- 1 - !" #$ %# & &"## '( ) !" # $ %&'$ %&'$ # ! " ( )" " " ! " *+ Digitally signed by PREMCHANDRA M R Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ,-./.0.,.1 .23452. 6478/9: 48 ;9<.:= 4= ,-<-0.>7?., .::44, =4, @<9 A9@-@-489, .82 ,-.::->.,178 .<7>.,=4,@<9,9/A48298@/<.09.AA9.,92-8A9,/48 <9/<4,@=.6@/.,9@<9/9 @ -/ /.-2 @<.@ @<9 A9@-@-489,+/ =.@<9, A7,6<./92 @<9 :.82 ;9.,-83 B4C) ?9./7,-83 $$ 6,9/ /-@7.@92 .@ -::.39 47823.48 .:7> 7,.2 -/@,-6@ -2., 7829, . ,93-/@9,92 /.:92992-8$D))=,4?-@/A,90-47/4589,.,7@-<9,9.=@9, "4,?5.//98@@4.</-:2.,@4A.//?7@.@-484,29,.82?.>9 98@,-9/-8@<9/./A9,@<9 6@<9A9@-@-489,+/=.@<9, 5./.8-::-@9,.@9A9,/48/4.:/4@<9A9@-@-489,@<9B59,97829, @<9-?A,9//-48@<.@ "4,?5-::;9/98@@4@<9.</-:2.,4==-69 =4,9==96@-83?7@.@-48=@9,/982-83@<9 "4,?-//792;B@<9 7;93-/@,., 7,.2 @4 @<9 .</-:2., =4, 9==96@-83 ?7@.@-48 @<9.</-:2.,2-284@/.86@-48@<9?7@.@-48./A9,@<9 "4,? @-//@.@92.=@9,@<929.@<4=<-/=.@<9,@<9A9@-@-489,6.?9@4 >845 @<.@ @<9 8.?9 4= .,8.@.>. 409,8?98@ 5./ /<458 -8 4:7?84/D.82$4=@<9 9-??92-.@9:B.AA,4.6<92 @<9.</-:2.,@429:9@9@<998@,B4=409,8?98@4=.,8.@.>. - 3 - .82 /.86@-48 @<9 ?7@.@-48 -8 <-/ 8.?9 ./ A9, @<9 93-/@9,92 .:9992./<-/=.@<9,<.22-92 <9 .</-:2., A7@ 7A @<9 =-:9 ./ 2-/A7@92 =-:9 -8 '$&$.82-//792.:9@@9,@4@<99098798/A96@4, =4,/A4@-8/A96@-48.82@4648276@.A.86<.8.?.-8,9/A96@4= @<9 :.82 ,93.,2-83 @<9 A4 -48 .82 67:@-0.@-48 4= @<9 /.-2 :.82/A9,@<92-,96@-48@<99098798/A96@4,?.29./A4@ -8/A96@-48.82648276@92A.86<.8.?..82,9A4,@92@<.@.,7@- .45./@<94589,.82A4 4,4=B4C) ?9./7,-83 6,9/78@./.82@<9A9@-@-489,+/=.@<9,<.2A7,6<./92@<9 :.82 @4 .8 9E@98@ 4= $$ 6,9/ @ 5./ .:/4 /@.@92 @<.@ .,7@- .4 <.2 4;@.-892 :4.8 =,4? .8> =4, 2-33-83 59:: -8 @<9 :.82 ;7@ =.-:92 @4 ,9A.B @<9 .8> .?478@ 9869 .8> .@@.6<92 @<9 :.82 .82 98@9,92 @<9 8.?9 4= @<9 409,8?98@ .82 @<9 .</-:2., -//792 .8 9824,/9?98@ 48 $C$'$/@.@-83@<.@<9<./8417,-/2-6@-48=4,64,,96@-484= /.822-,96@92@4.AA,4.6<@<99A7@B4??-//-489, @ -/ /.-2 @<.@ @<9 A9@-@-489, .AA:-92 =4, ?7@.@-48;9=4,9 @<9 .</-:2., 48 $)')'$) ;7@ @<9 .</-:2., -//792 .8 9824,/9?98@48''%'$)/@.@-83@<.@<96.884@64,,96@@<9 - 4 - 98@,-9/ <9 A9@-@-489, =-:92 . 90-/-48 -8 4$ '$) ,987?;9,92 ./ ' '$D# ;9=4,9 @<9 9A7@B 4??-//-489, <9 9A7@B 4??-//-489, 0-29 4,29, 2.@92 '' 6486:7292 @<.@ @<9,9 -/ . 29:.B .82 ,9196@92 @<9 6:.-? 4= @<9 A9@-@-489, 829, @<9/9 6-,67?/@.869/ @<9 A9@-@-489, -/ ;9=4,9 @<-/47,@ C 478/9: =4, @<9 ,9/A96@-09 A.,@-9/ 7,392 /909,.: 648@98@-48/ -8 A,9/98@-83 <-/ .,37?98@/ 09<9?98@:B 648@98292 @<.@@<9A9@-@-489,+/09824,<.2@.>98:4.8.82@<9/.?95./ 84@ A.-2 9869 @<9 :.82 5./ .@@.6<92 .82 @<9 8.?9 4= @<9 409,8?98@5./98@9,92 9/7;?-@/@<.@@<9,9-/.29:.B-8 .AA,4.6<-83@<9.7@<4,-@B 9869<917/@-=-92@<9.6@-484=@<9 .</-:2.,.82@<99A7@B4??-//-489, B 5.B 4= ,9A:B 6478/9: =4, @<9 A9@-@-489, /7;?-@/ @<.@ @<9 648@98@-48 ,93.,2-83 848A.B?98@ 4= :4.8 -/ 78@98.;:9 478/9: 2,95 @<9 .@@98@-48 4= @<9 47,@ @4 889E7,9$ @4 648@982 @<.@ 279/ 59,9 6:9.,92 ;B @<9 A9@-@-489,+/ 09824, 478/9: @<9,9=4,9 /7;?-@/ @<.@ @<9 !,-@ 9@-@-48 ?.B ;9 .::4592 - 5 - 9.,2 @<9 .,37?98@/ .82 A9,7/92 @<9 !,-@ A.A9,/ 5-@< 6.,9 & <9 =.6@/ .,9 /7==-6-98@:B /.-2 .82 24 84@ ,9F7-,9 ,9-@9,.@-48<9-//79=.::/5-@<-8.8.,,4564?A.//.82,9:.@9/ @4 @<9 98@,B 4= @<9 8.?9 4= @<9 A9@-@-489, -8 @<9 909879 964,2/@-//-38-=-6.8@@484@9@<.@96@-48/$%.82$D4= @<9 .,8.@.>. .82 909879 6@ -?A4/9 . .82 909879 6@ -?A4/9 . /@.@7@4,B 27@B 48 @<9909879==-69,@49==96@6<.8394=?7@.@-48-8,9/A96@4= ,-3<@ .6F7-,92 7829, . ,93-/@9,92 /.:9 2992 8 @<9 A,9/98@ 6./9 @<9 A9@-@-489,+/ =.@<9, <.2 A7,6<./92 @<9 :.82 7829, . ,93-/@9,92/.:92992-8$D))<9869@<9.</-:2.,5./,9F7-,92 @4.6@./A9,@<9A,40-/-48/4=@<9.,8.@.>. .829098796@ <9 648@98@-48 .;47@ 848A.B?98@ 4= @<9 .?478@ ?7/@ 8969//.,-:B =.-: <9 ,9./48 -/ .AA.,98@ 889E7,9$ -/ @<9 64??78-6.@-48 /98@ ;B @<9 .</-:2., @4 @<9 9A7@B 4??-//-489, A9,7/.: 4= @<9 /.?9 6:9.,:B 29A-6@/ @<.@ @<9 A9@-@-489,+/ 09824, <.2 6:9.,92 @<9 :4.8 .?478@ .82 -@ <./ ;998/@.@92@<.@@<94589,<./84@.AA,4.6<92@<94==-694=@<9 .</-:2.,@429:9@9@<998@,B.>-8384@94=@<9=.6@@<.@@<9 A9@-@-489,+/09824,<.26:9.,92@<9:4.8.?478@@<9,95./84 - 6 - -?A92-?98@=4,@<9.</-:2.,@49E9,6-/9@<9/@.@7@4,B27@B.82 @4 9==96@ 6<.839 4= ?7@.@-48 -8 ,9/A96@ 4= . ,-3<@ .6F7-,92 7829, . ,93-/@9,92 /.:9 2992 / .:,9.2B 84@92 .;409 @<9 A,40-/-48/4=@<96@-?A4/9/./@.@7@4,B27@B<9869F79/@-48 4= 29:.B 249/ 84@ .,-/9 "4, @<9 ,9./48/ /@.@92 .;409 @<9 9824,/9?98@-//792;B@<9.</-:2.,.82@<94,29,A.//92;B @<9 9A7@B 4??-//-489, .,9 :-.;:9 @4 ;9 /9@./-29 664,2-83:B@<9B.,9/9@./-29 <9!,-@4=9,@-4,.,--/4,29,92<99824,/9?98@ 2.@92''%'$)-//792;B@<9.</-:2.,0-29889E7,9.82 @<9 4,29, 2.@92 '' A.//92 ;B @<9 9A7@B 4??-//-489, -8 AA9.: 4' '$D 0-29 889E7,9 .,9 F7./<92 .82.?7/ -/ 4,29,92 2-,96@-83 @<9 .</-:2., @4 ?7@.@9@<98.?94=@<9A9@-@-489,-8@<9,909879,964,2/5-@<-8 =47,599>/=,4?@<9,969-A@4=69,@-=-9264AB4=@<-/4,29, ( 9/7:@.8@:B@<9!,-@9@-@-48-/ *( '&"##) & -/@4$:4C$