- 1 - ! "!#$ %#!&!&"## '!( ! " # $ %! ! & ' ! (( # ) ' '(( # ' ! (( ! # $ %' '& Digitally signed by PREMCHANDRA M R Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' ( ))*( ' ( ( ' ( ' +, ' -./0./1.2345678294-1:8;81.1.468-/6<-./2:/- /4 /246= >.1: -./22.?/-@56 /:5?/- 94- 1:8 -87;46<8617:/08/;;8/-8<.6;8-746 ) :83/;1.468<-.181.1.46.79.28<788?.6=94224>.6= -82.897 /& 4.7758/>-.1498-1.4-/-.4-/<.-831.4614A5/7:1:8 4-<8- </18< )))# .6 (.28 4 ! * )))# ;/778< BC 1:8 9.-71 -87;46<861 /51:4-.1C/7.228=/2/6</-B.1-/-C0.<8668D5-8 B& 4.7758/>-.149/6</E57<.-831.6=-87;46<8617 /6< ) 641 14 <82818 1:8 6/E8 49 1:8 ;81.1.468- .6 -87;831 49 C4#F E8/75-.6= # /3-87 7.15/18< /1 521/6;5-% &!.22/=8 /25?//6<.71-.31.</- :8;81.1.46/08-E8617/-8/756<8- - 3 - 1 .7 7/.< 1:/1 1:8 ;81.1.468-,7 9/1:8- /-/7/;;/ 4/6=/;;/ >/7.7758< >.1: +, (4-E 56<8- (4-E 4! .6 -87;83149/2/6<B8/-.6=C4#FE8/75-.6=#3-877.15/18< /1 521/6;5- % & !.22/=8 /25? /6< .71-.31 .</- .6 (.28 4 F GGG* </18< )*)GGG 1 .7 71/18< 1:/1 2/6< .6 C4#F 141/22C E8/75-.6= * 3-87 ) 561/7 >/7 4-.=.6/22C +/.-/6/, 2/6< /6< -834=6.H.6= 1:8 8D1861 49 56/51:4-.H8<3521.0/1.46BC1:8;81.1.468-,79/1:8-/8-1.9.3/18 49 -8=.71-/1.46 >/7 .7758< ;5-75/61 1:8-814 /6< 1:8 6/E8 49 ;81.1.468-,79/1:8->/7<52C8618-8<.61:8-808658-834-<7 :8 ;81.1.468-,7 9/1:8- <.8< 46 )FG))) /6< 1:8 6/E8 49 1:8 ;81.1.468->/7<52CE51/18<.61:8-808658-834-<7;8-1/.6.6= 14 75B@831 2/6< 1 .7 346186<8< 1:/1 B894-8 .775.6= 1:8 8-1.9.3/18 49 -/61 1:8 /:7.2</- 0.<8 34EE56.3/1.46 </18< #GG :/< 745=:1 683877/-C .694-E/1.46 B/78< 46 1:8 -834EE86</1.46 E/<8 BC 1:8 4EE.1188 94- .775/638 49 +, (4-E 14 1:8 1:.-< -87;46<861 B/78< 46 >:.3: 1:8 1:.-< -87;46<8610.<8-8;2C</18<GG=/08644B@831.4694- .775/63849+,(4-E.69/04-491:8B8689.3./-.87 - 4 - :8;81.1.468-346186<71:/1:8>/7.7758<>.1:/641.38 BC1:8499.38491:89.-71-87;46<861B/78<461:8/228=8<-8;4-1 -838.08< BC 1:8 1:.-< -87;46<861 -8=/-<.6= 1:8 /228=8< 863-4/3:E861 /6< 1:8 7/E8 B8.6= 1:8 <88E8< 94-871 /7 1:8 /:7.2</- .</- :/6<8< 408- 1:8 7/.< 2/6< 14 1:8 (4-871 8;/-1E8610.<828118-</18<FGFG/6<1:8-894-8745=:1 14346<531/6.6A5.-C :8;81.1.468-75BE.118</221:8-834-<7 /6< 745=:1 14 <-4; 1:8 ;-4388<.6=7 '4>808- 1:8 1:.-< -87;46<861 9.28< 4B@831.46 -82C.6= 5;46 1:8 2.71 49 +, /6< +, 2/6<7745=:114B81-/6798--8<BC1:8 /:7.2</-.69/04-491:8 (4-871 8;/-1E861 /78< 46 1:8 3461861.467 -/.78< BC 1:8 1:.-< -87;46<861 1:8 77.71/61 4EE.77.468- ;-4388<8< 14 :42<1:/11:8 /:7.2</-:/<64/51:4-.1C14.7758 1:84-<8-49 =-/61 BC 346186<.6= 1:/1 1:8 2/6< B8.6= 2/77 +, /6< +, 563521.0/B282/6</6<1:87/E8>/7:/6<8<408-141:8(4-871 8;/-1E861.6GFG1.7/2744B78-08<1:/11:875B@8312/6< 9/227>.1:.6?E7-/<.5749.</-56.3.;/2.E.17:8638=-/61 E/<8 BC 1:8 /:7.2</- .7 3461-/-C 14 528 %.0& 49 1:8 /-6/1/?//6<-/615287G*G/6<;-4388<8<14:42<1:/1 1:875B@8312/6<.71:8(4-871/6</6<641/808658/6</6< 1:8;-40.7.46749/-6/1/?//6<-/615287/-8641/;;2.3/B28 - 5 - /6< 781/7.<8 1:8 4-<8- 49 /:7.2</- .775.6= (4-E /6< 1:8 7/E8>/73/638228</6<<.-8318<1:/11:82/6<14B8-875E8< /6<08718<.61:8408-6E8619-889-4E/228635EB-/6387BC <.-831.6= 1:8 /:7.2</- 14 E/?8 861-.87 .6 1:8 /7 I(4-871 8;/-1E861 408-6E861 49 /-6/1/?/, .6 :44E. 491>/-8 0.<8 4-<8- </18< )))# 6<8- 1:878 3.-35E71/6387 1:8 ;81.1.468-.7B894-81:.745-1 # 456782 94- 1:8 -87;831.08 ;/-1.87 5-=8< 7808-/2 3461861.467 -=.6= 7808-/2 3461861.467 3456782 94- 1:8 ;81.1.468- ;2/38<-82./638461:8<83.7.46.6 ' ! .6 4))G )) <.7;478< 4946#))) :8 71/18E861 49 4B@831.467 .7 9.28< BC 1:8 408-6E861 -=.6=7808-/23461861.4671:8408-6E861;2/38<-82./63846 1:894224>.6=<83.7.467 & ( ' ! ! ' J ! FGF GG* - 6 - )& ! '!( ' J %!& F GG* ())GG* & ! '!( ' J))F# '8/-< 1:8 /-=5E8617 /6< ;8-578< 1:8 -.1 ;/;8-7 >.1: 3/-8 :8 9/317 /-8 7599.3.8612C 7/.< /6< <4 641 -8A5.-8 -8.18-/1.46 :8.7758-8042087/-456<1:88D8-3.78491:8;4>8- BC 1:8 77.71/61 4EE.77.468- 56<8- 1:8 ;-40.7.467 49 1:8 /-6/1/?//6<80865831G*#599.38.11464181:/11:8 2/6< .6 C4#F E8/75-.6= * 3-87 ) 561/7 7.15/18< /1 521/6;5- % & !.22/=8 >/7 / /.-/6/ 2/6< /6< 1:8 7/E8 >/7 56<8-3521.0/1.464956/51:4-.H8<;8-74676<8-/41.9.3/1.46 4 G </18< GGG 1:8 /:/7.2</- .7758< / 8-1.9.3/1849/=50/2.:.1 1.7/-=58<46B8:/29491:8408-6E8611:/11:82/6<.6 A5871.46.72/77+,/6<+,563521.0/B282/6</6<1:8 /:7.2</- 0.<828118-FGFG1-/6798--8</6<:/6<8<408-1:82/6<14 1:8(4-8718;/-1E8611.7/-=58<46B8:/29491:8;81.1.468- - 7 - 1:/1 1:8 2/6< .6 C4#F .7 68.1:8- / 641.9.8< 64- / -878-08< 94-871 56<8- 831.46 # 49 1:8 (4-871 31 64- .7 .1 / <88E8< 94-871 46 .671-531.46 75BE.17 1:/1 41.9.3/1.46 56<8- 831.46#.7641.7758<.6-87;831492/6<77.15/18</1521/6;5- % &!.22/=8 =-8/1<8/249/-=5E861.7/<<-8778</B4517831.46#49 1:8(4-87131 :8?8C/7;8317491:8/-=5E861/-88D/E.68< 831.46 # 49 1:8 (4-871 31 <8/27 >.1: 641.9.3/1.46 BC 1:8 =408-6E861/6<.1-8/<7/794224>7 831.46#41.9.3/1.46BC408-6E861J%&:86808-.1 :/7B886<83.<8<1434671.1518/6C2/6</-878-08<94-8711:8 1/18408-6E8617:/22.7758/641.9.3/1.46 %/& <832/-.6= 1:/1 .1 :/7 B886<83.<8< 1434671.1518 753:2/6</-878-08<94-871K %B& 7;83.9C.6= /7 68/-2C /7 ;477.B28 1:8 7.15/1.46 /6<2.E.1749753:2/6<K/6< %3& /;;4.61.6= /6 499.38- %:8-8.6/918- 3/228< 1:8 L(4-871 81128E861 99.38-M& 14 .6A5.-8 .614 /6< <818-E.68 1:8 8D.718638 6/15-8 /6< 8D1861 49 /6C -.=:17 32/.E8< BC 4- /228=8< 14 8D.71 .6 - 8 - 9/045- 49 /6C ;8-746 .6 4- 408- /6C 2/6< 34E;-.78< >.1:.6 753: 2.E.17 4- .6 4- 408- /6C 94-871 ;-4<538 /6< 14 <8/2 >.1: 1:8 7/E8 /7 ;-40.<8<.61:.7:/;18- %)& :8 499.38- /;;4.618< 56<8- 32/578 %3& 49 75B 7831.46 %& 7:/22 B8 / ;8-746 641 :42<.6= /6C 94-871 499.38 8D38;1 1:/1 49 (4-871 81128E861 99.38-KB51/(4-87199.38-E/CB8/;;4.618<BC 1:8 1/18 408-6E861 14 -8;-87861 .1 .6 1:8 .6A5.-C 56<8- 1:.7 :/;18- BC 1:8 (4-871 81128E86199.38- :8 408-6E861 :/7 ;2/38< -82./638 46 / 71/18E861 7:4>.6= 1:8 -8E/.6.6= +, /6< +, 2/77 2/6< %408-6E861 /6<& 1-/6798--8< 14 1:8 (4-871 8;/-1E861 49 /25?/ .</- 7.=68< BC 1:8 /:7.2</- 46 FGFG 14 346186< 1:/1 1:8 94-871 2/6< 3452< 641 :/08 B886 =-/618< 14 1:8 ;81.1.468-,7 9/1:8- /=50/2.:.13452<641:/08B886.7758<.6-87;83149/ 94-8712/6< :83461861.46491:8408-6E8611:/1.1,7/94-871 2/6<3/6641B87571/.68</7.1.7;.041/21464181:/11:8(4-871 31:/734E8.61494-38.6G*:4>808-.61:8/B7863849/ - 9 - 641.9.3/1.46 56<8- 831.46 # 49 1:8 /-6/1/?/ (4-871 31 1:8 /:7.2</- /;;8/-7 14 :/08 ;-8;/-8< / 71/18E861 1:/1 1:8 75B@831 2/6< :/7 B886 1-/6798--8< 14 1:8 (4-871 8;/-1E861 88<2877 14 7/C 1:8 (4-871 31 E/6</187 .775/638 49 / 41.9.3/1.4656<8-831.46#7/2-8/<C6418</B4081:8-8.7 64 41.9.3/1.46 56<8- 831.46 # 49 1:8 /-6/1/?/ (4-871 31 G* :8-894-81:83461861.46491:8408-6E8611:/1.1.7/ 94-8712/6<E571683877/-.2C9/.2 * 8D1 281 E8 3467.<8- >:81:8- 1:8 77.71/61 4EE.77.468-3452<:/086522.9.8<1:8(4-E/918-/2/;7849 /2E471 1>861C945- C8/-7 :8 /67>8- .7 64 :8 -8/746 .7 7.E;28 :8 2/> .7 >822 781128< 1:/1 1:8 ;4>8- E571 B8 8D8-3.78<>.1:.6/-8/746/B281.E861:8;-878613/781:8-8 .7/6.64-<.6/18<82/C6EC0.8>1:8;-4388<.6=7/-8328/-2C B/--8<BC2/3:87(5-1:8-E4-81:8408-6E8613452<641:/08 8D8-3.78<;4>8-143/63821:8=-/617461:8=-456<1:/11:8-8 .7 / 0.42/1.46 49 528 49 1:8 /-6/1/?/ /6< 808658 5287 45678294-1:8-87;831.08;/-1.87;2/38<-82./638461:8 <83.7.467 -898--8< 14 75;-/ <4 641 1:.6? 1:/1 1:8 2/> .7 .6 - 10 - <45B1 /3:<83.7.4615-6746.174>69/317 :8;-878613/78.7 /27418718<.61:82.=:1491:8/94-87/.<<83.7.467 (4-1:8-8/746771/18</B4081:84-<8-491:877.71/61 4EE.77.468- .7 2./B28 14 B8 781 /7.<8 334-<.6=2C .1 .7 781 /7.<8 F :8 -.1 49 8-1.4-/-. .7 4-<8-8< :8 -<8- </18< )))# ;/778< BC 1:8 77.71/61 4EE.77.468- .6 (.28 4 ! * )))#0.<8668D5-8 .7A5/7:8< 87521/612C1:8-.181.1.46.7 83/578 49 1:8 <.7;47/2 49 1:8 -.1 81.1.46 ;86<.6= .618-243514-C /;;2.3/1.467 .9 /6C /-8 <.7;478< 49 /6< 1:8 .618-.E<.-831.46.9/6C71/6<7<.73:/-=8< !)* '&"##( & .71424)G