Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 4096 (KAR)
BHARTHI W/O MANOHAR KARNAL v. STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/100810/2024 · 2025-01-27
S Rachaiah
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 4096 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 4096 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #$# ! %!&$"" & ! ! "
#
$
%
$
& ! '&()))
$ #* +! $
"
$ ," $
! # # )
#))-& )
(- ) ,(.&),&)&, , $ ,
$
))&
! ! ) # ),
$
$
$
. Digitally signed by SREEDHARAN BANGALORE SUSHMA LAKSHMI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
/ +
'
/ + "
# 0123 24 56613 6012703 8957:06 ;92 <=0 >0<4<49702 24 1?0:= =4@124 6012703 ;92 20:>97307< 9 # 173 24 +1@134:= 1<46 6012703 8957:06 ;92 20:>97307< 9 <=295@= A4309 897;020780
=4:>0<4<4974:;4603BC<=0>0<4<497025730208<497 ,"9;2 :00D47@81780661<4979;20@5612B146 @217<03 <9 =02 ;1<=02.47.61E 1885:03 9 BC <=4: 952<4726 9 #))-& )31<03# # )
!()*+,-.-/*,+.*
=0 >0<4<49702 89?>614717< ?122403179=12 E=9 4:1885:039 #17316:9:979;<=020:>97307<9 ;<02 <=0 ?12241@0 <=0 =5:B173 9; <=0 >0<4<49702 E07< <9 02?17C 97 =4: 9;;48416 35<C =0 E1:
20:4347@ E4<= =02 47.61E: 5247@ <=0 :143 >02493 <=0 20:>97307< 9 E1: :07347@ A56@12 ?0::1@0:
- 3 -
17316:9?1D47@:9?0@0:<520:17316:91:D47@=02 <9 39 :9?0 :0F516 ;1A952: 047@ 1779C03 BC <=0 18< 9; 20:>97307< 9 :=0 693@03 1 89?>6147< B0;920 <=0 >96480 1;<02 =1A47@ 0F=15:<03 166 <=0 >9::4B60 1A0750: ;92 =02 :1;0<C =0 G524:348<49716 >96480 =1A0 20@4:<0203 1 81:0 47 24?0 9 (- ) 1@147:<<=01885:03>02:97: , =0 20:>97307< 9 =13 9B<14703 17<484>1<92C B146 ;92 <=0 89?>6147< 693@03 BC <=0 >0<4<49702 =02047 =4: 952< @217<03 B146 97 <=0 89734<497 <=1< =0 :=9563 79< :073 17C ?0::1@0: <9 <=0 89?>614717< =0780;92<= =0 :143 92302 E1: >1::03 97 # # ) 9E0A02 <=0 >0<4<49702 =02047 ?130 1A1461B60 :9?0 3985?07<: 20;608<47@ <=1< <=0 20:>97307< 9 =13 :07< <=0 ?0::1@0: 0A07 1;<02 <=089?>614717<9B<14703120:<2147<92302 & 9E 4< 4: 2060A17< <9 20;02 <=0 G53@?07< 9; <=0 97/B605>20?0952<2061<47@<9<=081780661<4979;
B146 =0 97/B60 5>20?0 952< 47 <=0 81:0 9;
- 4 -
47 >121@21>= 9: #) 173 ## =063 1:
57302. ! " ##$ !%&! ' !"$ ("& )$ *&!+ !& ,$ "- -
"+#! " " " "' "
*&!+ '
"& $ $ "' ##$ # *&!+ !$ - #"- $ "' ("& " -$"-" ! -+! $"# "' " ./0 ( (
"$
"$ ' "+ " *&!+ # "!&! "- 1 2!&,$$((##3/4/5# $5406 75 ! (# 888 " 5.926 +#"- $ ("& $ - $ ("& "' $$" " ! : &$! # $"" $!""5.9206 +#"- $ ("& " ! : # $"-"$ $!"&! (# 888 "' ("! $!! "++!"&$"!:#"- " ! " &$!
# $" ; : "&!$'" ""'
"!: 26 &$! +$&$$ $ : : !&
$+ +
: 26 ' $ - "& $ "'
$" 26 +#$ " +# -
! " -$$$ 2 6 $ -$$$ " !&$ $+ $
1 (2024) 4 SCC 222
- 5 -
- -"&! +# $+"" $" 2 6 $<""!"'$'""
"& :2 6+#$"+<+$'$ :
" &! "&! "
"+ &
" $:2 6 +#$ " # +$' :"! "' $ $& : $ "&!$ &$ ! " =&$
$ ! &! # " $" "
" /3206 '" !'&
"'
# "$&"
"
"+#
$"$=:!:$' !'$ & ! : ' "' 4$ # "$&" +: $< "
! " "&! $" "&!$ "
&$! $
"++! "4
"''!$$$ :" $+ !"+++"&$"!:"-
$4+"! $ " -"&! =# : $ " "&!$ !! 2 &
"', >$"#"'$#"- " ("& &! " 5.9206 $
"$! !:$("& ;&
2"'6 / ;& $ $ ("& $ $&: =#! # " $" !""'&! ("! &! "& !'' $ ' "+ ("! "' ( + "!& ?9? 2'" $" 7 "! - 6 -
("!@6!&!!#"$""'- $4 A4 $ #"- $ "' "& $ ! $ ("& "$ ! $ &! 12((##0.405# /6 B/ " 5.9 "' - ("! "' $ $# #"- $ " ("& " ("& "'$$" ! $-$$"#"$"&! " 59?( ("'"!("!$"$:
' $ '&$$ "
" &$! # $" ("& " ("& "'$$"+:" ! '" "' ## "# $$ + : &! " 5.9206 "' -("!("& " ("&
"' $$" +: ! : # $" -" $ $!"" $! ! "++! " &$"!: "! ("! " 59?206 -$ -" !! $"+- !'' & - $! ("& " ("& "' $$"+:&$:# $"-"$ !+!"&! $&4$" 26" $!!+:"+++
" &$"!: " -" !$ &! " 59?206 "' "! ("! # $" -" ! !+! " : ("& "&! "++! " &$"!: ": : ("& + : ' # $" -$ !+!
" : ("& "' $$" -$ ":
- 7 -
("& "'$$""&!"++ + " &$"!: $ $ " &#" #"- "' + "' ##" '" "++ # $" !: !+! " " &$"!: $ '! - ("! &! " 5.9206 ! " 5.9206 "' - ("! ("& +: "++ # $" $! " &! (# 888::"& &!("&
"' $$" " &$"!: ' <$ ## "# "!"$"+&$"-
+! ("& "' $$"
" - $ !: ! : ("& &$$ - &+$$ $ !& # " $$ "' ' &$! # $"$!+!": ("& ' "- ("& "' $$" ! !+! &$! # $" " $ -"
"#"$ +: +" $$"$ %&!' - &+$$
$- - " <"-" !$$ : '" " ("& +: $ - ## " ("& $&# " "& &! " 5.9206 "
"++ &$! " &$"!:
"- $ !:
" ! "' $$"$ %&! - 8 -
! "- &+$$
"##! &# =# "$ !:=$!$'&'"
"+" $$"$%&!! $ "+# - " +"
("& '" " "' $ #"$" '""-$ ' "+ $&" ! #"$" "' ("& "' $$" $4A4
$("& C 3 $ "= $ # "' " ! &#" !$" "' $ ("& & +$$!$ $ ("& ! 2(( # .5> # 6
"# "' $ $! &*&$'! " # $
" ! $ $"&: !'' ' "+ " ! "' "
"&! &$! $ +$"!&! +$' " &$ "' $"+ $&# &+$$ - $&
" ! D+
"' ;&* 4%&!,"'$("& $ ! '" $! # # ! '& ! -!$"--" $# "' '
- " ## $ $ ("& ! ! !"## = $ "' #"- &! " 5.9206 "' ("!##-$"!!'" $ ("& ("& ! ! :
" ## !$" - # + $'" "'!"
- 9 -
"' , - '' + # # ! !"- & $ $
"$ !- + $
< " "$! " : "&
" ! "' $+ +<$ $!" !
& !$&*"$ &: : ## "& ! " - -"&!&! "./0"'("! $$ $ ("& $ "#! '
" ! "' "' $ # $ $+ $ & ": : $&# "
"& ! $ ' " ""+ '" - : $+"& ? '" $! # #$("& !$" *
"'E *
"' $ "$ ! 1 2(( # ?F/# 96 B9G $$"!$"-
"#
"' $ $! &*&$'!" # $" ! ! " "' " ! "' "
"&! &$! $ +$"!&! +$'
"
$&# &+$$- $&
"'" ! $ # $ " " #$$! "
+ $ &! :
$&# " "& C 9 '" "#"'$$! &*&$'! " # $ " ! $
- 10 -
!'' ' "+"#"'""'
" "&!"'&$!)$+$"!&" - ! $ '$ $& '! '
"' - H& $& " ! # &$ "' '" $! !$"$ -"&! # $ '" &$ " ! ": $ $! "
"&!$"'" " :"-:
"& $&# " ""& - ! !":$+"& 0F $ $ $#"!$ ! '! + +$"&$ #" '" ("& $<
" "' " "&!$ -$ "! : #" $ :
"$$ +$ # $" "' '$ +$! "& ! !& ' &! &$ #"!:"' "' ! H& ! " ! " $ $! " "&! "' # $ - & ! +" -"&! &
"
"'
&+$$
"& " " ! !! " ' : $&"- -$+$&$!: #" 4&$! '" ("&
"&! " ! $! #" !!" "&!$"' # $- 0 $ #! # # "' - - + $ ': !$#"$! "' :"& "& $$"'
- 11 -
! $&" :# " $"'&&$"''"! " ' $ # : '" ' + &$$ ! & #
"&$
" ! "' '!$#"$$$ $!" +"!'!"=$$"$!- *&!+ ! " ! " -!:"& #$$$& *&!+ ! " ! $ "' : =# $$ # " $" ("! '" $+
"./0"'("!"# $$ " : "" -"'$$!$#"$! "':"& $& =#"" $!
$&" : $ " " "' " + " :"& @ I- $ - $! : "' *&!+$ ! ! : $ ("& "$! "$ '"
"' ! " "' : !'' , ! " &$! ": ! ' ("& $ $$'! ' $!"1 26 &$! $ +$&$! : !"+J 26'"&!"!"$"'" ! J 26 -$ ! " "' $&" : # " $"$ $ #"- $ "' ("& " J 2!6 " -$ # "& ! : +$ # $"" ' &! # $ $ " "' $ $&"$ =$!@
- 12 -
7 8120;56 201347@ 9; <=0 1B9A0 348<5? 9; <=0 97/B60 5>20?0 952< <=0 B146 @217<03 <9 17 1885:03817976CB08178066034;<=0952<4::1<4:;403 <=1< 1;<02 B047@ 20601:03 97 B146 <=0 1885:03 =1:
?4:5:03<=064B02<C@217<03<9=4? - 1A47@ 897:430203 <=0 348<5? 9; <=0 97/B60 5>20?0952<47<=0>20:07<81:0<=020120:9?0 3985?07<:E=48=E9563473481<0<=1<<=020:>97307< 9 =1: ?4:5:03 <=0 89734<497: 4?>9:03 BC <=4:
952< =020;9204<4:1>>29>241<0<9817806<=0B146 ( 7 <=0 64@=< 9; <=0 9B:02A1<497: ?130 1B9A0 >298003<9>1::<=0;9669E47@. 4" =024?47160<4<4974:"-! 44" =0 17<484>1<92C B146 @217<03 <9 20:>97307< 9 1885:03 9 47 24?0 9 (- ) 9;
5BB1664.=12E13 4<C 9?07 96480 <1<497 A430 92302 31<03 # # ) 47 24?4716 0<4<4979 #))-& )4:817806603
- 13 -
444" 4B02<C 4: 20:02A03 <9 <=0 20:>97307< 9 # ' 96480 <9 <1D0 1>>29>241<0 :<0>: 47 1889231780 E4<=61E17316:934208<03<=020:>97307<9 # ' 96480 <9 ;9669E <=0 @54306470: 9; 1220:< :<4>561<03 ;92 <=0 1220:< 9; <=0 1885:03 47 <=0 ?1<24?974164::50:
"01
2" 3 $
:: 4:<9 #69