- 1 - !"!# $ %" & '" ! % (()*+ ,( ** ' !""" #$ % $ &' $ !"""! $ $ $ (""" #$ % $$' $ ) % ' $ $ ()" $ & Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * * $ ( ""*$ (" $ * + + , &* --./01 2 34 2()" 5041346 708290 :;02.9:28&113:324<=0//324/.160>/.9.<93/346 2.: 28 93?0 2(" 9063/:0901 7> <9</3?;<9<@< $2=3-0 :<:324 >/.9. 3:> 829 :;0 28804-0/ 5.43/;<7=0 .41090-:324/(""90<1A3:;0-:32428$ 3/ 708290 :;3/ 2.9:.4109 0-:324) 289$ /00B346 906.=<97<3= 0<91=0<9401-2.4/0=829:;05<9:30/ 34 93?0 2(" A</ 9063/:0901 7> <9</3?;<9<@< $2=3-0 :<:324 >/.9. 3:> <6<34/: 9.-0 00<41<42:;09829:;028804-05.43/;<7=0.41090-:324 - 3 - (90<1A3:;0-:32428$24:;07</3/28:;0839/: 34829?<:324 1<:01 "" 90-03C01 892? .=4<DA;2 3/:;0?2:;0928:;010-0</01>01<4/2294:;0839/: 34829?<:324 3: 3/ <C09901 :;<: 839/: 34829?<4:E/ /24 >01 <4/229 A</ 9.44346 < <7<7 /;25 <: <41;34<6<9 40<9 263 311<3<; 5<9B >/.9. <41 ;0 ;<1 6240 2.: 28 :;0 ;2./0 24 "" <: <72.: "" 5? 7.: ;<1 42: 90:.9401;2?0*;04:;0839/:34829?<4::9301:2-24:<-: ;09 /24 2C09 ?273=0 5;240 3: A</ 82.41 :;<: ;3/ ?273=0 5;240A<//A3:-;01288;090<8:0908829:/A090?<10:2 :9<-0 /<31 >01 <4/229 <41 ;3/ -<9 A</ 82.41 5<9B01 40<9:;0?<9B0:<90<28263311<3<;5<9B34-0<--./01 2/<41;<10<9=309F.<990=01A3:;>01<4/229:;0 839/:34829?<4:/./50-:01:;0;<4128<--./01 2/<41 <413:3/34:;3/7<-B692.41/;0;<1<5592<-;01:;052=3-0 <41 /.7?3::01 839/: 34829?<:324 7</01 24 A;3-; 34 93?0 2(" A</ 9063/:0901 .9346 :;0 -2.9/0 28 34C0/:36<:324 :;0 50:3:32409 ;09034 A</ <990/:01 24 "" ;0 34C0/:36<:324 34 :;0 -</0 3/ -2?5=0:01 <41 -;<960 /;00: ;</ 7004 83=01 <6<34/: 82.9 <--./01 - 4 - 509/24/;050:3:32409;</7004<99<>01</<--./01 2 34 :;0 -;<960 /;00: ;0 7<3= <55=3-<:324 83=01 7> :;0 50:3:32409 708290 :;0 93<= 2.9: 34 2()" A</ 90@0-:0124""(";0908290;03/708290:;3/2.9: 0<9401-2.4/0=829:;050:3:32409/.7?3:/:;<: :;0 -</0 28 :;0 592/0-.:324 3/ 7</01 24 -39-.?/:<4:3<= 0C3104-0 ;0 <==06<:324/ <6<34/: :;0 50:3:32409 <41 <--./01 2<90/3?3=<9--./01 2;</700469<4:01 906.=<9 7<3= 7> :;3/ 2.9: 34 93?34<= $0:3:324 2)!" 0 /.7?3:/ :;<: 50:3:32409 ;</ 42 2:;09 -93?34<= <4:0-0104:/ <41 <--291346=> ;0 59<>/ :2 <==2A :;050:3:324 $09 -24:9< =0<9401 36; 2.9: 2C094?04: $=0<109;</2552/01:;050:3:324 ( / 509 :;0 -;<960 /;00: <==06<:324/ <--./01 2/ <41 ;<1 3==A3== <6<34/: 10-0</01 >01 <4/229 <41 24 "" 40<9 ?<9B0: <90< 28 263 311<3<; 5<9B<--./01 2<41;<1<7./01<41<//<.=:01;3? --./01 2A;2A</590/04:<=246A3:;<--./01 2/ - 5 - <41;<1<//3/:01:;0?:25.==2.:>01<4/229892?;3/ -<9 70<9346 9063/:9<:324 2"( ;090<8:09 <--./01 2/<41-<99301>01<4/229:2:;0/52:28 -93?0 40<9 <4<9< <4B 70;341 =4/<<9 2/53:<= <41 <--./01 2/ <41 <==0601=> B3-B01 ;3? --./01 2 1925501 < /:240 24 :;0 ;0<1 28 >01 <4/229 <41 ?.910901;3?8:09:;0?.9109A</-2??3::01<--./01 2/<41A3:;:;0;0=528<--./01 2;<1/;38:01:;0 10<1 721> <41 :;92A4 :;0 /<?0 34:2 < -<4<= ;0 <==06<:324<6<34/:<--./01 2/<4134:;0-;<960/;00: 3//3?3=<9--./01 2;</700469<4:01906.=<97<3=7> :;3/2.9:3493?34<=$0:3:324 2)!" ! 4109 /.-; -39-.?/:<4-0/ <? 28 :;0 C30A :;<:50:3:32409E/59<>0982969<4:28906.=<97<3=3/90F.3901 :270<4/A0901<8839?<:3C0=>--291346=>82==2A34629109 3/5<//01+ ;050:3:3243/<==2A01 - 6 - ;0 50:3:32409<--./01 2 3/ 1390-:01 :2 70 04=<9601 24 7<3= 34 2()" 5041346 708290 :;0 2.9:28&113:324<=0//324/.160>/.9.<93/3462.: 28 93?0 2(" 9063/:0901 7> <9</3?;<9<@< $2=3-0 :<:324 >/.9. 3:> 829 :;0 28804-0/ 5.43/;<7=0 .4109 0-:324/ ( " " 90<1 A3:; 0-:324 28 $ /.7@0-::2:;082==2A346-2413:324/+ <' $0:3:32409/;<==0G0-.:0509/24<=7241829< /.? 28 /""""" A3:; :A2 /.90:30/ 829 :;0 =3B0/.? :2 :;0 /<:3/8<-:324 28 :;0 @.93/13-:324<= 2.9:H 7' $0:3:32409 /;<== <550<9 906.=<9=> 24 <== :;0 1<:0/28;0<9346708290:;093<=2.9:.4=0//:;0 93<= 2.9: 0G0?5:/ ;3/ <550<9<4-0 829 C<=31 90</24/H -' $0:3:32409 /;<== 42: 1390-:=> 29 341390-:=> :;90<:04 29 :<?509 A3:; :;0 592/0-.:324 A3:40//0/H 1' $0:3:32409 /;<== 42: 34C2=C0 34 /3?3=<9 28804-0/348.:.90H - 7 - 0' $0:3:32409/;<==42:=0<C0:;0@.93/13-:32428 :;0 93<= 2.9: A3:;2.: 509?3//324 28 :;0 /<31 2.9: .4:3= :;0 -</0 9063/:0901 <6<34/: ;3? 3/ 13/52/01288 -+. ( & '" !* " 3/: 2+)= 2+) +$