- 1 - !"# $% "" &'( )* "" ) * ! " # $$ # $$ % & # ' $()#(*) # % " ! Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # "'"! % "*""+ )"#"' % ) * # $$ , # $$ % (*-,"" ! " & # + $()#(*)# % *-,"" " ! - 3 - # "'"! ! )"#"' ! "*""+ )"#"' ""+,#( ) "*#(" % . / $ $ % / $ $! " 0121 3441352 36721 89: 8; :01 9<=>1?: 3?< @36< <3:1<"*""+43221<7? 8)"8;"'AB:01 5136?1< 7?=29=96;862086:C:0167A9?35.! 671; ;3D:2 513<7?= 6721 :8 :01 ;757?= 8; :0121 3441352 36132;8558@2 - 4 - ? ',") 3: 3A89: + 3> @0751 :01 41:7:78?16@3261:96?7?=:8016E7553=13;:163::1?<7?= 3 ;9?D:78? 3: >36120@363 1>451 7? 3? 9:8( 67DF203@ A1367?= 61=72:63:78? 8$()#(")+* :01 <67E168;:0139:8(67DF203@<68E1:0123>17?36320 3?<?1=57=1?:>3??163?<582:D8?:6858E16:0139:8( 67DF203@ 3?< :01 39:8 :96:51 <8@? 2 3 61295: :01 41:7:78?16 292:37?1< =671E892 7?G96712 092 :01 41:7:78?16 ;751< 3 D537> 41:7:78? 9?<16 1D:78? ")) 8; :01 8:86 107D512 D: "+-- 211F7?= D8>41?23:78? 8?3DD89?:8;:017?G96712292:37?1<7?:01683<:63;;7D 3DD7<1?: , 8:7D1 @32 72291< :8 :01 8@?16 8; :01 8;;1?<7?= E107D511247:1216E7D18;?8:7D1:018@?1661>37?1< 9?6146121?:1<3?<@32453D1< * 01 ?2963?D1 8>43?B ;751< 3 2:3:1>1?: 8; 8AG1D:78?2 <1?B7?= :01 3E16>1?:2 >3<1 7? :01 D537> 41:7:78?3?<D8?:1?<1<:03::01<67E168;:018;;1?<7?= E107D51 <7< ?8: 4822122 3 E357< 3?< 1;;1D:7E1 <67E7?= - 5 - 57D1?D1 3: :01 :7>1 8; 3DD7<1?: 0161 72 3 A613D0 8; 4857DB D8?<7:78?2 1?D1 463B2 :8 <72>722 :01 D537> 41:7:78?3=37?2::017?2963?D1D8>43?B ) 01 67A9?35 A321< 8? :01 4513<7?=2 8; :01 436:712 ;63>1<:016151E3?:722912 ' 01 41:7:78?16 :8 29A2:3?:73:1 016 D321 1H3>7?1< 016215; 32 (" 3?< >36F1< ",) <8D9>1?:2 32 H07A7:2(":8(",) - 011=78?3563?2486:;;7D16@321H3>7?1<32( "1H3>7?1<8?1@7:?12232(:011=35;;7D168; :01 ?2963?D1 8>43?B @32 1H3>7?1< 32 ( 3?< >36F1<+<8D9>1?:232H07A7:2(":8(+ + 01 67A9?35 3;:16 3221227?= :01 E16A35 3?< <8D9>1?:36B 1E7<1?D1 3558@1< :01 D537> 41:7:78? 7? 436: 3?< 3@36<1< 3 D8>41?23:78? 8; I""+,#( @7:0 7?:1612: 3: :01 63:1 8; +J 416 3??9> ;68> :01 <3:1 8; ;757?= :01 41:7:78? :755 :01 61357K3:78? 8; :01 3>89?: 3?< <761D:1< :01 7?2963?D1 D8>43?B :8 - 6 - <14827: :01 D8>41?23:78? 3>89?: 3?< 61D8E16 :01 23>1;68>:018@?168;:018;;1?<7?=E107D51 " 01 ?2963?D1 8>43?B 3==671E1< AB :01 <761D:78? 72291< AB :01 67A9?35 :8 43B 3?< 61D8E16 :01 D8>41?23:78? 3>89?: ;68> :01 8@?16 032 ;751< :01 344135 7? 8)* 8; 3?< :01 41:7:78?16 A17?= <7223:72;71< @7:0 :01 L93?:9> 8; D8>41?23:78? 3@36<1< AB :01 67A9?35 ;751< 344135 7? 8,*)8; "" 136<:015136?1<D89?215;86:017?2963?D1D8>43?B 3?<:015136?1<D89?215;86:0141:7:78?16 " 136?1< D89?215 ;86 :01 7?2963?D1 D8>43?B 29A>7:2 :03::0167A9?35@7:089:468E7<7?=:0184486:9?7:B:8 513< :01 8635 3?< <8D9>1?:36B 1E7<1?D1 43221< :01 7>49=?1< G9<=>1?: 7? 3 >1D03?7D35 >3??16 @07D0 032 51< :8 =6822 >72D36673=1 8; G92:7D1 1 3528 29A>7:2 :03: :0161 @161 >861 43221?=162 :63E157?= :03? :01 416>7227A51 213:7?= D343D7:B 8; 39:8( - 7 - 67DF203@ 8618E16 :01 <67E16 8; :01 39:8 03< ?8 E357<57D1?21:8<67E13D8>>16D735E107D511?D18? :0121 =689?<2 01 463B2 :8 3558@ :01 344135 ;751< AB :017?2963?D1D8>43?B3?<:8<72>722:01344135;751< AB:0141:7:78?16 " 5136?1<D89?215;86:0141:7:78?1629A>7:2 :03::01D8>41?23:78?3@36<1<AB:0167A9?35728? :01 58@16 27<1 3?< 01 29A>7:2 :03: :01 67A9?35 032 67=0:5B ;32:1?1< :01 573A757:B 8? :01 ?2963?D1 8>43?B1?D101463B2:8<72>722:01344135;751< AB :01 7?2963?D1 D8>43?B 3?< :8 3558@ :01 344135 ;751<AB:0141:7:78?16 ", 16921<:0161D86<23?<D8?27<161<:0129A>72278?28; :015136?1<D89?215;86:01436:712 "* 01 487?:2 :03: @895< 36721 ;86 D8?27<163:78? 361 61=36<7?=:01573A757:B3?<L93?:9>8;D8>41?23:78? ") 0161 72 ?8 <7249:1 61=36<7?= :01 8DD9661?D1 8; 3DD7<1?:3?<7?G96712292:37?1<AB:0141:7:78?167?:01 - 8 - 237<683<:63;;7D3DD7<1?:8DD9661<8?',")8 468E1 :03: :01 3DD7<1?: 8DD9661< <91 :8 6320 3?< ?1=57=1?: <67E7?= AB :01 <67E16 8; :01 8;;1?<7?= E107D51:0141:7:78?16032468<9D1<:01D036=1(2011: >36F1<32H07A7:2(3?<@07D0<72D5821:03::01 3DD7<1?:8DD9661<<91:863203?<?1=57=1?:<67E7?=AB :01 <67E16 8; :01 39:8(67DF203@ 1?D1 :01 67A9?35 @32G92:7;71<7?61D86<7?=7:2;7?<7?=:03::0141:7:78?16 032 292:37?1< 7?G96712 <91 :8 3D:78?3A51 ?1=57=1?: <67E7?= 8; :01 39:8 A1367?= 61=72:63:78? 8$()#( ")+*AB7:2<67E167?3683<:63;;7D3DD7<1?:@07D0:88F 453D1 8? ',") <8 ?8: ;7?< 3?B 16686 7? :01 ;7?<7?=261D86<1<AB:0167A9?358?22918"3?< D8?D96 @7:0 :01 ;7?<7?=2 61D86<1< AB :01 67A9?35 8? 22918" +,-./-0-12 "' 017?2963?D1D8>43?B032D8?:1?<1<:03::0139:8( 67DF203@ @32 45B7?= 89:27<1 :01 416>7: 57>7: 3?< 7? 86<16 :8 29A2:3?:73:1 :01 237< D8?:1?:78? 7: 032 - 9 - 468<9D1< :01 036=1(2011: @07D0 <72D58212 :03: :01 E107D51@3245B7?=89:27<1:01416>7:57>7: "- 8@1E16 :01 67A9?35 453D7?= 61573?D1 8? :01 G9<=>1?:28;:018?/A5141H 896:3?<:072 896:7? 21E1635 D3212 032 015< :03: :01 8@?16 8; :01 39:8( 67DF203@ 032 E7853:1< :01 4857DB D8?<7:78?2 01 67A9?35D8?27<167?=:014684827:78?537<<8@?AB:072 896: 32 @155 32 AB :01 8?/A51 41H 896: 032 61D86<1<7:2;7?<7?=:03:328;:01<3:18;3DD7<1?::01 8;;1?<7?= E107D51 @32 7?2961< @7:0 :01 7?2963?D1 D8>43?B3?<3229D0:017?2963?D1D8>43?B72573A51 :8 7?<1>?7;B :01 8@?16 3=37?2: :01 :076< 436:B AB <14827:7?= 86 43B7?= :01 D8>41?23:78? 3>89?: 3?< :01613;:16 61D8E16 :01 23>1 ;68> :01 8@?16 8; :01 39:8(67DF203@ "+ 0167A9?3503267=0:5B61D86<1<7:2;7?<7?=61=36<7?= :01573A757:B8?:01=689?<:03::0139:8(67DF203@03< ?8416>7:3::01:7>18;:01DD7<1?: - 10 - <8?8:;7?<3?B166867?:01;7?<7?=261D86<1<AB:01 67A9?35 <761D:7?= :01 7?2963?D1 D8>43?B :8 43B 3?< 61D8E16:013>89?:8;D8>41?23:78? +,34.514667+58.1-5 " 0167A9?35D8?27<167?=:013=18;:0141:7:78?163?< 3528 016 7?D8>1 32 416 :01 D036: ?8:7;71< AB :01 $36?3:3F3 1=35 16E7D1 9:0867:B 032 :3F1? :01 ?8:78?357?D8>13?<3528:01<723A757:B3221221<AB:01 <8D:863?<03267=0:5B3@36<1<:01D8>41?23:78?01 D8>41?23:78? 3@36<1< AB :01 67A9?35 72 G92: 3?< 468416 <8 ?8: ;7?< 3?B =689?<2 :8 1?03?D1 :01 D8>41?23:78? ?E71@8;:013A8E1<72D92278?468D11<:84322:01 ;8558@7?=86<16 ! 01 72D1553?1892762:441352361 - 11 - ! 01 7>49=?1< G9<=>1?: 3?< 3@36< 43221< AB :01 67A9?35 72 0161ABD8?;76>1< ! 011=72:6B72<761D:1<:8:63?2;16 :01 3>89?: 7? <14827: 3?< :01 6735 896:1D86<:8:0167A9?35 ;86:0@7:0 9) &( % $ 72:8" 58"