Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 42974 (KAR)
THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER v. MAHANTESH N
WA/200109/2025 · 2025-07-17
K S Hemalekha, Mohammad Nawaz
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 42974 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 42974 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"#"
$ %&# &&&'
%& # &
$$
( ) * +&$$ ,
*
! " #
Digitally signed by KHAJAAMEEN MALAGHAN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$
# %"
$%& #
"
'()*
(
+(,***
"
"
%
'()*
"
'()* ! "
-
# "'
$
., "
)** "
#
*))$*
#
"
,*
$
#
"
$%& #
"
&
'()* ! "
- 3 -
#
$
&
'()* ! "
"
(
'(,*** !"
%
#
'(,*** ! "
# "
&-
#
%
$ $ (
"
$
"
"
"
)'*'*" /
*))$* '
$
&
"#
- 4 -
0# 1
0#
#& 0#
23456789:768;;38<4=;73>3773?@A623B3C:64D3 5E4533785?623858E45E473C697875868F83378D874 4E8G 4G463? 8EE743D3? @A 623 97?37 ?863? )** ;8==3? 45 9*))$* A 623 =84? 97?37 <38753? 45E<3 #:?E3 28= ?473C63? 623 85? CH:4=46495 >>4C37 69 ;8A 623 C9G;35=86495 8G9:56 8= ;3762397?37;8==3?@A623==4=68569GG4==49537?863? *(**I462458;3749?9>62733G9562=>79G623?863 9>97?37
9563G;6 ;3646495 28= @335 >4<3? @A 623 ;36464953745 9*))$*8<<3E45E595'C9G;<485C3 9> 623 97?37 ?863? )** ;8==3? 45 I746 ;3646495 CC97?45E69623C9G;<845856?3=;463623=;3C4>4C?473C6495 4==:3? ?473C645E 623 85? CH:4=46495 >>4C37 69 ;8A 623 C9G;35=86495 45 8CC97?85C3 I462 623 97?37 9> 623
- 5 -
==4=6856 9GG4==49537 ?863? *(** 623 =84? C9G;35=8649528=596A36@335;84? % 387? 623 <38753? 35497 C9:5=3< 748J4D28F?2878;;38745E>976238;;3<<85645623I746 8;;38<85?<38753?C9:5=3<8;;38745E>9762373=;95?356$ C9G;<84585685?;37:=3?623G863748<9573C97? 38753? =35497 C9:5=3< 8;;38745E >97 623 8;;3<<856 @745E= 69 623 5964C3 9> 624= 9:76 6286 623 8;;3<<856 28= C28<<35E3? 623 97?37 9> 623 ==4=6856 9GG4==49537?863?*(**45 9*))$*( 23<38753?45E<3#:?E3@A85456374G97?3728==68A3? >:76237 ;79C33?45E= ;:7=:856 69 623 97?37 ?863? *(** 64<< 623 53B6 ?863 9> 238745E =:@J3C6 69 623 C95?46495 6286 8;;3<<856 ?3;9=46= (*K 9> 623 8G9:56 ?473C63?69@3;84?8=;3762397?37?863?*(**@A 623==4=68569GG4==49537I462458;3749?9>>9:7I33F=
64=623=:@G4==4959>623<38753?=35497C9:5=3<6286623 97?37 ?863? *(** I24C2 >97G= 623 >9:5?86495 >97 623 4G;:E53? 97?37 45 8;;38< 85? 595'C9G;<485C3 45
- 6 -
C9563G;6;36464954=:5?37C28<<35E385?62373>973?33G= 69@3=368=4?3
( 38753? C9:5=3< >97 623 73=;95?356 $ C9G;<845856 =:@G46= 6286 623 8;;3<<856 28D45E >84<3? 69 C28<<35E3 623 ==4=6856 9GG4==49537/= 97?37 ?863? *(**45864G3<AG85537C8559659I=33F3H:468@<3 73<43>6286699I235623C9563G;64=>4<3?>97?4=9@3?435C3 9>6234G;:E53?97?37
L 8D45EC95=4?373?623=:@G4==495=95@962=4?3 I3 >45? 6286 ?473C6495 69 ;8A C9G;35=86495 I8= =9<3<A ;73?4C863? 95 623 97?37 9> ==4=6856 9GG4==49537 ?863? *(** 286 97?37 9> 623 ==4=6856 9GG4==49537 28= 59I @335 C28<<35E3? 45 8 =3;87863 I746 ;3646495 85? 456374G73<43>45623>97G9>=68A28=@335E78563?2:= 8= <95E 8= 623 ==4=6856 9GG4==49537/= 97?37 4= :5?37 J:?4C48< =C7:645A 45 9*))$*( 85? =68A3? 623 4G;:E53?97?37><9I45E>79G46C85596@335>97C3? 5623 =84? C47C:G=685C3= 4G;:E53? 97?37 45 I746 8;;38< 28= 69 @3 =36 8=4?3 85? G8?3 =:@J3C6 69 >458< 9:6 C9G3 9> 623
- 7 -
9*))$*( 85? C9563G;6 ;3646495 8<<3E45E ?4=9@3?435C3 I9:<?
596 =:7D4D3 >97 623 ;73=356 CC97?45E<AI3;8==623>9<<9I45E
i) 7468;;38<4= ii) 23 4G;:E53? 97?37 ?863? )** 45 9*))$* 4= =:@J3C6 69 >458< 9:6 C9G3 9> 9*))$*( iii) 23 C9563G;6 ;3646495 4= 2373@A
35?45E
= 4> 85A ?93= 596 =:7D4D3 >97 C95=4?3786495
-* (&&&') #
-* ( &) #
4=69<9* #