- 1 - ! " # $ % # & '&()* '&)) % ! ! " # $ %%% " # &' # &'( " (' (%(& # # # ## ( # '# "(%% ## Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # ) * * + !) ,,-./0 1& 23 425/ 1(' (%(& 4/62.7/4/0 89 -30:-;/7 1:2,/ 7<7213 =<5<4<><3<6<4 ?14 1??/3,/. ;-32.=<8:/-30/4/,7213(1?=<4<729<9<9<<3=27< (%( <30 ./,7213. <30 ' 1? 7=/ 302<3 :/,742,279 ,7 5/305/37"(%%2.8/?14/7=2.,1-47-30/4./,7213 &'( 1? 7=/ =<4<729< <6<42@ -4<@.=< <3=27< (%( .//@236<372,2;<71498<2: ( /<40:/<43/0,1-3./:?147=/;<472/. # 23 425/ 1(' (%(& A<. 4/62.7/4/0 89 -30:-;/7 1:2,/ 7<7213 =<5<4<><3<6<4 <6<23.7 =<429<4=<3<307=4//17=/4.?147=/<?14/.<201??/3,/. 13 7=/ 8<.2. 1? 7=/ ?24.7 23?145<7213 0<7/0 ((%(& 4/,/2B/0 ?415 42<::/.= <36/ #14/.7 ??2,/4 -30<@/4/<36/-30:-;/7 <:-@=<5<4<><3<6<4 - 3 - & /727213/4=/4/23A<.<44<9/0<.<,,-./01&237=/ # ;;4/=/30236=2.<44/.7237=/,<./;/727213/4=<0 ?2:/0 4:2.,1& (%(& 8/?14/ 7=/ -42.02,7213<: /..213. 1-47 A=2,= A<. 4/>/,7/0 13 %C((%(& =/4/?14/=/2.8/?14/7=2.1-47 /<43/0 ,1-3./: ?14 7=/ ;/727213/4 .-8527. 7=<7 ;/727213/42.<<642,-:7-4<:,11:2/<6/0<81-79/<4./ =<. 31 ,42523<: <37/,/0/37. / A<. 13:9 A14@236 <. < 0<2:9 A<6/:<81-4/4 23 7=/;41;/479 8/:13623671 <,,-./0 1/2.4/<09<30A2::23671,11;/4<7/A27=7=/;1:2,/ ?147=/;-4;1./1?23B/.726<7213 ,,140236:9=/;4<9.71 <::1A7=/;/727213 /4 ,1374< :/<43/0 26= 1-47 1B/435/37 :/<0/4 =<.1;;1./07=/;/727213 3 7=/ ?24.7 23?145<7213 0<7/0 ((%(& 27 2. 5/37213/0 7=<7 23 7=/ ;41;/479 8/<4236 91 1? <@@<=<::2 B2::<6/ -30:-;/7 <:-@ =<5<4<><3<6<4 2.742,713((%(&13/5<:/8<89/:/;=<37=<002/0 - 4 - <.<4/.-:71?,152362371,137<,7A27=:2B//:/,742,279A24/ A=2,= A<. ?:1A236 13 7=/ ?/3,/ A=2,= A<. ?2D/0 71 7=/ ;41;/479 8/:136236 71 <,,-./0 1 3 7=/ ?24.7 23?145<7213272..7<7/07=<7<,,-./012.7=/1A3/41? 7=/<?14/.<20;41;/4798/<423691<30<,,-./01( A<. 7=/ <3<6/4 1? 7=/ ;41;/479 <30 <,,-./0 1 A<. 7=/ ;/4.13 A=1 A<. A14@236 23 7=/ ;41;/479 ,,-./0 1.(EA/4/;4/./37237=/;41;/47923F-/.7213A=/3 7=/?24.723?145<37=<0B2.27/07=/;41;/47913((%(& <?7/4=/=<04/,/2B/0<,15;:<237<81-77=/0/<7=1?5<:/ 8<89/:/;=<37/727213/4=/4/23A<.<:.1<::/6/0:97<@236 ,<4/ 1? 7=/ ;41;/479 8/<4236 91 302.;-7/0:9 ;/727213/4=<.3117=/4,42523<:<37/,/0/37./2.<6/0 <81-79/<4.<302..<20718/<642,-:7-4<:,11:2//=<. -30/47<@/3 71 ,11;/4<7/ A27= 7=/ ;1:2,/ ?14 7=/;-4;1./ 1?23B/.726<7213 =/<::/6/01??/3,/.<4/317/D,:-.2B/:9 ;-32.=<8:/A27=0/<7=14:2?/25;42.135/37 ' 30/4 7=/ ,24,-5.7<3,/. <5 1? 1;23213 ;4<9/4 5<0/897=/;/727213/4?1464<371?<372,2;<71498<2:3//0. - 5 - 71 8/ <3.A/4/0 <??245<72B/:9 ,,140236:9 ;41,//0 71 ;<..7=/?1::1A236* =/;/7272132.<::1A/0 =/ 4/.;130/37 1:2,/ 14 <39 17=/4 ;1:2,/ 23 7=/ 7<7/1?<43<7<@<<4/024/,7/0714/:/<./7=/;/727213/423 7=//B/371?=2.<44/.723425/1(' (%(&4/62.7/4/089 -30:-;/7 1:2,/ 7<7213 =<5<4<><3<6<4 ?14 1??/3,/. ;-32.=<8:/-30/4/,7213(1?=<4<729<9<9<<3=27< (%( <30 ./,7213. <30 ' 1? 7=/ 302<3 :/,742,279 ,7 5/305/37" (%% ;/30236 23 4:2.,1& (%(& 13 7=/ ?2:/ 1? 7=/ 4: 2.742,7 E /..213. -06/ =<5<4<><3<6<4.-8>/,7717=/?1::1A236,13027213.* < =/ ;/727213/4 .=<:: /D/,-7/ < ;/4.13<: 8130?14<.-51?.%%%% A27=7A1.-4/72/. ?14 7=/ :2@/.-5 71 7=/ .<72.?<,7213 1? 7=/ 23B/.726<72361??2,/4 8 =/;/727213/4.=<::4/6-:<4:9<;;/<48/?14/ 7=/ 42<:1-47A27=1-7?<2:-3:/../D/5;7/089 7=/ 42<:1-47?14B<:204/<.13. - 6 - , =/ ;/727213/4 .=<:: 317 7<5;/4 A27= 7=/ ;41./,-7213 A273/../. <30 =/ .=<:: ,11;/4<7/ A27= 7=/ ;1:2,/ ?14 23B/.726<7213 <30 <;;/<4 8/?14/7=/5A=/3/B/4,<::/0-;13 0 =/ ;/727213/4 .=<:: 317 23B1:B/ 23 .252:<4 1??/3,/.23?-7-4/ +*, &$ % ) 2.71*C:1*( *