Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 37068 (KAR)
MR VINOD RAJ v. STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/84/2025 · 2025-01-31
S Vishwajith Shetty
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 37068 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 37068 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#
$!% &! $ ' (')*+
'** &
!"
# $ % &
' %
%
% % (((
# $
%
&
%
' !" %
% $ !)" & % % !" ' %
% %% %((! $%%((!&''%' '% ' ''% % ! " $&$&( '
% %! ' % %
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
% ' *
% * + %
,,-./0 12 %314/ 5((! 3/61.7/3/0 89 :26:;53/ 54/2
5;1,/ 7:7152 :26:;53/ :<.=12: :22:0: 1.731,7 >53 5>>/2,/. ?-21.=:8;/ -20/3 /,7152. ! " $&$2& ( 5>
% :20 /,7152 ! 5> 7=/ 5@39 35=1817152 ,7 1. 8/>53/ 7=1. ,5-37 -20/3 /,7152 !" 5> %3
%.//<1263/6-;:38:1;
/:307=/;/:32/0,5-2./;>537=/?:371/. " ' 12 %314/ 5((! @:. 3/61.7/3/0 89 :26:;53/ 54/2
5;1,/ 7:7152 :26:;53/ :<.=12: :22:0: 1.731,7 :6:12.7 7=/ ?/717152/3 =/3/12 12171:;;9 >53 5>>/2,/. ?-21.=:8;/ -20/3 /,7152. ! " $&$2& :20 ( 5>
% 52 7=/ 8:.1. 5> 7=/ >13.7 12>534:7152 0:7/0 (((! 3/,/1A/0 >354 7=/ A1,714 ;:09 :6/0 :85-7 9/:3. - 3 -
! -3126 7=/ ,5-3./ 5> 12A/.716:7152 5> 7=/ ,:./ ?/717152/3 =/3/12 @:. :33/.7/0 52 (((! 1. 8:1; :??;1,:7152>1;/08/>53/7=/B-31.01,7152:;/..152.%5-3712 %3;1.,5!(! @:. 3/B/,7/0 52 ((! >7/3 : ;:?./ 5> " 0:9. 7=/3/:>7/3 : >3/.= 8:1; :??;1,:7152 @:. >1;/0 12 %3;1.,5((! @=1,= @:. :;;5@/0 89 7=/ A/39 .:4/ ;/:32/0 /..152. -06/ 89 530/3 0:7/0 ( (! %=:;;/26126 7=/ .:4/ 7=/
,54?;:12:27A1,714 =:0 :??35:,=/0 7=1. %5-37 12 %3;
5 (!>1;/0-20/3/,7152.!"$&5>%3
% =1. ,5-37 89 530/3 0:7/0 ((! =:0 :;;5@/0 7=1. :??;1,:7152527=/635-207=:77=/;/:32/0/..152. -06/ @:.257B-.71>1/012/27/37:121267=/./,5208:1;:??;1,:7152 :77=/.7:6/5>12A/.716:7152@=/27=/3/@:.25,=:26/12 7=/ ,13,-4.7:2,/ =/3/>53/ %3;
5 (! @:. :;;5@/0 :20 7=/ 530/3 ?:../0 89 7=/ ;/:32/0 /..152. -06/ 12 %3;1.,5((! @:. ./7 :.10/ 63:27126 ;18/37975 7=/ ?/717152/375>1;/ :>3/.= ?/7171528/>53/ 7=/ B-31.01,7152:; /..152. %5-37 :>7/3 ,=:36/ .=//7 1. >1;/0 =/?/717152/37=/3/:>7/3=:0.-33/20/3/08/>53/7=/31:;
- 4 -
%5-37 :20 :>7/3 >1;126 5> 7=/ ,=:36/ .=//7 =/ =:0 >1;/0 %3;1.,5(!(!@=1,=@:.3/B/,7/052(! =/3/>53/=/1.8/>53/7=1.%5-37
/:32/0,5-2./;>537=/?/717152/3.-8417.7=:7>354 7=/ :;;/6:7152 >5-20 12 7=/ >13.7 12>534:7152 :20 12 7=/ ,=:36/.=//7171.A/39,;/:37=:7?/717152/3:207=/A1,714 ;:09=:0:,52./2.-:;3/;:7152.=1?:2052;9:>7/37=/.:10 3/;:7152.=1? =:0 >:1;/0 89 4:<126 >:;./ :;;/6:7152 7=/ A1,714 ;:09 =:0 :??35:,=/0 7=/ ?5;1,/ 2A/.716:7152 5> 7=/ ,:./ 1. ,54?;/7/0 :20 7=/ ,=:36/ .=//7 1. >1;/0 ,,530126;9=/?3:9.75:;;5@7=/?/717152
/3 ,5273: ;/:32/0 16= %5-37 5A/324/27
;/:0/3 =:. 5??5./0 7=/ ?/717152 / .-8417. 7=:7 12 7=/ /A/27 ?/717152/3 1. /2;:36/0 52 8:1; =/ 1. ;1</;9 75 7:4?/3 @17= 7=/?35./,-7152@172/.. ,,530126;9=/?3:9.7501.41.. 7=/?/717152
=1.%5-37=:0:;;5@/0%3;
5 (!89530/3 0:7/0 ((! :20 =:0 ,:2,/;;/0 7=/ 3/6-;:3 8:1;
- 5 -
63:27/0757=/?/717152/3897=/;/:32/0/..152. -06/12 %3;1.,5((!
>53 7=/ 3/:.52 7=:7 7=/ ;/:32/0 /..152. -06/=:0/27/37:12/0:./,5208:1;:??;1,:7152 7=5-6=7=/?/717152/3=:0>:1;/0754:</5-7:29,=:26/12 ,13,-4.7:2,/ >53 /27/37:12126 =1. .-,,/..1A/ 8:1; :??;1,:715271.52;9527=/.:10635-207=/8:1;63:27/0 75 7=/ ?/717152/3 @:. ,:2,/;;/0 @17= ;18/379 75 7=/ ?/717152/3 75 >1;/ : >3/.= ?/717152 8/>53/ 7=/ B-31.01,7152:; /..152.%5-37:>7/3,=:36/.=//71.>1;/0=/3/:>7/37=/ ?/717152/3 =:0 .-33/20/3/0 8/>53/ 7=/ 31:; %5-37 12 ,54?;1:2,/ 5> 7=/ 530/3 ?:../0 89 7=1. %5-37 12 %3;
5 (! :20 :>7/3 7=/ ,=:36/ .=//7 @:. >1;/0 =/>1;/0:>3/.=8:1;:??;1,:715212%3;1.,5(!(! @=1,=@:.3/B/,7/052(! /717152/3C.8:1;@=1,= @:.63:27/0897=/31:;%5-37:77=/.7:6/5>12A/.716:7152 @:.,:2,/;;/0897=1.%5-37257524/317.5>7=/,:./8-7 52;9>537=/3/:.527=:77=/31:;,5-37=:0/27/37:12/07=/ .-,,/..1A/ :??;1,:7152 @17=5-7 7=/3/ 8/126 :29 ,=:26/ 12 7=/,13,-4.7:2,/@=/27=/12A/.716:7152@:..71;;?/20126
- 6 -
=/3/:>7/3 12A/.716:7152 =:. 8//2 ,54?;/7/0 :20 ,=:36/ .=//7=:.8//2>1;/0 ) /3-.:; 5> 7=/ :A/34/27. >5-20 12 7=/ >13.7 12>534:71520:7/0(((!:207=/,=:36/.=//7@=1,=
1. 25@>1;/0 :6:12.77=/?/717152/3@5-;065 75.=5@7=:7 ?/717152/3 :20 7=/ A1,714 613; @/3/ @53<126 756/7=/3 12 : ,54?:29 <25@2 :. % :7 :2<:2:09 12 :26:;53/ :<.=12: :22:0: 1.731,7 =/9 @/3/ :,D-:127/075/:,=57=/3>53:,52.10/3:8;/?/31505>714/ =/A1,714;:09@:.:;;/6/0;9.7:912612:3/27/0?3/41./. :20 7=/ ?/717152/3 =:0 =/;?/0 =/3 75 ./,-3/ 7=/ .:10 ?3/41./. 52 3/27 :20 =/ :;.5 .162/0 7=/ 3/27 0//0 :. : @172/.. ;;/6:7152 :6:12.7 7=/ ?/717152/3 1. 7=:7 52
"("("=/=:0,54/757=/3/27/0?3/41./.@=/27=/ A1,714 @:. :;52/ :20 :>7/3 /27/3126 7=/ =5-./ =/ :;;/6/0;9 ,:-6=7 =5;0 5> =/3 :20 =:0 >53,18;/ ./E-:; 127/3,5-3./@17==/3=/27=/A1,714D-/.7152/07=/:,7 5> 7=/ ?/717152/3 =/ :;;/6/0;9 :..-3/0 75 4:339 =/3 :20 :.</0 =/3 257 75 12>534 =1. :,7 75 :298509 =/3/:>7/3
- 7 -
>53:?/31505>:85-752/:20:=:;>9/:3.=/@:.,54126 75 7=/ =5-./ 5> 7=/ A1,714 :20 =:A126 ./E-:; 127/3,5-3./ @17==/3@17=:?3541./754:339=/371.>-37=/3.7:7/0 7=:7 52 ((!?/717152/3 =:0,54/ 75 7=/ =5-./5> 7=/ A1,714 :;526 @17= =1. ?:3/27. @17= : ?35?5.:; >53 4:331:6/ 8-7 7=/9 =:0 :;;/6/0;9 4:0/ : 0/4:20 >53 ?:94/27 5> 05@39 12,/ 7=/ >:41;9 4/48/3. 5> 7=/ A1,714 @/3/ 257 12 : ?5.17152 75 ?:9 7=/ 05@39 :. 0/4:20/0 7=/ ?/717152/3 :20 =1. >:41;9 4/48/3. :;;/6/0;9 3/>-./0 75 4:339 7=/ A1,714 613; :20 17 1. -20/3 7=/./,13,-4.7:2,/..=/=:0:??35:,=/07=/?5;1,/
'3547=/:>53/.:10:.?/,7.5>7=/4:77/317:??/:3. 7=:7 ?/717152/3 :20 7=/ A1,714 ;:09 =:0 : ,52./2.-:; 3/;:7152.=1? :20 7=/ .:10 3/;:7152.=1? ,52712-/0 >53 : ?/31505>453/7=:252/:20:=:;>9/:3.2;9:>7/37=/ 3/;:7152.=1?=:0>:1;/0>53,/37:123/:.52.7=/A1,714;:09 =:0 :??35:,=/0 7=/ ?5;1,/
/717152/3 @=5 =:. 25 57=/3 ,31412:; :27/,/0/27. 1. 12 ,-.7509 >354 (((! - 8 -
2A/.716:7152 5> 7=/ ,:./ 1.
,54?;/7/0 :20 7=/ ,=:36/ .=//7=:.8//2>1;/0 ( 20/3 7=/ ,13,-4.7:2,/. :4 5> 7=/ 5?12152 =1. ?3:9/3 >53 63:27 5> 3/6-;:3 8:1; 2//0. 75 8/ :2.@/3/0 :>>134:71A/;9 ,,530126;9?35,//075?:..7=/>5;;5@126*
=/?/7171521.:;;5@/0 =/ ?/717152/3 1. 013/,7/0 75 8/ /2;:36/0 52 8:1; 12 %314/5((!3/61.7/3/089:26:;53/54/2
5;1,/ 7:7152:26:;53/:<.=12::22:0:1.731,7>535>>/2,/. ?-21.=:8;/-20/3/,7152.! " $&$2&(5>
%:20 /,7152 ! 5> 7=/ 5@39
35=1817152 ,7 .-8B/,7 75 7=/ >5;;5@126,52017152.* :&=/?/717152/3.=:;;/E/,-7/?/3.52:;8520>53: .-4 5> .((((( @17= 7@5 .-3/71/. >53 7=/ ;1</.-4 75 7=/ .:71.>:,7152 5> 7=/ B-31.01,7152:; %5-37F 8&=/ ?/717152/3 .=:;; :??/:3 3/6-;:3;9 52 :;; 7=/ 0:7/.5>=/:31268/>53/7=/31:;%5-37-2;/..7=/
- 9 -
31:; %5-37 /E/4?7. =1. :??/:3:2,/ >53 A:;10 3/:.52.F ,& =/ ?/717152/3 .=:;; 257 013/,7;9 53 12013/,7;9 7=3/:7/2 53 7:4?/3 @17= 7=/ ?35./,-7152 @172/../.F 0&=/ ?/717152/3 .=:;; 257 12A5;A/ 12 .141;:3 5>>/2,/.12>-7-3/F /&=/ ?/717152/3 .=:;; 257 ;/:A/ 7=/ B-31.01,7152 5> 7=/ 31:; %5-37 @17=5-7 ?/341..152 5> 7=/ .:10 %5-37 -271; 7=/ ,:./ 3/61.7/3/0 :6:12.7 =14 1. 01.?5./05>>
,+- '% &! * ! 1.75*;5* %*