- 1 - ! "!#! ! $ %&!!! $ %&!% '!!( !"#$% $& ! !"#$% ' ( ( ( "$%%% ' ( ) $& * ( ( +%, ,,%, ( ) ) * ( -$+%, %+%, ( # ) ! Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - .(/ ) 0(! 0(! 0(! 123 45626278 23 9: 615 ;83;<<533=;> -44>2<-86 95=7?5 615-?8-6-@-6-65AB28236?-62C5?29;8->-6->-9;?-D2 =7? 317?6 .615 ?29;8->/ 28 44>2<-6278 7,,%, <->>28D 28 E;536278 615 7?A5? A-65A +%, F15?59: 615 ?29;8-> 1-3 A5<>285A 67 5865?6-28 615 -44>2<-6278 78 615 D?7;8A 61-6 617;D1 615 6?-83=5? 7?A5? 23 4?5B-6;?5 615 -44>2<-86 =-2>5A 67 ?547?6 67 615 4>-<5 7= 6?-83=5? -3 3;<1 615 -44>2<-86 1-3 =-2>5A 67 B-@5 7;6 - <-35 7= 1-?A3124 5-?A ?2 ;>544- 5?77? >5-?85A <7;835> =7? 615 456262785? -8A B6 -:- >5-?85A 2D1 7;?6 7C5?8B586>5-A5?=7?615?53478A5866-65 - 3 - G (?25=7;6>2857==-<63>5-A28D67=2>28D7=6123F?26 45626278-?5-3;8A5? 15-44>2<-86F-36?-83=5??5A676154?53586473628D 78%,%+%GC2A5885H;?5)12>515F-335?C28D28 615 3-2A 473628D 9: -8 7?A5? A-65A %+%, 15 F-3 6?-83=5??5A=?7B6154?53586473628D67-2<1;?123F-3 <->>5A28E;53627828615-44>2<-627895=7?5615?29;8->78 6154?5B23561-6-345?615D;2A5>2853A-65A%$%, 159528D ?7;45B4>7:551-3D766F7:5-?37=65?B28 6154?53586473628D15?29;8->-64-D57$<78628;5A 4-?-D?-41 7& 7= 263 7?A5? 36-653 61-6 617;D1 26 23 - 4?5B-6;?56?-83=5?7=615-44>2<-869;6151-39558D2C58 473628D67-C-<-864>-<5-6-2<1;?-=65?-<<7BB7A-628D 615 4?7B7655 28 615 4>-<5 7= 615 -44>2<-86 9: 5H5?<2328D 47F5?3 <78=5??5A ;8A5? 615 -97C5 3-2A <>-;35 28<5 15 1-3 876 ?547?65A 67 615 A;6: 615 ?29;8-> F-3 7= 615 7428278 61-6 615 -44>2<-86 1-3 876 B-A5 7;6 - <-35 -8A =-2>5A 67 B-@5 7;6 - <-35 7= 1-?A3124 -8A A5<>285A 67 2865?=5?5 4>-<28D ?5>2-8<5 78 615 I;ADB586 7= 615 78/9>5 - 4 - 45H 7;?6 28 615 <-35 7= ?547?65A28 , ?2 ;>544- 5?77? >5-?85A <7;835> =7? 615 456262785? 3;9B263 61-6 -3 45? 615 6?-83=5? D;2A5>2853 15 1-3D766F7:5-?37=65?B7=35?C2<5286154?535864>-<5 473628D 328<5 15 F-3 4>-<5A 28 615 4?53586 473628D 78 %,%+%G 615 2BB5A2-65 7?A5? A-65A %+%, F-3 F2612861565?B7=6F7:5-?3-8A1269:6?-83=5?D;2A5>2853 A-65A%$%,17;D1615?29;8->1-37935?C5A61-6 6156?-83=5?234?5B-6;?59;6=7?615?5-37861-6151-3 876 ?547?65A 67 A;6: 67 C-<-86 4736 67 F12<1 15 F-3 47365A A5<>285A 67 D?-86 615 ?5>25= -8A A23B2335A 615 -44>2<-6278 1->>58D28D 61-6 7?A5? 15 23 28 6123 F?26 45626278 123 7;?6 =28A28D - <-35 D?-865A 2865?2B 7?A5? -8A 615 3-B5 23 <78628;5A 62>> 6123 A-: <<7?A28D>:1537;D1667->>7F61545626278-8A6745?B26 12B 67 <78628;5 28 615 4?53586 473628D 62>> %,%+% -3 45?6156?-83=5?D;2A5>2853 - 5 - 5=;628D6153;9B2332787=615>5-?85A<7;835> -445-?28D=7?615456262785?B6-:->5-?85A2D1 7;?6 7C5?8B586 >5-A5? -445-?28D =7? 615 ?53478A586 6-65F261->>C515B58<53;9B2665A61-661578/9>545H 7;?628 <-353;4?-1-3B-A526<>5-?61-6615 D7C5?8B58635?C-86<-8876A23795:6156?-83=5?7?A5?9: 876?547?628D-66154>-<57=473628D 623123A;6:=2?3667 ?547?667615A;6:-8A2=1523-DD?25C5A9:6157?A5?15 1-367<1->>58D56157?A5?9:B-@28D-?54?53586-62787? -44?7-<128D6157;?6 86123<-35617;D115F-3317F8 -C-<-86473628D28-2<1;?15=-2>5A67?547?667615A;6: 33;<1615?29;8->4>-<28D?5>2-8<578615I;ADB5867= 615 78/9>5 45H 7;?6 28 615 <-35 7= 3;4?- A5<>285A 67 D?-86 -8: ?5>25= F12<1 A753 876 <->> =7? -8: 2865?=5?58<5 -6 615 1-8A3 7= 6123 7;?6 -8A 37;D16 67 A23B23361545626278 $ -C28D15-?A615>5-?85A<7;835>-445-?28D=7? 9761 615 4-?6253 -8A 1-C28D 45?;35A 615 5862?5 F?26 - 6 - 45626278 4-45?3 615 78>: 47286 F12<1 -?2353 =7? 7;? <7832A5?-627823 !"#$# $# %&'( )' $ (*$ (( +$#($ $#$$# $ *'( $,*$# $ $ $* $+ - .$# + $#+ +#$#- $ $ $# # $# '$ /'.0 & ;?-83F5?67615-97C547286=7?<7832A5?-6278 23 28 85D-62C5-8A 28 =-C7;? 7=615456262785? -8A-D-2836 6156-65=7?615=7>>7F28D?5-3783 # AB2665A>: 615 456262785? F-3 47365A 67 615 4?53586 473628D 9: 7?A5? A-65A %,%+%G -6 885H;?5 F26128-34-87=785:5-?9:7?A5?A-65A%+%, 615 -44>2<-86 F-3 47365A 67 -87615?4>-<5 -6 -2<1;? 3 45?6156?-83=5?D;2A5>2853A-65A%$%,61565?B7= 615 7==2<5 67 615 4?53586 473628D 23 6F7 :5-?3 328<5 615 -44>2<-8623- ?7;45B4>7:5517;D1615?29;8->1-3 7935?C5A 61-6 615 6?-83=5? 23 4?5B-6;?5 785 9;6 =7? 615 ?5-37861-6151-3876?547?65A676156?-83=5??5A4>-<5 - 7 - A5<>285A67D?-86-8:?5>25=7A7;96-345?615I;ADB586 7=61578/9>545H7;?628615<-357=3;4?- 61545?3787;D16671-C5?547?65A67615A;6:-6=2?36-8A <7;>A1-C5B-A5-8:<1->>58D52=1523-DD?25C5A9:-8: 7?A5?7=6?-83=5?9:B-@28D-?54?53586-62787?9:=2>28D -8: -44>2<-6278 -44?7-<128D6157;?67= >-F (;628 615 <-35781-8A61578>:?5-378=7??5I5<628D615-44>2<-6278 23 15 1-3 876 ?547?65A 67 615 A;6: 123 7;?6 1-C28D <7832A5?5A 615 <-35 7= 615 456262785? =28A28D <-35 D?-865A 2865?2B 7?A5? -8A 615 3-B5 23 <78628;28D 15 456262785? 1-3 35?C5A 28 615 4?53586 473628D ->B736 61565?B7=35?C2<51565?B7=6F7:5-?3F7;>A<7B4>565 78 %,%+% 8 615 =-<63 -8A <2?<;B36-8<53 7= 615 <-35F5A55B26-44?74?2-6567<78628;5615456262785?28 6154?53586473628D62>>%,%+% + 8 C25F 7= 615 ?5-3783 36-65A 3;4?- 328<5 615 85H6 6?-83=5? 7?A5? A-65A %+%, -6 885H;?5 23 126 9:6?-83=5?D;2A5>28536153-B5 23?5E;2?5A6795 356 -32A5 - 8 - % 7835E;586>: 615 2B4;D85A 7?A5? A-65A +%, 4-335A 9: 615 ?29;8-> 28 44>2<-6278 7,,%, -6 885H;?5 23 356 -32A5 15 -44>2<-6278 23 ->>7F5A 15 7?A5? 7= 6?-83=5? 95-?28D 7-$+%, A-65A %+%, 4-335A 9: 615 ?53478A586-6885H;?523E;-315A78>:2837=-?-3615 456262785?23<78<5?85A 15 6-65 7C5?8B586 23 D2C58 >295?6: 67 6-@5 -8:=;?615?365437=6?-83=5?2=26<1773533728-<<7?A-8<5 F2616156?-83=5?D;2A5>2853 )261 >295?6: 36-65A 3;4?- 615 F?26 45626278 23 A234735A7= !)* '!!( & !)* '%( & ( 2367>7,#