- 1 - !"# $#%## #"" &' &(")* &)) + ! " # $%&%!' # # $%&%!' Digitally signed by RAMESH MATHAPATI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( %&%!' # !) " # ( #(*+ # $ , # # -. ,# $ (+'' (!'' !&'!'( " # +%' # / # '! # # ," -, %# -, 01233144256718592::;<1=8531:824 2<1 >(!'' >5 601 ?841 >? 601 412@51= ==868>524 8<6@8:6 25= 1<<8>5< ,;=91 . # $ 2427;@298 01@1852?61@ @1?1@@1= 6> 2< A@824 >;@6B 8< 8C3;95859 601 D;=9C156 >? :>5E8:68>5 =261= !&'!'( 25= >@=1@ >? - 3 - <15615:1=261=('!'(:>5E8:685908C?>@601>??15:1 3;58<02741 ;5=1@ 1:68>5< (*/85 +%' >? 25= 1:68>5 / >? 601 @>61:68>5 >? 084=@15 ?@>C 1F;24 ??15:1<2:6'!?>@<0>@6A B25=<15615:8596> ;5=1@9>@89>@>;<8C3@8<>5C156?>@60131@8>=>?'G12@< 25=6>32G?851>?<''''$?>@601>??15:13;58<02741 ;5=1@ 1:68>5 / >? :6) <15615:859 6> ;5=1@9> 8C3@8<>5C156 ?>@ ( 60@11 G12@< 25= 6> 32G 2 ?851 >? <%'''$?>@601>??15:13;58<02741;5=1@1:68>5+%'>? H860=1?2;46<15615:1 #2:6< >? 601 :2<1 85 7@81? 2@1 6026 "!$601 E8:68C98@44>=91=601?8@<685?>@C268>52<31@F !29285<6 6012::;<1=24419859:>CC8<<8>5>?601>??15:13;58<02741 ;5=1@1:68>5<(*/85++&>? 25=1:68>5<+/ 25=!>?601 :6 560172<8<>?601<2C1601 #:2C16>71@198<61@1=85E1<689268>5H2<;5=1@62I15 ?61@ :>C34168>5 >? 601 85E1<689268>5 :02@91 <0116 :2C1 6>71?841=01412@51=298<6@2616>>I:>958J25:1>?601 27>E1 <28= >??15:1 25= <;CC>51= 601 2::;<1= 01 - 4 - 2::;<1= 23312@1= 71?>@1 601 @824 >;@6 3412=1= 5>6 9;846G25=:428C1=6>716@81= ( > 3@>E1 601 9;846 >? 601 2::;<1= 601 3@><1:;68>51F2C851= "<!6>!9>6C2@I1=F< !6> &25=8=1568?81= <!6>!'85<;33>@6>?86<:>561568>5 08< 2::;<1= 02< =1581= 244 601 85:@8C8526859 C261@824< 2E2842741>5@1:>@=8508<<6261C156;5=1@1:68>5(!(>? @ 7;60102<5>641=25G1E8=15:185<;33>@6>?08< =1?15:1 >H1E1@ 01 9>6 C2@I1= F<! 6> K =;@859 :@><<$1F2C85268>5>?6013@><1:;68>5H8651<<1< + ?61@ 62I859 856> :>5<8=1@268>5 244 601<1 C261@824<>5@1:>@=601@824 >;@6:2C16>601:>5:4;<8>5 6026 601 3@><1:;68>5 8< <;::1<<?;4 85 3@>E859 601 9;846 >? 2::;<1= 71G>5= @12<>52741 =>;76 25= 2::>@=8594G 601 2::;<1= :>5E8:61= 25= <15615:1= 2< <6261= 27>E1 1859 299@81E1=7G601<2C16012::;<1=8<71?>@1608< >;@6 % 12@=@8202561<01<28412@51=:>;5<14?>@ 601 233144256 @8 >324 @8<052 2=2E 412@51= 890 >;@6 >E1@5C156 412=1@ ?>@ 601 @1<3>5=156 >!$6261 - 5 - 25=@82E8011C<8590 02H25412@51=:>;5<14?>@601 @1<3>5=156 >< 25= ( 1@;<1= 601 C261@824< 85:4;=859 601@824 >;@6@1:>@=< / 5 E81H >? 601 @8E24 :>561568>5< ;@91= 7G 412@51=:>;5<14?>@7>6060132@681<6013>8566026H>;4= 2@8<1?>@CG:>5<8=1@268>58< * G 25<H1@ 6> 601 27>E1 3>856 8< 85 ?>@601?>44>H859 & 68<601:>561568>5>?6013@><1:;68>56026601 85?>@C256$ "! 8< 601 E8:68C 98@4 291= 716H115 !+ 6> !* G12@<25=6012::;<1=:@8C85244G6@1<32<<1=856>01@0>;<1 =;@859 12@4G C>@5859 >5 !%'('' :>CC8661= 601 - 6 - 31516@268E1 <1F;24 2<<2;46 25= 601@17G :>CC8661= 601 >??15:1<2<<6261=27>E1::>@=8596>60185?>@C2566026 H2< 5>6 601 ?8@<6 68C1 H015 601 2::;<1= :2C1 6> 601 0>;<125=:>CC8661=601>??15:17;6>@(68C1<12@481@ 6>601=261>?601?8@<685?>@C268>56012::;<1=02=:2C1 6> 01@ 0>;<1 25= :>CC8661= 31516@268E1 <1F;24 2<<2;46 @131261=4G>H1E1@601E8:68C98@402<5>6@1E1241=608< ?2:66>01@32@156< 560112@4GC>@5859>5!%'('' H0156012::;<1=H2<H860601E8:68C98@48501@@>>C601 C>601@ >? 601 E8:68C 98@4 012@= <>C1 5>8<1 :2C1 6> 01@ @>>C 25= <2H 601 2::;<1= 01 :2;906 0>4= >? 601 2::;<1= 25= 85 601 C12568C1 601 >601@ 31@<>5< 02E1 92601@1= 25= 2<<2;461= 601 2::;<1= 5 601 ?8@<6 85?>@C268>5 601 85?>@C256 <31:8?8:244G <6261= 6026 71?>@1 601 =261 >? 601 85:8=156 601 2::;<1= 02= :>CC8661= 31516@268E1<1F;242<<2;46?>@:874G27>;6+6>%68C18501@ >H50>;<1 K "! 8< 601 =>:6>@ H0> 1F2C851= 601 E8:68C 98@4 25= 8<<;1= 601 C1=8:24 :1@68?8:261 2< 31@ F ! < - 7 - 31@ 608< =>:;C156 E8:68C 98@4 H2< 1F2C851= >5 !%'(''26%''3C6>!/'(''6844!('3C01 #H2<@198<61@1=>5!%'(''26!('3C27>;6601 85:8=156602602=>::;@@1=>5601<2C1=2G26+''2C < 31@ F ! >5 1F2C85268>5 >? 601 E8:68C 98@4 86 8< 5>68:1=6026601@1H2<<1F;248561@:>;@<127>;660@11=2G< 72:I01E8:68C98@402<<6261=6026<01H2<<;7D1:61=6> <1F;24 2<<2;46 85 01@ 0>;<1 85 60112@4G 0>;@< ?>@>@ ( 68C1< 7;6 <01 02< 51E1@ =8<:4><1= 601 52C1 >? 601 2::;<1= 71?>@1 601 1=8:24 >??8:1@ > 1F61@524 85D;@81< H1@1 ?>;5= >5 601 3@8E261 32@6< >H1E1@ 6>@5 >4= 25= 01241=0GC15H2<5>68:1= !' <31@6012=8>4>98<6@13>@6601E8:68C98@4H2< 291= 716H115 !+ 6> !* G12@< < 31@ 601 # @13>@6 5> 74>>= <6285< <1C8524 <6285< <31@C26>J>2 E298524 <1:@168>5H1@1=161:61=8525G>?6012@68:41<1F2C851= !! "K 8< 601 C>601@ >? 601 E8:68C 98@4 01 <31:8?8:244G<6261=6026601E8:68C98@4;<1=6><41138501@ @>>C 7;6 <01 ;<1= 6> I113 601 C285 =>>@ >315 6 8< - 8 - <6261=6026>5601=261>?60185:8=156<01012@=6015>8<1 ?@>C 601 @>>C >? 601 E8:68C 25= 601@1?>@1 <01 H>I1 ;3 25=9>516>601@>>C>?601E8:68C "$H0>8<?2601@>? 601 E8:68C 98@4 H0> 24<> =13><1= 27>;6 601 85:8=156 I113859 601 =>>@ >? 08< 0>;<1 >315 25= 2::;<1= ?>;5= 85<8=1601@>>C ! 68<31@6851566>5>6160266012::;<1=8<291= !KG12@<E1560>;902<31@601<:0>>4@1:>@=<3@>=;:1= 7G "!( 601 =261 >? 78@60 >? 601 E8:68C 98@4 8< '!'/''%<31@6012=8>4>98<6>3858>5<01H2<291= !+6>!*G12@<01C261@824<>5@1:>@==8<:4><1<6026601 2::;<1=25=601E8:68C98@4H1@1?>;5=85<8=101@@>>C85 6010>;<18560112@4GC>@5859>5!%'(''01E8:68C 98@4<6261<602686H2<5>6601?8@<668C16012::;<1=02= :2C1 6> 01@ 0>;<1 25= :>CC8661= 31516@268E1 <1F;24 2<<2;46 7;6 0102= :2C1 12@481@ 27>;6 ( 6> + 68C1< 25= :>CC8661= <8C842@ 2:6< >H1E1@ <01 02< 5>6 @1E1241= 608<?2:61E156>01@32@156<::>@=8596>601E8:68C>;6 >??12@<0102=5>685?>@C1=608<?2:601:>561568>56026 - 9 - 601 2::;<1= 02= :@8C85244G 8568C8=261= 01@ 25= 601@1?>@1 601 E8:68C 02= 5>6 85?>@C1= 27>;6 601 85:8=156 6> 01@ 32@156<:255>6712::1361= !( 01 E8:68C 98@4 I113859 >315 601 =>>@ >? 601 0>;<1 25= 244>H859 601 2::;<1= 85<8=1@ 01@ @>>C =;@859 58906 0>;@< 6026 6>> <1E1@24 68C1< 98E1< 2 =8??1@156 >3858>5 27>;6 6018@ @14268>5<083 E15 60>;90 601 E8:68C 98@4H2<2:084=H0>H2<291=27>;6!+6>!*G12@<601 2::;<1= H2< 24<> 2 6115291@ 291= !& 6> !K G12@< ? 244 601<1 ?2:6< 25= :8@:;C<625:1< 2@1 62I15 856> :>5<8=1@268>5 86 :>;4= 71 @12<>5274G :>5:4;=1= 6026 601 E8:68C 98@4 25= 601 2::;<1= H1@1 02E859 :>5<15<;24 @14268>5<08325=601E8:68C98@402=51E1@>7D1:61=?>@601 <2C1 54G>5601=261>?60185:8=156H015601C>601@ >? 601 E8:68C 98@4 5>68:1= 601 2::;<1= 85<8=1 601 @>>C >? 601E8:68C25=02=71261508C601E8:68C98@44>=91=601 ?8@<685?>@C268>52<31@F !026C2G712@12<>5H0G 601E8:68C02<5>6=8<:4><1=60152C1>?6012::;<1=1E15 71?>@1 "!$6011=8:24 ??8:1@H0>1F2C851=01@ - 10 - !+ 6 8< 24<> 31@685156 6> 5>61 6026 601 E8:68C 98@4 714>59< 6> 85=; :>CC;586G H0841 601 2::;<1= 8< 2 ;<48C25=6026C2G71>51>?601@12<>5<?>@601E8:68C 98@4?>@5>6@1E12485960185:8=1566>01@32@156<01342:1 >?85:8=15625=601?@1L;15:GH860H08:06012::;<1=;<1= 6> :>C1 6> 601 0>;<1 >? 601 E8:68C 25= :>CC8661= 601 >??15:1@28<1<@12<>52741=>;7627>;6601:2<1C2=1>;6 7G6013@><1:;68>5E1560>;9086:255>671<28=6026601 E8:68C 98@4 :>;4= 98E1 :>5<156 ?>@ :>CC8<<8>5 >? <;:0 >??15:1 <85:1 601 E8:68C 98@4 25= 601 2::;<1= H1@1 6115291@<02E859<;??8:8156C26;@86G6012:6244191=C;<6 71 :>5<15<;24 2:6 ?>@ H08:0 >54G 601 2::;<1= :255>6 71 014=@1<3>5<8741 !% 012::;<1=H0>8<?>;5=9;846G>?601>??15:1 ;5=1@ 1:68>5 / >? :6 :>;4= 71 <15615:1= 6> ;5=1@9> 8C3@8<>5C156 ?>@ 48?1 H08:0 <0244 C125 8C3@8<>5C156 ?>@ 601 @1C285=1@ >? 526;@24 48?1 >? 6026 31@<>525=<024424<>714827416>?851>@1E15H860=1260 - 11 - !/ >>I859 6> 601 <1E1@86G >? 601 3;58<0C156 3@>E8=1= ;5=1@ 1:68>5 / >? 601 :6 601 @1<3>5<878486G>56013@><1:;68>56>3@>E16019;846>?601 2::;<1= H844 24<> 71 1L;244G C>@1 5 601 3@1<156 :2<1 1E1560>;906013@><1:;68>58<<;::1<<?;4853@>E8596026 601 2::;<1= H2< ?>;5= 85<8=1 601 @>>C >? 601 E8:68C 98@4 >5 601 =261 >? 601 85:8=156 26 27>;6 %'' 2C 25= 1E15 60>;90868<?>;5=6026601E8:68C98@4291=716H115!+6> !*G12@<H2<<;7D1:61=6>31516@268E1<1F;242<<2;46?>@( >@+68C1<7G6012::;<1=@28<1<<1@8>;<=>;7627>;6601 :2<1 C2=1 >;6 7G 601 3@><1:;68>5 @192@=859 601 9;846 >? 6012::;<1= 2<01 H2< 02@=4G!K G12@< >5<8=1@859 601 ?2:66026601E8:68C25=6012::;<1=H1@115>;90C26;@86G 25=H1@11L;2432@651@<856012:6244191=6@126859 "! 2< E8:68C 25= 601 233144256 2< 2::;<1= :255>6 71 2::1361=5=1@<;:0:8@:;C<625:1<6017151?86>?=>;76 :>;4=711F615=1=6>6012::;<1=15:1018<1568641=?>@ 2:L;86624 - 12 - !* 02E19>5160@>;906018C3;951=D;=9C156>? :>5E8:68>525=>@=1@>?<15615:132<<1=7G601@824 >;@6 01 @824 >;@6 02< 5>6 62I15 856> :>5<8=1@268>5 25G >? 601<1 ?2:6< 25= 3@>:11=1= 6> :>5E8:6 601 2::;<1= >5 601 72<8<>?601E1@<8>5>? "!H08:08<844192425=31@E1@<1 ?>@601=8<:;<<8>5<C2=127>E1 !& 5E81H>?60127>E12C>?601>3858>56026 601 8C3;951= D;=9C156 >? :>5E8:68>5 25= >@=1@ >? <15615:132<<1=7G601@824 >;@68<4827416>71<162<8=1 ::>@=8594G 25<H1@ 601 27>E1 3>856 85 601 25=3@>:11=6>32<<601?>44>H859 8 01 @8C8524331248< 88 01 8C3;951= D;=9C156 >? :>5E8:68>5 =261= !&'!'( 25= >@=1@ >? 15615:1 =261= ('!'( 32<<1= 85 31:824 2<1 >(!''>5601?841>?412@51= ==868>524 8<6@8:6 25= 1<<8>5< ,;=91 . # $ 2427;@298:>5E8:6859601 2331442562::;<1= ?>@ 601 >??15:1 - 13 - 3;58<02741 ;5=1@ 1:68>5< (*/85 +%' >? 25= 1:68>5 / >? 601 :68<01@17G<162<8=1 888 >5<1L;1564G2::;<1=8<2:L;8661=?>@601 >??15:1 3;58<02741 ;5=1@ 1:68>5 (*/85+%'>? 25=1:68>5/>? 601 :6 8E 2847>5=>?6012::;<1=8?25G25=6026 >?08<<;@1681<<0244<625=<:25:1441= E #8512C>;568?25G=13><861=7G2::;<1= 8< >@=1@1= 6> 71 @1?;5=1= 6> 08C 2?61@ 233124 31@8>= 8< >E1@ >5 =;1 8=1568?8:268>5 198<6@G 6> <15=72:I 601 @824 >;@6 1:>@=< 24>59 H860:>3G>?608<D;=9C156?>@85?>@C268>525=?>@511=?;4 2:68>5 ,* &##) % 8<6>!4>%