- 1 - ! " # $ % # & '&()* '&)) % ! "#$ "! # ## !!# %& ! !#$ ! # ' ## ( $ ! #'' #& ! # ! # $ #$ (#$ # "! ) ! ! " # * # Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! # ! ) ! + #+ !, * #"!)*!! --./012340-256#5/07''403123890:7;0 <=0 #7.;< 7: " 112<27356 2/<;2-< 531 0//273/ *.180 538567;0 .;56 2/<;2-< 538567;0 5;2/238 7.< 7: #;2>0 7& ;082/<0;01 :7; 7::03-0/ 4.32/=5960 .310; 0-<273/ 9$ -$ 531 (-$ 7: 5;-7<2- ;.8/ 531 /?-=7<;742- .9/<53-0/ :7; /=7;< @ A$ -< &'(% 2/ 90:7;0 <=2/ #7.;< .310; 0-<273 ' 7: #;# /00B238 ;08.65;9526 !05;1<=0605;301-7.3/06:7;<=045;<20/ 23 #;2>0 7& C5/ ;082/<0;01 9? 76510D535=5662762-0<5<273538567;0:7;<=05:7;0/521 7::03-0/ 58523/< <=040<2<2730;=0;023 73 <=095/2/ 7: <=0 :2;/< 23:7;>5<273 15<01 ' ;0-02D01 :;7> 5385445 5;5951 762-0 .9 3/40-<7; 5<<5-=01 <7 76510D535=5662 762-0 <5<273 538567;0 .;238 <=0 - 3 - -7.;/0 7: 23D0/<285<273 7: <=0 -5/0 40<2<2730; =0;023 C5/ 5;;0/<0173'531;0>53101<7E.12-256-./<71? 3D0/<285<273 7: <=0 -5/0 2/ -7>460<01 531 -=5;80 /=00< =5/9003:260158523/<=2>:7;<=05:7;0/5217::03-0/526 54462-5<273:260190:7;0<=0<;256#7.;<.310;0-<273'7: #;# 23 40-256 #5/0 7'' C5/ ;0E0-<01 73 &&=0;0:7;0=02/90:7;0<=2/#7.;< 05;301#7.3/06:7;<=040<2<2730;/.9>2</<=5< <=040<2<2730;2/5?7.38/<0;5801597.<?05;/=5D238 37 -;2>2356 53<0-0103</ =0;0 2/ 37 -7>46253-0 7: 0-<2737:<=0-<23<=04;0/03<-5/0531<=0;02/53 237;1235<0 1065? 23 -7>46?238 <=0 ;0F.2;0>03< 7: 0-<273 %$ 7: <=0 -< ;256 23 <=0 -5/0 2/ ?0< <7 90 -7>>03-01--7;12386?=04;5?/<75667C<=040<2<273 % 0; #73<;5 605;301 !28= #7.;< 7D0;3>03< 60510; =5/ 7447/01 <=0 40<2<273 !0 /.9>2</ <=5< <=0 /02G01 -73<;59531 5;<2-60 2/ 7: -7>>0;-256 F.53<2<? 531 <=0;0:7;0 <=0;287;.310; 0-<273&$9$ 7: <=0-<2/ 54462-5960<7<=04;0/03<-5/0!056/7 /.9>2</<=5<<=0 - 4 - 40<2<2730; =526/ :;7> 0;565 531 <=0;0:7;0 2< C7.61 90 12::2-.6< <7 /0-.;0 =2/ 4;0/03-0 90:7;0 <=0 #7.;< --7;12386?=04;5?/<712/>2//<=040<2<273 0;./56 7: <=0 >5<0;256 73 ;0-7;1 C7.61 <7 87 /=7C <=5< <=0 :2;/< 23:7;>53< =51 ;0-02D01 -;012960 23:7;>5<273 5< 597.< &&% 4> 73 ' C=03 =0 C5/23<=04762-0/<5<273597.<540;/73>5B2385<<0>4</ <7 /066 -73<;59531 5;<2-60/ <7 <=0 4.962- 0;./56 7: <=0 :2;/< 23:7;>5<273 531 7<=0; >5<0;256 5D5265960 73 ;0-7;1 C7.61 87 <7 /=7C <=5< <=0 ;0F.2;0>03< 7: 0-<273 7: <=05-<C5/37<-7>46201C2<=9?<=0:2;/<23:7;>53<90:7;0 4;7-001238 <7 -731.-< 5;521 531 544;0=031 <=0 5--./01 40;/73/:<0;<=0:2;/<23:7;>5<273C5/;0-02D01;521C5/ -731.-<019?<=0 :2;/< 23:7;>53< 56738 C2<= <=0 /<5:: 531 40<2<2730; C5/ 544;0=03101 :;7> <=0 5660801 /47< C=0;0 =0C5/>5B2385<<0>4</<7/066<=0-73<;595315;<2-60531 :;7> =2/ 47 273 8;5>/ 7: -73<;59531 5;<2-60 56608016? 531 ' 8;5>/ 7: -73<;59531 5;<2-60 56608016? 853E5 C5/ /02G01 =0 -73<;59531 5;<2-60 - 5 - 56608016? =5/<0/<0147/2<2D0<75/.9/<53-0B37C3 5/ >0<=5>4=0<5>230 1.;238 <=0 -7.;/0 7: -=0>2-56 0H5>235<273 7: <=0 /5>460 1;.8 C=2-= C5/ :7;C5;101 <7 <=0<5<0 7;03/2--203-0 597;5<7;?9?<=03D0/<285<273 ::2-0; =0 >5<0;256 73 ;0-7;1 C7.61 87 <7 /=7C <=5< <=7.8= <=0 -73<;59531 5;<2-60/ C0;0 /02G01 .310; 5 >5=5G5; 73 ' 2</06: <=0 23D03<7;? 7: <=0 -73<;59531 5;<2-60/ 5/ ;0F.2;01 .310; 0-<273 % $ 7: <=0 -<C5/4;045;01736?73&=0;02/ 53 237;1235<0 1065? 23 4;045;238 <=0 23D03<7;? C=2-= 2/ .30H46523019?<=04;7/0-.<273 312/4.<016? 40<2<2730; =5/ 37 7<=0; -;2>2356 53<0-0103</ 531 =0 2/ 5801 597.< ?05;/ !0 2/ 23 -./<71?:7;<=065/<>7;0<=53&%>73<=/531<;25623<=0 -5/0 2/ ?0< <7 -7>>03-0 531 <=0 4;7/0-.<273 23 566 =5/ -2<01&&-=5;80/=00<C2<30//0/23<=04;0/03<-5/0 ( 44;0=03/2730H4;0//019?605;301!28=#7.;< 7D0;3>03<60510;-5390<5B03-5;07:9?<=02>47/238 - 6 - 544;74;25<0 -7312<273/ 5/ 58523/< <=0 40<2<2730; --7;12386?4;7-001<745//<=0:7667C2387;10;+ =040<2<2732/+,,-./ =0 40<2<2730; 2/ 12;0-<01 <7 90 0365;801 73 9526 23 #;2>0 7& 7: 76510D535=5662 762-0 <5<273 03856.;. #2<? ;082/<0;01 :7; <=0 7::03-0/ 4.32/=5960 .310; 0-<273/ 9$ -$ 531 (-$ 7: -< &'(% 4031238 23 46#7'' 73 <=0 :260 7: <=0 605;301 " 112<27356 2/<;2-< 531 0//273/ *.180 03856.;. .;56 2/<;2-< 03856.;. /.9E0-< <7 <=0 :7667C238 -7312<273/+ 5$=040<2<2730;/=5660H0-.<040;/73569731:7;5 /.> 7: /& C2<= <C7 /.;0<20/ :7; <=0 62B0/.> 7.< 7: <=0 /5>0 730 /.;0<? /=566 90 67-56 /.;0<?$ <7 <=0 /5<2/:5-<273 7: <=0 E.;2/12-<27356#7.;<I 9$=0 40<2<2730; /=566 54405; ;08.65;6? 73 566 <=0 15<0/7:=05;23890:7;0<=0;256#7.;<.360//<=0 - 7 - ;256 #7.;< 0H0>4</ =2/ 54405;53-0 :7; D5621 ;05/73/I -$ =0 40<2<2730; /=566 37< 12;0-<6? 7; 2312;0-<6? <=;05<03 7; <5>40; C2<= <=0 4;7/0-.<273 C2<30//0/I 1$=0 40<2<2730; /=566 37< 23D76D0 23 /2>265; 7::03-0/23:.<.;0I 0$=0 40<2<2730; /=566 37< 605D0 <=0 E.;2/12-<273 7: <=0 ;256 #7.;< C2<=7.< 40;>2//273 7: <=0 /521 #7.;< .3<26 <=0 -5/0 ;082/<0;01 58523/< =2> 2/ 12/47/017:: /*0 &$ % ) 2/<7+&'67+ #+