Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 36017 (KAR)
SHOAIB v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/13068/2024 · 2025-01-23
S Vishwajith Shetty
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 36017 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 36017 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#$!% &! $ ' (')
*+
'** +& $
, $ $
,, $
+ &
!!" #$
!! %
& # '
(
#
!!! Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
#
( ! !!"
! %
& ) (* ( # # ('
( " &( " ' !! ( # ( ((
"!&'"!&'""! $!( ( ()
(
()
,+
&
(
! !! & ( # '
(
#
- 3 -
! (
!!! # ( ! !!"
! & ) (* ( # # ('
( " &( " '
!! ( #
$ ( ( )
(
( (( !"!&'"!&'""&'!(
()
+
&
#
" )
!"! & (# '
- 4 -
(
#
!!! #
( ! !!"
! & ) (* ( # # ('
( "&( "'
!! ( #
(
((
"!&'"!&'""&'! $ ! (
( ( )
(
()
,,+
&
(
"
! (
) +
- 5 -
!"! & # '
(
#
!!! #
( ! !!"
! & ) ( ( # # ('
( " &( " '
!! ( #
( ((
"!&'"!&'""&'!$!(
( ( )
(
()
+
&
)
- 6 -
))
"" )
)
! &
# '
(
#
!!! # ( ! !!"
! & ) ( ( # # ('
( " &"'
!! ( #
( ((
"!&'"!&'""&'!! (
!" ( ( " )
(
()
- 7 -
(
$ ,
, -
) #$)
../0123043567581 3!!7195041712:;
<=337 3>5.1 4<4536 <?0@56< <66<2< 50475.4 A37 4@1 3AA16.10 B/650@<:>1 /6217 1.45360 "!&' "!&' "
"&' ! &' !&' ! 71<2 C54@ 1.4536 ! 3A !" <71 :1A371 4@50 3/74 56 4@1 <:3=1 .<B453612 B14545360 A5>12 /6217 1.4536 " 3A !" 011?569 719/><7:<5>
1<724@1>1<7612.3/601>A374@1B<74510
" ( 56 7581 3!! C<0 7195041712 :; <=337 3>5.1 4<4536 <?0@56< <66<2< 50475.4 <9<5604 84 1@<8<4@ <62 4@1 B1454536170 @17156 56545<>>; A37 4@1 3AA16.10 B/650@<:>1 /6217 1.45360 "!&' "!&' "
"&' <62 ! 3A !" 36 4@1 :<050 3A 4@1 A5704 56A378<45362<412!!!71.15=12A738;2<7>5:734@17 3A21.1<012
/84<D>5/75694@1.3/7013A56=10459<4536 <../012 3 C<0<7710412 36 !!! <62 <../01230"
- 8 -
43 C171 <7710412 36 !!!
<62 <../012 3 C<0 <771041236!!<620/:01E/164>;718<621243F/25.5<> ./0432;<5><BB>5.<4536A5>12:;4@1<A3710<52<../012B170360 :1A371 4@1 F/75025.4536<> 1005360 3/74 56 7>
50.30"!!!!G!!C171 71F1.412 @171A3714@1;<71:1A3714@503/74
1<7612.3/601>0A374@1B14545361700/:8544@<421.1<012 @<2 5>>5.54 71><45360@5B C54@ <../012 63 A417 @50 A<85>;
818:170 .<81 43 ?63C <:3/4 4@1 0<81 @1 @<0 .38854412 0/5.521 (<>01 <>>19<45360 @<=1 :116 8<21 <9<5604 4@1 B1454536170A371H47<613/071<0360 @171C<063<>>19<453656 4@1A570456A378<4536<:3/4218<623A7<603837?526<B3A4@1 21.1<012 :; 4@1 <../012 =16 56 4@1 718<62 <BB>5.<45360 4@171 50 63 8164536 <:3/4 218<62 3A 7<6038 37 ?526<B 3A 21.1<012 :; 4@1 <../012 0 <9<5604 <../012 30" 43 <71 .36.17612 .@<791 0@114 @<0 :116 A5>12 36>; A37 3AA16.10 B/650@<:>1 /6217 1.45360 ! &' ! 71<2 C54@ 1.4536 !3A!"<624@18<H58/8 B/650@8164A374@10<52 3AA16.105058B750368164A37<B175323A416;1<70 1454536170
- 9 -
23634@<=1<6;01753/0.75856<><641.121640..372569>;4@1; B7<;43<>>3C4@1B14545360
17 .3647< >1<7612 59@ 3/74 3=1768164 >1<217 A37 710B362164 3 <62 >1<7612 16537 .3/601> A37 710B362164 321A<.43 .38B><56<64 C@3 @<0 A5>12 04<418164 3A 3:F1.45360@<=13BB30124@1B7<;178<21564@1B14545360
1<761216537.3/601>A37710B36216430/:85404@<4 <../0123C@3504@1@/0:<623A<../0123C54@C@38 21.1<012 @<2 5>>5.54 71><45360@5B C<0 <C<71 3A 4@1 0<52 71><45360@5B <62 @1 <>369 C54@ 34@17 <../012 B170360 @<0 .360B5712 43 .38854 4@1 <>>1912 3AA16.10 1 0/:8540 4@<4 <../012 B170360 <71 B170360 C54@ .75856<> <641.121640 <62 <..372569>;B7<;04325085004@1B14545360
64@14;B12A570456A378<45362<412!!!0/:854412 :;4@1:734@173A21.1<012
/84<D>55450<=177124@<4 4@1A570456A378<64@<2<0/0B5.5364@<4@50:734@17
/84<D >5@<2B<7?12@50.<761<7/>337:75291<4<:3/4!!<836 !!! <62 .38854412 0/5.521 :; F/8B569 5643 4@1 75=17 <62@5021<2:32;50634;1447<.12450A/74@17<>>1912564@1
- 10 -
A5704 56A378<4536 4@<4
/84<D >5 C<0 :1569 :><.?8<5>12 A7384@18364@3A)/>;!36C<720:;4@1<../012B170360 <62 ><?@0 3A 7/B110 C171 0C562>12 :; 4@71<416569 @58 @1 <../012 B170360 @<2 .360B5712 43 A5650@
/84<D >5 C@3 C<0 < 710B1.412 8<6 <62 <6 <.45=1 B3>545.5<6 @1 <../012 B170360C171<>>1912>;8<?569<A<>01B73B<9<62<4@<4
/84<D >5 C<0 @<=569 5>>5.54 71><45360@5B C54@ <../012 63 <62 :; 4@71<4165694@1;@<271.15=1283714@<6<0/83A0!><?@0 A738
/84<D >5 <62 < .@1E/1 A37 < 0/8 3A 0 ><?@0 C<0 71.15=12 A738 @58 C@5.@ C<0 16.<0@12 4 50 A/74@17 <=17712 4@<4 <../012 B170360 C171 218<62569 A37 < A/74@17 0/8 3A 0! ><?@0 A738
/84<D >5 <62
/84<D >5 @<2 0164 < C@<40<BB8100<91A738@5083:5>1B@361434@183:5>1B@361 3A4@1A570456A378<6404<45694@<4<../012<714@1.</01A37@50 21<4@450564@50:<.?973/62A570456A378<64@<20/:854412< 4;B12A570456A378<453636!!!:<01236C@5.@(56 75813!!C<07195041712<9<5604841@<8<4@<62 4@1B1454536170@17156
/7569 4@1 .3/701 3A 56=10459<4536 <../012 3 C<0 <771041236!!!<62<../01230"43C171<7710412
- 11 -
36!!!<62<../0123C<0<771041236!!
<62 0/:01E/164>; 718<6212 43F/25.5<> ./0432; 6=10459<4536 56 4@1 .<01 50 .38B>1412 <62 .@<791 0@114 @<0 :116 A5>12 603A<7<0<../01230"43<71.36.17612.@<7910@114@<0 :116 A5>12 <9<5604 4@18 36>; A37 3AA16.10 B/650@<:>1 /6217 1.45360 ! &' ! 71<2 C54@ 1.4536 ! 3A !" <62 <0 <9<5604 <../012 3 .@<791 0@114 @<0 :116 A5>12 A37 4@1 3AA16.10 B/650@<:>1 /6217 1.45360 "!&' "!&' &'!&'!71<2C54@1.4536!3A!"603A<7 <0 3AA16.10 A37 C@5.@ .@<791 0@114 @<0 :116 A5>12 <9<5604 <../012 30" 43 <71 .36.17612 4@1 8<H58/8 B/650@8164 A374@10<523AA16.105058B750368164A37<B175323A416;1<70 0<9<5604<../0123.@<7910@114@<0:116A5>1256=3?569 4@13AA16.1B/650@<:>1/62171.4536!&'3A!"<62 4@10<523AA16.150B/650@<:>1C54@21<4@37>5A158B750368164 4 50 71>1=<64 43 4<?1 6341 3A 4@1 A<.4 4@<4 63 <>>19<4536 C<0 8<21564@1A570456A378<4536<0<9<5604<../012<:3/4218<62 3A 7<6038 37 ?526<B 3A 21.1<012 :; <../012 /.@ <6 <>>19<4536 50 634 8<21 1=16 56 4@1 718<62 <BB>5.<45360 3A <../012 B170360 @1 <>>19<4536 3A 7<6038 <62 ?526<B C<0 8<21 A37 4@1 A5704 4581 :<012 36 4@1 04<418164 3A
- 12 -
$" <?0@85 C@5.@ C<0 71.37212 <A417 < B17532 3A 8371 4@<6!2<;0A7384@12<413A7195047<45363A(
B17/0<>3A4@1.@<7910@1148<4175<>C3/>293430@3C 4@<4 21.1<012 @<2 5>>5.54 71><45360@5B C54@ <../012 3 <62 <../012 3 <>>1912>; @<2 71.37212 @17 .36=170<4536 C54@ 21.1<012 56 @17 83:5>1 B@361 <62 0@1 <>03 @<2 71.37212 .174<56B75=<41=5213056@1783:5>1B@361<62C<04@71<416569 4@1 21.1<012 @1 <>>19<4536 <9<5604 <../012 3 50 4@<4 @1 @<2 .360B5712 C54@ <../012 30 " <62 <62 C<0 4@71<4165694@121.1<012364@1:<0503A4@1.36=170<4536<62 B75=<41 =52130 4@<4 C171 71.37212 :; <../012 3 56 @17 83:5>1B@361<624@171A37121.1<012@<2.388544120/5.521
@1 <>>19<4536 <9<5604 <../012 30" <62 50 4@<4 4@1;
@<2 .360B5712 C54@ <../012 30 <62 <62 4@1; <>03 C171 <>>1912>; 4@71<416569 4@1 21.1<012 43 @<78 @50 71B/4<4536 :;
.57./><4569 @50 B75=<41 .36=170<4536 <62 =52130 C@5.@ C<0 71.37212 56 4@1 83:5>1 B@361 3A <../012 3 @3/9@ 54 50 0/:854412 :; >1<7612 .3/601> A37 710B362164 3 4@<4 4@1 B1454536170 <71 B170360 C54@ .75856<> <641.121640 >504 3A <6;
0/.@ .75856<> .<010 56 C@5.@ B1454536170 <71 <../012 @<0 634
- 13 -
:116 A/7650@12 154@17 :; >1<7612 59@ 3/74 3=1768164 >1<217A37710B362164337>1<7612.3/601>A37710B362164 3
!
45071>1=<64434<?163413A4@1A<.44@<4<6<BB>5.<4536 C<0 A5>12 :; B7301./4536 43 56=3?1 1.4536 3A !" <9<5604<../012564@1B710164.<011.45363A!" B73=5210A37B/650@8164A3779<650127581 @3/9@4@10<52 <BB>5.<4536 A5>12 :; B7301./4536 :1A371 4@1 >1<7612
<95047<41 C<0 <>>3C12 <A417 56=10459<4536 .@<791 0@114 @<0 :116 A5>12 36>; A37 4@1 <A3710<52 3AA16.10 <62 4@1 3AA16.1 B/650@<:>1 /62171.45363A!"50273BB12564@1.@<7910@114 C@5.@ C3/>2 93 43 0@3C 4@<4 B1454536170 23 634 @<=1 <6; 01753/0 .75856<> <641.121640 6=10459<4536 56 4@1 .<01 50 <>71<2; .38B>1412 <62 .@<791 0@114 @<0 :116 A5>12 7301./4536 @<0 <>> 43914@17 .5412 .@<791 0@114C54610010 56 4@1 B710164 .<01 <62 4@171A371 .@<6.10 3A 475<> :1569 .38B>1412<624@1.<01:1569250B30123A36817540564@161<7 A/4/7150=17;718341
64@1.<013A ! " # $%
- 14 -
&4@136-:>1/B71813/7456B<7<97<B@30"G @<03:017=12<0/6217,
! "
# $
"
%
&
'
(
'
- 15 -
64@1.<013A #'(')*<4B<7<97<B@ 3"4@136-:>1/B71813/74@<03:017=12<0/6217,
) * +
, ! *
! #+
* ( -
" ! " 3605217569 4@1 6<4/71 3A <>>19<45360 A3/62 <0 <9<5604 B1454536170 56 4@1 .@<791 0@114 <62 <>03 @<=569 719<72 43 4@1 <A3710<52F/29816403A4@136I:>1/B71813/74<83A4@1
- 16 -
3B565364@<44@1B7<;178<21:;B1454536170A3797<643A719/><7 :<5> 56 4@101 B14545360 61120 43 :1 <60C1712 <AA578<45=1>; ..372569>;4@1A3>>3C56937217,
@1B14545360<71<>>3C12 @1B1454536170<712571.41243 :116><791236:<5>5675813!!7195041712:;<=337 3>5.1 4<4536 <?0@56< <66<2< 50475.4 A37 4@1 3AA16.10 B/650@<:>1/62171.45360"!&'"!&'""&'! &' !&' ! 71<2 C54@ 1.4536 ! 3A !" 0/:F1.4434@1A3>>3C569.362545360,
<' 14545361700@<>>1H1./41B17036<>:362A37 <0/83A0!!!!!1<.@C54@4C30/714510A37 4@1>5?10/8434@10<450A<.45363A4@1F/75025.4536<> 3/74*
:' @1B14545361700@<>><BB1<7719/><7>;36<>> 4@1 2<410 3A @1<7569 :1A371 4@1 75<> 3/74 /6>100 4@1 75<> 3/74 1H18B40 4@157 <BB1<7<6.1 A37 =<>52 71<0360*
.' @1 B1454536170 0@<>> 634 2571.4>; 37 562571.4>; 4@71<416 37 4<8B17 C54@ 4@1 B7301./4536 C54610010*
- 17 -
2' @1B14545361700@<>>63456=3>=1560585><7 3AA16.1056A/4/71*
1' @1 B1454536170 0@<>> 634 >1<=1 4@1 F/75025.45363A4@1 75<>3/74C54@3/4B1785005363A 4@1 0<52 3/74 /645> 4@1 .<01 7195041712 <9<5604 4@1850250B30123AA
-+. '% &! * ! 5043,!>3,
,