- 1 - ! "#! "## $#!! % ! " # $% ! " # ! & !' '' ! " # Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! ! " # $ ! $ ! " # !' % ! " # ( # % % ! " # % $$ ! " - 3 - # $ ! " # ' $ $! ! " # ! ! " # & ! $% ! " # ) * + - 4 - , ,, " #-$%' " #.$%' ) ! , / -' ) , *, 0 , 0 - , !+ , ' / , , / , , # ''' '!% '*-+ ,# " , - 5 - 1# 1#, * 1#+ 234 567789 34 :3478; <=9 =9;894 28 >=?@48: 6AA8693@B <=9 728 >=5A:63@6@74 C9=?B27 7= @=73>8 =< 7234 =?97 728 =9;89 ;678; ''' A6448; CD 728 :869@8; 3@B:8 #?;B8 64 3@78935 5864?98 6@; E23:8 B96@73@B 3@78935 =9;89 A8@;3@B ;34A=46: =< 728 E937 A87373=@ ;398>73@B 984A=@;8@7 @=$ @=7 7= ;85=:342 728 984A8>73F8 2=?484 =< 728 A87373=@894 437?678; 67 @;396 6B69 :?5 986 ?;;8C326: 6:?G 3H6D6A?9 34793>7 6@; 6:4= A8@;3@B344?8=<9?:8@343 28 >=?@48: 6AA8693@B <=9 728 >=5A:63@6@74 C9=?B277=@=73>8=<7234=?9772673@4A378=<463;=9;89 ;85=:3428;7288I3473@B479?>7?984E23>2343@F3=:673=@=< 728 =9;89 6@; 4658 34 98A=978; 3@ 728 A6A89 =@ '' 6@; 6:4= A6A89 >?773@B 67 @@8I?98- 34 - 6 - A9=;?>8; 6@; 28@>8 A96D8; 7234 =?97 7= 76G8 6>73=@ 6B63@47 984A=@;8@74 CD 3@373673@B 728 >=@785A7 A9=>88;3@B4 ! 28>=?@48:6AA8693@B<=9984A=@;8@74C9=?B27 7=@=73>8=<7234=?977267;8763:4767858@7=<=CH8>73=@434 <3:8; >=@78@;3@B 7267 =E@ ?@3>3A6: =?@>3: ?;;8C326: 34 728 =E@89 =< 728 :6@; C8693@B D=$ =< ?;;8C326: 6:?G E23>2 34 7=76::D 5864?93@B 6>984 B?@764 6@; A9=A897D346B=?726@:6@;7346:4=>=@78@;7267=@:D6@ 8I78@7=<'$6>984B?@764=@E84789@43;834@=7676:: ;347?9C8; CD 728 6>>?48; 6@; 728 98563@3@B A=973=@ =< :6@;7=6@8I78@7=<'%6>984!%B?@764C8:=@B3@B7==E@ ?@3>3A6: =?@>3: E23>2 264 C88@ 4?CH8>7 7= 48F896: 8@>9=6>258@7C648;=@728>=@78@73=@72677286::=758@74 56;8CD72869@676G6:?5=69; 28 >=?@48: 6:4= E=?:; F82858@7:D >=@78@; 7267@=;34A?78E37298B69;7=A=973=@E23>2E646>J?398; - 7 - CD984A=@;8@74-:?5=69;C?7@=73@984A8>7=<8@7398 8I78@7=<6>984B?@764 $ 7 34 4A8>3<3>6::D >=@78@;8; 7267 4=58 =< 728 <96?;4 >=553778; CD 728 >=5A:63@6@74 698 C9=?B27 7= @=73>8=<728=?97E23>26988F3;8@7<9=57286AA:3>673=@ 3748:<7267264C88@487=?73@A696B96A2@=% ?7=< >=5A:63@6@74 =@:D >=5A:63@6@74 38 >=5A:63@6@7@=4 7= ! $ 7= 6@; ' 7= 698 @=7 728 9843;8@>8 =< ?;;8C326:6@;9843;3@B3@6;3<<898@7A:6>84=58=<7285 6989843;3@B3@=728976:?G6@;=7289;34793>76@;465834 >:869 <9=5 728 6;269 >69; 6@G A644 C==G4 3@>=58 >8973<3>6784A9=;?>8;6:=@BE372728396::8B8;6AA:3>673=@4 7346:4=>=@78@;8;7267>=5A:63@6@7@=46@; 698 9843;8@7 =< ?;;8C326: C?7 728D 698 9843;3@B 3@ ;3<<898@7A:6>8286::=758@7 26GG?A67296=<>=5A:63@6@7 @=46@;E=?:;>:869:DB=7=42=E726737347284658 479?>7?98 <=9 E23>2 7E= @?5C894 698 6::=778; 6@; >=@>=>78; A2=7=B96A24 >6@ >:869:D 56;8 =?7 6@; 6:4= - 8 - >=@43;893@B 6::=758@7 =< >=5A:63@6@7 @=' 34 >=5A698; E3727267=<>=5A:63@6@7@=%3@=''' '7 34 >:869 7267 <96?; 34 A:6D8; =@ 728 4:?5 C=69; 6@; 7E= 2=?48 @?5C894 698 B3F8@ <=9 4658 479?>7?98 64 2=?48 @=$!6@;2=?48@=%A9=;?>8;67@@8I?98-! 28 984A=@;8@74 26F8 ;34A?78; 7267 72848 A87373=@894 >=5A:63@6@74 26F8 3@;?:B8 3@ >98673=@ =< ;=>?58@746@;<3:8;6A87373=@ % =?@48: 6:4= >=@78@; 7267 E28@ 72898 34 @= A9==<E37298B69;7=6>J?34373=@7=7288I78@7=<6>984 B?@7646@;3@7234>=@785A7A9=>88;3@B4=?97>6@@=7 ;8>3;8 728 ;34A?78; 344?8 3@F=:F8; 28 >=?@48: 6:4= A9=;?>8; @@8I?98-% C8<=98 7234 =?97 6@; 42=E4 7267 728479?>7?984698@=7728A8956@8@7479?>7?984728D=@:D A?7 K3@> 428874 6@; @=7 26F3@B 6@D 43B@ =< 728D E898 9843;3@B3@728463;A98534846@;4658348F3;8@77267=@:D <=96>98673=@=<;=>?58@74::7284867785A74E89856;8 6@; 6:4= 4?C5374 7267 728 567789 34 @=7 ;8>3;8; CD 728 - 9 - :869@8; 3@B:8 #?;B8 64 589374 6@; 4658 34 A8@;3@B <=9 >=@43;89673=@ 8@>8 72898 >6@@=7 C8 6 >=@785A7 A9=>88;3@B4 6F3@B 2869; >=5A:63@6@74L >=?@48: 6>>?48; >=?@48:6@;6:4=>=@43;893@B7283@78935=9;89A6448;CD 728 :869@8; 3@B:8 #?;B8 64 E8:: 64 728 4767858@7 =< =CH8>73=@4 <3:8; CD 728 984A=@;8@74 6@; A6973>?:69:D @@8?I98-% 37 34 F89D >:869 7267 785A=969D 428;4 26F8 C88@898>78;6@;72898346:4=;34A?787267=@:D6>J?34373=@ 343@984A8>7=<'$6>98B?@7646@;@=78@73988I78@7=< 6>984B?@764 ' 28@ 4?>2 C83@B 728 >648 7234 =?97 >6@@=7 ;8>3;8728344?83@6>=@785A7A9=>88;3@B4E37298B69;7= 728 ;34A?78; <6>74 234 =?97 6:4= F3;8 =9;89 ;678; ' 'E23:8;86:3@BE3727284353:69487=<<6>746@; >39>?5476@>84 E28@ 728 3@78935 =9;89 E64 A6448; CD :869@8; 3@B:8#?;B87234 =?97 3@>=@785A7A9=>88;3@B4 3@ @=! ' 56;8 6@ =C489F673=@ 3@ A696B96A2 - 10 - @= 7267 CD F89D 9864=@ 7267 728 =9;89 34 3@78935 3@ @67?98 @= 93B274 =< 6@D =< 728 A697384 698 <3@6::D >9D476::3K8; 67 7234 476B8 28 =?97 34 72898<=98 @=7 3@>:3@8;7=8@789763@728A9848@7>=@785A7A87373=@6@;@=7 3@>:3@8; 7= 8I89>348 H?934;3>73=@ ?@;89 728 =@785A7 =< =?974>7 @ A696B96A2 @=! =< 6<=98463; >=@785A7 A9=>88;3@B4 6:4= 56;8 37 >:869 7267 A87373=@89 56D E=9G =?7 234 93B274 6@; 9858;384 C8<=98 728 :869@8; 3@B:8 #?;B8E2898728A698@7A9=>88;3@B4=<728A87373=@894698 A8@;3@BCD96343@B6::728>=@78@73=@4488G3@B98F38E 6F3@B >=@43;898; 728 =9;89 A6448; CD 7234 =?97 6@; 6:4= 3@ 728 <6>7?6: 64A8>74 =< 728 >648 E28@ 72898 34 ;34A?78 E372 98B69; 7= 6>J?393@B 728 :6@; CD 728 :?5=69;=@:D7=728:35378;8I78@7=<'$6>98B?@764 6@;@=77=7288I78@7=<6>984B?@7646@;43773@B3@ >=@785A7 A9=>88;3@B4 7234 =?97 >6@@=7 ;8>3;8 728 ;34A?78; 344?8 3@F=:F8; 3@ 728 567789 E287289 37 >=584 - 11 - E3723@'$6>984B?@764=9E28728937>=584E3723@ 6>984 B?@764 6@; 72=?B2 >=?@48: 6AA8693@B <=9 A87373=@894 >=5A:63@6@74 C9=?B27 7= @=73>8 =< 7234 =?97 :347=<A894=@46983@=>>?A673=@64A89@@8I?98-3@728 98H=3@;89 <3:8; CD 728 >=5A:63@6@74 6@; 4658 >6@@=7 C8 ;8>3;8;3@7234>=@785A7A9=>88;3@B4 ! 8@>87234=?97;=84@=7E6@77=8IA98446@D =A3@3=@ =9 589374 =< 728 567789 6@; 728 4658 >=?:; C8 >=@43;898; 3@ E937 A87373=@ A8@;3@B C8<=98 728 :869@8; 3@B:8#?;B8 372 7234 =C489F673=@ 7234 >=@785A7 A9=>88;3@B 34 ;9=AA8; &' (!) &' (#) 347=:=%