- 1 - ! " # $!% &! $ ' '()* ')) & ! "#$ % & ! "$ % '() "% '( $ *'* **' %%% &*' ('* (*( (*' ( () () *& + &') % %% #% + % * **' % % + , Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - , -# +# & ../012 3 45 6471 3* **' 6184091612 :; <58<=361/6<=3=4.19<9435<58<=/6/49;>369?13>>15.10 @/540?<:=1/52161.94350&*' (*(*((*'( () () *&61<2A49?1.9435&')3>40:1>3619?403/69 /52161.9435'()3>6011B458618/=<6:<4= * 1<629?1=1<6512.3/501=>369?1@<69410 ( % 45 6471 3* **' A<0 6184091612 :; <58<=361 /6<= 3=4.1 9<9435 <58<=/6/ 49; 45494<==; >36 9?1 3>>15.10 @/540?<:=1 /5216 1.94350 () () <52 &') 3> <8<4509/5B53A5@160350:<012359?1>460945>367<94352<912 ****' 61.14C12 >637 <27<5<:?< 39;<5 3 =<91 3B<;;<33D<6;/64589?1.3/6013>45C10948<9435@194943516 ?16145 A<0 <6610912 35 ' **' <52 617<5212 93 D/24.4<= ./0932; 5C10948<9435 45 9?1 .<01 40 .37@=1912 <52 .?<681 0?119 ?<0 :115 >4=12 <0 <8<4509 & <../012 @160350 <52 9?1 @194943516 ?16145 40 <66<48512 <0 <../012 3 45 9?1 .?<681 0?119 <4= <@@=4.<9435 >4=12 :; 9?1 @194943516 :1>361 9?1 - 3 - D/64024.9435<= 1004350 3/69 45 6=40. 3)) **' A<0 61D1.91235&&**'?161>361?140:1>3619?403/69 ' 1<6512 .3/501= >36 9?1 @194943516 0/:7490 9?<9 <../012 30' & <52 && ?<C1 :115 86<5912 618/=<6 :<4= :; 9?40 3/69 194943516 ?<0 53 39?16 .64745<= <591.121590 5C10948<9435 45 9?1 .<01 40 .37@=1912 <52 .?<681 0?119 ?<0 :115 >4=12 40 ./0932; 40 53 7361 61E/4612 ..362458=; ?1 @6<;093<==3A9?1@1949435 16 .3596< =1<6512 48? 3/69 3C1657159 =1<216 ?<0 3@@30129?1@194943510/:74909?<99?1614061.3C16;459?1 @610159.<01>6379?1@194943516<52?40@61015.1<99?10@393> .647140>3/52459?1>339<81../012@160350A?3?<C1 :11586<5912618/=<6:<4=:;9?403/69A161539@610159<99?1 0@39 3> .6471 194943516 ?<4=0 >637 16<=< 9<91 <52 45 9?1 1C159 ?1 40 15=<6812 35 :<4= ?1 40 =4B1=; 93 >=11 <A<; >637 D/094.1..362458=;?1@6<;09324074009?1@1949435 @16/0<= 3> 9?1 .?<681 0?119 A3/=2 83 93 0?3A 9?<9 <../012 3* A<0 9?1 264C16 9?1 94@@16 =366; :1=358458 93 9?1 >4609 45>367<59 <52 ?1 ?<2 .350@4612 A49? ?40 >64152 <../012 3( 93 .37749 63::16; 45 9?1 ?3/01 3> >4609 45>367<59 5 - 4 - >/69?16<5.1 3> 0/.? .350@46<.; <../012 3( <==1812=; .359<.912 <../012 3' A?3 45 9/65 .359<.912 ?40 >64152 <../012 3 >637 16<=< A?3 .350@4612 A49? 39?16 <../012 @160350<527<21<66<58171590>36.3774994582<.349;459?1 ?3/01 3> >4609 45>367<59 5 >/69?16<5.1 3> 0<42 .350@46<.; 35 *&**'<../012 30 )&&&*93&.<71459A3 C1?4.=10 :1<6458 6184096<9435 3*&* <52 '# <52<7358099?1<>3610<42<../012<../012 30 &*&(&&& F&?<2159161245939?1.37@3/52A<==3> 9?1>460945>367<59-0?3/01<9<:3/9@735*&**' <52<>9169?61<9154589?1>460945>367<59<529?1457<9103>9?1 ?3/01 ?<2 <==1812=; .37749912 63::16; 3> 9?1 C<=/<:=10 45.=/2458 83=2 <52 04=C16 D1A1=6; <52 <=03 .<0? <52 39?16 <694.=10<52?<210.<@12>6379?10@39 ../012 3 40 9?1 @<69 3> 8<58 3> &* 717:160 A?4.? ?<2.371459A3C1?4.=1093.377499?1.6471<52<=03A<0< @<69 3> 9?1 8<58 3> 5451 717:160 A?3 ?<2 1591612 4593 9?1 .37@3/52A<==3>>460945>367<59G0?3/0193.377499?1.6471 ?17<9164<=3561.362A3/=283930?3A9?<99?1614061.3C16; 459?1@610159.<01>6379?1@194943516<52=1<6512?<0 <=030/:7499129?<9?40@61015.140>3/52459?1>339<81 - 5 - 3> 9?1 ?3/01 ../012 30' & <52 && A?3 ?<C1 :115 86<5912 618/=<6 :<4= :; 9?40 3/69 A161 539 @<69 3> 9?1 8<58 A?4.? ?<2 1591612 4593 9?1 .37@3/52 A<== 3> ?3/01 3> >4609 45>367<59 35 *&**' <52 <==18<9435 <8<4509 9?1 0<42 <../012 @160350 40 <:3/9 .350@46<.; 3=2 <52 04=C16 D1A1=6; <5239?16C<=/<:=1<694.=103>A?4.?63::16;A<0.3774991245 9?1 @610159 .<01 ?<C1 :115 61.3C1612 >637 <../012 3&( A?3A<0@<693>8<583>5451717:160A?3?<215916124593 9?1 .37@3/52 A<== 3> >4609 45>367<59G0 ?3/01 35 *&**' 161=; >36 9?1 61<035 9?<9 45C10948<9435 45 9?1 .<01 40 .37@=1912 <52 .?<681 0?119 ?<0 :115 >4=12 @194943516 .<5539 :1 86<5912 :<4= 7361 03 A?15 9?1 .?<681 0?119 <==18<94350 0?3A 9?<9 9?1 <../012 @160350 ?<C1 .37749912 ?1453/0 3>>15.1 ?<681 0?11912 3>>15.10 <61 @/540?<:=1 A49? =4>147@640357159 52169?1.46./709<5.10<73>9?13@45435 9?<9 <9 9?40 09<81 @6<;16 7<21 :; 9?1 @194943516 >36 86<59 3> 618/=<6 :<4= .<5539 :1 159169<4512 ..362458=; @1949435 40 240740012 +*, '% &! ) ! 409 3,&)= 3, ,