- 1 - !! ""#$ "%#&! ! '! (##)#) # #&& *)+ # #&& ! !" # # $ % #& " # !! % & # # '"("! ( # !) * '"(" Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - '"("! $ % + + !)!!" & ,%& %& # ! !- ! # ),! # * & . . !-/!,% %& -!!"& ! , # # $ % #& - 3 - " # !! % & # # '"("! '"("! $ % + !!!) & ,%& # !!-! # )/! # * # 0 # (" 1!)/(! 23 42567 89 :;6 <5=2>=?: 2? 1),! 366@2?A 6?;=?<6>6?: 14 <1>B6?3=:21? =C=D767 2? :;6 #E7A>6?: 7=:67 !!-! B=3367 89 :;6 - 4 - D2?<2B=5 6?21D2F25#E7A6=?7 =5=8ED=A2%41D3;1D: G:;6:D28E?=5.& 1!))! 23 42567 89 :;6 <5=2>=?: 2? 1)/! 366@2?A 6?;=?<6>6?: 14 <1>B6?3=:21? =C=D767 2? :;6 #E7A>6?: 7=:67 !!-! B=3367 89 :;6 D2?<2B=5 6?21D2F25#E7A6=?7 =5=8ED=A2%41D3;1D: G:;6:D28E?=5G& ;6 4=<:3 56=72?A :1 4252?A 14 :;6 <5=2> B6:2:21?3 =D6=3E?76D ;=:1?/!"!!=:=81E:,!!B>:;6<5=2>=?:2? 1)/! C=3 :;6 D276D =?7 :;6 <5=2>=?: 2? 1),!C=3:;6B25521?D276D14:;6>1:1D<9<5686=D2?A D6A23:D=:21?1 # )=?7C6D6BD1<6672?A:1C=D73 ;=;=8=7 ;6 D276D 14 :;6 >1:1D<9<56 C=3 D272?A :;6 >1:1D<9<562?=;2A;3B667D=3;=?7?6A52A6?:>=??6D=?7 =: :;=: :2>6 :;6 D276D 14 =?1:;6D >1:1D<9<56 86=D2?A D6A23:D=:21? 1 !! <=>6 4D1> 1BB132:6 72D6<:21? 2? = D=3; =?7 ?6A52A6?: >=??6D =?7 7=3;67 :1 :;6 >1:1D<9<5614:;6<5=2>=?:3=?7<=E367=<<276?:?:;63=27 - 5 - =<<276?::;6<5=2>=?:33E3:=2?67AD26F1E32?HED263=?7:=@6? :D6=:>6?: =: 13B2:=5 ;6 <5=2>=?:3 42567 <5=2> B6:2:21?3 ;6 :D28E?=5 =3363367 :;6 <1>B6?3=:21? =?7 B=3367 :;6 =C=D7 ;6 <5=2>=?:3 2? 81:; :;6 <=363 42567 :;6 BD636?: =BB6=53 366@2?A 6?;=?<6>6?: 14 :;6 <1>B6?3=:21? =3 =C=D76789:;6:D28E?=5 ) 6=D7:;656=D?67<1E?36541D:;6=BB655=?:3=?7 :;6 56=D?67 <1E?365 41D :;6 ?3ED=?<6 <1>B=?9 2? 81:; :;6 =BB6=53 " 6=D?67 <1E?365 41D :;6 =BB655=?: 2? 1!)/(! C1E57 <1?:6?7 :;=: :;6D6 23 4D=<:ED6 14 D2A;::282==?7428E5==?7:;61<:1D'C;16I=>2?67 :;6 <5=2>=?:;=3 =3363367 :;6 723=8252:9 =:/J=?7 233E67 723=8252:9<6D:242<=:6'I63E8>2:3:;=::;6:D28E?=52? 3B2:6 14 :;=: ;=3 6DD67 2? :=@2?A :;6 723=8252:9 =: J 6 4ED:;6D 3E8>2:3 :;=: :;6 <1>B6?3=:21? =C=D767 E?76D :;6 1:;6D;6=7326B=2?=?73E446D2?A5133142?<1>67ED2?A5=27 EBB6D2174117726:<1?F69=?<6=?7=::6?7=?:<;=DA63=?7 513314=>6?2:263=D61?51C6D327664ED:;6D3E8>2:3:;=: - 6 - 2>B5=?:3 =D6 42I67 =?7 :;6 1<:1D ;=3 3:=:67 :;=: :;6 2>B5=?:3 =D6 :1 86 D6>1F67 41D C;2<; :;6 :D28E?=5;=3?1: =C=D767 =?9 4E:ED6 >672<=5 6IB6?363 6 4ED:;6D 3E8>2:3 :;=::;6:D28E?=5;=36I1?6D=:67:;6?3ED=?<6<1>B=?91? :;6AD1E?7:;=::;67D2F6D14:;61446?72?AF6;2<56C=3?1: ;1572?A7D2F2?A52<6?3664ED:;6D3E8>2:3:;=:24:;67D2F6D 23 ?1: ;1572?A 7D2F2?A 52<6?<6 :;6 :D28E?=5 1EA;: :1 ;=F6 72D6<:67 :;6 ?3ED=?<6 <1>B=?9 :1 B=9 :;6 =C=D7 =>1E?: =?75=:6DD6<1F6D:;63=>64D1>:;61C?6D14:;61446?72?A F6;2<562?F26C14:;6#E7A>6?:14:;61?.856B6I1ED:2? :;6 <=36 14 D6B1D:672? !"#$%& =?7:;676<2321?14 :;231ED:2?:;6<=3614:;6 ''()*+ , - .* 2? /0 . 1 2.3 &345( 43&!6&72:;:;23;6BD=967:1=551C:;6=BB6=5 / 6=D?67 <1E?365 41D :;6 =BB655=?: 2? 1!))! C1E57 <1?:6?7 :;=: :;6 2?HED67 <5=2>=?: ;=3 3E3:=2?67 32>B56 2?HED263 =?7 ;6 C=3 =7>2::67 2? :;6 - 7 - ;13B2:=541D1?67=9;6<5=2>=?:;=32?<EDD67 3/! :1C=D73>672<=56IB6?363;6:D28E?=5;=3=C=D767=3E> 14 3//!! C;2<; 23 1? 51C6D 3276 =?7 :;6 :D28E?=5 ;=3 6DD672?6I1?6D=:2?A:;6?3ED=?<6<1>B=?91?:;6AD1E?7 14?17D2F2?A52<6?<66B5=<2?AD652=?<61?:;6=81F63=27 :C1 76<2321?3 BD=93 41D 42I2?A :;6 52=8252:9 1? :;6 ?3ED=?<6 <1>B=?9=?7:1B=9:;6=C=D7=>1E?:=?75=:6DD6<1F6D:;6 3=>64D1>:;61C?6D14:;6F6;2<56 , 6=D?67 <1E?365 41D :;6 ?3ED=?<6 <1>B=?9 C1E57 <1?:6?7 :;=: :;6 723=8252:9 :=@6? =?7 :;6 <1>B6?3=:21? =C=D767 2? 1),! % 1!)/(!&+ =?7 :;6 <1>B6?3=:21? =C=D767 2? 1)/!%1!))!&<1?3276D2?A:;6?=:ED6 14 32>B56 2?HED263 3E446D67 89 :;6 <5=2>=?: =D6 BD1B6D =?7 <1DD6<: =?7 :;6D6 =D6 ?1 AD1E?73 41D 2?:6D46D6?<6 2? :;6 =BB6=53 ( 64ED:;6D3E8>2:3:;=::;67D2F6D14:;61446?72?A F6;2<56;=7?17D2F2?A52<6?<6=::;6:2>614:;6=<<276?:=?7 1? :;=: AD1E?7 :;6 :D28E?=5 ;=3 D2A;:59 6I1?6D=:67 :;6 - 8 - ?3ED=?<6 <1>B=?9 4D1> B=92?A :;6 <1>B6?3=:21? <<1D72?A59;6BD=93:1723>23381:;:;6=BB6=53 - =F2?A ;6=D7 :;6 56=D?67 <1E?3653 2? 81:; :;6 =BB6=53 :;23 1ED: ;=3 B6DE367 :;6 2>BEA?67 #E7A>6?:3 =?7:;6:D2=51ED:D6<1D73 *) , $+ ! ;67=:614=<<276?:=?7:;6=A6142?HED67=::;6 :2>614=<<276?:=D6?1:2?723BE:6 ;6=<<276?:;=3:=@6? B5=<6 1? /!"!! =?7 1? :;6 7=:6 14 =<<276?: :;6 <5=2>=?: C=3 =A67 ! 96=D3 ;6 <5=2>=?: ;=3 3E3:=2?67 4D=<:ED614D2A;::282==?7428E5==?7:;61<:1D'C;1 ;=36I=>2?67;2>;=3233E67723=8252:9<6D:242<=:6'I ;=3 1B2?67 :;=: :;6 <5=2>=?: ;=3 3E446D67 /J B6D>=?6?: 723=8252:9 =?7 :;6 :D28E?=5 ;=3 :=@6? :;6 723=8252:9 =: J 1?3276D2?A :;6 3=27 2?HED9 =?7 :;6 6F276?<6 14 :;6 723=8252:9 ;=3 :1 86 :=@6? =: "J ;6 :D28E?=5 ;=3 D2A;:59 :=@6?:;62?<1>614:;6<5=2>=?:=: 3,"! B6D>1?:; =?7D2A;:59=BB5267>E5:2B526DG(.?F26C14:;6=81F6:;6 <5=2>=?:236?:2:56:15133144E:ED62?<1>6=341551C3 -$ ,.$ .$.$/0- - 9 - ;6<5=2>=?:;=33E3:=2?67:C14D=<:ED63=?7C=3 2? ;13B2:=5 41D ! 7=93 =?7 <1?3276D2?A :;6 3=>6 :;6 <1>B6?3=:21?=C=D76789:;6:D28E?=52?=3E> 3!!!! :1C=D73B=2?=?73E446D2?A231?51C6D3276=?7:;6<5=2>=?: 236?:2:56:1=3E>14 3"!!!! E?76D:;63=27;6=7;6 :D28E?=5 ;=3 D2A;:59 =C=D767 >672<=5 6IB6?363 14 3!-(-, ;6<5=2>=?:C=3=7>2::672?:;6;13B2:=541D !7=93=?7<1?3276D2?A:;63=>6:;6<5=2>=?:236?:2:56:1 5133 14 2?<1>6 7ED2?A 5=27 EB B6D217 41D :;D66 >1?:;3 2? = 3E>14 3)"! % 3,"! K>1?:;3&;6:D28E?=5 ;=3 ?1: =C=D767 36B=D=:659 41D 4117 726: =::6?7=?: =?7 <1?F69=?<6<;=DA631?3276D2?A:;64=<::;=::;6=BB655=?: C=3 2?B=:26?: 41D! 7=93;6 23 6?:2:56 41D =::6?7=?:4117 726:<1?F69=?<6<;=DA636:<2?=3E>14 3!!!! ;6 1<:1D;=33:=:67:;=:2>B5=?:3=D642I67=?741DD6>1F=514 :;63=>6:;6<5=2>=?:;=3:1E?76DA13EDA6D9=?7;=3:1 3B6?7 =>1E?: 2? :;=: D6A=D7 1?3276D2?A :;6 3=>6 :;6 <5=2>=?: 23 6?:2:56 :1 4E:ED6 >672<=5 6IB6?363 2? = 3E> 14 3!!!! ;6<5=2>=?:23=A67!96=D3:=BB6=D3:;=: ;6 23 ?1: >=DD267 =?7 :;6D641D6 :;6 <5=2>=?: 23 6?:2:56 :1 - 10 - 5133 14 =>6?2:263 2? = 3E> 14 3!!!!! =3 =A=2?3: 3"!!!! =3 =C=D767 89 :;6 :D28E?=5 ? F26C 14 :;6 =81F6 :;6 <5=2>=?: 23 6?:2:56 :1 :1:=5 <1>B6?3=:21? =3 E?76D #1 234-56728-39:8 6728-39:8 3;3<424 => 9?:-@<9 133144E:ED62?<1>6 3))""!! =2?=?73E446D2?A3 3"!!!! 672<=56IB6?363 3!-(-, ) 133142?<1>67ED2?A5=27EBB6D217 3)"! " ::6?7=?:<1?F69=?<64117726:=?7 ?1ED23;>6?:<;=DA63 3!!!! / 13314=>6?2:263 3!!!!! , E:ED6>672<=56IB6?363 3!!!! 931 -, ;6 <5=2>=?: 23 6?:2:56 :1 :1:=5 <1>B6?3=:21? 14 3-!//), =3 =A=2?3: 3/!/!! =3 =C=D767 89 :;6 :D28E?=5C2:;2?:6D63:=::;6D=:614/JB6D=??E> ?81:;=BB6=53:;6:D28E?=5;=36I1?6D=:67:;6 ?3ED=?<6 <1>B=?9 4D1> B=9>6?: 14 <1>B6?3=:21? 1? :;6 AD1E?7 :;=: :;6 7D2F6D 14 :;6 1446?72?A F6;2<56 ;=7 ?1 7D2F2?A52<6?<6 ) ? F26C 14 :;6 76<2321?3 D65267 EB1? 89 :;6 56=D?67 <1E?365 41D :;6 =BB655=?:3 24 :;6 7D2F6D 14 :;6 1446?72?AF6;2<56;=3?17D2F2?A52<6?<6:;6?:;6?3ED=?<6 - 11 - <1>B=?9 ;=3 :1 B=9 :;6 <1>B6?3=:21? =>1E?: :1 :;6 <5=2>=?:=?7D6<1F6D:;63=>64D1>:;61C?6D *) $+ " 3B6DI/ C1E?7<6D:242<=:6:;6<5=2>=?:;=3 3E3:=2?6732>B562?HED9=?7;6C=3=7>2::672?:;6;13B2:=5 41D1?67=9;6<5=2>=?:;=32?<EDD67>672<=56IB6?36314 3/! 1?3276D2?A :;6 2?HED263 3E3:=2?67 89 :;6 <5=2>=?: ;6 23 6?:2:56 :1 = A518=5 <1>B6?3=:21? 14 3"!!!! =3 =A=2?3: 3//!! =3 =C=D767 89 :;6 :D28E?=5 / ?F26C14:;6=81F6:;641551C2?A " %2& 1:;=BB6=53=D6=551C672? B=D:+ %22& ;6<5=2>=?:2?1!)/(!23 6?:2:56 :1 :1:=5 <1>B6?3=:21? 14 3-!//), =3 =A=2?3: 3/!/!! =3 =C=D767 89 :;6 :D28E?=5 C2:;2?:6D63:=::;6D=:614/JB6D=??E>4D1>:;6 7=:614B6:2:21?:2552:3D6=52L=:21?+ - 12 - %222& ;6<5=2>=?:2?1!))!23 6?:2:56 :1 = A518=5 <1>B6?3=:21? 14 3"!!!! C2:;2?:6D63:=::;6D=:614/JB6D=??E>4D1>:;6 7=:614B6:2:21?:2552:3D6=52L=:21?+ %2F& ? 81:; :;6 <=363 :;6 ?3ED=?<6 <1>B=?9 3;=55 B=9 :;6 =C=D7 =>1E?: :1 :;6 D63B6<:2F6<5=2>=?:3C2:;2?:6D63:=?7D6<1F6D:;6 3=>64D1>:;61C?6D14:;61446?72?AF6;2<56 #4 *#)#)+ (" 23:1 51)/