- 1 - ! " # $ % # & &'() * &(( % ! "# # $ % % &&& ! # $ # % '( # !% ') $ # ##('&' !###&&'$ ## Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # " % %% & & ( ' '% # % * * + " " # ,,-./0 1# 23 ##1#&&' 4/30235 6/718/ 9:/ ,1-89 17 9:/ 00;# 2.982,9 <30 /..213. "-05/ <=<3<5<8< 299235 <9 <3<><4-8< <82.235 1-9 17 82=/ 1#('&'8/52.9/8/06?<3<><4-8<-8<;1;2,/9<9213 <=<3<5<8< 718 177/3,/. 4-32.:<6;/ -30/8 ./,9213. & &('8@/,9213'17 2.6/718/9:2.1-89 -30/8/,9213'(178##.//>2358/5-;<86<2;# # /<809:/;/<83/0,1-3./;7189:/4<892/.# # % 23 82=/ 1#('&' @<. 8/52.9/8/0 6? <3<><4-8< -8<; 1;2,/ 9<9213 <=<3<5<8< 2.982,9 23292<;;? 718 177/3,/. 4-32.:<6;/ -30/8 ./,9213. & & 8@'17 <5<23.9<A2>-=<8<3019:/8.139:/6<.2. 17 9:/ 728.9 23718=<9213 0<9/0 &#&#&' 8/,/2A/0 781= - 3 - 20?<3<30<10/,/<./0-3<30<==<#/929213/8:/8/23 @<. <88<?/0 <. <,,-./0 1# 23 9:/ % # -8235 9:/ ,1-8./ 17 23A/.925<9213 .:/ @<. <88/.9/0 13 &(#&#&' <30 .-6./B-/39;? 8/=<30/0 91 C-02,2<; ,-.910?# 3A/.925<9213 17 9:/ ,<./ 2. ,1=4;/9/0 <30 ,:<85/ .://9 :<.6//372;/0<5<23.99:8//4/8.13.#/929213/82.<88<?/0 <.<,,-./01#239:/,:<85/.://9#<2;<44;2,<921372;/0 6?9:/4/929213/86/718/9:/"-82.02,9213<;/..213.1-8923 8;# 2.,#1#&' @<. 8/C/,9/0 13 &)##&'# :/8/718/.:/2.6/718/9:2.,1-89# '# /<83/0 ,1-3./; 718 9:/ 4/929213/8 .-6=29. 9:<9 4/929213/8 2. < ;<0? <5/0 <61-9 ?/<8. <30 .:/ :<. 31 19:/8 ,82=23<; <39/,/0/39# ,,-./0 1# 2. :/8 :-.6<30 <30 <,,-./0 1# 2. :/8 7<9:/8# ,,-./0 1# :<. 6//3 58<39/08/5-;<86<2;6?9:2.,1-89238;##1#&'# ;;/5<921317.=19:/82359:/0/,/<./0<30,1==2992359:/ =-80/8 2. 13;? <5<23.9 <,,-./0 1## ,,180235;? :/ 48<?.91<;;1@9:/4/929213# - 4 - # /8 ,1398< ;/<83/0 25: 1-89 1A/83=/39 ;/<0/8 :<.1441./09:/4/929213# # /8-.<; 17 9:/ =<9/82<; 13 8/,180 @1-;0 51 91 .:1@ 9:<9 <,,-./0 1.# <30 :<0 61881@/0 =13/? 781= 0/,/<./0-3<30<==<<30<;.1781=.1=/19:/8,:<85/ .://9@293/../.#23,/<,,-./01.#<30@/8/31923< 41.29213 91 8/4<? 9:/ .<20 <=1-39 9:/? :<0 0/,20/0 91 ,1==29 9:/ =-80/8 17 -3<30<==< <30 <,,180235;? 13 &'#&#&' 13 9:/ 5-2./ 17 8/4<?235 9:/ <=1-39 61881@/0<,,-./01#:<0.-==13/0-3<30<==<<30 :<09<>/3:/823:2.=191862>/6/<82358/52.98<92131# ')')<309:/8/<79/8:<0,1==299/0:/8=-80/86? .=19:/8235:/8910/<9:#:/51;0C/@/;8?@:2,:0/,/<./0 -3<30<=< @<. @/<8235 @<. 9:/8/<79/8 4;/05/0 6? <,,-./01.#<30239:/3<=/17<,,-./01#<301-9 17 9:/ .<;/ 481,//0. 8/,/2A/0 6? 9:/= 6? 4;/05235 9:/ 51;0C/@/;8?17-3<30<==<9:/?:<08/4<209:/<=1-39 61881@/0781=#91#&#;;/5<921317.=19:/8235 0/,/<./0-3<30<==<<30,1==299235:/8=-80/82.13;? - 5 - <. <5<23.9 <,,-./0 1# @:1 2. 9:/ :-.6<30 17 9:/ 4/929213/8 :/8/23# ,,-./0 1# @:1 <;;/5/0;? :<0 23.925<9/0 <,,-./0 1.# <30 91 ,1==29 9:/ =-80/8 17 -3<30<==<:<.6//358<39/08/5-;<86<2;6?9:2.,1-89 238;##1#&'#/929213/82.< =<882/0;<0?<30 <5/0<61-9?/<8.# # 13.20/8235 9:/ 3<9-8/ 17 <;;/5<9213. 71-30 <. <5<23.99:/4/929213/8239:/,:<85/.://9<3023A2/@17 9:/728.9481A2.191/,9213'!$178## <=179:/ 1423213 :/8 48<?/8 718 58<39 17 8/5-;<8 6<2; 3//0. 91 6/ <3.@/8/0<7728=<92A/;?#,,180235;?9:/71;;1@235180/8* :/4/9292132.<;;1@/0# :/ 4/929213/8 2. 028/,9/0 91 6/ /3;<85/0 13 6<2; 23 ##1#&&' 4/30235 6/718/ 9:/ 1-89 17 00;# 2.982,9 <30 /..213. "-05/ <=<3<5<8< 299235 <9 <3<><4-8<<82.2351-91782=/1#('&'8/52.9/8/06? <3<><4-8< -8<; 1;2,/ 9<9213 <=<3<5<8< 2.982,9 718 - 6 - 9:/ 177/3,/. 4-32.:<6;/ -30/8 /,9213. & & ( '8@'17 .-6C/,9919:/71;;1@235,13029213.* <$:/4/929213/8.:<;;/D/,-9/4/8.13<;6130718< .-= 17 .#&&&&& !-4//. 3/ <>: 13;?$ @29: 9@1 .-8/92/. 718 9:/ ;2>/.-= 91 9:/ .<92.7<,9213179:/C-82.02,9213<;1-89E 6$:/ 4/929213/8 .:<;; <44/<8 8/5-;<8;? 13 <;; 9:/ 0<9/.17:/<82356/718/9:/82<;1-89-3;/..9:/ 82<; 1-89 /D/=49. :/8 <44/<8<3,/ 718 A<;20 8/<.13.E ,$ :/ 4/929213/8 .:<;; 319 028/,9;? 18 23028/,9;? 9:8/<9/3 18 9<=4/8 @29: 9:/ 481./,-9213 @293/../.E 0$:/ 4/929213/8 .:<;; 319 23A1;A/ 23 .2=2;<8 177/3,/.237-9-8/E +), &$ % ( 2.91#*(;1#* *