- 1 - ! "# $% &$ # & ! ! "# ! $%& ! $'% #'#$ ! ! !! #% %' % ! ( ! ) ) )! Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! ( * * + ) () # ,,-./01231435/2#'#$4/63.7/4/089:;<;= 2<3,/7;7321:374;0-46;3.743,7>247:/2>>/1,/.?-13.:;8</ -10/4/,7321.#%%'% 2>7:/%3.8/>24/7:3. 2-47-10/4/,7321$'%2>%.//=3164/6-<;48;3< /;407:/</;41/02-1./<>247:/?;473/. % ! 31 435/ 2#'#$ @;. 4/63.7/4/0 89 :;<;= 2<3,/ 7;7321 :374;0-46; 3.743,7 >24 7:/ ;>24/.;30 2>>/1,/. ;6;31.7 3A9; ;10 7@2 27:/4. 21 7:/ 8;.3. 2> 7:/ >34.7 31>245;7321 0;7/0 %#$ 4/,/3A/0 >425 :3??/.@;59 B 8427:/4 2> 0/,/;./0 ;6:;A/104; -4316 7:/ ,2-4./ 2> 31A/.736;7321 2> 7:/ ,;./ ?/737321/4 :/4/31 @;. ;44/.7/0 21 #$1A/.736;73212>7:/,;./3.,25?</7/0;10,:;46/ .://7:;.8//1>3</0;6;31.77:4//?/4.21./737321/43.;44;9/0 ;. ;,,-./0 12 31 7:/ ,:;46/ .://7 3. 8;3<;??<3,;7321 >3</0 8/>24/ 7:/ C-43.03,7321;< /..321. 2-47 31 4< 3., - 3 - 2#$"$$ @;. 4/C/,7/0 21 %#$ :/4/>24/ :/ 3. 8/>24/7:3.2-47 $ /;41/0 2-1./< >24 7:/ ?/737321/4 .-8537. 7:;7 7:/ ?/737321/4 3. ;1 ;643,-<7-43.7 ;6/0 ;82-7 9/;4. :;A316 12 ,43531;< ;17/,/0/17. :/ /1734/ ,;./ 2> 7:/ ?42./,-7321 3. 8;./0 21 ,34,-5.7;173;< /A30/1,/ 1A/.736;7321 2> 7:/ ,;./ 3. ,25?</7/0 ;10 ,:;46/ .://7 :;. 8//1 >3</0 ,,240316<9 :/ ?4;9.72;<<2@7:/?/737321 /4 ,2174; </;41/0 :;. 2??2./0 7:/ ?/737321 / .-8537.7:;77:/?2.75247/54/?2472>7:/0/,/;./0.-??247. 7:/;<</6;7321.>2-10317:/,:;46/.://7;6;31.77:/;,,-./0 :/4/ ;4/ 034/,7 5;7/43;<. 72 ,211/,7 7:/ ?/737321/4 72 7:/ ,435/,,240316<9:/?4;9.7203.53..7:/?/737321 " /4-.;<2>7:/5;7/43;<214/,240@2-<06272.:2@7:;7 21 &$ ;,,-./0 12# B 3A9; :;0 7/</?:21/0 72 7:/ >34.7 31>245;17 ;10 31>245/0 72 :35 7:;7 :/4 :-.8;10 B ;6:;A/104; @;. ,25?<;31316 2> .725;,: ?;31 55/03;7/<9 7:/4/;>7/47:/>34.731>245;17./17:3.4/<;73A/;6;4;C;10:3. @3>/ ;16;<;55; 72 7:/ :2-./ 2> ;6:;A/104; / @;. 31>245/089;6;4;C7:;7;6:;A/104;:;003/0317:/:2-./ - 4 - 1 '&$ 7:/ <;.7 437/. 2> ;6:;A/104; @;. ?/4>245/0 ;10.31,/7:/,;-./>240/;7:2>;6:;A/104;@;..-.?/,7/0; ,;./ 31 2#$$ @;. 4/63.7/4/0 7 3. ;<</6/0 7:;7 .-8./D-/17<9?/737321/4:/4/31,21>/../0727:/>34.731>245;17 ;82-77:/5-40/42>;6:;A/104;,255377/089:35;<216@37: 7:/ 27:/4 7@2 ;,,-./0 ?/4.21. 7 3. 31 7:3. 8;,=642-10 21 %#$7:/>34.731>245;17:;0;??42;,:/07:/?2<3,/;10 8;./021:3.>34.731>245;7321 ! 31 435/2#'#$@;. 4/63.7/4/0-43167:/,2-4./2>31A/.736;732121#$ ?/737321/4 @;. ;44/.7/0 ;10 4/5;10/0 72 C-03,3;< ,-.7209 1A/.736;7321 2> 7:/ ,;./ 3. ,25?</7/0 ;10 ,:;46/ .://7 :;. 8//1>3</0 :/;<</6;7321317:/,:;46/.://73.7:;7;,,-./012#B 3A9;:;03<<3,374/<;7321.:3?@37:;,,-./012%B;C-;107:3. @;.2??2./089:/4:-.8;10;6:;A/104;:/4/>24/;,,-./0 12.# E % 0/,30/0 72 /<3531;7/ ;6:;A/104; ;10 >24 7:/ .;30 ?-4?2./7:/9:;0.2-6:77:/;..3.7;1,/2>7:/?/737321/4@:2 3. .;30 72 8/ 7:/ -1,</ 2> ;,,-./0 12# 1 &$ ;,,-./0 12.# E :;0 ?42A30/0 <3D-24 72 0/,/;./0 ;6:;A/104;;10;,,-./012#;<</6/0<953F/0.25/7;8</7.72 7:/<3D-247:;7@;.8/316,21.-5/089;6:;A/104;;10;.; - 5 - 4/.-<7 :/ <2.7 :3. ,21.,32-.1/.. 7 3. ;<</6/0 7:;7 ;,,-./0 12.# E 7:/4/;>7/4 .74;16-<;7/0 :3. 1/,= @37: ; @34/ ;10 ,255377/0:3.5-40/4 ' :/ /1734/ ,;./ 2> 7:/ ?42./,-7321 3. 8;./0 21 ,34,-5.7;173;</A30/1,//737321/4;6/0;82-79/;4.@:23. .;30728/;1;643,-<7-43.7:;.1227:/4,43531;<;17/,/0/17. 1A/.736;7321 2> 7:/ ,;./ 3. ,25?</7/0 ;10 ,:;46/ .://7 :;. 8//1 >3</0 1 7:/ ?2.75247/5 4/?247 2> 7:/ 0/,/;./0 7:/ ,;-./ 2> 0/;7: 3. 5/17321/0 ;. G0-/ 72 ,21.743,7321 >24,/ ;42-10 7:/ 1/,= :2@/A/4 0/,/;./0 :;. ,21.-5/0 /7:9< ;<,2:2< ;10 ,217;31. H2<?30/5 ./0;73A/ I <</6;7321. ;6;31.7 7:/;,,-./03.4/D-34/0728/?42A/031;>-<<></06/0743;<43;< 317:/,;./3.9/772,255/1,/;A3164/6;40727:/;>24/.;30 ;.?/,7. 2> 7:/ 5;77/4 ;5 2> 7:/ 2?31321 7:;7 7:/ ?/737321/4 :;.5;0/2-7;,;./>2464;172>4/6-<;48;3<,,240316<97:/ >2<<2@316240/4* & /737321 3. ;<<2@/0 :/ ?/737321/4 3. 034/,7/0 72 8/ /1<;46/0 21 8;3< 31 435/ 2#'#$ 4/63.7/4/0 89 :;<;= 2<3,/7;7321:374;0-46;3.743,7>247:/2>>/1,/.?-13.:;8</ -10/4/,7321.#%%'% 2>7:/%3.8/>24/7:3. - 6 - 2-47 -10/4 /,7321 $'% 2> % .-8C/,7 72 7:/ >2<<2@316,21037321.* ; :/?/737321/4.:;<</F/,-7/?/4.21;<8210>24; .-52>.#@37:7@2.-4/73/.>247:/ <3=/.-5727:/.;73.>;,73212>7:/C-43.03,7321;< 2-47J 8 :/?/737321/4.:;<<;??/;44/6-<;4<921;<<7:/ 0;7/. 2> :/;4316 8/>24/ 7:/ 43;< 2-47 -1</.. 7:/ 43;< 2-47 /F/5?7. :3. ;??/;4;1,/ >24 A;<304/;.21.J , :/ ?/737321/4 .:;<< 127 034/,7<9 24 31034/,7<9 7:4/;7/1 24 7;5?/4 @37: 7:/ ?42./,-7321 @371/../.J 0 :/ ?/737321/4 .:;<< 127 31A2<A/ 31 .353<;4 2>>/1,/.31>-7-4/J / :/?/737321/4.:;<<127</;A/7:/C-43.03,73212> 7:/ 43;< 2-47 @37:2-7 ?/453..321 2> 7:/ .;30 2-47 -173< 7:/ ,;./ 4/63.7/4/0 ;6;31.7 :35 3. 03.?2./02>> '() *% &$ + $