- 1 - !"!# $ %"& '" ! % ( ()*+ (** ' ! " " #$$$ ! % & % ! '''$' #''$' % " ! " % %% '$! # ' ' ' $ &# & #$ Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - '$( &% %%)"% " " % (" * "* +") () ,- .//01-2 3 45 647- 3#''$' 6-8419-6-2 :; ".58.<060 06.< 3<4/- 9.9435 ".58.<060 /49; =36 9,- 3==-5/-1 >0541,.:<- 052-6 -/94351 '$:! # ' ' ' $ &# & #$ '$ 6-.2 ?49, -/9435&3= 41:-=36-9,41 3069052-6-/9435 &3= 6 1--@4586-80<.6:.4< ' -.629,-<-.65-2/3051-<=369,->.694-1 %45 647-3#''$'?.16-8419-6-2:;9,- ".58.<06006.<3<4/-9.9435".58.<06045494.<<;=369,- 3==-51-1>0541,.:<-052-6-/94351&#&#$&3= .8.4519 05@53?5 >-61351 35 9,- :.141 3= 9,- =4619 45=367.9435 2.9-2 9,- ''$'$' 6-/-4A-2 =637 .27.5.:,. 39;.5 3 .9- 3@.;;. 33B.6; 06458 - 3 - 9,- /3061- 3= 45A-1948.9435 3= 9,- /.1- 9,- >-949435-6 ,-6-45 ?.1 .66-19-2 35 $$'$' .52 10:1-C0-59<; 6-7.52-293B024/4.</01932;5A-1948.94353=9,-/.1-41 /37><-9-2 .52 /,.68- 1,--9 ,.1 :--5 =4<-2 .8.4519 >-61351.52>-949435-641.66.485-2.1.//01-23459,- /,.68-1,--9.4<.>><4/.9435=4<-2:;9,->-949435-6:-=36- 9,-B064124/9435.<-114351 306945 6<"41/3&'$' ?.16-B-/9-235''$'.529,-6-=36-,-41:-=36-9,41 3069 -.65-2/3051-<=369,->-949435-610:74919,.9 9,- 35<; .<<-8.9435 .8.4519 9,- >-949435-6 41 9,.9 ,- ,.2 /351>46-2?49,.//01-23193.5293/377492./349; 45 9,- ,301- 3= =4619 45=367.59 5241>09-2<; ,- ,.2 539 835- 93 9,- ,301- 35 9,- .<<-8-2 2.9- 3= 45/42-59 - 10:7491 9,.9 .//01-2 3 ,.1 :--5 86.59-2 6-80<.6 :.4< :;9,41 306945 64745.<-9494353'$'241>31-2 3=35$''$' ,-45A-1948.94353=9,-/.1-41.<6-.2; /37><-9-2//362458<;,->6.;193.<<3?9,->-949435 - 4 - # -6 /3596. <-.65-2 48, 3069 3A-657-59 <-.2-6 ,.1 3>>31-2 9,- >-949435 - 10:7491 9,.9 9,- >-949435-6 ,.4<1 =637 -6.<. 19.9- .52 45 9,- -A-59 ,- 41 -5<.68-2 35 :.4< ,- 41 <4@-<; 93 =<-- .?.; =637 B0194/- //362458<;,->6.;19324174119,->-949435 % 45 9,- >6-1-59 /.1- ?.1 6-8419-6-2 .8.4519 05@53?5>-61351.<<-84589,.9359,-459-6A-5458548,93= '$'$'.52''$'$'.9.:309$$>7.:309$93 ' >-61351 ?,3 ?-6- ?-.6458 7.1@1 35 9,-46 =./- .52 8<3A-1 45 9,-46 ,.521 .<< 3= . 1022-5 -59-6-2 4593 9,- /37>3052 3= 9,- ,301- 3= 9,- =4619 45=367.59 .52 .=9-6 /.9/,458 ,3<2 3= ,47 =36/4:<; -59-6-2 4593 ,41 ,301- .52 /64745.<<; 4594742.9-2 9,- 457.9-1 3= ,41 ,301- ,- 1.42 .//01-2 >-61351 ?,3 -59-6-2 9,- ,301- 3= 9,- =4619 45=367.59933@.?.;83<214<A-6.5224.7352365.7-591 .52 .<13 /.1, =637 9,- ,301- 3= =4619 45=367.59 .52 -1/.>-2 45 . /.6 45 ?,4/, 9,-; ,.2 .664A-2 06458 9,- /3061- 3= 9,- 45A-1948.9435 3= 9,- /.1- 9,- >-949435-6 - 5 - ,-6-45 ?.1 .66-19-2 35 $$'$' ,- 45A-1948.9435 3= 9,-/.1-41/37><-9-2.52/,.68-1,--9,.1:--5=4<-2 5 9,- /,.68-1,--9 49 41 .<<-8-2 9,.9 .//01-2 3 ?.1 9,- 264A-6 3= 9,- <366; :-<358458 93 =4619 45=367.59 .52 ,- ,.2 ,.9/,-2 . /351>46./; ?49, 9,- .//01-2 3' 93 /37749 2./349; 45 9,- ,301-3= 9,-=4619 45=367.595=069,-6.5/-3=1.42/351>46./;.//01-23' ,.2/359./9-2.//01-23?,3459065,.2/359./9-2,41 =64-52 .//01-2 3 .52 6-C0-19-2 ,47 93 7.@- .66.58-7-591 93 /37749 2./349; 45 9,- ,301- 3= =4619 45=367.59//362458<;.//01-23/359./9-2,41=64-52 .//01-2 3 =637 -6.<. ?,3 .<<-8-2<; .66.58-2 >-3><- =36/3774994582./349;459,-,301-3=9,-=461945=367.59 5 =069,-6.5/- 3= 9,- /351>46./; :-9?--5 9,- .//01-2 >-61351 35 9,- 459-6A-5458 548,9 3= '$'$' .52 ''$'$'9,-.//01-2>-61351?,3.664A-2939,-,301- 3=9,-=461945=367.59459,-/.6:-<358458939,-.//01-2 3 .52 .<13 45 .539,-6 /.6 .<<-8-2<; /377499-2 9,- 2./349; 45 9,- ,301- 3= =4619 45=367.59 .52 9,-6-.=9-6 - 6 - -1/.>-2 ,- .<<-8.9435 .8.4519 9,- >-949435-6 ?,3 41 .66.485-2.1.//01-23419,.9,-,.2/351>46-2?49, 39,-6.//01-2>-61351.52.<13,-<>-29,-39,-6.//01-2 >-6135193/377492./349;5241>09-2<;,-?.1539>.69 3=9,-8.58?,4/,,.2-59-6-245939,-,301-3=9,-=4619 45=367.59.52/377499-22./349;359,-459-6A-5458548,9 3= '$'$' .52 ''$'$' -949435-6 23-1 539 ,.A- .5;39,-61-64301/64745.<.59-/-2-59 -41459,-/01932; =36 9,- <.19 5-.6<; 14D 7359,1 ,- 5A-1948.9435 3= 9,- /.1- 41 /37><-9-2 .52 /,.68-1,--9 41 =4<-2 ,- .>>6-,-51435 3= <-.65-2 /.5 :- 9.@-5 /.6- 3= :; 47>31458.>>63>64.9-/352494351 52-69,-1-/46/0719.5/-1.73=9,-3>45435 9,.9 9,- >-949435-6 ,.1 7.2- 309 . >647. =./4- /.1- =36 86.59 3= 6-80<.6 :.4< //362458<; >63/--2 93 >.11 9,- =3<<3?458362-6* 4! ,->-94943541.<<3?-2 - 7 - 44! ,->-949435-641246-/9-293:--5<.68-235:.4< 45 647- 3#''$' 3= ".58.<060 06.< 3<4/- 9.9435 ".58.<060 /49; 6-8419-6-2 =36 9,- 3==-5/-1 >0541,.:<- 052-6 -/94351 '$:! # ' ' ' $ &# & #$ '$ 6-.2 ?49, -/9435 & 3= >-52458 45 3'''$' 35 9,- =4<- 3= )"% 3069 ".58.<06010:B-/9939,-=3<<3?458/352494351* .! ,->-949435-61,.<<-D-/09->-6135.<:352=36. 107 3= 1$$$$$ ?49, 9?3 106-94-1 =36 9,- <4@-107.523093=9,-1.7-35-106-9;1,.<<:- <3/.< 106-9; 93 9,- 1.941=./9435 3= 9,- B064124/9435.< 3069E :! ,- >-949435-6 1,.<< .>>-.6 6-80<.6<; 35 .<< 9,- 2.9-13=,-.6458:-=36-9,- 64.< 306905<-119,- 64.< 3069 -D-7>91 ,41 .>>-.6.5/- =36 A.<42 6-.1351E /! ,- >-949435-6 1,.<< 539 246-/9<; 36 45246-/9<; 9,6-.9-5 36 9.7>-6 ?49, 9,- >631-/09435 ?495-11-1E 2! ,- >-949435-6 1,.<< 539 45A3<A- 45 1474<.6 3==-5/-145=0906-E - 8 - -! ,- >-949435-6 1,.<< 539 <-.A- 9,- B064124/9435 3= 9,- 64.< 3069 ?49,309 >-67411435 3= 9,- 1.42 3069 0594< 9,- /.1- 6-8419-6-2 .8.4519 ,47 41 241>31-23== ,+- (& '" !* " 4193*&<3*& *