Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2025 DAILYLAW 35947 (KAR)

MR SARAVANAKUMAR M v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

CRL.P/13078/2024 · 2025-02-14

S Vishwajith Shetty

body2025

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! !" #$ % & '% ! $()(*+, ( ++ ' ! "# $ % !% " $ ! !& ' ! !! ! !& ' ! " $ ! % ( ! "% ) $ ! ! !)% !% Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " $ ! !& ' % %% ! )"*$)(% !+! % % &&& # !# " !$ ! % + , , -# +# **./01 2 34 50*367 6/0 2) 5041348 90:2;0 <=0 2.;< 2: && 113<32467 3<> 3?37 @ 0//324/ #.180 ! 50*367 2.;< 04867.;. 3<> 6;3/3482.<2:2;083/<0;019>4/50*<2;2: ./<2A/ ./<2A/ 4<0773804*0 43< " $ 3;52;< @ 3; 6;82 2A570B 04867.;. :2; <=0 2::04*0/ 5.43/=6970 .410;0*<324/)"*$)641(2:6;*2<3* ;.8/ 641 !/>*=2<;253* .9/<64*0/ *< ()' ":2; /=2;< C ! *<D$3/90:2;0<=3/2.;<34<=3//.**0//3?0963765573*6<324 :3701.410;0*<324(2:;! 06;1<=0706;401*2.4/07:2;<=056;<30/ - 3 - < 3/ <=0 *6/0 2: <=0 5;2/0*.<324 <=6< <=0 *2A5763464< E=2 3/ <=0 ./<2A/ ::3*0; =61 ;0*03?01 *;013970 34:2;A6<324 24 ' <=6< <=0;0 6;0 *24*067A04</ 34 <E2 /=35A04</ E=3*= E0;0 7>348 34 <=0 2::3*0 2: / %010B B5;0// ;64/52;<6<324 641 .557> =634 0;?3*0/ 4136 !?< <1 906;348 <;6*F348 2''' 16<01 ) :;2A ;.//07/ 0783.A 641 )'' 16<01 :;2A =356<6 G6A936 E=3*= E0;0 611;0//01 <2 =.76/3;6A64 E3<= 6 10*76;6<324 6/ H67: =6:< :2; +06?348 6*=340/I 641 H01 =00</ 641 68 +6<*= 72<=0/I **./01 2/ 641 =61 6;;3?01 34 <=0 2::3*0 2: / %010B B5;0// ;64/52;<6<324 641 .557> =634 0;?3*0/ 4136 !?<<1*763A348<=6<<=0/631<E2/=35A04</907248<2 <=0A641<=0>=615;21.*015;34<2.<2:<=0*2530/2:<=0 692?0 ;0:0;;01 3;E6> 9377/ <;6*F348 4.A90;/ 641 E=04 <=0 692?0 ;0:0;;01 /=35A04</ E0;0 250401 3< E6/ :2.41 <=6< <=0 /6A0 *24<63401 *24<;69641 6;<3*70 67708017> E038=348 ') F3728;6A/ 641 *24<;69641 6;<3*70 67708017>=0;234E038=348F3728;6A/**./012/ - 4 - 641E=2=616;;3?0134<=0*2.;30;2::3*0:2;<=05.;52/0 2: *2770*<348 <=0 6:2;0/631 /=35A04</ E0;0 6;;0/<01 641 *24<;69641 6;<3*70 :2.41 34 <=0 /=35A04< E0;0 /03J01 .410; 564*=646A6 641 /.9/0K.04<7> 6**./01 E0;0 6;;0/<01641E0;05;21.*0190:2;0<=0L.;3/13*<324672.;< 641;0A64101<2L.13*367*./<21>63765573*6<324:37019> <=0 50<3<3240; E=2 3/ 6;;638401 6/ 6**./01 2 34 <=0 *6/090:2;0<=0<;3672.;<34;73/*2(E6/ ;0L0*<01 24 =0;06:<0; =0 =61 655;26*=01 <=3/ 2.;< 34 ;3A3467 !0<3<324 2 E=3*= E6/ 13/A3//019><=3/2.;<24.9/0K.04<7>=0 =61 :3701 ;3A3467 3/* 2)' 90:2;0 <=0 <;367 2.;<E=3*=E6/67/2;0L0*<0124=0;06:<0; <=0 50<3<3240; 3/ 90:2;0 <=3/ 2.;< 34 <=3/ /.**0//3?0 9637 65573*6<324 06;401*2.4/07:2;<=050<3<3240;/.9A3</<=6< <=050<3<3240;=6/422<=0;*;3A346764<0*0104</03/34 *./<21>:2;<=076/<406;7><=;00>06;/37716<0247>240 - 5 - *=6;80/=00< E3<40// =6/ 9004 56;<3677> 0B6A3401 **2;13487>=05;6>/<26772E<=050<3<324 ' !0; *24<;6 706;401 *2.4/07 65506;348 :2; <=0 ;0/524104<=6/2552/01<=050<3<3240/.9A3</<=6<<=0 *24<;69641 6;<3*70 /03J01 34 <=0 5;0/04< *6/0 3/ 2: *2AA0;*367K.64<3<>641<=0;0:2;034?30E2:;382;.410; 0*<324 "$"9$ 2: ! *< <=0 50<3<3240;D/ 9637 65573*6<3244001/<290;0L0*<01067/2/.9A3</<=6<<=0 50<3<3240;D/963765573*6<324:370106;730;=6/9004;0L0*<01 641 <=0;0 3/ 42 *=6480 34 *3;*.A/<64*0 <=0;0:2;0 <=0 50<3<324 *6442< 90 04<0;<63401 **2;13487> =0 5;6>/ <2 13/A3//<=050<3<324 <3/42<3413/5.<0<=6<<=050<3<3240;D/06;730; 9637 65573*6<324 :3701 34 ;3A3467 !0<3<324 2 E6/ 13/A3//01 9> <=3/ 2.;< 24 *24/310;348 <=0:6*<<=6<<=0*24<;696416;<3*70/03J0134<=05;0/04< *6/03/2:6*2AA0;*367K.64<3<>64134?30E2:;382;.410; 0*<324 "$"9$2: <=0 ! *<<=050<3<3240;D/5;6>0; :2;8;64<2:;08.76;9637E6/;0L0*<01=050<3<3240;E=2 - 6 - =6/ 42 2<=0; *;3A3467 64<0*0104</ 3/ 34 *./<21> 34 <=0 5;0/04<*6/0:;2A 4 <=0 *6/0 2: ;052;<0134 <=0 24D970 .5;0A0 2.;< <6F348 34<2 *24/310;6<324<=6<<=06**./01E6/34*./<21>:2;650;321 2: 240 >06; /0?04 A24<=/ 641 <=0;0 E6/ 42 /.::3*304< 5;28;0//34<;367E3<=2.<0B5;0//34864>253432424A0;3</ 64110A0;3</2:<=0*6/0=6/8;64<01;08.76;9637<2<=0 6**./01 ) 4 <=0 *6/0 2: !"# $ ;052;<0134 %346*6/0E=0;0*=6;80/=00<E6/:3701:2;<=0 2::04*0/ 5.43/=6970 .410; 0*<324/ "*$ 641 2: <=0 !*<6416**./01E6/34*./<21>:2;650;3212:240 >06; /0?04 A24<=/ <=0 24D970 .5;0A0 2.;< =6/ 8;64<01;08.76;963724<=08;2.41<=6<<=0<;3673//<37734 <=05;073A346;>/<6806/247>240E3<40//E6/0B6A3401 - 7 - ( =024-970.5;0A02.;<34<=0*6/02: &'( &)*+& *+ ') + , ,- ., / (-*'+0 1 *+- 34 56;68;65= 2 =6/29/0;?016/:2772E/, ! ! " # $ % &' ( ) *+ , ) -*., /01) , " ) 2 , ' 3 4 4<=0*6/02:2 -(3)* & +' +4' , ,- / & ' 5 ',5 ( ,'-5 1 6 - 8 - *+- 7 6< 56;68;65= 2( <=0 24-970 50B 2.;<=6/29/0;?016/:2772E/, 56 $ ) , 7 ) , 7 5 4<=05;0/04<*6/0<=050<3<3240;3/34*./<21> :2; <=0 76/< 406;7> <=;00 >06;/ =0 5;2/0*.<324 =6/ 677 <280<=0;*3<01/0?04*=6;80/=00<E3<40//0/34<=05;0/04< *6/0=2.8=<=0<;36734<=05;0/04<*6/0=6/*2AA04*01 34<=0>06;3</07:<37716<0<=05;2/0*.<324=6/247> 0B6A3401 240 *=6;80/=00<01 E3<40// 56;<3677> =0 0B6A346<32434*=30: 2: + E=2 3/ 0B6A3401 6/ !+ 34<=0*6/0=6/*2AA04*01249.<<377 16<0 =3/ 0B6A346<32434*=30: 3</07: 3/ 42< *2A570<01 9> <=0 5;2/0*.<324 - 9 - 410; <=0 *3;*.A/<64*0/ 6A 2: <=0 2534324 <=6< E3<=2.< 0B5;0//348 64> 2534324 24 <=0 A0;3</ 641 10A0;3</2:<=0*6/024<=08;2.412:34*6;*0;6<3249><=0 50<3<3240;=3/5;6>0;:2;8;64<2:;08.76;96374001/<290 64/E0;016::3;A6<3?07>**2;13487><=0:2772E3482;10;, =050<3<3243/6772E01 =0 50<3<3240; 3/ 13;0*<01 <2 90 0476;801 249637342;083/<0;019><=0 4/50*<2; 2: ./<2A/ ./<2A/ 4<0773804*0 43< " $ 3;52;< 641 3; 6;82 2A570B 04876.;. :2; <=0 2::04*0/ 5.43/=6970 .410; 0*<324/)"*$)641(2: !*< 5041348 24 <=0 :370 2: &&& 113<32467 3<> 3?37 @ 0//324/ #.180 641 50*367 #.180 " !$ 04867.;. /.9L0*< <2 <=0 :2772E348 *2413<324/, 6$=050<3<3240;/=6770B0*.<050;/2467 9241 :2; 6 /.A 2: / E3<= <E2 - 10 - /.;0<30/:2;<=073F0/.A<2<=0/6<3/:6*<324 2:<=0L.;3/13*<324672.;<M 9$=050<3<3240;/=67765506;;08.76;7>24677 <=016<0/2:=06;34890:2;0<=0;3672.;< .470// <=0 ;367 2.;< 0B0A5</ =3/ 65506;64*0:2;?6731;06/24/M *$ =0 50<3<3240; /=677 42< 13;0*<7> 2; 3413;0*<7> <=;06<04 2; <6A50; E3<= <=0 5;2/0*.<324E3<40//0/M 1$=0 50<3<3240; /=677 42< 34?27?0 34 /3A376; 2::04*0/34:.<.;0M 0$=0 50<3<3240; /=677 42< 706?0 <=0 L.;3/13*<324 2: <=0 ;367 2.;< E3<=2.< 50;A3//3242:<=0/6312.;<.4<37<=0*6/0 ;083/<0;0168634/<=3A3/13/52/012:: -,. ( & '% !+ % 3/<2,(72, ,!