<2;9-21;12;95 9-2;2E0/882267;9-2?9G>2/9.89-22H2@>9.87 /03262260/9-2;.:-903E05//>4/./92628@2-2/>4?.9/ 9-09 8 />4/9089.03 G>2/9.8 7 30E E>36 0;./2 7; @8/.62;09.8086/22F/7;6./?.//0379-2011203
20;62;>/269-2;2@;6/
- 15 -
" -2 ;.03 >;9 086 9-2 +.;/9 11233092 >;9 40/26 8 9-2 2<.628@2 326 45 9-2 10;9.2/ -0<2 @?2 9 9-2 @8@3>/.8 9-09 9-2 />.9 /@-26>32 1;12;95 ;.:.80335 4238:26 9 9-2 1;1/.9>/ ?2280110 0/ 2<.628@26 45 H $ 9-2 >909.8 89;5
(**$ 2 10//26 0E05 8 ##!)*( >18 E-.@- 9-2 />.9 /@-26>32 1;12;95 E0/ ?>90926 .8 9-2 80?2 7 -./ 7>; /8/ 086 60>:-92; -2 >;9/-0<203/@?299-2@8@3>/.89-099-27>;/8/ 7?2280110-06;0335?062<2;9-21;12;95.870<>;
7 030<<07;9-21>;1/27-2;?0.892808@20//-2E0/ 1-5/.@0335 @-03328:26 E.9- 0 @86.9.8 9-09 0792; -2; 62?./29-21;12;95E>3642:.<2899-24;9-2;/942 6.<.6260?8:/99-2?@@;6.8:3580?27 030<<0E0/ ?>90926 0/ 12;
(**" 792; 9-2 62?./2 7 /0.6 030<<0 627286089
) ;21;2/289.8: -.?/237 0/ 9-2 8354;9-2;7 030<<0-06490.8269-2?>909.8.8-./ 80?20/12;H
(8$#")!# * -2 >;9/ -0<2 9->/ @?2 9 9-2 @8@3>/.8 9-099-2/>.9/@-26>321;12;95;.:.803354238:2699-2
- 16 -
1;1/.9>/ 9-2;20792; ?062 <2; E.9- @86.9.8 9 030<<0E-./9-283560>:-92;086>18-2;62?./2 9-21;12;95>:-99-0<2422810;9.9.826 0?8:/9-./ 7>; /8/ 80?235 0;0/0110 0/0110 .;0:2110 086 627286089
) -086;0/2F-0;337>;79-2?42.8:
2G>0335 289.9326 7; (9- /-0;2 .8 9-2 1;12;95 -09 9-2 130.89.77/086627286089
/9);21;2/289269-24;08@- 7 62@20/26 0;0/0110 627286089 /# 9
;21;2/289269-24;08@-7.;0:2110627286089
/"9 ! ;21;2/28926 9-2 4;08@- 7 62@20/26 0/0110 627286089 ) ./ 9-2 9-2; /8 7 1;1/.9>/ ?2280110E-@8/9.9>926/210;0924;08@-->/40/26 8E-.@-9-2>;9/-0<2@?299-2@8@3>/.89-099-2 /032 2<28 .7 085 ?062 45 627286089
) .8 70<>; 7 627286089
/ $# 9 $ @>36 835 -0<2 4228 9 9-2 2H9289 7 -./ /-0;2 086 89 9 9-2 /-0;2 7 9-2 9-2; ?2?42;/79-270?.350860@@;6.8:3562@;2269-2/>.9
- 17 -
! -2 /299326 1/.9.8 7 30E ./ 9-09 ?>909.8 289;.2/490.826457;0>6>3289?208/E>3689@;2092085 /-0;2;.:-99.932;.892;2/9 ) -28C43212H>;9.89-2@0/27
' +
)
6203.8:E.9-9-21;2/>?19.87@;;2@982//7 ;2<28>2289;.2/0910;0/(086-0/-2360/>862; !
4
" *
2 *2 ""
"
"
5 6
"" 1
"""*2* 2 (
"
(
"
"
"
*
"" )
"
"5
)
7*" * " " "
, 4
89 %!$ &.//-++2)
/
."+ : 0 ;" , 6
" 6 """ <
<
,%7
"*
"2
/
89 %-$ ./= % &2%+
//**" *
"
- 18 -
56)
")
"
*
""#
! ! "2
"
)
"" "
*
"2)
"
)"" *2"
$# 11;1;.092 03/ 9 ;272; 9 2@9.8 (( 7 9-2 ;08/72;;12;95@9!!$E-.@-;206/0/>862; #$$ % ! &>
)
") *
"
" 2
"6"
2
" * "
2 ? *
"
2
"
2 "
""*2 2
)* ** 2
*
"
"
' $ 89-270@9/086@.;@>?/908@2/49-9-2>;9/ -0<.8: 0;;.<26 09 9-2 @8@3>/.8 086 627.8.92 7.86.8: 9-09 9-2 1;12;95 ;.:.80335 4238:26 9 ?2280110 086 0792;
-./ 62?./2 -./ @-.36;28 42.8: 289.9326 9 2G>03 /-0;2
- 19 -
9->:-7;04;.2712;.6?062.89-280?27 030<<07; 9-21>;1/27-2;?0.892808@29-./>;9689/22085 .332:03.95 ; .;;2:>30;.95 E0;;089.8: .892;72;28@2
/>4/9089.03 G>2/9.8 7 30E E>36 0;./2 7; @8/.62;09.8 @@;6.8:359-2011203./
9 ./ ?062 @320; 9-09 9-2 /032 ?062 45 627286089 ) .8 70<>; 7 627286089
/$ 9 $ E>36 42 4.86.8: 835 9 9-2 2H9289 7 -./ /-0;2 086 89 9 9-2 /-0;279-29-2;?2?42;/79-270?.35
,( '##) %
/EF ./9
3
"