- 1 - !!" !#$%& ' %("!"# )%* ! " # # ##$ ! ! !! % &# & ' # &! %% ( % ' Digitally signed by NIJAMUDDIN JAMKHANDI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # ( &! & !! # ( # & ) ! " $ #()" #)$ ! # #)* #)% # ! ! ( ) # ! (( ! && ! ! # ! " ! # & # ) $ - 3 - ! ( ! + ! ()% ,,,# # & "'$ !# , ! ! - -. & ! ! ! /012 13 1//40560 7/018/2 /8391 9:86/7 0;;/0138<98=/>07?9?13136>80:15>@#?91;/535398/1 082 13 !>0838210 7/018/2 /8391 9:86/7 0;;/0138< 98 =/>07? 9? 13 0<010A:7: 032: ?91 B04/0591 1/6;982/859 !0153/6595>/;/53539866>077=/1/?/11/25906;/1 5>/316505:6=/?91/5>/513079:15 % >36 ;/535398 36 ?37/2 =@ 5>/ ;/535398/12/?/82085 9 59 C:06> 5>/ 3D;:<8/2 912/1 205/2 ;066/2 98 9 ?37/2 :82/1 /B5398 9? ! 38 9D9()% =@ ,,,# 223539807 35@ 3437 - 4 - 082 /663986 &:2</ 9DD/1B307 9:15 /8<07:1: "'$ >/ ;703853?? ?37/2 0 6:35 0<03865 5>/ 2/?/820856 6//E38<?9779F38<1/73/?6- ! " ! # $ $! $ ! % " & %'(')*)')+, *-%./%).)) 0 ! ! 1 2 .(%.'%).-3 0 %-45 6 % !" & %*7/)3..+, 0 $ 8$! &9 :8& %-)34'*'(+, 0 -45 6 % " -3..... ! -.%.4%).)) $! ! ; - 5 - " ! < ! ! ! !! ! !% " =0 ! !! ! $ ! # % :138<5>/;/82/8B@9?5>/6:355>/;703853???37/2 9 :82/1 /B5398 9? ! 6//E38< 1/7/06/ 9? 0D9:85 2/;9635/2 =@ 2/?/82085 9 59F0126 1/85 >/ 60320;;73B05398B0D/59=/0779F/208235F06912/1/259 1/7/06/ 5>/ 0D9:85 9? 6) 38 ?049:1 9? 5>/ ;703853??98?:1836>38<08382/D835@=9825>05385>//4/85 5>/ 9:15 912/16 59 1/?:82 5>/ 6032 0D9:85 6>/ F9:72 2/;96355>/60D/385>/9:15 /38<0<<13/4/2=@5>/6032912/15>/;/535398/1 2/?/82085936=/?91/5>369:15 ( 5 36 5>/ B985/85398 9? 7/018/2 6/8391 B9:86/7 1//40560 0;;/0138< ?91 /6;982/85 9 5>05 5>/ 3D;:<8/2912/1205/2;066/298 936 ;/14/16/ 377/<07 01=35101@ 082 B985101@ 59 70F / =19:<>5 59 5>/ 8953B/ 9? 5>/ 9:15 5>/ 912/1 205/2 - 6 - %;066/2=@5>/513079:1598 9%F>3B> 1/02606:82/1- G 9% ?37/2 =@ 5>/ ;703853?? :82/1 /B5398 9? ! 36 0779F/2 082 2/?/82085 936231/B5/2592/;96350D9:859? 670E>6 ;/1 D985> "/C:3407/85 59 02D355/2 1/85$ ?19D 5>/205/9?6:355377205/9?236;96079?5>/6:35 5 36 D02/ B7/01 5>05 08@ 0D9:85 69 2/;9635/2 6>077 =/ 02A:65/2 59F0126 20D0</6)D/68/;19?356 91 011/016 9? 1/85 F>3B> D0@ =/ :753D05/7@ 0F012/2 38 5>/ 6:35 082 38 B06/ 89 6:B> 2/B1// 36 D02/ 38 ?049:1 9? 5>/ ;703853??5>/85>/60320D9:856>077=/1/?:82/2 595>/2/?/820859 >/ 2/?/82085 9 36 231/B5/2 59 2/;9635 5>/0=94/0D9:85?19D205/9?6:355377:;59205/ F35>38 ;/1392 9? ?9:1 F//E6 ?19D 5920@ 082 59 B98538:/592/;96355>/0=94/0D9:852:138<5>/ ;/82/8B@9?5>/6:35G ( >/1/?91/ 35 36 B985/82/2 =@ 7/018/2 6/8391 B9:86/75>0508@0D9:852/;9635/2=@5>/;/535398/165 2/?/82085 6>077 =/ 02A:65/2 59F0126 20D0</6)D/68/ - 7 - ;19?356 91 011/016 9? 1/85 F>3B> D0@ =/ :753D05/7@ 0F012/2385>/6:3508238B06/896:B>2/B1//36D02/38 ?049:1 9? 5>/ ;703853?? 5>/8 5>/ 6032 0D9:85 6>077 =/ 1/?:82/2595>/2/?/820859 ( 5 36 0769 B985/82/2 =@ 7/018/2 6/8391 B9:86/7 5>05 5>/ ;/535398/165 2/?/82085 B>077/8</2 5>/ 912/1 205/2%;066/298 9%=/?91/5>369:1538 ! 9%) 082 B988/B5/2 D055/16 082 5>36 9:15 236;96/2 9? 5>/ 6032 F135 ;/5353986 =@ 08 912/1 205/2 5> /;5/D=/1 F>/1/38 05 ;010<10;> 35 36 >/72 06 :82/1- G 986/C:/857@ 5>/ F135 ;/5353986 65082 236;96/2 9? F>37/ ;/1D35538< 5>/ ;/535398/1) 2/?/8208589592/;96355>/011/0169?1/8506 231/B5/2=@5>/9DD/1B3079:15F35>380;/1392 9?63H5@ "$ 20@6 ?19D 5>/205/ 9? 1/B/3;5 9? 0 B9;@9?5>36912/112/1/20BB91238<7@G (% 5 36 B985/82/2 =@ 7/018/2 6/8391 B9:86/7 5>05 5>/912/1 205/2 %;066/2=@ 5>/513079:15 >06 - 8 - D/1</2 F35> 5>/ 912/1 ;066/2 =@ 5>36 9:15 >/8 5>/ 912/1 205/2 % ;066/2 98 9% >0438< 895 =//8D923?3/2911/4/16/235F9:7289573/?915>/;703853?? 59 ?37/ 0 6/;0105/ 0;;73B05398 6//E38< 1/7/06/ 9? 5>/ 0D9:85>/513079:15F35>9:550E38<3859B98632/105398 5>/ 912/1 ;066/2 =@ 5>/ 51307 9:15 98 9% /1198/9:67@ 0779F/2 9 082 912/1/2 59 1/7/06/ 0 6:D9? 6)2/;9635/2=@5>/;/535398/165 2/?/82085 38 ?049:1 9? 5>/ ;703853?? 98 ?:1836>38< 5>/ 382/D835@=982/B985/8265>055>//8531/0;;190B>9? 5>/513079:1536B985101@5970F0825>/912/16;066/2=@ 5>/513079:1506F/77065>369:15 ( /018/2 6/8391 B9:86/7 ?:15>/1 B985/826 5>05 ;/535398/1)65 2/?/82085 >06 ?37/2 B9:85/1B703D 082 >/1 B703D 8//26 59 =/ >/012 98 D/1356 082 2:138< 5>/ ;/82/8B@9?5>/60D/5>/513079:15912/138<?911/7/06/ 9? 5>/ 0D9:85 98 ?:1836>38< 382/D835@ =982 36 895 ;19;/1/8B/5>/3D;:<8/2912/1;066/2=@5>/51307 9:1536;/14/16/377/<070828//2659=/6/50632/ - 9 - ( 5 36 0769 B985/82/2 =@ 7/018/2 6/8391 B9:86/7 5>05 5>/ ;/535398/1 65 2/?/82085 >06 ;032 0 6:D 9? 6) 06 02408B/ 0D9:85 082 5>/ 65 1/6;982/85;703853??36/8A9@38<5>/60D/?19D 5377 205/ 082 5>/ 60D/ >06 895 =//8 50E/8 3859 B98632/105398=@5>/513079:15 ( 85>/6/ <19:826 7/018/26/8391B9:86/7 6//E6 59 6/5 0632/ 5>/ 3D;:<8/2 912/1 082 B986/C:/857@ 0779F 5>/;/535398 ' !/1 B98510 13 !>0838210 7/018/2 6/8391 B9:86/7 0;;/0138< 98 =/>07? 9? 7/018/2 B9:86/7 13 0<010A:7:032:?91651/6;982/85);703853??B985/8265>05 5>/ ;703853?? 36 5>/ 0=697:5/ 9F8/1 9? 5>/ 6:35 6B>/2:7/ ;19;/15@>/2/?/820859365>/5/80850820=697:5/7@ 5>/1/3689236;:5/F35>1/<01259A:1071/7053986>3;9?5>/ 70827912 082 5/8085 =/5F//8 5>/ ;703853?? 082 5>/ 65 2/?/82085 53607696//85>0506:D9? 6) >06=//82/;9635/2=@2/?/82085938;:16:08B/9?5>/ 912/1 ;066/2=@ 5>36 9:15 5 36 0769895236;:5/25>05 - 10 - 5>/65 2/?/82085>06 D02/ 0 B9:85/1B703D ?91 20D0</6 9? 6 B191/6 0<03865 5>/ ;703853?? 5 36 0769 6//8 5>05 5>/513079:15F>37/;06638<5>/3D;:<8/2912/1>0650E/8 B9<83I08B/ 9? 5>/ /0173/1 912/1 205/2 % ;066/2 98 9%F>3B>3689F1/73/2=@7/018/2B9:86/7?91 2/?/820856@08912/1205/2%;066/298 9% 5>/ 51307 9:15 D02/ 35 B7/01 5>05 08@ 0D9:85 2/;9635/2=@ 5>/65 2/?/82085 6>077 =/ 02A:65/2 59F0126 20D0</6 D/68/ ;19?356 011/016 9? 1/85 F>3B> D0@ =/ :753D05/7@0F012/2385>/6:3508238B06/896:B>2/B1// 36D02/38?049:19?5>/;703853??5>/85>/0D9:856>077=/ 1/?:82/2595>/2/?/820856>/513079:15>0438<50E/8 B9<83I08B/ 9? 5>/ ?0B5 9? /0173/1 912/1 >06 0779F/2 5>/ 0;;73B05398 ?37/2 =@ 5>/ ;703853?? ?91 F35>210F07 9? 5>/ 0D9:85 082 912/1/2 ?91 1/7/06/ 9? 5>/ 0D9:85 98 ?:1836>38<9?382/D835@=982=@5>/;703853?? 8?0B55>/ 65 2/?/82085 36 65377 2:/ 9? 08 0D9:85 9? 6%) 06;/15>/912/1;066/298 9%F>3B>36@/559=/ ;0320825>/60D/368952/;9635/2/1/7@=/B0:6/5>/ - 11 - 652/?/82085>06?37/2B9:85/1B703D6//E38<20D0</635 36 895 ;19;/1 59 659; 5>/ ;703853?? ?19D F35>210F38< 91 :5373I38<5>/0D9:852/;9635/259F01261/85 ' 8 5>/6/ <19:826 7/018/2 6/8391 B9:86/7 B985/826 5>05 5>/1/ 36 89 377/<0735@ 91 ;/14/1635@ 38 5>/ 3D;:<8/2912/1;066/2=@5>/513079:15>/1/?91/>/ 6//E659236D3665>/;/535398082B986/C:/857@0??31D5>/ 912/1;066/2=@5>/513079:15 0438< >/012 7/018/2 6/8391 B9:86/76 98 /35>/1 632/5>/;93855>050136/6?91B98632/105398385>/;1/6/85 F135;/53539836- G>/5>/1 5>/ 3D;:<8/2 912/1 ;066/2 =@ 5>/513079:1536;/14/16/91377/<070821/C:31/6 59=/6/50632/J 2D355/27@5>/1/3689236;:5/F35>1/<012595>/ < 1/7053986>3; 9? 70827912 082 5/8085 =/5F//8 ;703853?? 0822/?/820859>/2/?/820859F065>/5/8085 :82/1 ;703853?? ?91 0 D985>7@ 1/85 9? 6) >9:<> 5>/1/ 01/ 6/4/107 077/<053986 082 B9:85/1 - 12 - 077/<0539860<03865/0B>95>/1F35>1/<012596505:69?5>/ ;19;/15@805:1/9?5>/;19;/15@0820769F35>1/<01259 ;19;/15@ =/38< 6:=6/C:/857@ 2/4/79;/2 =@ 5>/ 65 2/?/82085 5>/ 60D/ F9:72 =/ 2/B32/2 38 5>/ 6:35 0?5/1 B9D;7/5398 9? 5>/ 51307 >/ ;9385 5>05 0136/6 ?91 B98632/10539836F>/5>/15>/0D9:852/;9635/2=@5>/65 2/?/82085 082 912/1/2 59 =/ 1/7/06/2 38 ?049:1 9? 5>/ ;703853??3659=/6:65038/291895J >/513079:15>0650E/8895/9?5>//0173/1912/1 205/2 % 98 9% 082 =/38< 0F01/ 9? 5>/ 60D/ ;066/2 5>/ 3D;:<8/2 912/1 ?91 1/7/06/ 9? 6) 38 ?049:1 9? 5>/ ;703853?? 98 ?:1836>38< 382/D835@ =982 5>05 38 5>/ /4/85 9:15 912/16 59 1/?:82 5>/60320D9:856>/F9:722/;96355>/60D/385>/9:15 >/ ?0B5 1/D0386 5>05 5>/ ;703853?? 36 5>/ 70827912 9? 5>/ 6:35 6B>/2:7/ ;19;/15@ 082 2/?/82085 89 36 5>/ 5/8085 536076989538236;:5/5>055>/652/?/82085>06D02/0 B9:85/1B703D 6//E38< 20D0</6 59 08 /H5/85 9? 6 B191/6 F>3B> D/1/7@ B08895 659; 5>/ ;703853?? ?19D - 13 - F35>210F38< 91 :5373I38< 5>/ 0D9:85 2/;9635/2 59F0126 1/85 =06/2 98 F>3B> 5>/ 65 2/?/82085 36 ;1/6/857@ B98538:38< 38 5>/ 6:35 6B>/2:7/ ;19;/15@ 8?0B5 35 36 5>/ 7/<07 13<>5 9? 5>/ ;703853?? 59 F35>210F 5>/ 0D9:85 2/;9635/2=@5>/652/?/8208559F01261/85>/B9:85/1 B703D9?5>/;/535398/1)652/?/820858//2659=/>/012082 2/B32/298D/1356 ?050776>/6:BB//266>/F9:72=/ /85357/2 59 5>/ 20D0</6 06 B703D/2 38 5>/ B9:85/1B703D >/ 51307 9:15 >06 50E/8 B9<83I08B/ 9? 5>/ 912/1 205/2 %;066/298 9%0825>/6032912/1F9:72 895 1/6513B5 5>/ ;703853?? ?19D B703D38< 5>/ 0D9:85 =@ 0 6/;0105/ 0;;73B05398 0E38< 3859 B98632/105398 077 5>/6/ 06;/B565>/513079:1513<>57@;066/25>/3D;:<8/2912/1 82/15>/B31B:D6508B/6 29895?38208@<992 <19:82 91 B9</85 1/0698 59 385/1?/1/ F35> 5>/ 3D;:<8/2 912/1 ;066/2 =@ 5>/ 51307 9:15 BB91238<7@ ;066 5>/ ?9779F38<- - 14 - ! 3$ >/F135;/53539836+,-.,--/+ 33$ /6;982/85 9);703853?? 36 /85357/2 59 F35>210F 5>/ 0D9:85 38 2/;9635 =/?91/ 5>/ 51307 9:15 9F/4/1 6>/ 6>077 ?9779F 5>/ 6513B5 231/B53986 366:/2=@5>/513079:15F35>1/<01259382/D835@ =982 12/1/20BB91238<7@ "+0 )!"#* (! !010659! !010659/82 3659-79-%