6-SA-46-2024 1 12 Niti IN THE HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY AT GOA SECOND APPEAL NO.46 OF 2024 Shri. Madan Deshpande, 60 years of age, Business, Son of Dattaram Deshpande, R/o 373/2, Nehru Road, Tilak Wadi, Belgaum, Karnataka State. ...Appellant Versus 1. Mr. Aloysius Soares alias Aluisio Soares, 77 years of age, married, medical practitioner, Son of late Jose Aluisio Soares, r/o of B/2, Unique 2000, Housing Society, Chembur, Mumbai. (Since deceased) 1 (a) Mr. Neelkamal Soares, Son of Aloysius Soares, 43 ears of age. (b) Mr. Vivek Soares, Son of Aloysius Soares, 39 years of age. Both residents of "BEL VEDERE" Plot No. 258, Central Avenue, Chembur, Mumbai 400071. 2. Mrs. Freda Soares, Major of age, housewife, Wife of Aloysius Soares, r/o B/2, Unique 2000, Housing Society, Chembur, Mumbai. 2025:BHC-GOA:1406 6-SA-46-2024 2 12 3. Mrs. Mrunal Niket Walke, 33 years of age, housewife, Daughter of Ramprasad Joshi, B2, Unique 2000, Housing Society, r/o Near Agriculture Department, Altinho, Mapusa, Bardez Goa. 4. Mrs. Triveni R. Joshi, 52 years of age, Business, Wife of Ramprasad Joshi, r/o H. No. 50, Subray Joshi Road, Joshi wada, Mapusa - Goa. …Respondents Mr Vibhav Amonkar with Mr Omkar Bhave, Mr Raj Chodankar and Mr Shaish Naik, Advocate for the Appellant. Mr G. Panandikar, Advocate for Respondent Nos.3 and 4. CORAM : BHARATI DANGRE, J. DATE : 25th JULY 2025 ORAL JUDGMENT : 1. 2. 6-SA-46-2024 3 12 3. 4. 6-SA-46-2024 4 12 5. 6-SA-46-2024 5 12 6. 7. 6-SA-46-2024 6 12 8. 6-SA-46-2024 7 12 6-SA-46-2024 8 12 6-SA-46-2024 9 12 9. 6-SA-46-2024 10 12 6-SA-46-2024 11 12 10. 6-SA-46-2024 12 12 11. 12. BHARATI DANGRE, J. Signed by: NITI KISHOR HALDANKAR Designation: Private Secretary Date: 01/08/2025 14:41:45