- 1 - IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, DHARWAD BENCH DATED THIS THE 26TH DAY OF AUGUST, 2022 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE RAVI V.HOSMANI REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 5230 OF 2012 (PAR) ! "## $ ! %& ! ! ! !'( ' ! ! ) ! ! )* ' ! ! ) - 2 - ! ! ' ! )! ! ! % % * +,- # # # # *! ! ( % % ! ! % # ! "# $ ! %'$.&/ !%!#! %'& ' ! ! 0 ' # * 1 !)!) # !!!)* ' ' - 3 - ## ' !*!) # !!! )2 ' ' % $!!& ' '# ## ! ## ' ! ' ! +3345 6+7 89734- :;5 ,;,.<;=>89+,<4 ;, ;::9<4 ;?@4<39;, ;,)*!!)))!'A53B4539=4;:36;644C7;,>+D=4,3;:<;73 ;:7!).+,-79,<4,44-:A86+7,;3-;,4=+33456+789734- ;,2!!)))!'A53B4536;644C739=497E5+,34-!B454+:345 =+33459789734-3;-+D!493B45<;7397>+9-,;5;::9<4;?@4<39;,7 +54<;=>894-!B979,-9<+3473B+3+>>488+,397,;39,3454734-9, >A57A9,E +>>4+8! 4,<4 +>>4+8 97 -97=9774- :;5 ,;, >5;74<A39;,! VMB