Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 42965 (KAR)
BASANNA S/O MALKAMBANNA v. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER AND ORS
WP/201814/2022 · 2025-09-04
Jyoti Mulimani
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 42965 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 42965 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "!#$
%#!&!&"##
'(!)
! "
#$%""
&
#$%""
'
#$%""
%
#$%""
$
#$%""
Digitally signed by THEJAS KUMAR N Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
( )
! )*
#$%""
)
*
"
$+ (
! )
*
&&( &&,**
* )
* -. /012134562 1407 89:3657 ;9/ 425 <54040935/ 13= /01721/
19 1793> ?042 /025621=/0 106213@1/ ;9//56<93=5346"49$21A51<<51/5=03<5/693 & 25629/4;18461/542565 4 06 610= 4214 425 <54040935/ <:/82165=425 713= B51/03> C9"&$ D516:/03> $ 8/56 & :3416 604:145= 14 0/5413:/ 0771>5 1=1/70 9B70 03=213:/ 17:@
1082:/ 064/084;/9D51/705/9?35/0DD191/161<<103"E((25 31D5 9; 425 <54040935/ 81D5 49 B5 5345/5= 42/9:>2 =:7C 85/40;05= D:414093 534/C 9"% 25 <54040935/.6 31D5 ?16
- 3 -
5345/5=03425/5A53:5/589/=603"E(BC=575403>42531D59;
425 51/705/ 9?35/ 03 97:D3 9E 9; 425
25 <54040935/ 1769658:/5=138:DB/13855/40;0814503*9/D9"$;/9D425 9;;0859;:B#
5>064/1/03=213:/;9/1<5/09=;9/"%"E(( 49 '"'&% 4 06 610= 4214 5F85<4 425 4/136184093 9; 425 <54040935/ 425/5 1/5 39 9425/ 4/1361840936 ;9:3= 03 425 610= 6:/A5C3:DB5/;/9D"E((49&% 6425D1445/6499=42:642560F42/56<93=534?29?16 39 ?1C 89385/35= 49 425 <54040935/.6 ;1D07C 9/ 49 425 713= 03 G:56409325/31D581D549B55345/5=0397:D39E9;425 629?03>D516:/5D53416'8/5603"E#E?0429:413C B16069/613840939;71?1689345D<7145=:3=5/584093"&13=
"&E 9; 425 84 25/51;45/ 03 "EE#EE 425 31D5 9; 425 <54040935/?16629?3937C03/56<5849;D516:/5D534&8/56 & :3416 03 C9"&$ 13= 1 65<1/145 0661 :DB5/ ?16 >0A5316C9"&$1D516:/03>'8/560342531D59;425 60F42 /56<93=534 BC 066:03> 35? 3 &"' 425 <54040935/ 394085= 425 0775>17 534/056 D1=5 03 425 31D5 9; 425 60F42 /56<93=534 5385 25 ;075= 13 1<<517 B5;9/5 425 65893= /56<93=534 03
<<517 9',(&"'#"% ?042 1 </1C5/ 49
- 4 -
=57545 425 31D5 9; 425 60F42 /56<93=534 03 C9"&$ 39? C9"&$!
D516:/03> $ 8/56 & :3416 9; 0/5413:/ 0771>5 17:@1 03=213:/
1082:/ 064/084 13= 49 /54103 425 <54040935/.6 31D5 49 425 5340/55F4534 03 425 1;9/5610= :/A5C 3:DB5/ 25 65893= /56<93=534 1;45/ 251/03> 425 <54040935/ 13= /56<93=5346 ' 49 ( <1665= 425 9/=5/ 93 &,,&"( 13= =06D0665= 425 1<<517 >>/05A5= BC 425 610= 9/=5/ 425 <54040935/</5;5//5=1
5A060935404093039&&&"(#",B5;9/5 425 5<:4C 9DD0660935/ 25 5<:4C 9DD0660935/ A0=5 9/=5/=145="("&&&"=06D0665=425
5A0609354040933=5/ 4256580/8:D6413856425<54040935/216;075=42581<40935=)/04 5404093 ' 9:3657 ;9/ 425 /56<5840A5 <1/4056 :/>5= 65A5/17 89345340936 H:640;05=4251840939;425/5A53:51:429/04056/>03> 9425/89345340936256:BD0464214131<</9</01459/=5/D1CB5 <1665= 51/= 425 1/>:D5346 13= <5/:65= 425 )/04 <1<5/6 ?042 81/5
- 5 -
% 25066:5;1776?04203131//9?89D<16613=/571456 49 =5754093 9; 425 <54040935/.6 31D5 03 /56<584 9; ' 8/56 9;
713= 03 C9"&$ 4 06 394 03 =06<:45 4214 425 <54040935/ <:/82165= 425 </9<5/4C :3=5/ 1 /5>0645/5= 6175 =55= =145=
"&"E(( 165= 93 425 1;9/5610= 6175 =55= 425 12607=1/ 5345/5=20631D585/40;C03>D:4140939"%=145=&"""E(( :/</0603>7C42531D59;425<54040935/?16/5<7185=03"EE ?0429:413CB160613=B5203=206B18@03/56<5849;'8/569;
713=40660>30;081344939454214584093"& %!D13=1456425 1:429/04056495345/42531D59;<5/693B165=93425/5>0645/5= =98:D534 1;45/ 21A03> /5850A5= 425 /5G:06045 ;55 25/5;9/5 425 /56<93=5346 1/5 =:4C B9:3= 49 D1034103 425 /589/=6 16 /5G:0/5= :3=5/ 425 71? 13= 13C 6:B6404:4093 03 425 /5A53:5 534/05662177B5031889/=1385?042425</9A0609369; 1/3141@1 13=
5A53:5 84 5385 5345/03> 425 31D5 9; 60F42 /56<93=534 ?0429:4 394085 49 425 <54040935/ 06 B1657566 13= 06 >/966 35>70>5385 93 425 <1/4 9; 425 /5A53:5 1:429/04056 55=7566 49 61C 4214 D1034531385 9; /5A53:5 /589/=6 06 D13=149/C :3=5/ 425 </9A060936 9; 425 84 *:/425/D9/5 425 =571C 813394 B5 144/0B:45= 49 425 <54040935/ 60385 425 /5A53:5 1:429/04056 21A5 ;1075= 49 89D<7C 425 6414:49/C =:4C
- 6 -
81645=93425D:3=5/4256414:4525/5;9/542518409393425 <1/49;425
5A53:5:429/04056813394B56:641035= *9/ 425 /516936 64145= 1B9A5 425 9/=5/6 <1665= BC 425 66064134 9DD0660935/ 13= 425 5<:4C 9DD0660935/ 1/5 701B7549B5654#160=5889/=03>7C425C1/5654#160=5 $ 25 )/04 9; 5/409/1/0 06 9/=5/5= 25 9/=5/ =145= &,,&"( <1665= BC 425 66064134 9DD0660935/ 03 <<517 9',(&"'#"% A0=5 335F:/5#* 13= 425 9/=5/ =145=
"("&&&" <1665= BC 425 5<:4C 9DD0660935/ 03
A0=5 335F:/5# 1/5 G:1625=
D13=1D:6069/=5/5==0/58403>42512607=1/495345/42531D5 9;425<54040935/03
9;713=B51/03>C9"&$D516:/03> $ 8/56 & :3416 9; 0/5413:/ 0771>5 03=213:/ 17:@ 064/084
1082:/ ( 56:741347C425)/04540409306
!*( '&"##) &
0649"79''