- 1 - !" # $ % %% &"' ( ! " # $% " & ' '()*$# "#+$,$, - & '(,% ! " &-. -* -%-* # Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & & /*"# & & --'%'-%-- '0 */- -%) & *$%%% ' *%%%%% ' -1 & & 2 & 3 $ " 3 # 45674 849 :;;9:< => <=>89? @5A :?B=>>=5C D=84 849 E5C>9C8 5@ <9:AC9? E56C>9< @5A 849 ;:A8=9> =8 => 8:F9C 6; @5A@=C:<?=>;5>:< - 4=> :;;9:< => @=<9? :7:=C>8 849 G6?7B9C8 :C? :D:A? ?:89? -- % -%-- ;:>>9? HI 849 585A EE=?9C8 <:=B> A=H6C:< 5 0 =G:I:;6A: =C 5 */- 5@ -%) * 49 E<:=B:C8 :79? $ I9:A> >86?9C8 B98 D=84 :C:EE=?9C85C-/ %/ -%)?6985849A:>4:C?C97<=79C8 ?A=J=C7 5@ 849 ?A=J9A 5@ 849 :A H9:A=C7 A97=>8A:8=5C - 3 - 5 ' '()*$ :C? >6>8:=C9? 7A=9J56> =CG6A9> 49 D:> A9;A9>9C89?HI 49A @:849A :>: C:86A:< 76:A?=:C :C? @=<9? : E<:=B ;98=8=5C H9@5A9 849 A=H6C:< E<:=B=C7 E5B;9C>:8=5C5@> *%%%%% ' $ 49A=H6C:<E5C>=?9A=C78499C8=A99J=?9CE95C A9E5A? 7A:C89? :C :B56C8 5@ > *--*) 85D:A?> B9?=E:<9K;9C>9>:C?:7<5H:<>6B5@> -(%%% '6C?9A :<< E5CJ9C8=5C:< 49:?> :C? 849A9HI 7A:C89? : 858:< E5B;9C>:8=5C 5@ > *$%%% ' D=84 =C89A9>8 :8 ,1 ; : @A5B 849 ?:89 5@ ;98=8=5C 8=<< A9:<=>:8=5C :C? ?=A9E89? A9>;5C?9C85 -'C>6A:CE95B;:CI85?9;5>=8849>:B9 ( 77A=9J9?HI849>:=?G6?7B9C8:C?:D:A?849 =CG6A9? E<:=B:C8 4:> ;A9@9AA9? 84=> :;;9:< =C D4=E4 =8 => E5C89C?9?84:8849:;;9<<:C8D:>9:AC=C7> %%%% ';9A B5C84 H68 849 A=H6C:< 9AA9? =C C58 8:F=C7 849 =CE5B9 :C?C58:D:A?=C7:CIE5B;9C>:8=5C85D:A?><5>>5@@686A9 9:AC=C7. >49 >6>8:=C9? @A:E86A9 :C? >6@@9A=C7 @A5B ;9AB:C9C8;4I>=E:<=B;9?=B9C8.>49>;9C8> (%%%%% ' 85D:A?> B9?=E:< 9K;9C>9>. 849 A=H6C:< 4:> 7A:C89? - 4 - B9:7A9 :B56C8 6C?9A E5CJ9C8=5C:< 49:?> 49A9@5A9 A9L69>89?@5A9C4:CE9B9C85@E5B;9C>:8=5C , 9:A?849:A76B9C8>5@H584>=?9> / > ;9A 849 D56C? E9A8=@=E:89 + K / 849 :;;9<<:C8 4:> >6>8:=C9? A=748 9:A H<99? >686A9? D56C? :;;A5K=B:89<I =C@A5C8 5@ A=748 9:A :HA:>=5C 5J9A <9@8 @5A9:AB :HA:>=5C 5J9A A=748 @5A9:AB :HA:>=5C 5J9A ?5A>6B5@<9@8@558HA:=C'<9@889B;5A:<E5C86>=5C:C? A=74889B;5A:< D=84 49C:86A95@=CG6A=9>=>C58 B9C8=5C9? =C 849 >:=? E9A8=@=E:89 68 =C 849 ?=>E4:A79 >6BB:AI =8 => B9C8=5C9? 84:8 >49 D:> :?B=889? =C 849 45>;=8:<5C-/ %/ -%):C??=>E4:A79?5C % -%):C? 846> >49 D:> 45>;=8:<=>9? @5A ( ?:I> :C? =8 D:> ?=:7C5>9? :> 8A:6B:8=E HA:=C =CG6AI D=84 ?=@@6>9 :K5C:< =CG6AID=84<9@889B;5A:<4:9B5AA4:7=EE5C86>=5CD=84A=748 ;:A=98589B;5A:< 49:;;9<<:C84:>C589K:B=C9?849 ?5E85A :C? :> >6E4 849 ?=>:H=<=8I D:> C58 :>>9>>9? :C? 849A9HI 849 A=H6C:< 4:> C58 :D:A?9? :CI :B56C8 85D:A?> <5>> 5@ @686A9 9:AC=C7 5D9J9A E5C>=?9A=C7 849 - 5 - C:86A95@=CG6A=9>;9A=5?5@45>;=8:<=>:8=5C:C?849:795@ 849 :;;9<<:C8 84=> 56A8 @=C?> =8 A9:>5C:H<9 85 8:F9 849 ?=>:H=<=8I :8 %1 :> ;9A 849 E=8:8=5C 5@ 849 5CMH<9 ;9K 56A8 =C 849 E:>9 5@ :C? 846> 849 :;;9<<:C8 => 9C8=8<9? @5A > %%%%% ' 85D:A?> ;:=C :C? >6@@9A=C7 :<A9:?I 6C?9A75C9 :C? 85 H9 >6@@9A9? =C @686A9 B9C8:< :C? ;4I>=E:< >45EF 4:A?>4=; =CE5CJ9C=9CE9 :C? ?=>E5B@=8> 98E :C?<5>>5@:B9C=8=9>=C<=@95C:EE56C85@;9AB:C9C8 ?=>:H=<=8I 49@:849A5@849:;;9<<:C8=>?5=C7:7A=E6<86A9 :C?49D:>:79?$(I9:A>:C?)*+,--./+0)--122+/.0 )*+ 3+,2 45 9CE9 84=> 56A8 @=C?> =8 A9:>5C:H<9 85 7A:C8 :C :B56C8 5@ > %%%% ' @5A ?=>E5B@5A8 =CE5CJ9C=9CE9 :C? <5>> 5@ 9:AC=C7> 85 849 ;:A9C8> ?6A=C7 849;9A=5?5@45>;=8:<=>:8=5C 1 (2014) 14 SCC 396 - 6 - ) 49 A=H6C:< 4:> 7A:C89? :C :B56C8 5@ > *--*) '85D:A?>B9?=E:<9K;9C>9>:C?> -(%%% ' 85D:A?>E5CJ9C8=5C:<49:?>=C:<<> *$%%% 'D4=E4=> G6>8:C?;A5;9A:C?C99?>C5=C89A@9A9CE9 % 9CE9849:;;9<<:C8=>9C8=8<9?@5A849B5?=@=9? E5B;9C>:8=5C6C?9A?=@@9A9C849:?>:>H9<5D 9:?> 5B;9C>:8=5C :B56C8 9?=E:< 9K;9C>9> E5CJ9C8=5C> 49:?> > *$%%% ' :=C :C? >6@@9A=C7 :<A9:?I 6C?9A75C9 :C? 85 H9 >6@@9A9? =C @686A9 B9C8:< :C? ;4I>=E:< >45EF 4:A?>4=; =CE5CJ9C=9CE9 :C? ?=>E5B@=8> 98E :C? <5>> 5@ :B9C=8=9> =C <=@9 5C :EE56C8 5@ ;9AB:C9C8?=>:H=<=8I > %%%%% ' =>E5B@5A8 =CE5CJ9C=9CE9 :C? <5>> 5@ 9:AC=C7> 85 849 ;:A9C8> ?6A=C7 849;9A=5?5@45>;=8:<=>:8=5C > %%%% ' 58:< 9>>:D:A?9?HIA=H6C:< C4:CE9B9C8 > $(%%% ' > *$%%% ' 644 ' 49 C>6A:CE9 5B;:CI 4:> :<A9:?I ?9;5>=89? 849 :B56C8 :D:A?9? HI 849 A=H6C:< 46> 849 :;;9<<:C8 => 9C8=8<9?@5A9C4:CE9?E5B;9C>:8=5C5@> %%%% 'D=84 - 7 - =C89A9>8 :8 ,1 ;9A :CC6B :C? 849A9@5A9 849 :;;9:< ?9>9AJ9>85H9:<<5D9?=C;:A8 C849A9>6<8849@5<<5D=C75A?9A=>;:>>9? "=# ;;9:<=>:<<5D9?=C;:A8 "==# 49 :;;9<<:C8 E<:=B:C8 => 9C8=8<9? @5A 849 9C4:CE9? E5B;9C>:8=5C 5@ > %%%% ' D=84 =C89A9>8 :8 ,1 ;9A :CC6B @A5B 849 ?:89 5@ ;98=8=5C 8=<< 849 ?:89 5@ A9:<=>:8=5C "===# 9>;5C?9C8 5 -'C>6A:CE9 5B;:CI => ?=A9E89? 85 ?9;5>=8 849 :@5A9>:=? E5B;9C>:8=5C :B56C8 D=84=C5C9B5C84@A5B849?:895@84=>G6?7B9C8 "=J# C >6E4 ?9;5>=8 849 :;;9<<:C8 => ;9AB=889? 85 D=84?A:D 849 9C8=A9 :B56C8 :<5C7 D=84 =C89A9>8 :EEA69? 5C=8 6/7 &% ' $ =>85 <5 /*