- 1 - ! "# $% &$ # '& #( ' & ! ! "# $%%&$ $# $ %%" ' ( ) Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * * $%%% ! +! , $%%"& ' ( *- ! ) * #" (* #& ) !!!%!# ( #$!%!) * * , * ** !$( ) !$((())* !%##! #### #& &%!% %"!%!%!!%#!! #"* ()(.)(!)() (#) #* * / !%%%( ) (' & , ! * #!# - 3 - $%%& ( ) * * $%%% ! ! , $%%"& ( *- ! ) * #"(#&) !!!%!# (#$!%!) * * , * ** !$ ( )!$(()) * !%()##! #### #& &%!% %"!% !%! !%# !! #" * (!)() (!)( ) ( ) "&" ()()(!)()(#) # * * !%%%( ) * + + 0 , , - 4 - 112345 673 !! 8 !# 9:4 ;4<7:4 =>.3 72:= .6 =>434 =?7@4=.=.763<.A452654:41=.76#":344B.6C:4C2A9:;9.A .6 @A7!!!%!# @465.6C ;4<7:4 =>4 72:= 7< :A .=D .E.A 8 433.763 ,25C4 46C9A2:2 9:.3.6C 72= 7< :.F4 7#$!%!:4C.3=4:45;D9:9@@969 C:9>9:97A.14=9=.76 46C9A2:2 .=D <7: =>4 7<<46143 @26.3>9;A4 2654: 41=.763 !$( ) !$()() 7< =>4 65.96 :F3 1= 41=.763 !% # #! # ## # #& & %! % %" !% !%!!%#!!:495?.=>#"41=.763(!)(E)(!)(E9)7< =>4 8 (:4E46=.76 7< ==:71.=.43) 1= "&" 8 41=.763 ()(.) (!) () (#) 8 # 7< =>4 9:69=9B9 76=:7A 7< :C96.345:.F4 1=!%%% ! 49:5=>4A49:64572634A<7:=>4@9:=.43 * .6 :.F4 7#$!%! ?93 :4C.3=4:45 ;D 9:9@@969 C:9>9:9 7A.14 =9=.76 46C9A2:2 .=D 93 9C9.63= =>:44 69F45@4:3763965&=7%7=>4:3<7:=>47<<46143@26.3>9;A4 2654:41=.76341=.763!$( )!$()()7<=>465.96 :F3 1=41=.763##! ## #&%!!%#&76 - 5 - =>4;93.37<=>4<.:3=.6<7:F9=.76:414.E45<:7F:43@76546=67! >4:4.6G?.<47<541493459>43> # 2:.6C=>4172:347<.6E43=.C9=.769112345673 8!! ?4:49::43=4576!$%&!%!965911234567!#?939::43=45 76!!%&!%!6E43=.C9=.767<=>41934.317F@A4=45965=>4 @7A.14>9E467?<.A451>9:C43>44=9C9.63=!&9112345@4:3763 <7:=>49<7:439.57<<461439<=4:<7AA7?.6C524@:71452:42654: A9? 9.A 9@@A.19=.76 <.A45 ;D =>4 @4=.=.764:3 >4:4.6 ;4<7:4 =>4 :.9A 72:= .6 @A7!!!%!# ?93 :4H41=45 >4:4<7:4 =>4D9:4;4<7:4=>.372:= $ 49:64572634A<7:=>4@4=.=.764:3>9E.6C:4.=4:9=45=>4 C:72653 2:C45 .6 =>4 @4=.=.763 32;F.=3 =>9= 265.3@2=45AD @4=.=.764:3?4:467=@:4346=9==>43@7=7<1:.F476%#%&!%! 965=>476AD9AA4C9=.76939C9.63==>4F.3=>9==>4D>95>4A@45 =>491=29A9339.A96=3=74319@49<=4:17FF.==.6C=>4F2:54:7< 54149345 9>43> = .3 9A37 9AA4C45 =>9= @4=.=.764:3 >95 67= :4E49A45=>4?>4:49;72=37<=>49112345=7=>4@7A.14.63@.=47< =>4D B67?.6C 9;72= =>4 39F4 112345 67!# 9AA4C45AD >95 @:7E.5459576CA4=7911234567@:.7:=7=>459=47<9AA4C45 1:.F4432;F.=3=>9=9112345673"!%!8!$=7! 93 - 6 - 9C9.63=?>7F3.F.A9:9AA4C9=.7639:4<7265.6=>41>9:C43>44= >9E4;4469A:495D46A9:C4576:4C2A9:;9.A;D=>4 :.9A72:= 965=>4:4<7:4=>4 :.9A72:=?9367=H23=.<.45.6:4H41=.6C=>4 ;9.A9@@A.19=.767<=>4@4=.=.764:3 4: 176=:9 A49:645 >93 7@@7345 =>4@4=.=.763 4 32;F.=3 =>9= =>4 @4=.=.764:3 9:4 @4:3763 ?.=> 1:.F.69A 96=414546=3 112345673 8!!?4:4@9:=7<=>4C96C?>.1> >9549:A.4:C764=79AA9:.76!%$!%!=717FF.==>4F2:54: 7< 9>43> 965 =>4:4 .3 @:.F9 <91.4 F9=4:.9A =7 3>7? =>9= =>4 9112345 673 8 !! >95 E.3.=45 9AA9:. 965 3=9D45 .6 >7=4A :77F9653.6149>43>?9367=:4A49345<:7F9AA9:.,9.A=>4D >95 :4=2:645 ;91B 112345 67!# >95 32@@A.45 9 576CA4 =7 9112345 67 @:.7: =7 =>4 59=4 7< 1:.F4 ?>.1> ?93 2345 ;D 911234567<7:17FF.33.767<1:.F449117:5.6CAD@:9D3=7 5.3F.33=>4@4=.=.763 = .3 67= .6 5.3@2=4 =>9= @4=.=.764:3 >4:4.6 ?4:4 67= @:4346= 9= =>4 3@7= 7< .61.546= ?>46 =>4 91=29A 9339.A96=3 17FF.==45 =>4 F2:54: 7< 54149345 9>43> 76 %#%&!%! 9= 9;72=!%>72:3 >49AA4C9=.769C9.63==>4@4=.=.764:3.3=>9= =>4D >95 >4A@45 965 933.3=45 =>4 9339.A96=3 =7 4319@4 9<=4: - 7 - 17FF.==.6C=>41:.F4965=>4D9A37>95E.3.=45=>4@A914?>4:4 =>49339.A96=3>95=9B463>4A=4:9<=4:17FF.==.6C=>41:.F4965 >95 @9:=.1.@9=45 .6 9 @9:=D .6 =>4 39.5 @A914 9A76C ?.=> =>4 91=29A9339.A96=3965.63@.=47<=>439F4=>4D>9567=:4E49A45 9;72==>4?>4:49;72=37<=>49339.A96=3=7=>4@7A.14 112345 67!# 9AA4C45AD >95 @:7E.545 9 576CA4 =7 9112345 67 ?>.1> ?932345;D>.F=717FF.==>41:.F4 & >4 @7A.14 9<=4: .6E43=.C9=.76 .6 =>4 @:4346= 1934 >9E4 <.A45 1>9:C4 3>44= 9C9.63= =>4 9112345 @4:3763 .6E7B.6C =>4 @:7E.3.763 7< 965 =>4:4<7:4 .= .3 4E.546= =>9= 9AA =>4 9112345 @4:3763 .6 =>4 @:4346= 1934 9:4 @4:3763 7< 1:.F.69A 96=414546=3 112345 673" !% ! 8 !$ =7 ! 93 9C9.63= ?>7F 3.F.A9: 9AA4C9=.763 7< 933.3=.6C =>4 9339.A96=3 =7 4319@4 9<=4: =>4D 17FF.==45 =>4 1:.F4 965 9A37 E.3.=.6C =>4 @A914 ?>4:4 =>4 9339.A96=3 >95 =9B46 3>4A=4: >9E4 ;446 C:96=45 :4C2A9: ;9.A ;D =>4 433.763 72:= 4=.=.764:3 >9E4 ;446 546.45;9.A76@9:.=D?.=>9112345673"!%!8!$=7! 76AD<7:=>4:49376=>9==>9==>4:4.39AA4C9=.769C9.63=9112345 673 8!!=>9==>4D>9549:A.4:C764=79AA9:.9A76C?.=>=>4 7=>4:9112345@4:3763?.=>96.6=46=.76=717FF.==>4F2:54: 7<9>43>965>953=9D45.69>7=4A:77F9=9AA9:.9653.614 - 8 - 9>43>?9367=:4A4934576;9.A=>4D>95:4=2:645;91B965 =>9=911234567!#>9532@@A.459576CA4=7911234567@:.7: =7 =>4 59=4 7< 1:.F4 ?>.1> ?93 2345 ;D 9112345 67 <7: 17FF.33.767<1:.F4 " 65.3@2=45AD @4=.=.764:3 >95 67= @9:=.1.@9=45 .6 96D 1:.F4 52:.6C =>4 39.5 E.3.= 7< =>4.:3 =7 9AA9:. 76 !%$!%! 4:4AD<7:=>4:49376=>9=9112345673 8!!>95=:9E4A45=7 9AA9:. 965 >95 3=9D45 =>4:4 <7: 9 59D .6 9 >7=4A :77F .=34A< 19667= ;4 1763.54:45 9 1:.F4 34:.723 4672C> =7 546D =>4F :4C2A9:;9.A?>46=>47=>4:9112345@4:3763939C9.63=?>7F =>47=>4:9AA4C9=.7634I14@=E.3.=.6C=79AA9:D9653=9D.6C=>4:4 .3 3.F.A9: >9E4 ;446 C:96=45 :4C2A9: ;9.A ;D =>4 433.763 72:= E46 93 9C9.63= 9112345 67!# =>4 76AD 955.=.769A 9AA4C9=.76.3=>9=>4>95@:7E.5459576CA4=7911234567 % 4=.=.764:3 9:4 .6 123=75D <7: =>4 A93= 649:AD J D49:3 >4=:.9A.6=>41934.3D4==717FF4614965=>4@:73412=.76.6 9AA>931.=45!$1>9:C43>44=?.=643343.6=>4@:4346=1934 965 =>4:4<7:4 1>96143 7< =:.9A ;4.6C 17F@A4=45 .6 =>4 649: <2=2:4.3E4:D:4F7=4763.54:.6C=>469=2:47<9AA4C9=.76393 9C9.63= =>4 @4=.=.764:3 .6 =>4 @:4346= 1934 965 9A37 >9E.6C - 9 - :4C9:5=7=>4<91==>9=9112345673"!%!8!$=7! 93 9C9.63= ?>7F 3.F.A9: 9AA4C9=.763 7< 933.3=.6C 965 >4A@.6C =>4 91=29A 9339.A96=3 .3 <7265 >9E4 ;446 C:96=45 :4C2A9: ;9.A ;D =>4433.76372:=9F7<=>47@.6.76=>9==>4@:9D4:F954 ;D =>4 @4=.=.764:3 <7: C:96= 7< :4C2A9: ;9.A .3 :4K2.:45 =7 ;4 963?4:459<<.:F9=.E4AD 117:5.6CAD=>4<7AA7?.6C7:54:+ >4@4=.=.7639:49AA7?45 >4@4=.=.764:39:45.:41=45=7 ;446A9:C4576;9.A.6@A7!!!%!#@465.6C;4<7:4=>4 72:=7<:A.=D.E.A8433.763,25C446C9A2:29:.3.6C72= 7<:.F47#$!%!:4C.3=4:45;D9:9@@969 C:9>9:97A.14 =9=.76 46C9A2:2 .=D <7: =>4 7<<46143 @26.3>9;A4 2654: 41=.763!$( )!$()()7<=>465.96 :F3 1=41=.763 !% # #! # ## # #& & %! % %" !% !%! !%# !! :495 ?.=> #" 41=.763 (!)(E) (!)(E9)7<=>48 (:4E46=.767< ==:71.=.43) 1="&"8 41=.763()(.)(!)()(#)8#7<=>49:69=9B976=:7A 7< :C96.345 :.F4 1= !%%% 32;H41= =7 =>4 <7AA7?.6C 1765.=.763+ 9) >4 @4=.=.764:3 3>9AA 4I412=4 @4:3769A ;765 <7: 9 32F 7< 3%%%%% 491> ?.=> =?7 - 10 - 32:4=.43 <7: =>4 A.B432F =7 =>4 39=.3<91=.76 7< =>4 H2:.35.1=.769A72:=- ;) >4 @4=.=.764:3 3>9AA 9@@49: :4C2A9:AD 76 9AA =>4 59=43 7< >49:.6C ;4<7:4 =>4 :.9A 72:= 26A433=>4 :.9A72:=4I4F@=3=>4.:9@@49:9614<7: E9A.5:493763- 1) >4 @4=.=.764:3 3>9AA 67= 5.:41=AD 7: .65.:41=AD =>:49=46 7: =9F@4: ?.=> =>4 @:73412=.76 ?.=643343- 5) >4@4=.=.764:33>9AA67=.6E7AE4.63.F.A9: 7<<46143.6<2=2:4- 4) >4 @4=.=.764:3 3>9AA 67= A49E4 =>4 H2:.35.1=.767<=>4 :.9A72:=?.=>72=@4:F.33.767< =>4 39.5 72:= 26=.A =>4 1934 :4C.3=4:45 9C9.63= =>4F.35.3@73457<< )'* +% &$ , $