- 1 - !" #$ %# " & '&()* &)) % ! " # " $ % & ' #" % #& $ % & Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " % " & % & ' () ' ! * #%&%& #%&%& ) ! ! + + ,- ! - ../012 3 45 3 6152457 8193:1 ;<1 61.4=>3/:;93:.353?4.9915010157=>/:/:1740;1:12 93: ;<1 39915.10 6/540<=8>1 /521: 1.;435 #%&%8& =52 #%&%.& 39 ;<1 /0;3?0 .; ) =:40457 3/; 39 3' () 39 157=>/:/ '35=> 54; 157=>/:/ 40 8193:1 ;<40 3/:; /521: 1.;435" 39:011@457=5;4.46=;3:A8=4> 1=:2>1=:512.3/501>93:;<16=:;410 1=:512 1543: .3/501> =661=:457 93: ;<1 61;4;4351: 0/8?4;0 ;<=; ;<1 ?=B4?/? 6/540<?15; 93: ;<1 - 3 - =>>1712 39915.10 40 4?6:4035?15; 93: = 61:432 39 01C15 A1=:0 ../012 3 D<3 D=0 =::10;12 45 ;<1 6:1015; .=01<=26>1=2127/4>;A=52;<1:4=>3/:;8A3:21:2=;12 #) <=0 015;15.12 <4? ;3 /521:73 04?6>1 4?6:4035?15; 93: = 61:432 39 2=A0 =52 6=A 9451 39 0# 1=.< 93: ;<1 39915.10 6/540<=8>1 /521: 1.;4350 #%&%8& =52 #%&%.& 39 ;<1 /0;3?0 .; )=52;<1015;15.1403:21:12;3:/5.35./::15;>A1 0/8?4;0 ;<=; =../012 3 D=0 .=/7<; :12<=5212 D<1:1=0;<161;4;4351:D=053;93/52=>357D4;<=../012 3=01235;<1.3591004350;=;1?15;39=../0123 :1.3:212/521: 1.;435 39;<1/0;3?0 .;);<1 61;4;4351:40=::=47512=0=../01245;<16:1015;.=01<1 61;4;4351:40:1=2A=52D4>>457;3.3361:=;18193:1;<1:4=> 3/:;=52<10<=>>=>03=84218A=5A.3524;4350;<=;?=A 814?6301235<4?10/8?4;0;<=;61;4;4351:,0?3;<1:40 53;D1>>=52<1409=.45701:43/024994./>;A;3;:=C1>;3524= 81.=/01 39 615215.A 39 ;<1 =93:10=42 .:4?45=> .=01 ..3:2457>A<16:=A0;3=>>3D;<161;4;435 - 4 - " 1: .35;:= >1=:512 .3/501> =661=:457 93: ;<1 :10635215;<=03663012;<16:=A1:?=2145;<161;4;435 10/8?4;0;<=;;<161;4;4351:<=08115=80.35245793:;<1 >=0;?3:1;<=594C1A1=:0=52;<3/7<.31:.4C10;160D1:1 ;=@15 ;3 01./:1 <40 6:1015.1 <1 <=0 8115 1C=2457 ;<1 0=?110/8?4;0;<=;045.1;<161;4;4351:4053D:1042457 =; 457=63:14;D3/>28124994./>;;301./:1<406:1015.1 ..3:2457>A<16:=A0;3240?400;<161;4;435 # 3?6>=45;45;<16:1015;.=01D=094>12=7=450; ;<1 =../012 61:0350 D4;< =5 =>>17=;435 ;<=; ;<1A <=2 =;;1?6;12 ;3 0?/77>1 93:1475 ./::15.A 3/; 39 524= D4;<3/;21.>=:457;<10=?18193:1;<1/0;3?0 /;<3:4;410 =; 524= =52 ;<1:193:1 ;<1A <=2 .3??4;;12 ;<1 39915.10 6/540<=8>1/521: 1.;4350#%&%8&=52#%&%.&39;<1 /0;3?0 .;);4053;452406/;1;<=;=../0123 D<3 D=0 =::10;12 45 ;<1 6:1015; .=01 <=0 0/801E/15;>A 6>1=212 7/4>;A 8193:1 ;<1 :4=> 3/:; =52 ;<1 :4=> 3/:; <=0015;15.12<4?;3/521:7304?6>14?6:4035?15;93:= 61:432392=A0=526=A9451390#1=.<93:;<1 - 5 - =93:10=42 39915.10 <1 ?=B4?/? 6/540<?15; 93: ;<1 =>>1712 39915.10 40 4?6:4035?15; 93: = 61:432 39 01C15 A1=:0 ; 40 53; ;<1 .=01 39 ;<1 6:301./;435 ;<=; ;<1 61;4;4351: <=0 =5A 3;<1: .:4?45=> =5;1.1215;0 <1 61;4;4351:<=0/521:;=@15;3.3361:=;1D4;<;<1:4=>3/:; 93: ;<1 6/:630139240630=> 39;<1 .:4?45=> .=01 D<4.<40 53D61524574538193:1;<1 61.4=>3/:;93: .353?4.9915.10=;157=>/:/=52<1<=0/521:;=@15;3 =84218A=5A.3524;4350;<=;?=A814?6301235<4?<1 61;4;4351: <=0 =>03 /521:;=@15 ;3 .3361:=;1 93: 9/:;<1: 45C10;47=;43549=5A 350421:457;<1=93:10=42=061.;039;<1?=;;1: =?39;<13645435;<=;;<16:=A1:?=218A;<161;4;4351: 45 ;<40 61;4;435 011@457 =5;4.46=;3:A 8=4> 51120 ;3 81 7:=5;12 0/8F1.; ;3 4?630457 =66:36:4=;1 .3524;4350 35 <4?D<4.<D3/>2;=@1.=:139;<1=66:1<1504351B6:10012 8A >1=:512 .3/501> =661=:457 93: ;<1 :10635215; ..3:2457>A93>>3D4573:21:406=0012+ - 6 - <1.:4?45=>61;4;43540=>>3D12 <1 :10635215; 3: =5A 3;<1: 63>4.1 45 ;<1 ;=;1 39 =:5=;=@= =:1 24:1.;12 ;3 :1>1=01 ;<1 61;4;4351: 45 ;<1 1C15; 39 <40 =::10; 45 3 6152457 8193:1 ;<1 3/:;39 61.4=> 3/:; 93: .353?4. 9915010 157=>/:/ =:40457 3/; 39 3' () 39157=>/:/'35=>54;157=>/:/:1740;1:1293:;<1 39915.10 6/540<=8>1 /521: 1.;435 #%&%8& =52 #%&%.& 39 ;<1 /0;3?0 .; ) 0/8F1.; ;3 ;<1 93>>3D457.3524;4350+ <161;4;4351:0<=>>=661=:8193:1;<1:4=> 3/:; D4;<45 351 ?35;< 9:3? ;<1 2=;1 39 ;<40 3:21: =52 0<=>> 1B1./;1 = 61:035=> 8352 93: = 0/? 39 0 D4;< ;D3 0/:1;410 93: ;<1 >4@10/?;3;<10=;409=.;43539;<1:4=>3/:;3/; 39D<4.<3510/:1;A0<=>>81>3.=>0/:1;A <1 61;4;4351: 0<=>> 0/::1521: <40 6=0063:; 8193:1 ;<1 :4=> 3/:; 35 ;<1 2=;1 <1 =661=:0 8193:1 ;<1 :4=> 3/:; =52 ;<1 0=?1 0<=>> 81 - 7 - 0/8F1.;;39/:;<1:3:21:0;<=;?=A816=00128A ;<1:4=>3/:; <161;4;4351:0<=>>:17/>=:>A=661=:8193:1 ;<1:4=>3/:;D4;<3/;9=4>/5>1001B1?6;128A ;<1:4=>3/:;93:C=>42:1=0350 " <1 61;4;4351: 0<=>> 53; ;=?61: D4;< ;<1 6:301./;435 D4;510010 =52 <1 0<=>> .3361:=;1 D4;< ;<1 :10635215; 93: 45C10;47=;435 =52 =661=:8193:1;<1?D<151C1:.=>>12/635 # <1 61;4;4351: 0<=>> 53; 45C3>C1 45 04?4>=: 39915.10459/;/:1 +*, &$ %# ) # 40;3+) >3+ +