Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body

2025 DAILYLAW 40169 (PNJ)

BIMLA SHARMA v. STATE OF HARYANA

CWP/16646/1999 · 2025-01-13

Tribhuvan Dahiya

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

! "#$ %&'('() % *+,- !" # !" $ %%% & # ' " ' !" & ()*" + ,! !" ) ! " * -./) 0 -./ 1*' " /2/3-+-)*" "" 33)"*)* 4&,! !" ) 5* 5"& ) 0 , 1*)* 6' " //3-.7 33 )2* , " 8 & 2 9" " & 2 4 $ : " ):* " & 32-; ' MANINDER 2025.01.13 10:44 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. 2 "&! 2./-.7 !" " </+--+$ !" "8 8" =5</;-+2 " , &,>?;.+--7 # " 22/=3// "" 8" " & , ! /2/3--+ 6 =3 :@ 1 44& ! 2</+-7+' " </;-+2 22 5 & ! ' : ! " 1'6 ' & 6" /2/3-+-& + -./ 2< " " + & "" ! 1 4 ' ' ' -+-" '6 ;;/ ! " 727=/7/ -./ & " 6" ' " /2/3-+- ! "" + ' " ! & & " 4 ! ? ? $ 4 $ " : " 22/=3// ! 8 5 $? 2+3-;. 23--+3 2 5 A 7+-;- </;-+3 < B 7-;. 7;-+3 3 : /2-;. 2/-+3 7 A' 277-;. 2/-+3 MANINDER 2025.01.13 10:44 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. < 4 ' 272@= 3-+- " 22/=3//' ' 2;/@= 3-+- 4 ' ' 6 ;;/@= ! " 727=/7/ ! -./ 23 1 " " " "" 33 )"* )* , & & ' 8 " " "6 "" '' ! 2///)3*,/<. & " & 27 " 6 33 )2* , ' ' " //3-.7 ' ! " 8 6 " ' # : " 6 & ' ' ! & " ' " //3-.7 "" " & # ' "" ' " 2./-.7 2; & " & " + -./ " 33)"*)* , & & 6 33)2*' " '"" < 5 "&"# " & " " MANINDER 2025.01.13 10:44 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. 3 & "" " " 1 4 ' ' -./ ' 6 ! " ' & + -./ " & " " " & " & & " " " 6 33 , " ! " "" & !" ' &$! " , ! 4 " )* C " " " " & 33)2* , ' " '" " '//3-.7 '! ' " 2./-.7 6 &" " '& ! " ! & 3 C " " ' & " "'& & " + -./ '& " ' ' ' # " & " 22/= 3//' " </;-+2 "8 8" =5 '6 ;;/ ! " 727=/7/ ; -./ ' 6 MANINDER 2025.01.13 10:44 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. 7 " //3-.7 & " 6 /2/3-+-'& " '4 " @ & 6 ! " ' " ' & ' " " & " " '' # "8 8" ""' " ' ' " " ""& "" ' & ! 33 )2* , & ' " &! ( 6' 8 & " "" 6 " '& 6 33)2* 7 !" & " ! & " ; " " 4 : " 32-;' : ' " ' 8! 1 22/=3// ' " </;-+2 "8 8" =5 ! 2</+-7+ ' ' " 2./-.7 " ' ! & ! ! -./ ' " //3-+- ! 14 ' : !8" =5 ' ' 272 ' MANINDER 2025.01.13 10:44 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. ; ' ' 2;/ !" & ' 4 ' 6 ;;/ " 727=/7/ + 5 " 6 " ! " /2/3-+- +)* -./ ' " . /0# "#1# 02 03##425#$,"/6#7 )* 6 " ! ' & 6 "" " ' ;' " -+- & -./ 9 ' ! ! " 6 6 ! " '' 6 " ) ! ! " * 6" ! " '& ' )2*)<* 666 + " //3-+- 14 ' '' : ! ! " " !D;;/ 4 "" +)* -./ & " 6 " ! " ' /2/3-+-5! '" ! & & & & " 8" & " " MANINDER 2025.01.13 10:44 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. + " 1 4 ' ' ' ' ' : ' ' # " : " +2 E " "" , ! 4 +/+2/23 ,>?72-2// ! ' " " # ! '& ; " & & ' ' ' & ! ' ' "' # 6" ' 8 & ! 6 ' ' 8 4 "" ' & " had been given to him as a personal measure. The reasoning is flawed since the Rule makes no such distinction. Further, it has been specifically averred by the petitioner in para 8 of the petition that his juniors wi 8" " ' ( ! " ' " //3-+- 4 ' & ' " ! + -./ ' " ' " /2/3-+- & ! & . " 33)"*)* , ' " 28/02 202/6/9 &! ! ' &! =" '= )*)&* 666 MANINDER 2025.01.13 10:44 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. . )"*)*?' " ' ! """ &! """ " & " " & " & 6 6&! ' & ' ! " & $ F" ' ",555G5! ' " ! ' ' ' ! " " ' & @ )* !&= )2* 33 & "& " ' 6 " 5" ' ! & ' 6 " ' " & 6 ! &=" )*&! H666666 0#0' 666666 . " & " & : " & ' 8 " " & " '& " '' " )* & " & " ! '# & , " )* " # & , ! 2//; )/* ,,27 ' 4 , " ' & MANINDER 2025.01.13 10:44 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. - & @ " & " 5 " " & ' ' #' @ & " " '' " / 4 ' " / " " " 1 " "8 " 8" " ' 5 # A 4 " I " 2///=<7//' "& " 7 !" 5 " , " 6 922)5*)*)* " > ' " ' ' # : " ' ! & " " 6 ' " '& & ' ' # :" " " " ' ' 4 4& , ' ! ' ! & " ! & ' & "! '& 6 33 ? " - & 6 33 , ' " /92"2/02 :4# 1# 01;69##5 & 888 888 &4 " ! 3< 3; ! ' " ' ! MANINDER 2025.01.13 10:44 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. / ( F " &! " ' " ! & =6 &= )* " " ' " ' " =6 ! - 33 6 " ! &= )2* 8 " &! & " " ' " & 6 &= )* " " 5 '& ! & " 6 ! ' ! ' ! & " '! : & 8" & 6 & 8 9 " &! " & " 33)"*)* , " &! " " 33)2*" & "" ! """ 4 " / 5 ! ' " " "" " + -./ ' " /2/3-+- ' " 8 & " ' @ & " & ' ' # " ! " " ' ' ! & = ' " & ! ' 6 " " ' " MANINDER 2025.01.13 10:44 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment. " "" 33)"*)* 6 33)2* , " "" 2 " ")*)* !& " - </2/27 > #@ J > & J MANINDER 2025.01.13 10:44 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this order/judgment.