Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2025 DAILYLAW 35675 (KAR)
MOHAMMAD SINAN ABDULLA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
CRL.P/12706/2024 · 2025-02-05
S Vishwajith Shetty
body2025
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 35675 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2025 DAILYLAW 35675 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "#$ %#
" & '(&)*+
,'&** +%
" ( & '(&)*+ ,'&**
+
%
! "#$
# # # #
#
%&&&
! # $
Digitally signed by SHIVAKUMAR HIREMATH Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
#
# # ! '
# %'
& # # # '!($!($!$ #
) # # # #
# # * #
(+
%
%
"
#
! "#$
# # # #
#
%&&&
! # $
#
# #! ' $
# %'
&
#
# '!#$
!#$!$ #
) ## # #
# #
*
#
- 3 -
# ) +
#+ , *#")*
((-./0 1.234#536/ 1%'
& 5/73.8/5/09: # #536/ 1;3(/ 8<8314 <47<;15/ <=.>34< <44<0< 3.853(8?151??/4(/.@-43.><9;/-40/5/(8314.'!#$#2 !$1? (85/<0A38>/(83141? #<5/9/?15/ 8>3. #1-58 -40/5 /(8314 1? #5 # .//=347 5/7-;<5 9<3;
/<508>/;/<54/0(1-4./;?158>/@<583/. 34#536/ 1%'
&A<.5/73.8/5/09:# #536/ 1;3(/ 8<8314 <47<;15/ <7<34.8 14/ -><66<0 .><4 <40?1-518>/5.148>/9<.3.1?8>/?35.834?156<83140<8/0 && 5/(/3B/0 ?516 ><5<4<@@< ><40<5: 1;3(/ ??3(/5 <88<(>/0 81 ## @1;3(/ <47<;15/ 438 <=.>34< <44<0<3.853(848>/?35.834?156<83148>/@/838314/5. >/5/34<5/<55<:/0<.<((-./0 1.<40;;/7<831434 8>/?35.834?156<83143.8><89<./014(5/039;/34?156<8314
- 4 -
5/(/3B/0 8>/ ?35.8 34?156<48 <;147 A38> 8>/ .8<?? <40 @<4(><. ><0 (140-(8/0 < 5<30 81 8>/ @;<(/ A>/5/ ?1-5 @/5.14. ><0 <;;/7/0;: 951-7>8 (1485<9<40 <583(;/ 34 < (<5 9/<5347 5/73.85<8314 4-69/5 &# '?158>/@-5@1./1?./;;3478>/.<6/818>/@-9;3(<40 8>/.<30?1-5@/5.14.A/5/<@@5/>/40/04/4C-35:8>/:
5/B/<;/0 8>/35 4<6/. <. 1><66<0 634 1><66<0 34<4 1><66<0 <-6<4 <40 1><66<0 <?//; A>1 <5/<55<:/0<.<((-./0 1.81348>/#1485<9<40 <583(;/ <;;/7/0;: 818<;;: A/37>347 & 75<6. A<. ./3D/0 ?516 8>/ 0<.>91<50 1? 8>/ (<5 <40 14 34C-35: 8>/ <@@5/>/40/0 <((-./0 <;;/7/0;: 34?156/0 8>/ ?35.8 34?156<48 8><8 <8 8>/ 34.8<4(/ 1? 14/ 1><66<0 .><4 A>1 A<. <55<:/0 <. <((-./0 1 34 8>/ 8>/: ><0 @-5(><./0 8>/ (1485<9<40 <583(;/ <40 951-7>8 38 81 <47<;15/ ?15 8>/ @-5@1./ 1? .<;/ >/ <@@5/>/40/0 <((-./0 <40 ./3D/0 (1485<9<40 <583(;/ A/5/ .-9E/(8/0 81 <4(><4<6< <40 8>/5/<?8/5 A<. 5/73.8/5/0 <7<34.8 ?3B/@/5.14.>/?1-5@/5.14.A>1<5/<@@5/>/40/0A/5/ .-9./C-/48;: <55/.8/0 <40 5/6<40/0 81 E-03(3<; (-.810:
- 5 -
4B/.837<8314 1? 8>/ (<./ 3. (16@;/8/0 <40 (><57/ .>//8 ><. 9//4 ?3;/0 /838314/5. A>1 <5/ <55<:/0 <. <((-./0 1.<40348>/<5/<55<:/0<.<((-./0 1.2 348>/(><57/.>//8>/359<3;<@@;3(<8314?3;/09/?15/8>/ *-53.03(8314<; /..314. #1-58 34 #536/ 1%'
& A<. 5/E/(8/0 14 &%&'& >/5/?15/ 8>/: <5/ 9/?15/ 8>3. #1-58
/<54/0 (1-4./; ?15 8>/ @/838314/5 .-9638. 8><8 @/838314/5. <5/ .8-0/48. @-5.-347 8>/35 (1-5./ 34 /41@<:< #1;;/7/ <8 <47<;15/ >/: 01 418 ><B/ <4: (53634<; <48/(/0/48 >/: ><0 14;: <((16@<43/0 8>/ 18>/5 8A1 <((-./0 A>1 <5/ <;.1 8>/35 (;<..6<8/.
/ .-9638.8><88>/5/3.41(16@;3<4(/1?/(8314<40 !$1?8>/<(8348>/@5/./48(<./4B/.837<83141?8>/ (<./3.<;5/<0:(16@;/8/0((150347;:>/@5<:.81<;;1A 8>/@/838314
/5 (1485< ;/<54/0 37> #1-58 1B/546/48 ;/<0/5 ><.1@@1./08>/@/838314
- 6 -
% <8/53<; 14 5/(150 A1-;0 71 81 .>1A 8><8 9<./0 14 (5/039;/ 34?156<8314 5/(/3B/0 8>/ ?35.8 34?156<48 ><. (140-(8/0<5<30<40?5168>/<;;/7/0.@18?1-5@/5.14. A/5/ <@@5/>/40/0 <40 ?516 8>/35 (-.810: & 75<6. 1? (1485<9<40 583(;/ A<. ./3D/0 /3D/0 (1485<9<40 <583(;/ ><. 41A 8/.8/0 @1.383B/ 81 < 05-7 =41A4 <. F/8><6@>/8<634/G <40 .<30 05-7 A/37>347 <91B/ & 75<6. 3. (14.30/5/0 <. < (166/5(3<; C-<4838: >/ 05-7 A<../3D/0?5168>/(<534A>3(><((-./0 1.81><0 <553B/0818>/.@18?516A>/5/8>/:A/5/<55/.8/0
<8/53<; 14 5/(150 A1-;0 71 81 .>1A 8><8 5<30 A<. (140-(8/0 <40 8>/ (1485<9<40 <583(;/ A<. ./3D/0 9: 8>/ ?35.834?156<48)>/5/<.34(16@;3<4(/1?./(83141?8>/ (85/@1583.418?3;/09:8>/?35.834?156<48<408>/5/?15/ 38 <@@/<5. 8><8 8>/5/ 3. 41 (16@;3<4(/ 1? /(83141?8>/(8348>/@5/./48(<./8<;.1<@@/<5. 8><88>/(><57/.>//86<8/53<;<;.101/.4185/?;/(88><8 8>/5/3.(16@;3<4(/1?5/C-35/6/481?/(8314!$1?8>/ (8 34 8>/ @5/./48 (<./ 4 <0038314 81 8>/ .<6/
- 7 -
@/838314/5. A>1 <5/ .8-0/48. 01 418 ><B/ <4: 18>/5 (53634<;<48/(/0/48.40/58>/(35(-6.8<4(/.8>/53715 -40/5 /(8314 !$!9$1? 8>/ (8(<44189/ B/5: .853(8;: 6<0/ <@@;3(<9;/ <. <7<34.8 8>/6 >/: <5/ 34 (-.810: ?516 && #14834-/0 0/8/48314 1? 8>/ @/838314/5. A>1 <5/ :1-47.8/5. <40 .8-0/48. @-5.-347 8>/35
(1-5./ 3. ;3=/;: 81 ><B/ <0B/5./ 36@<(8 14 8>/35 ?-8-5/ (<5//5<40@51.@/(8. ' 40/5 8>/ (35(-6.8<4(/. <6 1? 8>/ B3/A A38>1-8 /H@5/..347<4:1@34314148>/6/538.<400/6/538.1?8>/ (<./@5<:/5?1575<481?5/7-;<59<3;4//0.819/<4.A/5/0 <??356<83B/;:((150347;:8>/?1;;1A347+
>/#53634<; /838314.<5/
>/@/838314/5.<5/035/(8/0819//4;<57/0149<3;34 #536/ 1%'
& 5/73.8/5/09:# #536/ 1;3(/8<8314 <47<;15/ <=.>34< <44<0< 3.853(8 ?15 1??/4(/. @-43.><9;/-40/5/(8314.'!#$#2!$1? (8 5/<0 A38> /(8314 1? # @/40347 9/?15/ 8>/ ;/<54/0
- 8 -
534(3@<; 3.853(8 2 /..314. *-07/ <=.>34< <44<0< <47<;15/.-9E/(8818>/?1;;1A347(14038314.+ <$>/ @/838314/5. <((-./0 2 .><;; /H/(-8/ @/5.14<; 9140 ?15 < .-6 1? .&&&&&
A38> 8A1 .-5/83/. /<(> ?15 8>/ ;3=/.-6 81 8>/ .<83.?<(83141?8>/E-53.03(8314<;#1-58I 9$>/ @/838314/5. <((-./0 2 .><;; <@@/<5 5/7-;<5;: 14 <;; 8>/ 0<8/. 1? >/<5347 9/?15/ 8>/ 53<; #1-58 -4;/.. 8>/ 53<; #1-58 /H/6@8. 8>/35 <@@/<5<4(/?15B<;305/<.14.I ($ >/@/838314/5. <((-./02.><;;418035/(8;:
15 34035/(8;: 8>5/<8/4 15 8<6@/5 A38> 8>/ @51./(-8314A384/../.I 0$>/@/838314/5. <((-./02.><;;41834B1;B/34 .363;<51??/4(/.34?-8-5/I /$>/@/838314/5. <((-./02.><;;418;/<B/8>/ E-53.03(83141?8>/53<;#1-58A38>1-8@/563..314 1?8>/.<30#1-58-483;8>/(<./5/73.8/5/0<7<34.8 8>/63.03.@1./01?? -+. &$ %# * #
3.8 1+; 1+