- 1 - ! "# $ % # & '&()* '&)) % ! "#$ %& & ' ! &$ % ( !% ) $ * (% %++ %% % , # " % %% )()()()( *% Digitally signed by SHILPA R TENIHALLI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % * - - ." # *" //0123 45 6 ++ 7253458 92:6;2 <=2 60;< 6: , 334<465>? 4<@ 4A4? >53 2114651 "0382 258>?0;0>;4145860<6:/;4B2 6( ++;2841<2;239@ 09;>B>5@>70;> 6?4/2 <><465 >58>?6;2 4<@ :6; <=2 6::25/21 70541=>9?2 0532; 2/<4651 )( )( )( >53)(;2>3C4<= 2/<4656:4192:6;2<=4160;< 45 <=41 10//2114A29>4? >77?4/><465 :4?23 0532; 2/<465 ( 6:;122D458;280?>;9>4? + 2>;3<=2?2>;523/60512?:6;<=27>;<421 % 45 /;4B2 6( ++ C>1 ;2841<2;23 9@ 09;>B>5@>70;> 6?4/2 <><465 >58>?6;2 4<@ :6; <=2 >:6;21>43 6::25/21 >8>451< <=2 72<4<4652; >53 >56<=2; 65 <=2 9>141 6: <=2 :4;1< 45:6;B><465 3><23 (++ ;2/24A23 :;6B >8=0 >4D 6?4/2 09 5172/<6; ><<>/=23 <6 09;>B>5@>70;>6?4/2 <><465>58>?6;20;458<=2 - 3 - /60;12 6: 45A21<48><465 72<4<4652; =2;245C>1 >;;21<23 65 (++ >53 10912E025<?@ ;2B>5323 <6 F034/4>? /01<63@ 5A21<48><465 6: <=2 />12 41 /6B7?2<23 >53 /=>;82 1=22< =>1 9225 :4?23 45 <=2 7;2125< />12 >8>451< :60;72;1651>5372<4<4652;41>;;>@23>1>//0123 645 <=2 /=>;82 1=22< >4? >77?4/><465 :4?23 9@ <=2 72<4<4652; 92:6;2 <=2 F0;4134/<465>? 2114651 60;< C>1 ;2F2/<23 >53 <=2;2:6;2=2=>32>;?42;>77;6>/=23<=260;<45;? 6 ++ ++ C=4/= C>1 ;2F2/<23 65 +()++ =2;2>:<2; 72<4<4652; =>3 :4?23 ;?41/ 6)( ++ 92:6;2 <=2 F0;4134/<465>? 2114651 60;< C=4/= C>1 ;2F2/<2365+(++=2;2:6;2=24192:6;2<=4160;< 45<=4110//2114A29>4?>77?4/><465 2>;523/60512?:6;<=272<4<4652;109B4<1<=>< <=2 72<4<4652; >823 >960< @2>;1 41 45 /01<63@ :6; <=2 ?>1<<C6@2>;1>53=2=>1566<=2;/;4B45>?>5<2/2325<1 2 109B4<1 <=>< >//012 61+ <6 =>A2 9225 8;>5<23 ;280?>; 9>4? 9@ <=41 60;< >:<2; 341B411>? 6: 72<4<4652;G1 2>;?42;/;4B45>?72<4<4652109B4<1<=><<;4>?45<=2/>12 - 4 - 41 @2< <6 92 /6BB25/23 //6;3458?@ =2 7;>@1 <6 >??6C <=272<4<465 2; /65<;> ?2>;523 48= 60;< 6A2;5B25< ?2>32;=>16776123<=272<4<4652109B4<1<=><<=2;241 56/=>58245/4;/0B1<>5/2<625<2;<>45<=210//211:0?9>4? >77?4/><465>5345<=22A25<72<4<4652;4125?>;823659>4? =241?4D2?@<6:?22>C>@:;6BF01<4/2 2;01>? 6: <=2 B><2;4>? >A>4?>9?2 65 ;2/6;3 C60?3 86 <6 1=6C <=>< <=2 72<4<4652; =2;245 >53 >//0123 6+C2;2>;;21<23 C=25 <=2@ C2;2B>D458 ><<2B7<1<6 /4;/0?><2 <=2 /605<2;:24< 7>;<1 C=4/= <=2@ =>3 9;608=< :;6B 53=;> ;>321= <><2 <6 &>;5><>D> %;6B <=2 76112114656:>//0123 61>53++)/605<2;:24<56<21 6:1 3256B45><465C>1124H23>53>7<67 C=4/=/65<>45231/>552356<2:4?21>7;45<2;>53>45D 96<<?2 0123 :6; 7;27>;458 <=2 /605<2;:24< 56<21 C2;2 10912E025<?@;2/6A2;23:;6B<=2/01<63@6:>//0123 61 >53//0123 6+=>192258;>5<23;280?>;9>4?9@<=2 /66;345><2 25/= 6: <=41 60;< 45 ;? 6+ ++ - 5 - 34176123 6: 65 +++++ //0123 6 =>1 9225 8;>5<23 ;280?>; 9>4? 9@ <=41 60;< 45 ;? 6+++ ++ 34176123 6: 65 ++ >53 >//0123 6 =>1 9225 8;>5<23;280?>;9>4?9@<=2F0;4134/<465>? 211465160;<45 ;?41/ 6) ++341761236:65+)++ 2<4<4652;>823>960<@2>;1=>156/;4B45>? >5<2/2325<1 >53 =2 41 45 /01<63@ :6; <=2 ?>1< 52>;?@ <C6 @2>;1;612/0<465=>1/4<23++/=>;821=22<C4<52112145 <=2 7;2125< />12 >53 <=2 <;4>? 45 <=2 />12 41 @2< <6 92 /6BB25/23 =2 65G9?2 07;2B2 60;< 45 <=2 />12 6: ;276;<23 45 ! >< 7>;> 6=>16912;A23>1:6??6C1I J - 6 - ) 77;2=2514652K7;211239@?2>;52348=60;< 6A2;5B25< ?2>32; />5 92 <>D25 />;2 6: 9@ 4B761458 >77;67;4><2 /6534<4651 65 <=2 72<4<4652; C=4?2 25?>;8458 =4B659>4? ( 532; <=2 /4;/0B1<>5/21 >B 6: <=2 /651432;23 A42C <=>< C4<=60< 2K7;211458 >5@ 6745465 65 <=2B2;4<1>5332B2;4<16:<=2/>12<=27;>@2;B>329@ <=2 72<4<4652; :6; 8;>5< 6: ;280?>; 9>4? 52231 <6 92 >51C2;23>::4;B><4A2?@//6;3458?@7;6/223<67>11<=2 :6??6C458- =272<4<46541 " =2 72<4<4652; >//0123 6 41 34;2/<23 <6 92 25?>;823659>4?45;4B2 6( ++6: 09;>B>5@>70;> 6?4/2 <><465258>?0;04<@;2841<2;23:6;<=26::25/21 70541=>9?2 0532; 2/<4651 )( )( )( )( ;2>3 C4<= 2/<4656:725345845 6 ++65<=2 :4?2 6: 60;< 6: ?2>;523 , 334<465>? 4<@ 4A4? >53 - 7 - 2114651 "0382 258>?0;0 109F2/< <6 <=2 :6??6C458 /6534<4651- >$=272<4<4652;1=>??2K2/0<272;165>?9653:6;> 10B 6: 1 C4<= <C6 10;2<421 :6; <=2 ?4D210B60<6:C=4/=6521=>??92>?6/>?10;2<@ <6<=21><41:>/<4656:<=2F0;4134/<465>?60;<I 9$=2 72<4<4652; 1=>?? >772>; ;280?>;?@ 65 >?? <=2 3><216:=2>;45892:6;2<=2;4>?60;<05?211<=2 ;4>? 60;< 2K2B7<1 =41 >772>;>5/2 :6; A>?43 ;2>1651I /$ =2 72<4<4652; 1=>?? 56< 34;2/<?@ 6; 4534;2/<?@ <=;2><25 6; <>B72; C4<= <=2 7;612/0<465 C4<521121I 3$=2 72<4<4652; 1=>?? 56< 45A6?A2 45 14B4?>; 6::25/2145:0<0;2 +*, &$ % ) 41< 6-( ? 6- -&