- 1 - ! " # $ % # & '&()* + &)) % !!" # $ % & & !!!' # $% & () $& (* % )) ! & ''!' ! & && ! ( & &$"!% ) + & , Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - , + + ' --./01 2' 34 2''!' ! 5041346 708290 :;0 2.9: 28 << 113:324=> 3:? 3@3> A 0//324/ +.160 =46=>290 =93/346 2.: 28 93B0 2)) ! 9063/:0901 7? =6=>=6.4:0 2>3-0 :=:324 =46=>290 829 28804-0/ 5.43/;=7>0.41090-:324!9 C(283/708290:;3/ 2.9:.41090-:324()289 0=91:;0>0=9401-2.4/0>829:;05=9:30/ & 34 93B0 2)) ! C=/ 9063/:0901 7? =6=>=6.4:0 2>3-0 :=:324 =46=>290 -3:? =6=34/: 50:3:32409 =41 =42:;09 829 :;0 =8290/=31 28804-0/ 24 :;0 7=/3/ 28 :;0 839/: 34829B=:324 1=:01 !!! 90-03@01 892B.4=41= 210-0=/01 2;=4.B=9.9346:;0 -2.9/0 28 34@0/:36=:324 50:3:32409 ;09034C=/ =990/:01 24 !!! =41 /.7/0D.04:>? 90B=4101 :2 E.13-3=> -./:21?8:0934@0/:36=:324C=/-2B5>0:01-;=960/;00: C=/83>01=6=34/::C2509/24/=4150:3:324093/=99=?01=/ - 3 - =--./012'34:;0-;=960/;00:=3>=55>3-=:32483>017? :;0 50:3:32409 708290 :;0 93=> 2.9: 34 9> 3/-2''!) ! C=/ 90E0-:01 24 !'!( ;0908290:;050:3:324093/708290:;3/2.9: ( 0=9401 -2.4/0> 829 :;0 50:3:32409 /.7B3:/ :;=: =>>06=:324=6=34/:=--./01 2=41 :;0 50:3:32409;09034 34 :;0 -;=960 /;00: =90 /3B3>=9 --./01 2 ;=/ 7004 69=4:01906.>=97=3>7?:;3/-2.9:349>2'') ( !( 0:3:32409 =601 =72.: ( ?0=9/ 3/ 34 -./:21? 829 :;0 >=/: 40=9>? :;900 ?0=9/ --291346>? ;0 59=?/ :2 =>>2C :;0 50:3:324 09 -24:9= >0=9401 36; 2.9: 2@094B04: >0=109 ;=/2552/01:;050:3:324 =:093=> 24 90-291 C2.>1 62 :2 /;2C :;=: 50:3:32409 =601=72.:(?0=9/3/34-./:21?829:;0>=/:40=9>?:;900 ?0=9/ 92/0-.:324 34 =>> ;=/ -3:01 ( -;=960 /;00: C3:40//0/34:;0590/04:-=/0=41:3>>1=:024>?240-;=960 /;00:C3:40//;=/70040F=B3401 - 4 - " 09./=> 28 :;0 -;=960 /;00: B=:093=> C2.>1 62 :2 /;2C :;=: =>>06=:324 =6=34/: :;0 50:3:32409 =41 =--./01 2 =90 /3B3>=9 --./01 2' A 72:; =>>0601>? =//=.>:01 10-0=/01 2;=4 .B=9 C3:; = ->.7 =41 =/ = 90/.>: ;0 ;=1 1301 --./01 2 ;=/ 7004 69=4:01 906.>=97=3>7?:;3/2.9:349>2'') ( !( * 4109 :;0 -39-.B/:=4-0/ =B 28 2534324 59=?09 B=10 7? :;0 50:3:32409 829 69=4: 28 906.>=9 7=3> 4001/ :2 70=4/C0901=8839B=:3@0>?C3:;2.:0F590//346=4?2534324 24 :;0 B093:/ =41 10B093:/ 28 :;0 -=/0 --291346>? 592-001:25=//:;082>>2C346, ;050:3:3243/=>>2C01 ;0 50:3:32409 3/ 1390-:01 :2 70 04>=9601 24 7=3> 34 93B0 2)) ! 9063/:0901 7? =6=>=6.4:0 2>3-0 :=:324 =46=>290 829 28804-0/ 5.43/;=7>0 .4109 0-:324 !9 C(285041346342''!' !5041346 708290 :;0 2.9: 28 << 113:324=> 3:? 3@3> A 0//324/ +.160=46=>290/.7E0-::2:;082>>2C346-2413:324/, - 5 - =%;050:3:32409/;=>>0F0-.:0509/24=>7241829= /.B 28 /'!!!!! C3:; :C2 /.90:30/ 829 :;0 >3G0/.B :2 :;0 /=:3/8=-:324 28 :;0 E.93/13-:324=> 2.9:H 7%;0 50:3:32409 /;=>> =550=9 906.>=9>? 24 =>> :;0 1=:0/28;0=9346708290:;093=>2.9:.4>0//:;0 93=> 2.9: 0F0B5:/ ;3/ =550=9=4-0 829 @=>31 90=/24/H -% ;0 50:3:32409 /;=>> 42: 1390-:>? 29 341390-:>? :;90=:04 29 :=B509 C3:; :;0 592/0-.:324 C3:40//0/H 1%;0 50:3:32409 /;=>> 42: 34@2>@0 34 /3B3>=9 28804-0/348.:.90H 0%;0 50:3:32409 /;=>> 42: >0=@0 :;0 E.93/13-:324 28 :;0 93=> 2.9: C3:;2.: 509B3//324 28 :;0 /=31 2.9: .4:3> :;0 -=/0 9063/:0901 =6=34/: ;3B 3/ 13/52/01288 ,*- &$ % ) 3/:2,')>2,'! ,